Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kelly Bryant on paid fertility leave

215 replies

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:09

Did anyone see this discussion today on Loose women (I know, I know)
I found her views just so insensitive and bizarre
As someone who struggled for nine years to conceive, had multiple miscarriages, an emergency ectopic, was prodded and poked for years, three rounds of ivf, sickness and emotional upset-all whilst working full time and two jobs, it's upsetting

OP posts:
SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 18:19

Firefly1987 · 06/11/2026 18:08

That's so offensive to adopted children to say "do you actually think it's the same as having a child of your own?" and laughing about it. I know couples who have adopted children-they are their children. Not everyone cares about DNA that much.

It's not the same though. For either the parents or the children. Speaking to adult adoptees Will tell you that.

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 18:15

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 17:53

Tbh I find your response a bit hyperbolic as well. People are allowed to disagree, "lived experience" or not.

Your "research" (i.e. article) says "Current research has shown that the stress levels of women with infertility are equivalent to those with cancer" with no substantiation, no details of the measures used in the study, the sample size or comorbidities. If you call that research, I have got a bridge to sell you. The article actually describes the benefical effects of reducing stress on fertility outcomes - which makes complete sense. Tbh even it was actual research and not just trash, I am not credulous enough to believe it as "fact", because these things are inherently subjective.

FWIW I have an autistic son and apparently that means that my stress levels "are akin to those of a combat soldier" according to - presumably equally shonky - research. Yes it's stressful, but a combat soldier? Pull the other one!

My "lived experience" (🙄) of both infertility and cancer is this: one was sad and tough, the other was terrifying and physically bloody hard. I am not trying to play Top Trumps, but I really think the "we need special leave for every possible eventuality" crowd would benefit from a bit of a grip. Life has been infinitely tougher in previous generations, and remains so for many, but somehow people were more resilient and kept buggering on.

Actually it does sound like you're trying to play top trumps.

After my fifth IVF failure I went to my GP sobbing my heart about after 4 hours of sustained panic attacks and told them I needed help because I wanted to kill myself. I was on the last warning for attendance at work both due to my destroyed mental health and inability to actually get through a work day without breaking down or fucking something up anymore and the endless chronic pain of endometriosis. Thankfully they helped me, if they had told me that I was being hyperbolic and just needed to get a grip because the older generation had it worse and just "kept buggering on" I would have told them to go fuck them so and left. And probably killed myself. Why do people like you always glamorise the suffering of older generations as if suffering without help is a badge of honour? I can tell you my manically depressed grandmother and my great grandfather who used to shout about Germans under his bed in his later years would have loved help and didn't actually just have a happy life by deciding to get grip. They were miserable until their dying day. Why do people want that to continue for people living today? What's actually wrong with them?

The fertility leave offered by my company, which was only 2 days anyway was the fine line between losing my job for being sick too often and still being paid is what stopped me going broke whilst paying eye watering IVF bills. It really helped me in my most desperate time, and for two measley days of paid leave, in return they have a happy, healthy , grateful and loyal employee that has worked hard for years. Surely people aren't too stupid to see that when companies offer benefits like this it buys them loyalty and hard work from their employees?

And yes it's an article about research, not research itself. A lot of it is behind a pay wall and I don't care to read it. I know how harrowing infertility was for me and I don't need a research paper to tell me that. What people who have never experienced it need to understand though is that it's not simply not getting what you want so just getting over it and moving on like some have posted here. Many never get over it and never move on. Your accusations of hyperbole, drama and fragility don't help with the misconceptions about the trauma of infertility, which is shocking considering you've actually been through it. I really can't understand what's wrong with some people.

bridgetreilly · 06/11/2026 18:13

I do think employers are asked to cover a lot these days. Which is one thing if the employer is a huge multinational worth billions, and quite another if its a small business with half a dozen employees. What would fertility leave actually cover? It can’t surely be the years of potential heartache and repeated treatments and so on? So, what, just the day of the actual IVF procedure? But you could already take that as medical leave without explanation.

Nobody is saying it’s not awful, just that it’s not a problem that employers can solve.

Firefly1987 · 06/11/2026 18:08

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 07:16

I’ve had 4 rounds of IVF. Paid for it all privately including a few specialist tests. In total I’ve spent about 40k. I didn’t even bother trying with the NHS. Didn’t get any paid time off. Every single appointment was totally unpaid. I also had to have time off unpaid for my multiple miscarriages. And after all that. The 40k expense and the thousands of lost wages. I still don’t have children. And at this point will not have children. I’m not adopting or fostering. It is not for me at all. Do you actually think it’s the same as having a child of your own? 🤣 I have all the respect in the world for people who adopt or foster. The world needs more people like them. But it is not for me.
FYI, this might come as a surprise, but fertile people are also allowed to adopt and foster! It isn’t just a consolation prize for the infertile!

