Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kelly Bryant on paid fertility leave

215 replies

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:09

Did anyone see this discussion today on Loose women (I know, I know)
I found her views just so insensitive and bizarre
As someone who struggled for nine years to conceive, had multiple miscarriages, an emergency ectopic, was prodded and poked for years, three rounds of ivf, sickness and emotional upset-all whilst working full time and two jobs, it's upsetting

OP posts:
Thosedogsarenoisy · 07/11/2026 12:46

SerenaCat93 · 07/11/2026 11:50

Ok so I'm sensing minimising other people's experience is a thing.

Infertility is widely accepted as traumatic in psychiatry. The procedures were traumatic for me. Especially the egg collections that were done whilst I was awake and only mildly sedated. The miscarriages were traumatic too. I hope you don't think that trauma isn't real either as again it is well established that losing babies is traumatic. You may have not been bothered either way if it worked or not but many women are. That you can't accept that fact, or the widely accepted impact on women's mental health by mental health professionals is strange. It's literally researched, widely agreed by professionals and self reported. It's not just made up. Do you often struggle with facts?

Fertility leave is already offered by some companies, mine included, and improves employee engagement and loyalty. So you'll just have to "woman up" and accept that people are getting something you don't like.

And yes, I do think there is something wrong with someone who sees no reason to alleviate suffering and actively wants people to suffer just because previous generations did. The blatant lack of empathy is a personality flaw in my opinion which is only seen in bitter people usually.

100% agree

OP posts:
Thosedogsarenoisy · 07/11/2026 12:44

MrsShawnHatosy · 07/11/2026 10:08

You got your baby. Can you not imagine that people who went through the same journey you did but didn’t get their baby might feel differently? My experience of IVF was shit. Everything that could go wrong did. My response to the ovulation stimulation was very poor and I produced very few eggs and the ones I did, it took three weeks of two injections a day to get them ready for harvesting. We did manage to freeze a couple of embryos, but actually getting them transferred was….well, the first attempt the embryo didn’t survive the thawing. 2nd attempt, a uterine polyp was discovered at preliminary scan so had to have that removed. 3rd attempt, the drugs didn’t work properly and I started a period the day before transfer was to take place. Last attempt went smoothly but no pregnancy. Forgive me for finding all that traumatising.

So so sorry, it's a horrendous, complicated, long, heartbreaking journey for so many xx

OP posts:
Thosedogsarenoisy · 07/11/2026 12:42

StartTheBid · 07/11/2026 08:59

Kelle Bryan has been in films and other TV shows, including Hollyhoaks.

She leads a theatrical agency in London.

She doesn't come across as a good person, she's often defensive and unpleasant, I can imagine the other women struggle with her

OP posts:
Thosedogsarenoisy · 07/11/2026 12:34

Vinvertebrate · 07/11/2026 08:09

Your accusations of hyperbole, drama and fragility don't help with the misconceptions about the trauma of infertility, which is shocking considering you've actually been through it. I really can't understand what's wrong with some people.

Okay, so I’m sensing that hyperbole is your thing, so you do you. And there is nothing “wrong” with someone just because they happen to disagree with you or have a totally different experience. I walked into the IVF clinic knowing that it might not work and I was fine with either outcome. Difficulty conceiving wasn’t remotely traumatic, it was sad and difficult, but just part of life. (Cancer, on the other hand…)

Isn’t it great that we’re all different? Anyway, the idea of “fertility leave” is so not compatible with what’s going on in the job market rn, I feel fairly confident that we’ll just have to woman up for the foreseeable.

You are doing a massive disservice to many women going through ivf describing it as hyperbole, how dare you play down a very real, traumatic experience for many woman as with the poor woman you're replying to. It's fantastic that the experience wasn't that bad for you, Ive never heard any woman struggling with fertility and doing ivf describe things the way you are and being so blase about it...we need to 'Woman up?' You should be ashamed of yourself to be honest!

OP posts:
SerenaCat93 · 07/11/2026 11:50

Vinvertebrate · 07/11/2026 08:09

Your accusations of hyperbole, drama and fragility don't help with the misconceptions about the trauma of infertility, which is shocking considering you've actually been through it. I really can't understand what's wrong with some people.

