Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what the fervently anti-UPF posters feel about the usual British Christmas?

163 replies

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 11:33

I’m enjoying all the Christmas threads about what sweets and treats people are looking forward to, but it occurred to me (especially with Halloween just behind us and all the threads about sweet consumption!) that it might be a rather difficult time of year, if you’re the kind of person who avoids sugar, saturated fat, salt, nitrites, UPF etc. Particularly if you have children who are also being bombarded with media featuring every gorgeous unhealthy treat under the sun. I’ve lost a lot of weight this year and have started running, so I’m hoping to be a bit more moderate this year - but I will relax my usual “rules” and eat some truly terrible crap over the actual Christmas period. I’m really looking forward to it!

So how do people with a more purist attitude to diet - and their children’s eating - navigate Christmas?

OP posts:
Clonakilla · 06/11/2026 23:14

The people with disordered eating - they tend to reveal themselves by the contempt and disgust they show towards eating, calling food ‘crap’ or ‘gunk’ and referring to ‘shoveling’, ‘stuffing faces’ ‘gobs’ etc - will continue to have disordered eating.

The rest of the population will continue to eat for both nutrition and pleasure, within the context of their background and budgets.

Enjoy your jelly babies.

Letsgonowthen · 06/11/2026 23:29

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 11:46

Jelly babies, After Eights, crisps, commercially produced chocolates, fig rolls I didn’t make myself, pigs in blankets, fizzy drinks…there are loads of things that aren’t part of the “traditional Christmas” that are very much part of the average British family’s Christmas and have been for decades. I can see that it’s still possible to avoid UPFs by sticking to homemade cake, mince pies, trifle etc (which I already do), but it would still be markedly different. And if you’re still eating your own body weight in sugar and double cream, then I’m not sure the health benefits would be worth it.

I try to avoid UPFs but I'll still enjoy After Eights at Christmas.

But most of the things you list are easy for us to avoid as we don't particularly like them (Fig rolls, fizzy drinks, trifle) or associate them with Christmas (Jelly Babies, crisps).

We do enjoy pigs in blankets but they're a tiny part of the roast dinner. We make our own mince pies. We use emulsifier free dark chocolate in a lot of recipes rather than cheap brands.

I don't really care about fat or sugar content. But your body doesn't process things in UPF food the same way as whole food, so imo it does still make a difference.

Oldbaglady46 · 07/11/2026 07:42

Lupin5555 · 06/11/2026 22:21

Mince pies definitely are junk food if not home made.

They are indeed homemade

Ponoka7 · 07/11/2026 08:09

TaptheCap · 06/11/2026 22:18

I actually think UPF definition depends on tour perspectives (and on what sources you read, there isn't a single, universally recognised definition). I use it to mean "can't be made in a domestic kitchen" - if I can't buy the ingredient in a general, if somewhat extensive, supermarket, it's probably a UPF. If it requires specialist equipment you can't get for home use, then same.

No that means it is processed. UPF is a completely different category. The Victorians ate processed food. We certainly did in the 60/70s. It wasn't and isn't harmful. UPF should be kept to a minimum. So should some ingredients that have crept into foods. We've had sneering comments about Iceland/Aldi. Aldi is worth checking out. Iceland sell ingredients and they've only started using palm oil because of the Ukraine/Russian war, but so have other, more expensive, retailers. There's a shortage.

RaininSummer · 07/11/2026 08:55

I'm pretty aware of UPF and don't buy much properly processed food as I don't like it. I've never bought tubs of cheap sweets as they are revolting but may pick up some malteser reindeer and some matchmakers or mints for after dinner. I do buy more crisps than normal for Christmas. My treat Christmas food was always lovely cheeses and good crackers and chutney but now I am dairy intolerant, it's left an empty Christmas void. Very sad

TaptheCap · 07/11/2026 10:05

Ponoka7 · 07/11/2026 08:09

No that means it is processed. UPF is a completely different category. The Victorians ate processed food. We certainly did in the 60/70s. It wasn't and isn't harmful. UPF should be kept to a minimum. So should some ingredients that have crept into foods. We've had sneering comments about Iceland/Aldi. Aldi is worth checking out. Iceland sell ingredients and they've only started using palm oil because of the Ukraine/Russian war, but so have other, more expensive, retailers. There's a shortage.

No. I can make processed foods in my kitchen. Like cheese, ham, bread and bacon. I can't make ultra processed food because the methods used to synthesise or extract the substances (like hydrogenation) require industrial level techniques and technology not available for general use or the chemicals involved are highly regulated.

