Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to let the kids go their own christening?

219 replies

ProudMamaBear92 · 05/11/2026 20:51

So long story short I’m not religious but from a Christian background. DH is not from UK but is Christian orthodox family. Though rarely ever goes to church nor lives a devout life 😑.

he wants to christen the kids, I’d rather not but said if it’s important to him he can, I’ll go along with it. He can organise it as it’s something he wants, but my ONLY stipulation is no undressing and submersion of the kids.

We went to a nephews christening and the poor boy was publicly stripped naked and dunked in a barrel. I found it horrifying to watch and the child was inconsolable for a long while after. I disagree with it massively, it feels humiliating and a bit abusive to me.

Next year a cousin of DH is getting married abroad and the whole huge family is going. BIL and DH want to christen all the kids together, we have two they have two. Sure, makes sense. Bride is fine with us piggybacking her wedding week I did check with her.

They are insisting on orthodox ceremony, fine, but I’m insisting the priest mustn’t strip and dunk my kids.

They said maybe he will?! I’m repeating myself with this and just kind of getting shrugged off. There’s a language barrier also to work around and I feel I’m left out of the conversations ALOT. DH will never disagree with his brother, or his dad. History has proven it.

If they don’t take my wishes seriously, AIBUto just refuse to let the kids go full stop? Take the passports and refuse to let them leave the UK? Or just cause a massive scene at the christening?? What do I do??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheJoyousBiscuit · 15/11/2026 13:33

EmeraldShamrock000 · 13/11/2026 19:00

Have you read the thread? Or even OP’s replies?

Yes I have have u I’m just saying that in my denomination that’s how it’s done it’s completely normal people just have to stop focusing on the social norm and what god wants them to do I just want them to say that being baptised is a huge commitment u must go at least every Sunday at least where I’m from so compromise if u don’t want that!

LavenderSweetPea · 13/11/2026 19:13

I've been to an orthodox baptism. It was a full submersion affair but the child was wearing some kind of white robe thing. They were also old enough to get into the pool and dunk themselves without assistance so they weren't being forced under the water or anything awful like that. I'd absolutely not allow my child to be naked in front of strangers or forced under the water, sounds horrific.

DraigCymraeg · 13/11/2026 19:12

ProudMamaBear92 · 05/11/2026 20:51

So long story short I’m not religious but from a Christian background. DH is not from UK but is Christian orthodox family. Though rarely ever goes to church nor lives a devout life 😑.

he wants to christen the kids, I’d rather not but said if it’s important to him he can, I’ll go along with it. He can organise it as it’s something he wants, but my ONLY stipulation is no undressing and submersion of the kids.

We went to a nephews christening and the poor boy was publicly stripped naked and dunked in a barrel. I found it horrifying to watch and the child was inconsolable for a long while after. I disagree with it massively, it feels humiliating and a bit abusive to me.

Next year a cousin of DH is getting married abroad and the whole huge family is going. BIL and DH want to christen all the kids together, we have two they have two. Sure, makes sense. Bride is fine with us piggybacking her wedding week I did check with her.

They are insisting on orthodox ceremony, fine, but I’m insisting the priest mustn’t strip and dunk my kids.

They said maybe he will?! I’m repeating myself with this and just kind of getting shrugged off. There’s a language barrier also to work around and I feel I’m left out of the conversations ALOT. DH will never disagree with his brother, or his dad. History has proven it.

If they don’t take my wishes seriously, AIBUto just refuse to let the kids go full stop? Take the passports and refuse to let them leave the UK? Or just cause a massive scene at the christening?? What do I do??

I've never heard of such a thing in recent times. Naked baptism for Christians stopped in the Middle Ages.
Even if the baptism is a full immersion folk are clothed - you need to double check the facts.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 13/11/2026 19:00

TheJoyousBiscuit · 13/11/2026 18:46

Bruh it’s not horrible normally at least on my church when kids get the sacrament of reconciliation they wear this white kinda jumpsuit thing so maybe u could ask about ur kids wearing something like that. Do u want them to be bapsited? Communicate with ur husband, simple

Have you read the thread? Or even OP’s replies?

