Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you feel sorry for children in breakfast and after school club every day?

596 replies

numberblockhead · 05/11/2026 16:20

Just wondering. Considering career change but would involve y2 and yR age children doing the above every day.

OP posts:
scramalam · 06/11/2026 17:34

I work in them and do feel sorry for the ones who have a long day. Before I worked with kids my own went full time long hours because of my job and hated it and now I see the other side I know why, they are just exhausted. But needs must and no judgement. I spend a lot of time with those ones giving them extra attention and care because its such a long day.

Just make sure to spend as much time before bed reading because the kids i have who do wraparound long hours are the ones struggling a bit more academically even though they are capable - I know from personal experience what the struggle was like to get them home, fed, homework, bath etc done. Worth it to try to fit a bit of extra storytime into the day if you can.

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 16:48

dippittydoda · 06/11/2026 16:05

Not necessarily. Of course parents can have careers but I do think if both parents do so then something has to give and in most instances it’s time spent with the children. Just my opinion but why have children if you’re going to put them in childcare etc for 10-12 hours per day, just so you can have your career.

Because my DC’s have benefited hugely from mine and DH’s careers and will continue to do so for the rest of their lives.

Highnone · 06/11/2026 16:28

I hope posters appreciate that many roles that require wrap around care provide huge benefit to society.
My children were in breakfast and afters - in order that I could continue my nursing career.

sparklyblueberry2 · 06/11/2026 16:21

Mine loves it, his friends are there so he sees it like a play date just at the school and not a softplay!

Would you have quality time outside of school on weekends and holidays? Would you have more disposable income for holidays and nicer experiences together?

sometime you have to do what you have to do, children do adapt.
what would you do for childcare in the school holidays is probably the bigger question?

contraview · 06/11/2026 16:17

I would feel sorry for them, because I know I would have hated it as a child, but I would feel just as sorry for the parents. Nobody should have to be in the position to require both breakfast and after-school club every day, but unfortunately that's the world we live in right now.

(In your position, I'd wait a few years as the children are so young. But "working in a job you don't hate" is a pretty solid reason to use it down the line, because your wellbeing is important too.)

dippittydoda · 06/11/2026 16:05

Not necessarily. Of course parents can have careers but I do think if both parents do so then something has to give and in most instances it’s time spent with the children. Just my opinion but why have children if you’re going to put them in childcare etc for 10-12 hours per day, just so you can have your career.

EndlessTreadmill · 06/11/2026 15:57

I think one OR the other is ok if needs must, and some children probably do enjoy after school clubs, depending on clubs and personality and friends. It’s the BOTH that is extreme.
To be honest, I am surprised anyone would consider this who didn’t REALLY have to.

Skyseek · 06/11/2026 14:13

numberblockhead · 06/11/2026 13:02

My child who starts reception in September is a summer birthday too so she’ll only be four and one month when she does start. I don’t know, I just worry that it’s a lot. A couple of days a week totally is enjoyable and fun just every day feels a lot.

I think some of it is due to the culture at the school too. If everyone does it it’s barely remarkable but if it’s only a couple of kids from every class staying then it is more noticeable. Not that this makes it a bad thing of course.

My child was 4.1 when they started too. They struggled a bit with taking belongings, bottle,
book bag, coat etc over to afterschool.
and yes, you are right that children their own age and their friends being there helps. His club did food then an activity every day (optional but could be cooking,
craft…). There was a chill space to crash out on bean bags, books, board games but my child liked to play football outside or play on the x box. Some schools just use the hall which isn’t as good. As I said upthread, He was ok but grew out of it. With the best will in the world, activities repeat especially if they do holiday clubs too. He is at secondary now and, whilst I wouldn’t do anything different,
not having to deal with wraparound is a relief!

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/11/2026 13:56

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/11/2026 12:46

What's the difference between that and some pp's insisting that all children who go must be exhausted and want to be at home. Isn't that repetitive?

These threads often go the same way and are largely repetitive from both sides.

A - the poor children must be so exhausted, it's too much for them. They want to be at home. Why have children if you're going to farm them out (after 3pm).

