Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you feel sorry for children in breakfast and after school club every day?

596 replies

numberblockhead · 05/11/2026 16:20

Just wondering. Considering career change but would involve y2 and yR age children doing the above every day.

OP posts:
Mama2many73 · 06/11/2026 06:54

I now think for many parents they have no choice so I definitely wouldnt judge. I have a family member who has to do this but makes sure she 'connects' with her child (reception class) during their time together. She is an amazing mum.

I think parents often feel parent guilt about their situation. Both my DH and I were teachers as ours grew up and we often joke that during term time our DS brought/dragged himself up and during summer holidays he could spend up to 2 weeks in school getting classes sorted and ready. But do you know something, he is a pretty amazing and kind man with a good understanding of family, support and the need to work hard etc.

We do what we have to. What is the alternative??

OtterlyAstounding · 06/11/2026 06:46

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 06:38

Wow, I think you need to understand child development and human society a bit better. The nuclear family with Mum and kids at home being "cosy" is a patriachal product of the industrial revolution and only became widespread in the post war period. There is nothing natural or aspirational about it. Group childcare for mobile children is much closer to our ancesteral routes. The straight jacket of the nuclear family is largely responsible for the falling birthrate and demographic crisis.

Tbf, societies have been almost universally patriarchal since societies began, and the industrial revolution led to many children working in factories, not being cosy at home.

Extended relations often looking after children (nieces, nephews, cousins, grandchildren, second cousins once removed, etc) would've been how our ancestors worked most likely, but then all of society would've been very different - and I imagine children and babies most likely would've accompanied their mothers while hunting small game or gathering, or even cultivating, etc.

Tiredofitallagain · 06/11/2026 06:43

Sorry haven't read the whole thread so sorry if it's been said but I actually find the younger they are the better they find the routine. My kid is turning 7 and is starting to find afternoon club boring...he never wanted to leave before and actively asked to be put in all week previous years.

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 06:42

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 06:38

Wow, I think you need to understand child development and human society a bit better. The nuclear family with Mum and kids at home being "cosy" is a patriachal product of the industrial revolution and only became widespread in the post war period. There is nothing natural or aspirational about it. Group childcare for mobile children is much closer to our ancesteral routes. The straight jacket of the nuclear family is largely responsible for the falling birthrate and demographic crisis.

What an odd comment, children being with their parent isn’t “aspirational” but somehow group childcare in a hall is?

Neurodiversitydoctor · 06/11/2026 06:38

BySnugGreenBeaker · 05/11/2026 22:44

Yes. I feel very sorry for them. They are exhasuted & want to be cosy at home. I include up teenage kids, I used to work in a private day school where teenagers were dropped off at 7.45am & collected around 6pm. An exhausting long day. And competetive tiredness amongst middle class.
Let alone very small children who should be a home cosy and relaxing for most days. I am totally against again type of creche or nursery. Not only is it an awfully artificial way of looking after large numbers of children but dont be naive abouut what they're really like. I also believe children shouldn't begin school earlier than 6. They should be at home with at least one parent for the majority of their day. The only people who I wouldn't judge are single mothers in low paid jobs. For middle class professionals, there is usually a way around it by paying extra for childminder, working part time and cutting back on luxuries (yes coffees lunches Netlix takeaways random Amazon hauls are luxuries)

The saddest & most judgement I feel is for children in boarding schools. They should be banned. Eg Prince George should now be at home with his parents, his siblings, his own bedroom & privacy when still a child. It is wrong. And no 'memories' of nice weekends or long expensive holidays makes up for opting out of parenthood.

Wow, I think you need to understand child development and human society a bit better. The nuclear family with Mum and kids at home being "cosy" is a patriachal product of the industrial revolution and only became widespread in the post war period. There is nothing natural or aspirational about it. Group childcare for mobile children is much closer to our ancesteral routes. The straight jacket of the nuclear family is largely responsible for the falling birthrate and demographic crisis.

Bollin · 06/11/2026 06:09

My child adores after school club. All their friends go and they have an absolute blast. Not so keen on breakfast club though as it means an early start.

numberblockhead · 06/11/2026 05:53

I understand what both are saying.

if you’re on your own, the only breaks you’re going to get is if you pay somebody.