Okay, so I’m sensing that hyperbole is your thing, so you do you. And there is nothing “wrong” with someone just because they happen to disagree with you or have a totally different experience. I walked into the IVF clinic knowing that it might not work and I was fine with either outcome. Difficulty conceiving wasn’t remotely traumatic, it was sad and difficult, but just part of life. (Cancer, on the other hand…)

Isn’t it great that we’re all different? Anyway, the idea of “fertility leave” is so not compatible with what’s going on in the job market rn, I feel fairly confident that we’ll just have to woman up for the foreseeable.

Ok so I'm sensing minimising other people's experience is a thing.

Infertility is widely accepted as traumatic in psychiatry. The procedures were traumatic for me. Especially the egg collections that were done whilst I was awake and only mildly sedated. The miscarriages were traumatic too. I hope you don't think that trauma isn't real either as again it is well established that losing babies is traumatic. You may have not been bothered either way if it worked or not but many women are. That you can't accept that fact, or the widely accepted impact on women's mental health by mental health professionals is strange. It's literally researched, widely agreed by professionals and self reported. It's not just made up. Do you often struggle with facts?

Fertility leave is already offered by some companies, mine included, and improves employee engagement and loyalty. So you'll just have to "woman up" and accept that people are getting something you don't like.

And yes, I do think there is something wrong with someone who sees no reason to alleviate suffering and actively wants people to suffer just because previous generations did. The blatant lack of empathy is a personality flaw in my opinion which is only seen in bitter people usually.

MrsShawnHatosy · 07/11/2026 10:08

Vinvertebrate · 07/11/2026 08:09

Your accusations of hyperbole, drama and fragility don't help with the misconceptions about the trauma of infertility, which is shocking considering you've actually been through it. I really can't understand what's wrong with some people.

Okay, so I’m sensing that hyperbole is your thing, so you do you. And there is nothing “wrong” with someone just because they happen to disagree with you or have a totally different experience. I walked into the IVF clinic knowing that it might not work and I was fine with either outcome. Difficulty conceiving wasn’t remotely traumatic, it was sad and difficult, but just part of life. (Cancer, on the other hand…)

Isn’t it great that we’re all different? Anyway, the idea of “fertility leave” is so not compatible with what’s going on in the job market rn, I feel fairly confident that we’ll just have to woman up for the foreseeable.

You got your baby. Can you not imagine that people who went through the same journey you did but didn’t get their baby might feel differently? My experience of IVF was shit. Everything that could go wrong did. My response to the ovulation stimulation was very poor and I produced very few eggs and the ones I did, it took three weeks of two injections a day to get them ready for harvesting. We did manage to freeze a couple of embryos, but actually getting them transferred was….well, the first attempt the embryo didn’t survive the thawing. 2nd attempt, a uterine polyp was discovered at preliminary scan so had to have that removed. 3rd attempt, the drugs didn’t work properly and I started a period the day before transfer was to take place. Last attempt went smoothly but no pregnancy. Forgive me for finding all that traumatising.

StartTheBid · 07/11/2026 08:59

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · 06/11/2026 09:36

I haven't seen her name since she was kicked out of Eternal in the late 90s. I had to open the thread just to check if it was the same person.

Kelle Bryan has been in films and other TV shows, including Hollyhoaks.

She leads a theatrical agency in London.

Bushmillsbabe · 07/11/2026 08:27

Firefly1987 · 06/11/2026 23:45

How do adult adoptees know it's not the same? They have nothing to compare it to. Neither does someone who hasn't adopted OR had their own child yet is convinced they're not the same. You don't love an adopted child any less, they are not any less your child. Although I suppose if someone would rather be childless than adopt then at least they're being honest about being unfit to be an adoptive parent. Especially when they call it a "consolation prize"...

It is different though. My brother and SIL adopted a 5 year old boy. Through the 'foster to adopt' period and even now,he has to be taken to see his birth mother 3 times a year, his birth father 3 times, his maternal and paternal grandparents each a couple times too. it takes a few days each time to get him back on track. There was a lot of trauma and he is much more settled than when they first met him, but every visit takes him backwards, and he is torn between his biological family and his new family. It is hard for them, knowing that a part of their son is always reaching towards his biological family, he looks like them, talks like them, acts like them, and I know my SIL in particular finds them traumatic, and finds it hard taking her son to do something she feels is harmful. But it's court ordered, they have no choice.

mtobrokeme · 07/11/2026 08:13

ThisOliveKoala · 05/11/2026 21:19

So who’s supposed to pay? The taxpayer again? I’m assuming most of the people are already getting IVF on the nhs. It’s a lot that is expected from public funds, yes you didn’t choose to be infertile but you can adopt, or foster. The taxpayer is already so burdened.