B - children love extra play time with their friends and never want to come home. They'd be angry if I dared to pick them up early.

The reality is probably somewhere in between with variations as all children are different.

Edited

Very true. My children enjoy going but that doesn’t mean that they would prefer not to sometimes.

BareGrylls · 06/11/2026 13:34

clownstomyleft · 05/11/2026 22:03

I'm amazed how many parents are able to do 3pm pick ups. What jobs do you have?!

I don't use wrap around care so that I can chase a high flying career, I use it because the cost of living is ridiculous and one salary doesn't cover our bills.

Civil service.
I started very early and finished early so DH did the drop off at 9 and I picked up at 3.30.
I also had 8 weeks unpaid holidays a year so they never went into holiday clubs. This was 20+ years ago I'm retired now.

numberblockhead · 06/11/2026 13:02

My child who starts reception in September is a summer birthday too so she’ll only be four and one month when she does start. I don’t know, I just worry that it’s a lot. A couple of days a week totally is enjoyable and fun just every day feels a lot.

I think some of it is due to the culture at the school too. If everyone does it it’s barely remarkable but if it’s only a couple of kids from every class staying then it is more noticeable. Not that this makes it a bad thing of course.

OP posts:
villadicance · 06/11/2026 12:57

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 12:56

To be fair when their specific alternative is coming home and being told to quietly leave their parent alone because they are busy working it’s not exactly a great option.

But they also felt the same when I worked part time

They did enjoy time with me but they prefer after school club because there's more to do and more kids

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 12:56

villadicance · 06/11/2026 12:51

I don't know why we find it so hard to accept that children are all different.

Mine are old enough to be pretty clear about what they think and they hate being picked up before 6 because they "miss out", when I briefly had a more part time job, they actually moaned about less after school club (!) and when I have suggested that they could instead come home and play quietly while one of us WFH they look at me like I am mad for suggesting it

I have no difficulty in believing that some children feel differently.

To be fair when their specific alternative is coming home and being told to quietly leave their parent alone because they are busy working it’s not exactly a great option.

CraftyNavySeal · 06/11/2026 12:55

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 11:22

I would be wondering why a child didn’t enjoy after school club - happy and fun places

Because they’re tiring. Many children, like many adults, after hours of work or school don’t want enforced happy fun they want to sit down quietly and do their own thing.

I’ve not worked in after school clubs but I have worked in summer camps and even the older kids get sick and tired of it after a while.

villadicance · 06/11/2026 12:51

I don't know why we find it so hard to accept that children are all different.

Mine are old enough to be pretty clear about what they think and they hate being picked up before 6 because they "miss out", when I briefly had a more part time job, they actually moaned about less after school club (!) and when I have suggested that they could instead come home and play quietly while one of us WFH they look at me like I am mad for suggesting it

I have no difficulty in believing that some children feel differently.

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 12:48

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/11/2026 12:46

What's the difference between that and some pp's insisting that all children who go must be exhausted and want to be at home. Isn't that repetitive?

These threads often go the same way and are largely repetitive from both sides.

A - the poor children must be so exhausted, it's too much for them. They want to be at home. Why have children if you're going to farm them out (after 3pm).

B - children love extra play time with their friends and never want to come home. They'd be angry if I dared to pick them up early.

The reality is probably somewhere in between with variations as all children are different.

Edited

I didn’t post that. But you could address your question to those who did?

user1471538283 · 06/11/2026 12:47

You have to do what you have to do.

My DS did before and after for a week and it was too much for him. But I worked full time and with flex so he then just did after which he enjoyed. By the time he'd had beans on toast and some playing I was picking him up.

He went through a period of wishing I was at home but I was a single working parent and I had to work. He now recognises that everything he had was down to this.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/11/2026 12:46

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 12:41

I agree. It’s been an awful lot of repetitive “ but they are playing with their friends!” which smacks of putting fingers in ears and going “la la la”. Meanwhile, lots of kids in very variable standards of childcare are not, in fact, skipping gaily off to “play with their friends”.