That's so offensive to adopted children to say "do you actually think it's the same as having a child of your own?" and laughing about it. I know couples who have adopted children-they are their children. Not everyone cares about DNA that much.

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 17:53

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 16:51

It's not hyperbole. It's been researched.

It might be outrageous to you but not to others living with it. 42% of women going through long term infertility suffer with suicidal thoughts and the depression caused by infertility is severe. Be grateful you're not in the 42% and stop shaming other women who were for being hyperbolic.

I was in the 42%. I nearly lost my career and home due to the crushing depression and constant anxiety attacks caused by living with endometriosis, infertility and repeated IVF failures.

Go fight the psychologists and researchers about their findings if you think it's that stupid. I'm not interested in arguing something that has nothing been found to be true by mental health professionals and true as my own lived experience by someone who thinks the truth is just dramatic.

New Research on Stress and Infertility | Psychology Today share.google/SqQIZgZ99mm7zMSdO

Tbh I find your response a bit hyperbolic as well. People are allowed to disagree, "lived experience" or not.

Your "research" (i.e. article) says "Current research has shown that the stress levels of women with infertility are equivalent to those with cancer" with no substantiation, no details of the measures used in the study, the sample size or comorbidities. If you call that research, I have got a bridge to sell you. The article actually describes the benefical effects of reducing stress on fertility outcomes - which makes complete sense. Tbh even it was actual research and not just trash, I am not credulous enough to believe it as "fact", because these things are inherently subjective.

FWIW I have an autistic son and apparently that means that my stress levels "are akin to those of a combat soldier" according to - presumably equally shonky - research. Yes it's stressful, but a combat soldier? Pull the other one!

My "lived experience" (🙄) of both infertility and cancer is this: one was sad and tough, the other was terrifying and physically bloody hard. I am not trying to play Top Trumps, but I really think the "we need special leave for every possible eventuality" crowd would benefit from a bit of a grip. Life has been infinitely tougher in previous generations, and remains so for many, but somehow people were more resilient and kept buggering on.

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 06/11/2026 17:38

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:38

Following cancer.
Not because you want massive breasts.
I would very much like to be taller, with straighter teeth... but no matter how much that affects my mental health the NHS isnt going to stump up is it?

But my friend wanted a baby following cancer. More than she wanted her breasts reconstructed after the double mastectomy.

why should be allowed her breast reconstruction but not allowed ivf to conceive her baby? Your argument makes no sense at all.

Skyseek · 06/11/2026 17:08

I used all my annual leave for two years on IVF. There was no work policy at that time however, my preference was not to share
details as I wanted to keep it private anyway.

I combined private and NHS treatment. You can (could?) do that though there are rules to stick to. I had my child at 41 - they were an NHS round as it happens. Over a decade on, I am beyond happy and grateful. I genuinely cannot imagine my life without the richness and joy they have brought.

people who don’t understand IVF often mistake a few things. First, despite the tv dramas it features in, it is a production line. From the scans to the egg retrieval - your bum barely touches the bed (I exaggerate but only slightly!) There is little in the way of lengthy, appointments. My NHS nurse practitioner told me that they could process many more people than got funding to proceed. The private prices (I think I paid 5k a round) are of course in excess of what it costs the NHS but present a false impression. Then there’s the age thing - it takes a long time to realise you are infertile and then get to the stage of IVF. Each IVF cycle then takes months so even women who have been lucky to find a life partner by early 30s might not discover their issues until mid to late 30s.

and yes to the many points on things the NHS pays for that are non-essential @Thwilp @SerenaCat93 have mentioned multiple examples but I will chuck in another - miscarriage investigation. What heartless person would send a woman with multiple losses on her way to get private treatment? And for good measure for those who view medicine as an exact science, what about cancer ‘treatments’ that extend life by weeks or days at vast cost? I don’t see anyone begrudging either if these things, indeed in case where NICE have limited access on cost/benefit analysis there is always public backlash. I don’t see why IVF is different.

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 16:51

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 16:27

I have had cancer and IVF. I think it's pretty outrageous to compare the two tbh. I am not aware of any studies comparing their psychological impact, and it would hardly be robust if it does exist. Some people cheerfully fly fighter planes with no legs, others call an ambo for a broken fingernail. <shrug>

I feel very fortunate to have conceived DS, but not as lucky as I do to still be here 20-odd years after my cancer diagnosis. I would far rather be alive and childless than 6 feet under, which is the realistic alternative.