TheJoyousBiscuit · 13/11/2026 18:46

Bruh it’s not horrible normally at least on my church when kids get the sacrament of reconciliation they wear this white kinda jumpsuit thing so maybe u could ask about ur kids wearing something like that. Do u want them to be bapsited? Communicate with ur husband, simple

FunPartyIdeas · 08/11/2026 19:14

Meadowfinch · 06/11/2026 10:10

That is no difficulty at all. Unless there is agreement, it shouldn't happen. End of.

Unfortunately it doesn't work like that. An example: I consented to my young sons having the flu vaccine. My ex-husband said no.
So the school nurse couldn't vaccinate.

Mischance · 07/11/2026 08:43

Well done for standing your ground.

Chilihealer · 07/11/2026 07:39

ProudMamaBear92 · 06/11/2026 20:28

This!
We’ve had a catch up tonight about it and he’s being very open. Said he won’t do it if I am so opposed to it as I explained very clearly how I feel. I asked him if he would strip me naked without consent kicking and screaming in front of his family and he answered ‘no’, so that’s settled for now.

im still not convinced that his family won’t try to steer it their way but we will see. I will absolutely then just lose the passports.

Absolutely OP you protect yours, don’t let crack pot in-laws bully you or your children. DH should be keeping them inline his self but if he can’t find his spine you do what you need to do!

mathanxiety · 07/11/2026 00:55

Wooky073 · 07/11/2026 00:24

I’d remove the issue by arranging it here in uk yourself. Think of it as a functional thing to protect your children from the terrible (questionable) ceremony abroad. Or it doesn’t need to be a big thing. For Christian church if England christenings it’s part of a service and the church arrange it all. You just need to make the enquiries, agree the date, let close family know in case they want to come, make sure they have smart clothes then book a family meal after. It do t be too much effort to do and I’d rather put the energy into that than energy into worrying about loosing control of events abroad.

Tell me you slept through RE without telling me you slept through RE.

Wooky073 · 07/11/2026 00:24

I’d remove the issue by arranging it here in uk yourself. Think of it as a functional thing to protect your children from the terrible (questionable) ceremony abroad. Or it doesn’t need to be a big thing. For Christian church if England christenings it’s part of a service and the church arrange it all. You just need to make the enquiries, agree the date, let close family know in case they want to come, make sure they have smart clothes then book a family meal after. It do t be too much effort to do and I’d rather put the energy into that than energy into worrying about loosing control of events abroad.

ProudMamaBear92 · 06/11/2026 20:38

Mischance · 06/11/2026 13:52

You can objectively state whether this is right or wrong, if only because the church in question seems to be above UK law in this matter.

Is it legal to take off a child's clothing in front of a group of adults and then submerge this child in water? Assault, child exploitation etc.

Because swathes of humanity do this does not make it acceptable just because religion invokes some sort of special pleading in these matters which bizarrely the law turns a blind eye to.

Take out the religious element and ask yourself if these activities are lawful. Or chopping bits off a child's genitals by an unqualified person for no medical reason.

We have to tackle religious practices that are otherwise outside the law - they cannot go on getting away with all this. It horrifies me.

Hard agree

OP posts:
ProudMamaBear92 · 06/11/2026 20:35

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 05/11/2026 22:53

yoh could just organize your own christening here then it’s done

This has crossed my mind. The reason I didn’t is I’m not Christian so it’s not really something I’m keen on doing for them myself, and also, I’m 100% default parent and work full time, and I barely have time to brush my teeth let alone organise a christening I don’t want.

OP posts:
ProudMamaBear92 · 06/11/2026 20:28

Chilihealer · 05/11/2026 22:02

To add if ‘D’H is adamant that this should happen maybe suggest him also getting naked infront of everyone and hopping in too as a refresh for all the in Christian shit he’s done over the years!