What's the difference between that and some pp's insisting that all children who go must be exhausted and want to be at home. Isn't that repetitive?

These threads often go the same way and are largely repetitive from both sides.

A - the poor children must be so exhausted, it's too much for them. They want to be at home. Why have children if you're going to farm them out (after 3pm).

B - children love extra play time with their friends and never want to come home. They'd be angry if I dared to pick them up early.

The reality is probably somewhere in between with variations as all children are different.

villadicance · 06/11/2026 12:45

Skyseek · 06/11/2026 11:19

This shows signs of descending into a debate about SAHP - I type ‘p’ but who am I kidding?

one thing I want to mention. People talk
about time at home with parents as though it is a quality experience. I grew up 70s
80s and experienced no childcare. My mum,’like many others, wasn’t providing enriching experiences. She was stressed and poor - I went on no school residentials and was once the only child out of a secondary year group not to go on a day trip - and didn’t the teachers make it known what an inconvenience I was. I remember trips to the park - I say trips plural as there were indeed two of them. I also remember a craft activity where I was bought a scrap book and glue. That was memorable as a one off. There were few resources (see lack of cash) and my mum could not have left her relationship as she had no money nor means to earn it. I once walked myself at 7 to a club and asked if I could join in. So, let’s not romanticise what the alternative to childcare and two jobs in a home can look like.

Edited

I agree. As a child, I was very bored after school and was very pleased when my parents moved me to a club from being at home after school. I was a neurodiverse introvert too.

All too often these days the kids whose parents are smug about avoiding childcare are stuck in front of screens while their parents WFH. I don't really think that's any better.

sprigatito · 06/11/2026 12:41

numberblockhead · 06/11/2026 11:42

I don’t think it’s the worst thing by any means but you do have an unusually entrenched view and it’s dominated the thread a bit.

I agree. It’s been an awful lot of repetitive “ but they are playing with their friends!” which smacks of putting fingers in ears and going “la la la”. Meanwhile, lots of kids in very variable standards of childcare are not, in fact, skipping gaily off to “play with their friends”.

SouthLondonMum22 · 06/11/2026 12:40

numberblockhead · 06/11/2026 09:47

It can keep - my current job is good for childcare and reasonably well paid. I just hate it! 😂

If you hate your job, go for it! Having a job you actually enjoy is beneficial to your DC.

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 12:37

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 11:22

I would be wondering why a child didn’t enjoy after school club - happy and fun places

It should be pretty easy to understand why not every child would enjoy going somewhere for hours every day that they haven’t picked.

It’s quite obviously not in every child’s best interest.

OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 12:31

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 11:22

I would be wondering why a child didn’t enjoy after school club - happy and fun places

I know some children who enjoy breakfast or afterschool care, and some who don't. High energy, extroverted, neurotypical children tend to do better having longer days outside of the home, and would be more likely to thrive in afterschool clubs, but lower energy, introverted, or neurodiverse children probably wouldn't be as likely to cope with that.

It's weird that you can't imagine children not liking a longer day.

Personally, I would've hated it as a shy, awkward, quiet child who was bullied a good deal on and off throughout my school life, and so already struggled enough just being at school - being at home in my own space was the only time I really relaxed. It would've had a very negative effect on me, I'm quite sure.

Really, it depends on OP's children - it's the sort of thing she should probably test for a few months before she makes any decisions. If they do well, great! If not, then it's probably best to stick with the status quo for a while longer.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 06/11/2026 11:55

If you hate your job then go for it. Waiting for career advancement when in a job you like is one thing but if you hate it then don’t wait

Parker231 · 06/11/2026 11:50

numberblockhead · 06/11/2026 11:42

I don’t think it’s the worst thing by any means but you do have an unusually entrenched view and it’s dominated the thread a bit.

I’ve a positive view and can proactively contribute as DT’s went to breakfast and after school clubs from ages 4-11. They also did holiday clubs during the same periods. Others haven’t had that experience to contribute.

Swipe left for the next trending thread