Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just failed a pre-interview assessment to work in a supermarket

434 replies

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:06

I just failed an M&S assessment. You know the kind: where you've got a multiple choice situation and you've got to say what you would be most likely and least likely to do.
Also failed assessments for civil service.

I don't understand. I like to think I'm a pretty capable person with a lot of life and work experience, good with people, pretty canny. So why do I keep failing these tasks? 😂 Often the options in the multiple choice questions all sound pretty damn similar to me.

OP posts:
JudgeJ · 07/11/2026 01:51

Damnloginpopup · 06/11/2026 22:37

"Tell me about a challenging situation you've had at work and how you dealt with it."

Well I've had multiple incidents of fire, suicide, overdose, death, assault, rape, medical emergencies etc but they were confidential so I can't talk about them.

I love the looks on the faces of the interview panel, especially when it's a very, very different type of workplace 🤣

...and I failed to pass Christmas shelf stacking at fucking Tesco 😂

Edited

Failing shelf stacking at Tesco must take some skill! I've recently had 3 or 4 issues with them where the shelf price and the actual price are different, no question of honouring the wrong price. Years ago in Sainsbury's I wanted a colandar with a long handle, saw a very nice looking, very hefty, stainless steel one the only sort they had and was surprised i twas only about £5. At the checkout is came up as nearly £20, a supervisor went to check it and said the stock label was wrong, they'd had 2 types and it referred to the cheaper one, however she out it through at £5 because it was their mistake.

FreddysFingers · 07/11/2026 02:20

I know exactly what you mean OP, I am a Civil Servant and they make you jump through hoops during the application and interview process!

Keep going, you'll get the job that's right for you, what is meant for you won't pass you by ❤️🙏.

Good luck ✨✨

trui · 07/11/2026 08:44

My DD is final year at uni and has failed the CS one, even though she did her placement year with them, they loved her, glowing references from previous boss, but her application can't go to the next stage unless she passes the initial assessment.
Her feedback was that she scored low on empathy, but she's just done the NHS management one, and she got the highest score on empathy!
I'm shocked that they're even legal - they surely must discriminate against ND people?

Piggywaspushed · 07/11/2026 09:07

DS has failed them all as I said upthread. The consistency thing is soemthign that apparently is flagged. They throw in similar questions and if you answer them differently , this is bad... in my view that would actually suggest the respondent is human...

I forgot that DS also failed the apprentice train driver one.

Lots of jobs have a way more tortuous application process than getting into uni - and , yet, MNers often fling out the 'tell them to get an apprenticeship' or ' there are lots of jobs if you look' lines as if it's the easiest thing in the world. This thread is weirdly reassuring!

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 07/11/2026 09:09

Doggymummar · 05/11/2026 20:12

Oh don't. I failed the one for CoOP AND I was a store manager for years and years. The people they took on ( this was six months ago) are terrible. I go in there everyday as it has a Post Office and I have a side hustle and the manager is always complaining about them. One did one day and had been off sick since, another shakes so bad she drops stuff and another has about three teeth. I honestly despair. I've been unemployed now for over a year, it's soul destroying job hunting in this climate.

Edited

I think your comment about an employee only having three teeth may be reported to Mumsnet as a hate crime. Honestly.

I personally couldn't care less. But l know what you mean about the suitability of some retail staff. I don't think they get much training and will just take on anybody really.

The vast majority of staff at our local Coop are very helpful. Most have been there for years And they have a very good Security Guard.

Whatdpidoooo · 07/11/2026 09:12

trui · 07/11/2026 08:44

My DD is final year at uni and has failed the CS one, even though she did her placement year with them, they loved her, glowing references from previous boss, but her application can't go to the next stage unless she passes the initial assessment.
Her feedback was that she scored low on empathy, but she's just done the NHS management one, and she got the highest score on empathy!
I'm shocked that they're even legal - they surely must discriminate against ND people?

I wonder if they're actually easier for ND people?

OP posts:
Whatdpidoooo · 07/11/2026 09:13

Piggywaspushed · 07/11/2026 09:07

DS has failed them all as I said upthread. The consistency thing is soemthign that apparently is flagged. They throw in similar questions and if you answer them differently , this is bad... in my view that would actually suggest the respondent is human...