This!
We’ve had a catch up tonight about it and he’s being very open. Said he won’t do it if I am so opposed to it as I explained very clearly how I feel. I asked him if he would strip me naked without consent kicking and screaming in front of his family and he answered ‘no’, so that’s settled for now.

im still not convinced that his family won’t try to steer it their way but we will see. I will absolutely then just lose the passports.

OP posts:
GoldenGail · 06/11/2026 19:57

Papyrophile · 05/11/2026 21:19

It doesn't really qualify as abuse to dunk the child in water surely.... it's a bath? Do they have to be held down and half-drowned?

To be stripped naked in public???? These aren’t babies!

MMUmum · 06/11/2026 18:44

wishfulthinking25 · 05/11/2026 21:00

There is no way I’d allow my kids to be stripped naked by a stranger and dunked in water, not a chance. I’m catholic so baptism’s typically happen a few months after birth but the priest just puts holy water on the child’s forehead no matter the age they decide to be baptised. How old are your kids?

My Dd was Christened at 6 months with a simple head wetting ceremony during morning service, I have never come across anything more extreme for children

MMUmum · 06/11/2026 18:40

ProudMamaBear92 · 05/11/2026 20:51

So long story short I’m not religious but from a Christian background. DH is not from UK but is Christian orthodox family. Though rarely ever goes to church nor lives a devout life 😑.

he wants to christen the kids, I’d rather not but said if it’s important to him he can, I’ll go along with it. He can organise it as it’s something he wants, but my ONLY stipulation is no undressing and submersion of the kids.

We went to a nephews christening and the poor boy was publicly stripped naked and dunked in a barrel. I found it horrifying to watch and the child was inconsolable for a long while after. I disagree with it massively, it feels humiliating and a bit abusive to me.

Next year a cousin of DH is getting married abroad and the whole huge family is going. BIL and DH want to christen all the kids together, we have two they have two. Sure, makes sense. Bride is fine with us piggybacking her wedding week I did check with her.

They are insisting on orthodox ceremony, fine, but I’m insisting the priest mustn’t strip and dunk my kids.

They said maybe he will?! I’m repeating myself with this and just kind of getting shrugged off. There’s a language barrier also to work around and I feel I’m left out of the conversations ALOT. DH will never disagree with his brother, or his dad. History has proven it.

If they don’t take my wishes seriously, AIBUto just refuse to let the kids go full stop? Take the passports and refuse to let them leave the UK? Or just cause a massive scene at the christening?? What do I do??

I agree it's abusive, totally humiliating and cruel to the children. I've heard of total immersion, fully clothed, for adults but never children, I would never consent to this

Monty36 · 06/11/2026 18:31

theadultsaretalking · 06/11/2026 18:14

I was not implying that you were saying it - sorry if it came across as accusatory.

It's more of a general point about how easy it is to dismiss something culturally unfamiliar as weird or wrong, and it is indeed on parents to make sure children understand and are prepared.

But it should be on both parents to understand each other's cultures and want to learn and adapt - and I am speaking from experience here.

Well, in the OP’s case you can view that from her perspective as much as from his.
The issue they both have to attend to is that the children are raised here. Not somewhere else. And if how they are raised means they are unfamiliar with this, they have to reflect on whether or not to go ahead with it.

theadultsaretalking · 06/11/2026 18:14

Monty36 · 06/11/2026 17:14

I am not saying they should not be aware of, nor connected to their heritage. Of course they should. So please do not suggest it.

I am saying that if this ceremony is not something they will be familiar with here then it may well be an issue. If they are not, it will not be a normal thing they expect to happen. Which I think the parents should think about and reflect on. And if it is something they are utterly unfamiliar with you cannot suddenly make it so. Cultural heritage or not.

I was, ( perhaps incorrectly), assuming it was not something they have grown up with.

If not, I think the parents should either ensure they become more familiar with it , or seriously think again about it. Especially if their children are older.

