Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kelly Bryant on paid fertility leave

215 replies

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:09

Did anyone see this discussion today on Loose women (I know, I know)
I found her views just so insensitive and bizarre
As someone who struggled for nine years to conceive, had multiple miscarriages, an emergency ectopic, was prodded and poked for years, three rounds of ivf, sickness and emotional upset-all whilst working full time and two jobs, it's upsetting

OP posts:
MaidsRoom · 06/11/2026 12:55

I think the more important point is availability of IVF on the NHS. For most couples with infertility in most places it is essentially not available now - certainly it wasn’t for us, even though we were both under 35 and otherwise healthy. There are so many conditions that most people end up excluded, and even if by some miracle you are declared eligible they only fund one round, which is near useless. Fix that first.

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 12:48

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · 06/11/2026 12:19

Since we're discussing the concept of (employer) paid IVF leave...

The treatment for your arthritis makes you more capable of being able to work (so financial benefit for you) and therefore of more value to the business with a reasonable chance you'll have fewer sick days, or restricted duties. It will, as you say, also improve your QoL but that's not really of interest to an employer.

IVF leave would be a nett cost for an elective procedure. To take it to the extreme, why should an employer not also provide bonking-leave to enable men and women to procreate.

I'm not sure when employers first became an arm of the welfare state, but it is getting ridiculous when governments win favour with the population by dumping societal costs onto businesses.

If you're self-employed you don't get these same benefits - so to all the people talking about equality for women who haven't conceived 'naturally', i would ask would you be happy for your taxes to go up so some people can have paid sick-leave whenever they want it, by making these things taxpayer-funded rather than employer-funded.

I do see your point. And I was maybe going off point as my comment was responding to a poster who said the nhs shouldn't fund IVF as its not treating an illness.

ThisOliveKoala · 06/11/2026 12:29

Somedayitwillclick · 06/11/2026 10:24

If you can’t work during having fertility treatment you need to sick leave. The same as if you needed chemo etc you get signed off and follow your companies sick pay policies. It should be treated like any other form of medical condition.

I say this as someone who had gone through the process twice. I worked through it because I could but if you need time off it needs to be signed off by the doctor.

This is what I think as well

CanSeeClearlyNowTheRainHasGone · 06/11/2026 12:19

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 11:31

It's not curing anything, the biggest impact is on my quality of life and mental health, similar to IVF

Since we're discussing the concept of (employer) paid IVF leave...

The treatment for your arthritis makes you more capable of being able to work (so financial benefit for you) and therefore of more value to the business with a reasonable chance you'll have fewer sick days, or restricted duties. It will, as you say, also improve your QoL but that's not really of interest to an employer.

IVF leave would be a nett cost for an elective procedure. To take it to the extreme, why should an employer not also provide bonking-leave to enable men and women to procreate.

I'm not sure when employers first became an arm of the welfare state, but it is getting ridiculous when governments win favour with the population by dumping societal costs onto businesses.

If you're self-employed you don't get these same benefits - so to all the people talking about equality for women who haven't conceived 'naturally', i would ask would you be happy for your taxes to go up so some people can have paid sick-leave whenever they want it, by making these things taxpayer-funded rather than employer-funded.

Benjithedog · 06/11/2026 11:55

Lomee · 05/11/2026 21:17

I watched this. As someone who went through a decade of fertility treatment and who worked through it even when I was hormonal, depressed, in pain without causing a fuss, I found her so insensitive, stubborn, and rude. Penny and Kelly were very eloquent and sensible. Yes, it was my choice to do IVF just like it's most people's choice to have a baby, but it's not my choice to be infertile. I wouldn't wish this journey on my worst enemy and I've paid my tax thank you.

I hope you got your baby too.

Benjithedog · 06/11/2026 11:54

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:09

Did anyone see this discussion today on Loose women (I know, I know)
I found her views just so insensitive and bizarre
As someone who struggled for nine years to conceive, had multiple miscarriages, an emergency ectopic, was prodded and poked for years, three rounds of ivf, sickness and emotional upset-all whilst working full time and two jobs, it's upsetting

I am so hoping you got your baby

TheLastSilverSaint · 06/11/2026 11:52

I don't think deciding to have IVF is actually akin to needing treatment for an illness. It's a choice. People want to have children; they don't need to have them.

However, I do think it's a good and compassionate move to allow IVF leave and my preference would be for people to be able to take it. But to my mind allowing IVF leave is a 'should do' rather than a 'must do'.

I'd also add that while you might not agree with Kelle Bryant - I don't agree with her either - she's perfectly entitled to hold and express her opinion. She's not taking an extreme stance on this and she's not attacking anyone. Just because you disagree with her, that doesn't make it 'insensitive' of her to express her perfectly valid opinion. I don't agree with her view, but that doesn't mean her view is unreasonable.

