Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think donating to charity is a bit like sponsoring a panda?

191 replies

ThatDeepGoose · 06/11/2026 08:57

I give money in the hope that it reaches those it’s intended to help but there’s always a little voice in the back of my mind wondering where it actually ends up.

It’s a bit like sponsoring a panda. I sincerely hope the panda gets the money, but part of me fears it’s being spent on drugs and prostitutes.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
AutumnOakTree · 07/11/2026 12:45

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2026 11:22

I personally hope the panda doesnt get the money, because I'm not sure it'd be able to do much with a bunch of bank notes.

Eat it instead of bamboo?

bababamama · 07/11/2026 11:48

Charities are not a homogeneous entity. You can see their accounts, look at programmes and aims then decide whether you support them. Sometimes you also need to look at the bigger picture eg a hospice charity will have inpatient, outpatient and telephone helpline services, support for other healthcare professionals eg training courses and placements to learn about palliative care, outreach groups, counselling and then a fundraising arm, but even within that they can be helping people because volunteering can be therapeutic, the shops for instance can help with isolation and loneliness when someone has lost a loved one, them coming to volunteer 4 hours a week is a benefit to them and potentially reducing need for taxpayer funded help. People moan about the chief executive salary without realising that the knock on effects of organisations is hugely positive.

sillycoldmondays · 07/11/2026 11:30

I’d rather donate to smaller local charities where possible. What pisses me off is the begging on card machines in shops

RedToothBrush · 07/11/2026 11:22

I personally hope the panda doesnt get the money, because I'm not sure it'd be able to do much with a bunch of bank notes.

Itsasecretnow · 07/11/2026 11:18

PaperMachePanda · 07/11/2026 11:02

I used to work in the accounting department of a well known charity (think one with loads of high street shops). I could write a book on how iffy they were at fudging the books.

I no longer give money directly to these charities.

I prefer to give food to my local food bank instead.

I think it’s larger charities that I’m more wary of, for these reasons. My personal experience as an elected trustee of a charity - and before that (and during trusteeship) also a committee member -was with a local charity that I already had involvement with and that was extremely transparent and had many rules around different grants and fundraising money. Majority of people were volunteers, and during my period of involvement with them there were never more than three full time staff. Financial accounts were looked at most months, plus at the end/beginning of each quarter. Very little money went to the staff, and every penny was accounted for.

I think, because of my experience, I am very wary of large/inter/national charities. I know they are very tightly regulated like the one I was involved in, but that surely changes the more staff they have, the higher overheads etc. And you do hear of so much mismanagement, with so (relatively) little of the money making it through to the charity itself, especially the bigger these charities become. For these reasons I do only support local charities, particularly ones I’m familiar with.

PaperMachePanda · 07/11/2026 11:02

I used to work in the accounting department of a well known charity (think one with loads of high street shops). I could write a book on how iffy they were at fudging the books.

I no longer give money directly to these charities.

I prefer to give food to my local food bank instead.

topcat2014 · 07/11/2026 10:33

I donate to two charities (RNLI and UNICEF), and am trustee of another local one.

However - I remember a news article about a lady from Bristol, I think, who killed herself possibly because she was being hounded by loads of charities.

Like a PP - as a slightly desperate young graduate I did what is now called "chugging" and earned quite well for signing people up.

TheRealSmurfette · 07/11/2026 10:29

13RidgmontRoad · 07/11/2026 09:15

What’s that quip from Henning Wehn? “In Germany we don’t have charities. We pay taxes.”

Again, as someone at the sharp end, many of the things on your list ought to be provided by a competent government interested in the welfare of its population.

Yes as someone who works for a charity I completely agree with you but they are NOT. So this is the system we have.

Charities are like businesses they have operating costs. Support them or we’ll loose them. It’s as simple as that.

Darker · 07/11/2026 10:10

Sorry I meant to reply to @13RidgmontRoad

Darker · 07/11/2026 10:00

Well I agree with you @Anarchy99 in many ways especially regarding services being funded by our taxes. but unfortunately that isn’t happening any time soon. Once upon a time charities could get government grants to support their work.

