I know some children who enjoy breakfast or afterschool care, and some who don't. High energy, extroverted, neurotypical children tend to do better having longer days outside of the home, and would be more likely to thrive in afterschool clubs, but lower energy, introverted, or neurodiverse children probably wouldn't be as likely to cope with that.
It's weird that you can't imagine children not liking a longer day.
Personally, I would've hated it as a shy, awkward, quiet child who was bullied a good deal on and off throughout my school life, and so already struggled enough just being at school - being at home in my own space was the only time I really relaxed. It would've had a very negative effect on me, I'm quite sure.
Really, it depends on OP's children - it's the sort of thing she should probably test for a few months before she makes any decisions. If they do well, great! If not, then it's probably best to stick with the status quo for a while longer.