Edited

I was not implying that you were saying it - sorry if it came across as accusatory.

It's more of a general point about how easy it is to dismiss something culturally unfamiliar as weird or wrong, and it is indeed on parents to make sure children understand and are prepared.

But it should be on both parents to understand each other's cultures and want to learn and adapt - and I am speaking from experience here.

JuliaMaesa · 06/11/2026 17:19

SixtySomething · 06/11/2026 16:36

Because of the language they use.

When the language used is (quotes OP)

We went to a nephews christening and the poor boy was publicly stripped naked and dunked in a barrel.

Then I refuse to be guilted into #BeKind.

Monty36 · 06/11/2026 17:14

theadultsaretalking · 06/11/2026 16:54

I think this is really tricky territory.

Again, I am not saying that the right way is to give in to something you are not comfortable with, but I think it is important to remember that while the children are being brought up in the UK, they are from a mixed cultural background, and it is a shame to deny them that.

It is so easy to default to "this is how we do things here", but I think it's nice to be mindful that they are already being shaped by their local environment, which is only a part of their identity.

I am not saying they should not be aware of, nor connected to their heritage. Of course they should. So please do not suggest it.

I am saying that if this ceremony is not something they will be familiar with here then it may well be an issue. If they are not, it will not be a normal thing they expect to happen. Which I think the parents should think about and reflect on. And if it is something they are utterly unfamiliar with you cannot suddenly make it so. Cultural heritage or not.

I was, ( perhaps incorrectly), assuming it was not something they have grown up with.

If not, I think the parents should either ensure they become more familiar with it , or seriously think again about it. Especially if their children are older.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/11/2026 16:58

Did we ever find out where this is? Which country and area of that country?

Would help with people giving the right advice re what is actually done in said country, whether the relevant church is represented much in the UK and if a UK priest can be spoken to for advice etc

OP seems to have departed a long time ago.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/11/2026 16:55

theadultsaretalking · 06/11/2026 11:36

Again, I am not sure whether the OP has actually discussed this specific baptism with anyone organising it.

Common practice is not to strip toddlers naked, as that wouldn't be appropriate; they usually wear a swimsuit. Not many are fully immersed either, as the tubs are often too small for that. They usually stand in a basin of sorts while the priest pours water on them, but that depends on the priest and the church and is up for discussion with parents.

The actual water process is super quick - even with babies, they are usually held by the parents/godparents until they are ready, then undressed very quickly for a quick triple dunk in warm water and straight into a towel. There is usually an option to avoid immersion even for babies.

Now, if the OP doesn't want to baptise her children, that is another discussion to be had with her husband.

From this thread it seems like it varies massively between different orthodox churches and different countries.

theadultsaretalking · 06/11/2026 16:54

Monty36 · 06/11/2026 16:08

It is not something your children would understand. If they lived amongst your DH’s family abroad then it would be ‘the norm’ there. And your children would be far more able to accept it.
But your children don’t. So it will seem wrong in so many ways.

You have to assert yourself and your opinion. And explain it.

I think this is really tricky territory.

Again, I am not saying that the right way is to give in to something you are not comfortable with, but I think it is important to remember that while the children are being brought up in the UK, they are from a mixed cultural background, and it is a shame to deny them that.

It is so easy to default to "this is how we do things here", but I think it's nice to be mindful that they are already being shaped by their local environment, which is only a part of their identity.

SixtySomething · 06/11/2026 16:36

takealettermsjones · 06/11/2026 10:47

Why are you assuming those criticising are ignorant?

Because of the language they use.

Mischance · 06/11/2026 16:12

I have no problem with faiths... I get that they mean a lot to some people.
I have no problem with rituals that bring families and communities together.

I do have a problem with organised religions acting outside the law that applies to everyone else. Or acting in ways that make others feel uncomfortable.

I also have a problem with a parent being manipulated into something that she is not happy with for her children ... all in the name of the special pleading reserved for religion.