I don't think the hyperbole associated with infertility does anyone any favours tbh.

It's not hyperbole. It's been researched.

It might be outrageous to you but not to others living with it. 42% of women going through long term infertility suffer with suicidal thoughts and the depression caused by infertility is severe. Be grateful you're not in the 42% and stop shaming other women who were for being hyperbolic.

I was in the 42%. I nearly lost my career and home due to the crushing depression and constant anxiety attacks caused by living with endometriosis, infertility and repeated IVF failures.

Go fight the psychologists and researchers about their findings if you think it's that stupid. I'm not interested in arguing something that has nothing been found to be true by mental health professionals and true as my own lived experience by someone who thinks the truth is just dramatic.

New Research on Stress and Infertility | Psychology Today share.google/SqQIZgZ99mm7zMSdO

Vinvertebrate · 06/11/2026 16:27

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 16:08

Just because she had cancer doesn't mean she needs breasts. She functions perfectly fine without them so according to you it shouldn't be funded.

The psychological impact of infertility has been judged as comparable to the psychological impact of cancer in studies on mental health so if the psychological impact of wanting breast implants after cancer is worthy of funding then IVF funding to alleviate the psychological impact of infertility is worth funding.

Not that this will make any sense to you though, you're clearly confused over what you think is necessary and isn't and change your mind from one moment to the next. You sound very inexperienced in life and logical debating.

I have had cancer and IVF. I think it's pretty outrageous to compare the two tbh. I am not aware of any studies comparing their psychological impact, and it would hardly be robust if it does exist. Some people cheerfully fly fighter planes with no legs, others call an ambo for a broken fingernail. <shrug>

I feel very fortunate to have conceived DS, but not as lucky as I do to still be here 20-odd years after my cancer diagnosis. I would far rather be alive and childless than 6 feet under, which is the realistic alternative.

I don't think the hyperbole associated with infertility does anyone any favours tbh.

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 16:08

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:38

Following cancer.
Not because you want massive breasts.
I would very much like to be taller, with straighter teeth... but no matter how much that affects my mental health the NHS isnt going to stump up is it?

Just because she had cancer doesn't mean she needs breasts. She functions perfectly fine without them so according to you it shouldn't be funded.

The psychological impact of infertility has been judged as comparable to the psychological impact of cancer in studies on mental health so if the psychological impact of wanting breast implants after cancer is worthy of funding then IVF funding to alleviate the psychological impact of infertility is worth funding.

Not that this will make any sense to you though, you're clearly confused over what you think is necessary and isn't and change your mind from one moment to the next. You sound very inexperienced in life and logical debating.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:56

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:38

Following cancer.
Not because you want massive breasts.
I would very much like to be taller, with straighter teeth... but no matter how much that affects my mental health the NHS isnt going to stump up is it?

Look it’s fine to just say you don’t think it should be funded full stop. You don’t need to give a reason and then try and change the reason when questioned.
You said originally the NHS should only fund life saving treatment which IVF isn’t. Then you said actually it’s fine to fund breast reconstruction following cancer as it helps people psychologically. But then said again it should only be for things that help someone function. But actually again breast reconstruction FOLLOWING CANCER is still fine even though they would be perfectly functional without one or two breasts. So really you just don’t think IVF should be funded full stop. That’s fine. I get it.

FYI though, the NHS can and does do breast implants and enlargements on people for other reasons not just cancer. Someone born with uneven breasts. They are fully functional breasts. No horrible cancer. Just born that way. You can get it fixed. In fact in some cases (albeit rarely I imagine) you can get a breast enlargement for simply psychological reasons. If you can prove it is affecting your mental health so badly etc. So yes in theory you can have breast implants simply because you want them.

MaidsRoom · 06/11/2026 15:45

Hoops123 · 06/11/2026 14:43

wow? Being infertile is very sad but it’s not the same as life saving things that the NHS needs to pay for and struggles to do so. Having children is not a right

I think in many circumstances, for many people, having children can be more important than life saving treatment.

The majority of “life saving” treatment the NHS does is for the very old. It might prolong their lives by a few years or a few months or often just a few days.

By contrast, IVF is transformative to the parents’ lives forever. Equally importantly, it creates a whole new life. Is creating a whole new life for a much longed for baby a better use of money then giving a very sick elderly person a few more weeks which they may not even want? I think it often is.

As a country we don’t have enough babies or children to be the adults of tomorrow. If we insist on investing all our resources in the end of life, and are petty and mean spirited about investing in the start of life, then we will fully deserve our inevitable decline.

