Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just failed a pre-interview assessment to work in a supermarket

434 replies

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:06

I just failed an M&S assessment. You know the kind: where you've got a multiple choice situation and you've got to say what you would be most likely and least likely to do.
Also failed assessments for civil service.

I don't understand. I like to think I'm a pretty capable person with a lot of life and work experience, good with people, pretty canny. So why do I keep failing these tasks? 😂 Often the options in the multiple choice questions all sound pretty damn similar to me.

OP posts:
Gingernaut · 05/11/2026 21:07

I keep failing the one for Aldi

I try every year too

ExpressCheckout · 05/11/2026 21:08

Online questionnaires are just used to reduce 200+ applications down to a handful, but make it appear to be a objective and non-discriminatory process.

Employers have made rods for their own backs by having online application processes. Going back to hand-written applications (not typed) sent by post is the obvious solution. Or a sign in the window.

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 21:08

Gingernaut · 05/11/2026 21:07

I keep failing the one for Aldi

I try every year too

I really hope you come back to this thread and let us know when you eventually make it!

OP posts:
OhWhatToDoAboutThis · 05/11/2026 21:11

I also failed a test like that multiple times for boots. I was trying to get a part time job/seasonal work during uni. I now have a masters degree and a professional job but clearly I’m not capable of figuring out how to work a till.
there must be something I’m missing. But unless you had your heart set on a job in retail I wouldn’t worry about it. I did get a job in sainsburys though. Maybe try there. Their customer service must be worse if they employed me 😂

icecreamscreams · 05/11/2026 21:11

Whocanbelieveit · 05/11/2026 20:26

Surely you call the fire brigade first, then let your team mates know so between you you can evacuate the store.

I mean in real life you would probably hit the fire alarm break glass, say FIRE to a team mate and ring 999 whilst evacuating people so all at once?

CarryOnRewardless · 05/11/2026 21:12

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:17

Like "you are supposed to be photocopying something but new recruit Dave has asked for help with one of his tasks. What do you do?"

Well it depends. How urgent is the photocopying? Is Dave taking the piss?

Possible answers:

  • You tell Dave you will be with him in a minute and finish photocopying
  • You drop the photocopying and help Dave
  • You ask Dave to ask a different colleague

It fucking depends really doesnt it? 😂
Or:

  • You tell Dave you will be with him in a minute and finish photocopying
  • You ask Dave to do his best and will help him as soon as you can
  • You encourage Dave to complete his task and explain you have to do photocopying

Is that not the exact same fucking action?

Tell Dave to fuck off 🤣🤣

Whattodo4best · 05/11/2026 21:13

glendabrownlow · 05/11/2026 20:22

Many years ago when I was still a teenager, I thought I'd get a stop gap kind of job while I looked around for something better. I had this similar kind of interview for Woolworths (all multiple choice crap) and I failed! For bloody Woolworths! I felt so insulted.

On the way out of the interviewer's office, I saw the women on the shop floor all watching me with bitchy looks on their faces and arms folded, so I suspect that they would have had it in for me if I had got the job, because at the time I was much younger than them.

You had a lucky escape at Woolworths. I passed the assessment when I was 16, got the job.

First day, I was given an old employee’s name badge as they “wouldn’t waste money on a name badge for someone who hasn’t completed their probation” and then given a bucket of turps to clean the windows with once I’d removed the massive posters to get rid of the poster glue.

After spending all day with gloveless hands elbow deep in turps ruining my nails, I handed back my uniform and Barbara’s name badge and told them to stuff it.

Legoandloldolls · 05/11/2026 21:13

Yet when you actually get a job they baseline you against a doorknob. Eg working with kids these are the type of safeguarding questions we have on the job

Bob tells you at the end of day he doesn't want to go home as his stepdaughter shouts at him. Do you

A) wave Bob off. Traitors is on tonight
B) do nothing as someone else will deal with it
C) go to the pub and tell the dsl when you next remember
D) make sure Bob doesn't go home and tell the dsl urgently

VioletMatilda · 05/11/2026 21:14

I failed one once. There were several questions which had to be answered following the STAR method. (Situation, Task, Action and Result). One question was about identifying and contacting the local vicar for community liaison. I completely forgot about the STAR method and simply replied - "The local vicar is my husband."