’I’m assuming most people are already getting IVF on the NHS’

Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha.

Vinvertebrate · 07/11/2026 08:09

Your accusations of hyperbole, drama and fragility don't help with the misconceptions about the trauma of infertility, which is shocking considering you've actually been through it. I really can't understand what's wrong with some people.

Okay, so I’m sensing that hyperbole is your thing, so you do you. And there is nothing “wrong” with someone just because they happen to disagree with you or have a totally different experience. I walked into the IVF clinic knowing that it might not work and I was fine with either outcome. Difficulty conceiving wasn’t remotely traumatic, it was sad and difficult, but just part of life. (Cancer, on the other hand…)

Isn’t it great that we’re all different? Anyway, the idea of “fertility leave” is so not compatible with what’s going on in the job market rn, I feel fairly confident that we’ll just have to woman up for the foreseeable.

SerenaCat93 · 07/11/2026 06:58

Firefly1987 · 06/11/2026 23:45

How do adult adoptees know it's not the same? They have nothing to compare it to. Neither does someone who hasn't adopted OR had their own child yet is convinced they're not the same. You don't love an adopted child any less, they are not any less your child. Although I suppose if someone would rather be childless than adopt then at least they're being honest about being unfit to be an adoptive parent. Especially when they call it a "consolation prize"...

Oh for goodness sake. Adoptees often struggle with wondering what their birth family is like if they didn't know them. They often struggle with knowing they're not related to their parents and wonder where they get their traits from. There's often guilt about wondering these things because they don't want to hurt their adoptive parents. They often struggle with feelings of abandonment if they were given up, distress if they were taken or grief if their parents died. There are often attachment issues and childhood trauma that affects them for life.

Adoptees aren't stupid enough to not know any different 🙄 To repeatedly state there's no difference is minimising their struggles.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 07/11/2026 06:44

I don't think fertility leave should be a separate thing as such because i think it should fall within the bracket of sick leave, same as anything else. But I think time off for medical appointments should be permitted regardless of the nature of the appointment, I don't think its fair that a pregnancy appointment gets special leave but a colonoscopy is a holiday day. No one should be using up holiday days for medical appointments. I think there should be 2 days a year leave for health related issues (dental, bloods, etc) and more if someone has a condition where they need to see a specialist, which needs to be documented of course.

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 07/11/2026 05:46

Firefly1987 · 06/11/2026 23:45

How do adult adoptees know it's not the same? They have nothing to compare it to. Neither does someone who hasn't adopted OR had their own child yet is convinced they're not the same. You don't love an adopted child any less, they are not any less your child. Although I suppose if someone would rather be childless than adopt then at least they're being honest about being unfit to be an adoptive parent. Especially when they call it a "consolation prize"...

What? Give your head a wobble. Of course the experience of an adopted child is different, not least because they’ve suffered the loss of their birth parent. How does an amputee know that going through life without a leg is different to having both legs?

Adoption isn’t (usually) picking up a cute newborn to take home, it’s quite often taking on a toddler exposed to alcohol in pregnancy, or early exposure to neglect or violence, and fighting for scarce provision of the additional psychological and health needs that may mean. The average age of a child at their adoption is about 4.

It is a completely different kettle of fish (in many cases) to raising children you’ve birthed yourself, and frankly often much harder. Adoptive parents are special people and there is no shame in saying it’s not a life you would choose.

Firefly1987 · 06/11/2026 23:45

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 18:19

It's not the same though. For either the parents or the children. Speaking to adult adoptees Will tell you that.

How do adult adoptees know it's not the same? They have nothing to compare it to. Neither does someone who hasn't adopted OR had their own child yet is convinced they're not the same. You don't love an adopted child any less, they are not any less your child. Although I suppose if someone would rather be childless than adopt then at least they're being honest about being unfit to be an adoptive parent. Especially when they call it a "consolation prize"...

DoreenCorkhill · 06/11/2026 22:40

Terrible program
Don’t watch it
Simply ghastly .