IceLollly · 06/11/2026 11:52

My GP put me on sick leave whilst I was undergoing ivf but I was having bad side effects, but she also said she wanted me well rested so not to go back if they went away.

beechandbuddleia · 06/11/2026 11:49

I'm not really sure I think there should be special "fertility leave", and I say this as someone who has recently done IVF. I think there should be better rules around medical leave in general, but that there shouldn't be a special carve out for IVF. Not least because you shouldn't be under any obligation to explain why you need the time off if you don't want to.

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 11:37

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:29

She could have simply not had a baby.

I presuming you either don't have children, or paid for yours to be delivered privately? Seeing as you think people should pay for all costs associated with having children?

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 11:32

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:29

She could have simply not had a baby.

And instead get told how much of a drain on society she’ll be in old age. How she should pay more tax. Be grateful for all those who had kids because it’ll be those that will be “wiping her bum” in old age. Be told she must save for a high private pension and care home fees because it’s not fair that other people’s children are funding her in old age.

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 11:31

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:29

The treatment you’re receiving for arthritis is improving your health.

It's not curing anything, the biggest impact is on my quality of life and mental health, similar to IVF

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:29

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 06/11/2026 10:10

Had my friend not had IVF, her baby would very likely have had a gene that would have given her cancer as a young adult and cost the NHS a lot more money than the IVF did.so it absolutely improved her baby’s health and possibly saved the baby’s life too.

She could have simply not had a baby.

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:29

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 09:12

Many NHS treatments aren't life saving, but based on improving quality of life. I have early onset arthritis, it's not going to kill me, but it's very painful. My treatment isn't going to save my life, or cure me. But it reduces my pain,reduces the damage to my joints. It also improves my mental health as living in constant pain is pretty depressing.
Women get breastfeeding implants post mastectomy, children get braces etc. These aren't live saving, but they are quality of life improving, as is IVF. Like any publicly funded treatment, funding needs to be targeted towards those for whom its most likely to be effective, but otherwise it should be viewed like any other medical treatment.

The treatment you’re receiving for arthritis is improving your health.

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 10:44

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 10:29

Could the same not be said for pregnancy? I thought women spent years trying to fight for equal employment rights. You get women on here saying maternity should never be a reason to either not employ someone or not to promote them etc. Even when women on here have back to back maternity leaves for 2-3 years everyone says this should never affect your career/employment opportunities etc. And rightly so surely? If you substituted the word fertility treatment with pregnancy surely everyone would be up in arms! I’m sure there are plenty of employers out there who do avoid hiring women of childbearing age as they don’t want them to go off on maternity leave for years. But most people recognise that as discrimination. So why wouldn’t it be for fertility treatment related reasons?

It probably would be discrimination under the existing law, but it's extremely difficult to judge a hiring manager's true motives in most cases (and I say that as a lawyer of 25 years). I suspect that most private sector hiring managers with a hypothetical choice between an equally qualified and talented man and woman of childbearing age would take the man. And that is often the right thing for the business, because it mitigates the risk that the new hire takes extended time off. Nonsense like "paid time off for IVF" will simply perpetuate that.

Academically, of course you (and @Gengha ) are correct. There is no reason for men to be the default, and at a societal level, we are all invested in ensuring continuation of the species. But the person in a business who is accountable for the top line - or the bottom line for that matter, because mat cover is not cheap - is going to take what is perceived to be the least risky option, because that is the pragmatic thing to do.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 10:29

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 09:59

I had my DS through IVF, and I don't think women should receive paid leave. It can be counterproductive to women's career prospects - even those who don't need IVF - to be perceived as needing more time off than a man. Ultimately, you are hired to carry out a role and hiring managers are able to make certain choices, provided of course that they comply with the law.

Could the same not be said for pregnancy? I thought women spent years trying to fight for equal employment rights. You get women on here saying maternity should never be a reason to either not employ someone or not to promote them etc. Even when women on here have back to back maternity leaves for 2-3 years everyone says this should never affect your career/employment opportunities etc. And rightly so surely? If you substituted the word fertility treatment with pregnancy surely everyone would be up in arms! I’m sure there are plenty of employers out there who do avoid hiring women of childbearing age as they don’t want them to go off on maternity leave for years. But most people recognise that as discrimination. So why wouldn’t it be for fertility treatment related reasons?

Somedayitwillclick · 06/11/2026 10:24

If you can’t work during having fertility treatment you need to sick leave. The same as if you needed chemo etc you get signed off and follow your companies sick pay policies. It should be treated like any other form of medical condition.

I say this as someone who had gone through the process twice. I worked through it because I could but if you need time off it needs to be signed off by the doctor.

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 06/11/2026 10:10

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 07:02

IVF is, ultimately, elective. It doesn’t save your life and it doesn’t improve your health.

Had my friend not had IVF, her baby would very likely have had a gene that would have given her cancer as a young adult and cost the NHS a lot more money than the IVF did.so it absolutely improved her baby’s health and possibly saved the baby’s life too.