Failed the test on the basis that I wouldn't be able to identify and contact my husband.

MagnoliaParks · 05/11/2026 21:16

Whocanbelieveit · 05/11/2026 20:26

Surely you call the fire brigade first, then let your team mates know so between you you can evacuate the store.

If you woke up and your house was on fire, would you stay in bed ringing 999, then tell your husband then get the kids out?

Pfpppl · 05/11/2026 21:16

I ended up doing these for my son last year when he was looking for a temp Xmas job as a just turned 16 year old. The recruitment process is the same for 8 hours a week for a month as it is for a permanent manager role!

How they expect anyone looking for a first job to pass these tests is beyond me. Surely you get training when you start?!

He managed to pass Aldi but he then failed the group interview. I passed the Next one for him, but every job he applied for (they had loads of roles going with different shifts) he was rejected without even an interview. I then applied to Next myself this year and didn't get an interview either. It's soul destroying.

And I agree most of the questions are bloody stupid and not based on real life. And then you go into the shops, get crap service and wonder how they hell they settled on the staff they did 😂

SanctusInDistress · 05/11/2026 21:23

Whattodo4best · 05/11/2026 21:13

You had a lucky escape at Woolworths. I passed the assessment when I was 16, got the job.

First day, I was given an old employee’s name badge as they “wouldn’t waste money on a name badge for someone who hasn’t completed their probation” and then given a bucket of turps to clean the windows with once I’d removed the massive posters to get rid of the poster glue.

After spending all day with gloveless hands elbow deep in turps ruining my nails, I handed back my uniform and Barbara’s name badge and told them to stuff it.

My first day of a new job, on my desk was a box of personal possessions. They were from my predecesor. Who had passed. Hence why there was a job opening to which I had applied. In the box was a pair of sandals. I’ve never felt more profoundly sad that when I looked at that pair of sandals after being told whose box that was. I still think of those sandals sometimes. I think I was expected to ‘do something about it’. I put the box on tbe floor by my side. One day it was gone.

Howaboutthis1 · 05/11/2026 21:24

I worked in a job through an agency for 6 years. When a job came up I applied via the company, did the most difficult mind boggling series of ridiculous timed questions and failed. I didn't get a job that I was already doing! And had been for the previous 6 years!!
Others applied, for most of them English wasnt their first language but still got employed! I was gobsmacked, as the questions were so difficult. Turns out they applied via the agency ( along with many others with English as first language) and didn't have the questions and were interviewed by their current employers ! I was a fool to try via the company.
I carried on working with the agency til I found a job with no nonsense interview process!

ForgottenPasswordNewAccount · 05/11/2026 21:27

I failed the civil service entry level but passed the middle management one in the top 5.

Who knows what they want!

Overflowingbasket · 05/11/2026 21:31

Fuck me, this thread is making me really worried for my kids. How is it so hard to get a job now? When I was looking for minimum wage ( not that I think there was a minimum wage then 🧐.) retail job about 30-35 years ago, I just took a print out of my work experience and walked the streets handing it out to managers until I got a job. One shop ( Haagen dasz) did a group assessment thing over a couple of hours, but nowhere else did anything like that. Some places took me on on the spot, others it was a brief interview.

MrsMoastyToasty · 05/11/2026 21:38

I failed an interview for a job with CAB. It was for a role that was identical to and funded by the same funder who had funded my previous charity sector role.

Gengha · 05/11/2026 21:39

Clairey1986 · 05/11/2026 20:17

Is the answer to this not teammates then between you, you call 999 and evacuate customers (and yourselves)?