Apotofrealcoffee · 06/11/2026 22:39

I think the issue is, when does it end? I’m currently following someone online who is on her 9th round of IVF, who is vowing to continue until she has a baby. If fertility leave was implemented for all IVF appointments, she would barely be at work - not in the least as her clinic is overseas so she’s constantly flying back and forth (a lot of people do donor egg abroad now).

She’s also campaigning for IVF to be extended across the NHS, which I disagree with.

Perhaps a finite number of days per year could be agreeable.

FireworksFuckOff · 06/11/2026 22:38

MandemChickenShop · 06/11/2026 15:44

loose woman. you might as well eat a dog shit

Ha, I was going to put it differently, but this covers it.

This woman is irrelevant. Some has been singer in a crap group now desperately trying to stay relevant and willing to say whatever is necessary to do that. Her opinion is worthless.

goingtotown · 06/11/2026 22:32

Disgusted with Kelly Bryant’s opinion. She should apologise to those going through IVF.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 21:51

Soontobe60 · 06/11/2026 20:55

Neither infertility nor cancer is a choice (depending on the reason for the infertility - a man who has a vasectomy or a woman who has her fallopian tubes tied have both made a choice) The result of each of those conditions if left untreated is not the same.

No one said it was the same. That wasn’t the point.

Thosedogsarenoisy · 06/11/2026 21:29

Benjithedog · 06/11/2026 11:54

I am so hoping you got your baby

Yes 💓

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 06/11/2026 20:55

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 18:55

That wasn’t the discussion though. I was responding to someone who said IVF is a choice and cancer is not. I was trying to point out that infertility is also not a choice. That is all. It wasn’t about which one was most worthy of NHS funds. It simply a debate about whether funding should be given on whether something is a choice or not.

Neither infertility nor cancer is a choice (depending on the reason for the infertility - a man who has a vasectomy or a woman who has her fallopian tubes tied have both made a choice) The result of each of those conditions if left untreated is not the same.

Skyseek · 06/11/2026 19:25

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 18:55

That wasn’t the discussion though. I was responding to someone who said IVF is a choice and cancer is not. I was trying to point out that infertility is also not a choice. That is all. It wasn’t about which one was most worthy of NHS funds. It simply a debate about whether funding should be given on whether something is a choice or not.

Well, number one, it’s not a competition between cancer and ivf - I don’t know why people always pull that one out. I mean we
dont think hmm what should we choose corrective surgery for scoliosis or a heart bypass? You’d think an ivf cycle is robbing a cancer patients it really isn’t. Number two, medical outcomes are poorly understood. lots of treatments have poor outcomes. Cancer treatments don’t save or not save. In fact I read something depressing recently that early diagnosis of cancers is what extends the figures on life expectancy after diagnosis ie people aren’t living longer with cancer per se, they are living longer with a cancer diagnosis.

on adoption/fostering of course it isn’t the same. The best way I heard to describe this was that adoption is about finding
families for children, not finding children for families. And that sums it up for me. It is as it should be.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 18:55

Soontobe60 · 06/11/2026 18:36

Infertility isn’t a choice. But the treatment, IVF, is.
Cancer isn’t a choice. But having the treatment, chemo, is

@Thwilp Which one has a high chance of resulting in the death of the person?

Edited

That wasn’t the discussion though. I was responding to someone who said IVF is a choice and cancer is not. I was trying to point out that infertility is also not a choice. That is all. It wasn’t about which one was most worthy of NHS funds. It simply a debate about whether funding should be given on whether something is a choice or not.

Soontobe60 · 06/11/2026 18:36

Infertility isn’t a choice. But the treatment, IVF, is.
Cancer isn’t a choice. But having the treatment, chemo, is

@Thwilp Which one has a high chance of resulting in the death of the person?

Soontobe60 · 06/11/2026 18:32

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 22:01

Every unfortunate circumstance?
It's a medical condition, which also causes huge psychological stress to many women
We get sick leave for all sorts of conditions

Not necessarily paid sick leave. And employers can, and do, dismiss employees who take extended sick leave.
The question should be is there comparator between a person who has been diagnosed with cancer, for example, and someone who is unable to have a child. At a most basic level, one is likely to result in death if left untreated, one isn’t. Having needed fertility treatment in order to conceive, I absolutely do understand the pain of not getting / maintaining a pregnancy to full term.
The debate is far too complex and emotive to be able to debate with any degree of impartiality on a daytime TV chat show though.