Processed foods are fine in moderation. UPFs shouldn't be in our food chain, but I don't ban them outright in our home. Yes, Victorians ate processed foods, we have for most of history to one degree or another.

Ponoka7 · 07/11/2026 12:23

TaptheCap · 07/11/2026 10:05

No. I can make processed foods in my kitchen. Like cheese, ham, bread and bacon. I can't make ultra processed food because the methods used to synthesise or extract the substances (like hydrogenation) require industrial level techniques and technology not available for general use or the chemicals involved are highly regulated.

Processed foods are fine in moderation. UPFs shouldn't be in our food chain, but I don't ban them outright in our home. Yes, Victorians ate processed foods, we have for most of history to one degree or another.

You are mixing up processed with UPF. Some things that you can't buy and wouldn't use in your kitchen, doesn't mean that it's harmful. What constitutes UPF isn't a perception, it's a definition. We've eaten processed foods you couldn't do in your kitchen since the 18th century. They are completely separate to UPF. Good sausages and bacon aren't UPF. Some chocolate isn't UPF. The Christmas pies from M&S, I used to buy aren't UPF. Some crisps aren UPF and unless you are eating loads of the rest, they aren't a concern.

Calliopespa · 07/11/2026 12:26

Anyway, for a few days, it'll all be fine!

bababamama · 07/11/2026 12:33

Most traditional Christmas foods are not upf eg turkey, veggies, I’ve made my cake and Christmas pudding already, made two jars of mincemeat (ok bought veggie suet but that’s a minor one), most pastry I make with plant based butter due to the pesky vegan but that’s his fault Grin I’d rather use butter and lard, very much natural. Cheeses, I will bake focaccia. Mum will bake chocolate cake, vegan flapjacks, make creme brûlée’s…. All those upf treats are very much optional

bababamama · 07/11/2026 12:39

By the way, many crisps aren’t upf, batch cooked ready salted is pretty ok in the treat category. Pringles (food of the gods and a complete weakness of mine) definitely are upf but I don’t care! I do t like mass produced chocolates really, and I haven’t seen things like jelly babies for years, are they even still around, I certainly don’t think of them as essential for Christmas! After 8’s are disgusting, toothpaste in chocolate, yuck

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 18:28

Who drinks baileys....it's the devil's work...it eggnog all the way....

BIossomtoes · 07/11/2026 18:31

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 18:28

Who drinks baileys....it's the devil's work...it eggnog all the way....

Me. You can keep your egg nog.

BugJuice · 07/11/2026 18:35

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 18:28

Who drinks baileys....it's the devil's work...it eggnog all the way....

I bloody love a Baileys.

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 18:40

I have discovered that people enjoy baileys, who knew??...i think they might have mental health issues....

BugJuice · 07/11/2026 19:38

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 18:40

I have discovered that people enjoy baileys, who knew??...i think they might have mental health issues....

No more so than someone who likes eggnog 😬😁

BIossomtoes · 07/11/2026 19:55

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 18:40

I have discovered that people enjoy baileys, who knew??...i think they might have mental health issues....

No, just fully functional taste buds.

SunnyCrab · 07/11/2026 20:30

Most researchers and experts I’ve read suggest following the 80/20 rule - 20% UPH to ensure you optimise your mental and physical health! Means you can enjoy some treats at Christmas :)

Lupin5555 · 07/11/2026 21:11

Clonakilla · 06/11/2026 23:14

The people with disordered eating - they tend to reveal themselves by the contempt and disgust they show towards eating, calling food ‘crap’ or ‘gunk’ and referring to ‘shoveling’, ‘stuffing faces’ ‘gobs’ etc - will continue to have disordered eating.

The rest of the population will continue to eat for both nutrition and pleasure, within the context of their background and budgets.

Enjoy your jelly babies.

No disordered eating here, I love food and eat well. I don’t however like ultra processed crap and it is crap. Young people are getting cancer in increasing numbers. UPFs are being looked at.

BebbanburgIsMine · 07/11/2026 22:10

I don’t really have much extra food during Christmas, we have our roast chicken (or beef if we can afford it), homemade roast tatties, carrots, peas, green beans, skirlie and gravy.

We start with homemade vegetable and lentil soup, and finish with Sticky Toffee Pudding.

We don’t have endless sweets and things on the day or throughout the whole period. Certainly no double cream for me as I detest most dairy foods. Sometimes have a bit of cheddar, but nothing fancy.