Would imagine the “right” answer is always teamwork or cautious - keeps corp happy right?

The answer in any online modules is always “raise the alarm” so this could be all of them!

LandSsmum · 05/11/2026 21:41

I’ve failed every single test like this I’ve ever done. Still got by in life but not in big chains/orgs

Redpaisley · 05/11/2026 21:41

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:12

The questions are also like:
A fire has broken out. What do you do first?

  • Evacuate clients
  • Call the fire brigade
  • Let your teammates know"
I'd actually do all three simultaneously FFS

But you can’t do all 3 at once.

Evacuate clients should be first.

DoggerelBank · 05/11/2026 21:44

I failed that one too. Spent too long thinking about the answers and didn't finish the whole thing. It seems to be a test of detailed reading comprehension - surprising that that's what makes a good M&S employee, but I guess they know better than me...

Nottoobadreally · 05/11/2026 21:45

On the m&s one, customer always comes first unless a safety hazard. E.g. something on the floor, remove hazard, help customer. Also, these things like strong answers at both ends, not the middle options. E.g. if between whether you like helping people all the time, most of the time, some of the time, not at all- put all.

LIZS · 05/11/2026 21:45

After my nephew failed one at 18 my dbro and sil both of whom have decades of retail experience each tried it and also failed! Dbro spoke to hr at his branch then dn got an interview for a pt role and was taken on. AI filtering of applicants is all very well but clearly flawed. DD recently had similar issue with Next for a seasonal role but got a better paid offer from another retailer.

Redpaisley · 05/11/2026 21:45

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:17

Like "you are supposed to be photocopying something but new recruit Dave has asked for help with one of his tasks. What do you do?"

Well it depends. How urgent is the photocopying? Is Dave taking the piss?

Possible answers:

  • You tell Dave you will be with him in a minute and finish photocopying
  • You drop the photocopying and help Dave
  • You ask Dave to ask a different colleague

It fucking depends really doesnt it? 😂
Or:

  • You tell Dave you will be with him in a minute and finish photocopying
  • You ask Dave to do his best and will help him as soon as you can
  • You encourage Dave to complete his task and explain you have to do photocopying

Is that not the exact same fucking action?

In reality, I agree it depends but I think if the question is worded as ‘ you are supposed to’ then that activity takes the priority so you tell Dave ti wait a minute and finish photocopying.

Tapoopoo · 05/11/2026 21:46

Just don't overthink.
If you start thinking "but what if...?" or try to second guess what they want you to answer then you will fail.
Literally you just need to take them at face value, all things being equal etc. All the information you need is in the question.

The first thing anyone would do in a fire is tell people to get out. You wouldn't leave people shopping while you call 999 in the staff room and you certainly wouldn't run to your work bestie and leave the stock room burning down.

Dave and the photocopying - you have no other information so assume everything is equal and your photocopying is as much of a priority/time sensitive as Dave's work. Don't start thinking about what task Dave might have or adding extra information. If it was relevant they would say in the question. So the questiom is literally "you have a task and dave has a task. Dave asks you to stop your task to help him with his. What do you do?". That is it. You don't need to think any deeper. So the answer would be "tell dave you'll help him when you've done your photocopying".

If it doesnt provide the information in the question, it isn't relevant and you don't need it. If you start thinking "it depends" then you are looking into it too deeply.

I have always done well in the civil service ones.

Having said all that, they are nonsense tests. 🤣

Fortuity · 05/11/2026 21:50

InjuredDuck · 05/11/2026 20:21

You tell Dave you'll help him in a minute. This basically shows that you prioritise your own tasks while being a good / helpful colleague so in real terms, your job won't go to shit but you're also willing to step up so someone else's job doesn't go to shit.

What if it's a mountain of photocopying that's going to take to take at least an hour?

They just don't give enough information for these questions.

I also feel you need to know what viewpoint they are coming from. You may well need to present differently to clients, colleagues and rivals/opponents.