Charities are independent and agile, and connect people with causes. They offer incredible volunteering opportunities. They give people a chance to support things that they want to if the government can’t or won’t…

I’m glad they exist.

13RidgmontRoad · 07/11/2026 09:15

Darker · 07/11/2026 07:58

@Anarchy99

I wonder what a world would look like without charities.

What would exist to do the job these charities do?

Lifeboats /Air ambulance
Samaritans/Mind
Trussell Trust/City Harvest
Citizens Advice
Farms for City Children
All the breast cancer and women’s health charities
Amnesty International
Crisis

What’s that quip from Henning Wehn? “In Germany we don’t have charities. We pay taxes.”

Again, as someone at the sharp end, many of the things on your list ought to be provided by a competent government interested in the welfare of its population.

Unihorn · 07/11/2026 09:08

I donate to Lumos, the charity founded by JK Rowling, because she covered all running costs to ensure more donations went directly to the work. That charity has had a huge impact on orphanages. I also do Air Ambulance and a local children's charity because they seem like the more worthy causes to me.

Itsasecretnow · 07/11/2026 08:54

Ormally · 06/11/2026 14:37

They haven't got the energy because they are not at all well equipped to digest bamboo. So need up to 40lb a day of the stuff in order to get it together sufficiently for a day of pondering and not shagging.
Perhaps some wheatgrass shots and an IV drip system project might be a worthy panda charity campaign.

So need up to 40lb a day of the stuff in order to get it together sufficiently for a day of pondering and not shagging.

Christ, that sounds far more like me than I’m comfortable admitting to 😴 I don’t do the 40lb bamboo bit, but maybe I need a charity campaign for an iv drip of something explosive!

You’d think by now they’d have found more digestible food, most species would’ve adapted a little by now! But then when you’re that tired it’s hard to try new things…I think I’m all in if you want to set up the New Genetic Energetic Panda Charity Commission. Might need a new name though, that’s a bit of a mouthful! (Much like the bloody bamboo!).

eta: I’ve just realised that it sounds like I’m shagging all day and not pondering…I clearly read that backwards in my head! I am definitely not shagging all day 😂

IDontHateRainbows · 07/11/2026 08:24

I used to work for a national charity and a lot of money went on management jolllies, travel, meals etc. I know some business travel is necessary but costs were never scrutinized so hotels/ meals etc when maybe not necessarily needed.

Meanwhile front line charity shop staff never got any overtime for excess hours as expected to do it free for the cause.

Opened my eyes

Darker · 07/11/2026 07:58

@Anarchy99

I wonder what a world would look like without charities.

What would exist to do the job these charities do?

Lifeboats /Air ambulance
Samaritans/Mind
Trussell Trust/City Harvest
Citizens Advice
Farms for City Children
All the breast cancer and women’s health charities
Amnesty International
Crisis

NotAnotherScarf · 07/11/2026 07:57

IdleGossip · 06/11/2026 09:04

The Charity Commission requires far more financial information about charities than regular businesses are required to provide.

You can go onto their website, or the website of any charity, and see exactly where the money is going.

Hmm politely I'd like to disagree I've been following a small local charity over the last few years. After the way the "managers" behaved towards a business i part own.

The way they report financial information to the charity commission changed a couple of years ago and seems to deliberately hide how they spend their money.

Before that they spent £22k to raise £24k. But the fund raising is all exciting activities and gala balls. I can't see how the participants of the activities are funded. Ie is the guy doing the white water rafting paying for himself.

Plus the events and actual work of the charity seems to be very small scale and infrequent. Which is odd given that the support needed for those effected by the cause the charity tries to help with would need regular aid and support

Anarchy99 · 07/11/2026 07:48

Darker · 07/11/2026 07:44

We need all kinds of charities.

Local doesn’t always mean better managed. I volunteered for a much praised, much needed local charity a few years ago and left within weeks because it was so badly run. Trustees, volunteers and paid staff seemed to be equally clueless as to their responsibilities. The beneficiaries were treated with very little respect .

I currently volunteer for another local charity which is brilliant.

But no local charity will help resolve some of the national or international or problems that concern me. They won’t find a cure for MND or tackle climate change.