MandemChickenShop · 06/11/2026 15:44

loose woman. you might as well eat a dog shit

ThisOliveKoala · 06/11/2026 15:41

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:19

Don’t worry it turns out she also started the initial part of private IVF herself before conceiving naturally. Hasn’t really given a reason why she didn’t consider adoption or fostering first other than agreeing it isn’t the same. Basically everyone else should but not her.

I did give the reason, I said it’s not the same. I never said I was against IVF on the NHS read my posts. What I am against is a special leave type for IVF treatments etc. This is what I’m questioning, who will fund this extra. The subject matter at hand is about fertility leave for those who use IVF and that is what my response pertains to.

Eg should there be special leave for Ttc? Where does it all end and taxpayers can’t keep paying for every single thing

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:38

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:36

You can function without breasts but you said that was needed to help people psychologically so that was fine?

Following cancer.
Not because you want massive breasts.
I would very much like to be taller, with straighter teeth... but no matter how much that affects my mental health the NHS isnt going to stump up is it?

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:36

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:35

We cant really leave you with cancer or a broken leg can we?
You can function without being pregnant.

You can function without breasts but you said that was needed to help people psychologically so that was fine?

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:35

thebrowncatisback · 06/11/2026 15:03

@Paganpentacle

what about cancer treatment for smokers or obese people or anyone who has substance abuse?

how about if i break my leg skiing. Is that ok cos skiing is my choice

We cant really leave you with cancer or a broken leg can we?
You can function without being pregnant.

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 15:34

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

How about a women who has to use ivf and doner eggs to conceive due to ovarian cancer? A side effect of cancer/cancer treatment. Do you see them as deserving?

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 06/11/2026 15:32

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:42

Life prolonging and risk-reduction in the main...if not 'life saving'.
Although I would argue that low-level actions such as prescribing antihypertensives ARE life saving, unless you want to die of a massive CVA.
.
Pregnancy does neither of those things...in fact it is a risk to life. .

Actually there’s evidence that pregnancy and breastfeeding are health protective for women. Pregnancy substantially reduces the risk of uterine cancer and reduces the risk of ovarian cancer. Breastfeeding is protective against the same two cancers plus offers reduced risk of breast cancer, Type 2 diabetes and hypertension.

So there is an argument that having children is also risk reduction for women’s health.

I will always remember a manager of mine who got breast cancer having been unable to have children, and an additional source of grief was being told that part of her increased risk was because she’d not been able to have them.

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 15:30

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

The psychologic impact of infertility is huge. 42% of women facing long term infertility felt suicidal and more than half of couples going through infertility divorce. It ruins lives. It's not just a "want" like wanting a cake FFS 🙄

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:19

Notasbigasithink · 06/11/2026 15:11

Wow!
You complete and utter disgrace of a human for saying that.
How dare you tell people to simply just 'adopt or foster'?!
As someone who has been through years of (self funded because apparently I didn't qualify for one single NHS round even though I've paid taxes since I was 16!) IVF that has got to be the most insensitive comment I have ever read on MN.

Don’t worry it turns out she also started the initial part of private IVF herself before conceiving naturally. Hasn’t really given a reason why she didn’t consider adoption or fostering first other than agreeing it isn’t the same. Basically everyone else should but not her.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:15

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

Ok so we’ve established it’s not actually just life saving things you think should be funded like you said. Fertility treatment could help women struggling mentally not being able to have children. Would that be ok if it helps the psychological impact of infertility? I’m going to take a stab in the dark and guess that you are still going to say no…..
Basically you think pretty much everything other than fertility treatments should be funded as they all help something and/or aren’t a choice. Infertility, despite not being a choice, should not. Got it.

Notasbigasithink · 06/11/2026 15:11

ThisOliveKoala · 05/11/2026 21:19

So who’s supposed to pay? The taxpayer again? I’m assuming most of the people are already getting IVF on the nhs. It’s a lot that is expected from public funds, yes you didn’t choose to be infertile but you can adopt, or foster. The taxpayer is already so burdened.

Wow!
You complete and utter disgrace of a human for saying that.
How dare you tell people to simply just 'adopt or foster'?!
As someone who has been through years of (self funded because apparently I didn't qualify for one single NHS round even though I've paid taxes since I was 16!) IVF that has got to be the most insensitive comment I have ever read on MN.

thebrowncatisback · 06/11/2026 15:03

@Paganpentacle

what about cancer treatment for smokers or obese people or anyone who has substance abuse?

how about if i break my leg skiing. Is that ok cos skiing is my choice

Hoops123 · 06/11/2026 14:43

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:24

Wow

wow? Being infertile is very sad but it’s not the same as life saving things that the NHS needs to pay for and struggles to do so. Having children is not a right

Swipe left for the next trending thread