I forgot that DS also failed the apprentice train driver one.

Lots of jobs have a way more tortuous application process than getting into uni - and , yet, MNers often fling out the 'tell them to get an apprenticeship' or ' there are lots of jobs if you look' lines as if it's the easiest thing in the world. This thread is weirdly reassuring!

It is kind of reassuring actually! 😂

OP posts:
Dimsumthang · 07/11/2026 09:17

JudgeJ · 07/11/2026 01:51

Failing shelf stacking at Tesco must take some skill! I've recently had 3 or 4 issues with them where the shelf price and the actual price are different, no question of honouring the wrong price. Years ago in Sainsbury's I wanted a colandar with a long handle, saw a very nice looking, very hefty, stainless steel one the only sort they had and was surprised i twas only about £5. At the checkout is came up as nearly £20, a supervisor went to check it and said the stock label was wrong, they'd had 2 types and it referred to the cheaper one, however she out it through at £5 because it was their mistake.

This is just abit of info about Tesco they have cheekily started hiking prices on certain foods. Their organic milk full blue was 2.40 in last week now 2.55. Same as Sainsbury. Would never buy it now from them.

SwirlyGates · 07/11/2026 09:26

trui · 07/11/2026 08:44

My DD is final year at uni and has failed the CS one, even though she did her placement year with them, they loved her, glowing references from previous boss, but her application can't go to the next stage unless she passes the initial assessment.
Her feedback was that she scored low on empathy, but she's just done the NHS management one, and she got the highest score on empathy!
I'm shocked that they're even legal - they surely must discriminate against ND people?

There was someone on a similar thread a while ago whose son had worked at a shop in his uni holidays over few years, but then they moved to an online application system. The manager wanted the son to work there again, but he had to do the online questionnaire and failed. It's a completely ridiculous system.

FairKoala · 07/11/2026 09:30

moonraker0 · 06/11/2026 14:02

There’s nothing on the screening assessment that’s specific to Tesco. They are general questions used to test your judgment. Myself and many others passed the assessment despite not knowing anyone who worked there. It’s an advantage having anyone who works retail sat by your side when you are completing it but it’s not a necessity.

These questions were like that but if you know how Tesco ran behind the scenes and the little things that only someone who worked for Tesco would know, there were certain answers that Tesco were looking for.

2Opinionated · 07/11/2026 09:33

So I don t work in retail, I work in exam setting in another field. I don't know the answer for sure, but for the fire one I think they are looking for risk assessment: what is the worst that happens? Worst that happens is customers die horribly in a fire.. Therefore evacuate customers. Dave? Well photocopying isn't going to change the world this exact minute, Dave could be struggling with customer service issue/helping a customer. Therefore help Dave. Basically, happy customer always wins. Educated guess

topcat2014 · 07/11/2026 09:50

I have a business degree and professional finance qualifications and have held jobs at board level - I tried to help DD with hers for Primark, and genuinely couldn't work out how to answer them for the best.

She didn't get through

(DD has 3 A* A levels and is at uni doing maths)

NamechangeRugby · 07/11/2026 10:32

I appreciate this isn't retail, but in same vein...

Recently chatting with someone who had just done a similar screening test for a few weeks placement with an accountancy firm.

Discussing that different answers can still be correct as long as consistently different...🤔 (I am so sceptical about the value of these tests, but they are the gatekeeper).

Apparently the firm offers a course on how to pass the test, but you have to PAY for it

Which sparked a debate - others thought payment entirely fair, whilst I was outraged. Quite aside from being a money making wheeze in my eyes (hope supermarkets don't go down this line!), surely it means they can't be an equal opportunities employer?

salskibe · 07/11/2026 10:47

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:12

The questions are also like:
A fire has broken out. What do you do first?

  • Evacuate clients
  • Call the fire brigade
  • Let your teammates know"
I'd actually do all three simultaneously FFS

Surely they will do an induction as to exactly what they want you to do, so it’s irrelevant what you think anyway?!