Most of this is because I just don’t have the money to buy extra, and I don’t think I’d change much even if I did. It’s just DD, me and our cat anyway, so I don’t have to worry about having a houseful!

ForQuirkyFawn · 07/11/2026 22:28

Touche.....😉

PaisleyElephant · 07/11/2026 22:36

I avoid UPFs, but I also do allow myself some things. Not all UPFs are the same, some might just have a few bits in, others are more chemicals than food

I will get some bits in but not go too mad. I will get one box of mince pies from the bakery. I will have pigs in blankets with my Christmas dinner. I will likely have a shop bought Christmas pudding.

I won't be eating jelly sweets or pringles. I won't have any of that sort of stuff in the house so temptation won't be there. Although some marshmallows and hot chocolate will indeed be making it's way into my house.

Calliopespa · 07/11/2026 22:41

BebbanburgIsMine · 07/11/2026 22:10

I don’t really have much extra food during Christmas, we have our roast chicken (or beef if we can afford it), homemade roast tatties, carrots, peas, green beans, skirlie and gravy.

We start with homemade vegetable and lentil soup, and finish with Sticky Toffee Pudding.

We don’t have endless sweets and things on the day or throughout the whole period. Certainly no double cream for me as I detest most dairy foods. Sometimes have a bit of cheddar, but nothing fancy.

Most of this is because I just don’t have the money to buy extra, and I don’t think I’d change much even if I did. It’s just DD, me and our cat anyway, so I don’t have to worry about having a houseful!

Sounds perfectly lovely! 😋

beeble347 · 07/11/2026 23:07

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 11:46

Jelly babies, After Eights, crisps, commercially produced chocolates, fig rolls I didn’t make myself, pigs in blankets, fizzy drinks…there are loads of things that aren’t part of the “traditional Christmas” that are very much part of the average British family’s Christmas and have been for decades. I can see that it’s still possible to avoid UPFs by sticking to homemade cake, mince pies, trifle etc (which I already do), but it would still be markedly different. And if you’re still eating your own body weight in sugar and double cream, then I’m not sure the health benefits would be worth it.

Interesting, ours doesn't look like this. We spend it with DH's side who aren't British but my family wouldn't have had much of these. Plenty of chocolate coins as kids but it would be a homemade lunch and dessert, then homemade dinner at my grandparents'. My grandma would usually have some samosas, bhajis that kind of thing out before dinner which I think were UPF ones, probably from frozen.

Never been in a house that's trying to be UPF-free on Christmas, I guess we're both from families that loved cooking and we never had the tins of quality street etc. Bottles of Schloer and so on, absolutely, it still felt like an indulgent celebration

MommaMia26 · 08/11/2026 02:59

SiegfriedSassoon · 06/11/2026 11:54

I agree that traditional British Christmas fare is non UPF foods. Certainly in our household.

To add, I've never bought much chocolate for my children's stockings, just a bag of coins shared between the four of them, but I have decided to change that this year. They eat so well year round, we dont do Halloween so no sweets there, they are all a bit older now (12-6) and I think they will absolutely love having a little stash to enjoy over the Christmas hols. The main reason also is that I feel like I've run out of ideas for stockings and I don't want to buy things that won't get used.

So this year I am 'in the market' for festive goodies and I am appalled at the array of crap our there! Waitrose and amazon have been the places I've found the most likely things. Cornish fudge, crystallised ginger, real liquorice, scottish shortbread, Turkish delight. Just need to find some decent chocolate now that isn't filled with palm oil. Oh I found some nice chocolate Brazil nuts.
I'd love to get them a Terry's chocolate orange and a selection box like I used to get but that stuff is not chocolate anymore, just cheap gunk.

https://chococo.co.uk/collections/all

Chococo sounds like what you’re looking for (I haven’t read all the posts so you might have had suggestions already).
They sell cute stocking filler gifts but the chocolate is good quality and palm oil free (as well as lots of other sustainability and ethical credentials).

They do most of their designs in dark, milk, blonde and oat milk chocolate. Their chocolate florentines and chocolate dipped candied oranges are delicious!

Bobloblaw84 · 08/11/2026 03:13

Your Christmas fare sounds rather unusual OP and really not the tradition at all. I love the odd processed treat but would rather tuck in to homemade roasts and cakes. I think the “specialness” of Christmas is the homemade care that goes into a meal, sometimes days of preparation (usually by women of the family) and not stuffing your face with processed crap.