Gengha · 06/11/2026 10:08

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 09:59

I had my DS through IVF, and I don't think women should receive paid leave. It can be counterproductive to women's career prospects - even those who don't need IVF - to be perceived as needing more time off than a man. Ultimately, you are hired to carry out a role and hiring managers are able to make certain choices, provided of course that they comply with the law.

I don’t quite agree with that point, why did men and their requirements become the default? Women and their bodies have different needs to men. My objection is just that everyone has things going on that are difficult and may have an impact on them and their ability to attend work, but ultimately why is it an employer’s responsibility to pay for these all the time. People are employed to actually turn up and do jobs, they already enjoy quite a lot of rights to protected time off, paid or unpaid. An expectation of yet more is taking the piss.

ClairDeLaLune · 06/11/2026 10:06

Bushmillsbabe · 05/11/2026 21:47

Infertility is a medical condition.
Many medical conditions are treated not because they are life threatening, but to improve a person's quality if life, their mental health etc. IVF comes under this.

Those of us who can conceive naturally should count ourselves fortunate that we do not have to go through the traumas and tests and treatments which women who struggle with their fertility go through, through no fault of their own, to acheive the same outcome.

I had fertility treatment in the early 2000s, which was entirely paid for by ourselves, nothing was provided by the NHS except some initial investigations and treatment for a miscarriage and an ectopic pregnancy.

I personally think that this was right. I don’t think fertility treatment should be available on the NHS in these times when it’s on its knees. I think the NHS should be prioritising treating the people we’ve already got, not creating new ones. Resources are limited, they should be targeted where they are most needed.

I also don’t think there should be paid leave, but I do think employers should be flexible and allow unpaid time off and flexible working. I was lucky that the clinic was nearby and I went to my appointments in my lunch hour. I had the additional stress of not wanting my colleagues to know what I was doing.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 10:05

ThisOliveKoala · 06/11/2026 09:37

Mmmh makes sense, I actually hadn’t thought of it like that. However isn’t that already available? Granted I have been contracting for over 10 years so I’m not sure what’s what. For eg if you have an ivf appt can’t it just be taken as a doctor appts morning or afternoon etc? Don’t full time workers already get time to attend dentists, GP etc? I’m happy to wrong, but you raised a good point I had not considered

No, no employee is entitled to time off (either paid or unpaid) for standard medical appointments. You are legally allowed time off for pregnancy or disability related appointments only. Employers must ensure their employees are able to be healthy etc so refusing all medical appointments would likely result in legal issues. But they absolutely do not need to be paid. And they can make you make the time up etc.

And no with IVF you often cannot choose what time you go. Even with private. I had rounds at the very expensive ARGC in London and you have to be there when they tell you. Normally you must arrive at 8am and wait. Then you may or may not need a blood test. Sometimes I was still there at lunchtime. Now admittedly not all IVF clinics are as intense as ARGC (I have also had rounds elsewhere), but you are at their mercy as to appointment times. Not everyone can be seen at 8am and be out by 8.15am obviously. You also don’t always know when your egg collection will be. They could suddenly say right it’s tomorrow! It’s a very stressful process.

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 09:59

I had my DS through IVF, and I don't think women should receive paid leave. It can be counterproductive to women's career prospects - even those who don't need IVF - to be perceived as needing more time off than a man. Ultimately, you are hired to carry out a role and hiring managers are able to make certain choices, provided of course that they comply with the law.

Jk987 · 06/11/2026 09:52

Jk987 · 06/11/2026 09:45

I went through 7 rounds of IVF while working full time. I most definitely DID NOT want to tell my mostly male colleagues that I was undergoing fertility treatment. I didn’t want them knowing I’m trying to get pregnant as it’s very personal to me. I didnt want them knowing my business and that 4 years later, why wasn’t I pregnant yet? (I eventually conceived naturally but that’s not the point) There’s also the worry it might impact their perception knowing I might be off on maternity leave.

So no, I don’t think being explicitly being given paid leave for fertility is right as it forces you to share private information. Just like menstrual time off, it’s ridiculous thinking I’d tell my boss when I’m on my period! However sick leave or duvet days could be used to allow flexibility and I did take sick or holiday or Flex Time when needed.

My IVF was all self funded if that makes a difference.

Jk987 · 06/11/2026 09:45

I went through 7 rounds of IVF while working full time. I most definitely DID NOT want to tell my mostly male colleagues that I was undergoing fertility treatment. I didn’t want them knowing I’m trying to get pregnant as it’s very personal to me. I didnt want them knowing my business and that 4 years later, why wasn’t I pregnant yet? (I eventually conceived naturally but that’s not the point) There’s also the worry it might impact their perception knowing I might be off on maternity leave.

So no, I don’t think being explicitly being given paid leave for fertility is right as it forces you to share private information. Just like menstrual time off, it’s ridiculous thinking I’d tell my boss when I’m on my period! However sick leave or duvet days could be used to allow flexibility and I did take sick or holiday or Flex Time when needed.