Monty36 · 07/11/2026 11:10

This recruitment is insane. And I suspect really expensive in the long run.
Years ago ( I am talking years), managers were expected to have good judgement. And part of the task was selecting the right people for the job.

Nobody is going to convince me that this system is better than a manager who can wisely choose.
If the manager cannot wisely choose then that is a different issue entirely the company need to deal with. They have an incompetent manager.

With this system, good people get turned away and incompetent managers get to hide behind such a system.

Frequency · 07/11/2026 11:13

salskibe · 07/11/2026 10:47

Surely they will do an induction as to exactly what they want you to do, so it’s irrelevant what you think anyway?!

I would think what you do would depend on the situation, surely?

If the fire starts on the shop floor, you call 999 while simultaneously alerting fellow staff and customers.

If you're in the storeroom alone, call 999, find the nearest fire alarm, alert fellow staff, and then evacuate customers.

The questions are too vague, and the answer is usually "it depends" or "all of the above".

Frequency · 07/11/2026 11:38

Having seen the quality of some of the new hires my friend has been forced to endure at her shop, I think my interview questions, if I ran a similar business, would be, "How often do you use a mop at home, and how much water is left on the floor when you finish?" "If someone gives you £10 and their bill is £7.36, how much change do they need?" and "What way round do tins go on the shelf and why?"

That would tell me far more about their capability to do the job than whether they would call 999 before or after evacuating the shop.

lovenotfight · 07/11/2026 12:03

I failed the Next one a few years ago. I worked for them for about 7 years when I was younger and used to run the ladies wear floor in the old Knightbridge store! 😖😏

Whatdpidoooo · 07/11/2026 12:25

lovenotfight · 07/11/2026 12:03

I failed the Next one a few years ago. I worked for them for about 7 years when I was younger and used to run the ladies wear floor in the old Knightbridge store! 😖😏

Literally just received a Next fail email 🙌🙌🙌

OP posts:
HappyViewer · 07/11/2026 12:50

This probably explains why the standard of staff is so high. I’ve noticed since Covid that in most shops and restaurants the staff are really good. I often think to myself that 10 or more years ago this or that person would be working in a five star hotel or whatever and now they are in Greggs etc.

MirrorClocks · 07/11/2026 12:53

Whatdpidoooo · 05/11/2026 20:12

The questions are also like:
A fire has broken out. What do you do first?

  • Evacuate clients
  • Call the fire brigade
  • Let your teammates know"
I'd actually do all three simultaneously FFS

I totally agree with you, OP. A bunch of stupid questions with answers that all seem applicable. Presumably, once you get the job, they’ll tell you what the procedures are.

Frequency · 07/11/2026 13:07

I'd also want to know how large the fire is and what type of fire it is (electrical/fat fire or just a plain old fire)? How far away is the nearest water source/extinguisher?

Because if it's a small fire that could be extinguished by dumping a colleague's half-drunk can of Diet Coke on it, I am doing none of the above. I'm putting the small fire out before it grows into a big fire, and then I'm going to find a manager so we can work out who's been having a cheeky fag in the stock room.

Snorlaxo · 07/11/2026 13:15

I’ve failed the M&S one too but have passed loads of others which is puzzling. I agree that there were lots of good possible answers given in the M&S one unlike their competitors who gave questions where the answer is more obvious (ie stop what you’re doing and help the customer )

snailhunter · 07/11/2026 13:30

If anyone is looking for a company that doesn’t do these stupid tests, my 17yo just got a job at Wetherspoons. Uploaded their CV, invited to a face to face interview where they were friendly and asked sensible questions, given job five days later. My other kid got a job at Tesco when they were 17 by going on Reddit, making friends with a couple of Tesco employees on there and getting the test answers from them. They’re still there four years later.

Lupin5555 · 07/11/2026 13:33

HappyViewer · 07/11/2026 12:50

This probably explains why the standard of staff is so high. I’ve noticed since Covid that in most shops and restaurants the staff are really good. I often think to myself that 10 or more years ago this or that person would be working in a five star hotel or whatever and now they are in Greggs etc.

I e noticed the opposite, staff seem to have zero product knowledge and couldn’t give less of a shit.