But not when there is embezzlement within that charity and people get away with it, I know for a fact this happens. So I don’t give money to any

Darker · 07/11/2026 07:44

We need all kinds of charities.

Local doesn’t always mean better managed. I volunteered for a much praised, much needed local charity a few years ago and left within weeks because it was so badly run. Trustees, volunteers and paid staff seemed to be equally clueless as to their responsibilities. The beneficiaries were treated with very little respect .

I currently volunteer for another local charity which is brilliant.

But no local charity will help resolve some of the national or international or problems that concern me. They won’t find a cure for MND or tackle climate change.

AllJoyAndNoFun · 06/11/2026 19:48

AutumnOakTree · 06/11/2026 19:31

I guess you’ve to speculate to accumulate. Social media is effectively an advert for your charity, so probably brings in revenue or at least a higher profile. Plus people like to know where their money is spent.

Yes- SM is the new mail shot. It’s a donor acquisition strategy, so if paying someone 38k gets an additional 100k of donations for hunger alleviation then the hungry people have nearly three times as much food as if you just spent the 38k on food. These people will often design and execute quite a sophisticated marketing strategy across multiple platforms using both own and third party content. They’ll also have a role in an advocacy or campaigning the charity does.

CassandraWebb · 06/11/2026 19:42

I am trustee of a local almshouse charity, we have one part time employee. She has a huge impact looking out for the residents and their homes. The rest is volunteer run. Any money donated has an impact and so many of the residents have said how much having an almshouse has transformed their lives.

Please donate to your local charities. We don't have a marketing budget but we are out there doing great things

Blueseaurchin · 06/11/2026 19:38

SorcererGaheris · 06/11/2026 17:20

@Blueseaurchin

In my 30 years in the sectors I can say that the majorities of CEOs and Chairs I worked under were simply not up to the job, wasted money and were in fact more of an hindrance

Thanks for sharing your experience. If the above is the case - CEOs and Chairs not being up to the task on salaries of, say, around £150,000 - then surely salaries that are vastly lower than that would attract people that end up being just as bad at the job or even worse.

If they need people with a certain skillset - especially business skills - then I would think it's doubtful that they'd get them on a salary of, say, £80k a year if they're not getting the required talent with their current offering.

The point is that the regular/frontline charity staff who are likely to make anything from 20K to 50K are usually really good at their job in spite of the very average salaries they get and could probably do a better of managing the charity than many of these CEOs.

AutumnOakTree · 06/11/2026 19:31

I guess you’ve to speculate to accumulate. Social media is effectively an advert for your charity, so probably brings in revenue or at least a higher profile. Plus people like to know where their money is spent.

13RidgmontRoad · 06/11/2026 18:26

Darker · 06/11/2026 18:09

£38k is not a vast salary for an experienced member of staff, especially a big organisation. (Though I couldn’t find one of that name)

I'm using a dummy name because their lawyers are also, er, rather well-renumerated and they've historically been a bit trigger-happy.

The salary's a salary, but I'm not sure in all honesty whether a charity dedicated to international hunger alleviation needs a FT person doing social media. Especially knowing what I do about their output, that feels very much like spending money to solicit donations to spend money to solicit donations. Obviously my perspective, as I said above, is of someone doing grassroots work at the pointy end but I'd need a lot of convincing to think it wasn't pissing money up the wall. My social media management strategy consists of posting a couple of photos on Instagram every other week and saying "yes" when I'm invited on podcasts.

CharityVolunteer · 06/11/2026 18:18

Just a reminder, in general chair of trustees and trustees are not paid and should not profit from the charity in any way. Whilst there’s sometimes corrupt trustees (Captain Tom Moore’s daughter and son-in-law were paying themselves as trustees) that’s relatively rare. Mostly they are working for free and sometimes putting in a lot of time.

Darker · 06/11/2026 18:09

13RidgmontRoad · 06/11/2026 17:06

I mean.. to some extent. I remember when we worked with them Googling and discovering that International Hunger Charity plc was recruiting a social media officer on £38k a year. That's a lot of rice and lentils.

£38k is not a vast salary for an experienced member of staff, especially a big organisation. (Though I couldn’t find one of that name)