So somebody with a partner is ‘getting a break’, they aren’t literally doing it all.

OTOH @OtterlyAstounding is correct that being cared for by a parent (and I’d even extend that to a grandparent) isn’t like being cared for in childcare of any description.

OP posts:
OtterlyAstounding · 05/11/2026 23:22

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 23:13

I'm not saying that at all.

I'm saying you can't criticize others for "farming out" their dc if you don't have full care of your own dc.

I am fulling in favour of shared childcare, and I have no issue with use of childcare either. I have a huge problem with women who believe themselves superior and try to knock down others in public.

Regardless of your opinion on childcare, there is a very large difference between either a mother or father caring for their child while the other parent works or goes out to see friends, or does a hobby, and a child going to childcare to be looked after by paid employees. In one case, the child is always being cared for by a parent, and in the other case they are being cared for by someone paid to do so (who may of course, do a brilliant job).

I find it difficult to believe you genuinely don't grasp the difference. It doesn't feel in good faith.

Nylonflares · 05/11/2026 23:17

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 23:13

I'm not saying that at all.

I'm saying you can't criticize others for "farming out" their dc if you don't have full care of your own dc.

I am fulling in favour of shared childcare, and I have no issue with use of childcare either. I have a huge problem with women who believe themselves superior and try to knock down others in public.

I don’t think I’m superior. I have a view that might be different to yours that’s all

I made my choice and can comment on the question

I actually made that choice to look after my niece first (circumstances) and them my dc, among with my then DH

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 23:13

OtterlyAstounding · 05/11/2026 23:06

'Farming out' is an emotive term, yes. I'm not commenting on that though, I'm commenting on your attempts to say that a father looking after his own children is somehow the same as a paid employee caring for a child. That's just silly. It's their father! Why would he not care for his own children?

You might disagree with pp, and fair enough, but it's silly to equate a parent caring for their child, to a child going to after school clubs.

I'm not saying that at all.

I'm saying you can't criticize others for "farming out" their dc if you don't have full care of your own dc.

I am fulling in favour of shared childcare, and I have no issue with use of childcare either. I have a huge problem with women who believe themselves superior and try to knock down others in public.

OtterlyAstounding · 05/11/2026 23:06

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 23:02

Well, I don't think allowing a child to be cared for by another safe adult for periods of time is "farming out" at all. I think it's an unpleasant and unreasonable way to describe a totally normal part of parenting. Obviously it's good for dc to be cared for by both parents, just like there's no problem with a night at grandma's or going to school or clubs.

But I think anyone who wants to sit on their high horse accusing other women of "farming out" their dc is a hypocrite if they are also letting others care for their dc!

'Farming out' is an emotive term, yes. I'm not commenting on that though, I'm commenting on your attempts to say that a father looking after his own children is somehow the same as a paid employee caring for a child. That's just silly. It's their father! Why would he not care for his own children?

You might disagree with pp, and fair enough, but it's silly to equate a parent caring for their child, to a child going to after school clubs.

Gealach · 05/11/2026 23:03

Nobody can answer this for your own situation. Maybe they’ll love it, one of mine thrived while being in a group, maybe you need to do this to fund everything.

Every situation is different. It’s a long day. Your kids should enjoy it or else look for a different solution.

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 23:02

OtterlyAstounding · 05/11/2026 22:55

I don't think parents sharing the parenting load equally is 'farming out', as the children are always with a parent. In fact, it makes a lot of sense to share the load equally if possible, as otherwise the father doesn't get to parent as much, and is missing out!

I don't see the hypocrisy there at all. Unless you're saying fathers shouldn't be actively parenting their children?

Well, I don't think allowing a child to be cared for by another safe adult for periods of time is "farming out" at all. I think it's an unpleasant and unreasonable way to describe a totally normal part of parenting. Obviously it's good for dc to be cared for by both parents, just like there's no problem with a night at grandma's or going to school or clubs.

But I think anyone who wants to sit on their high horse accusing other women of "farming out" their dc is a hypocrite if they are also letting others care for their dc!

Lifeislikeaboxofchocolate · 05/11/2026 23:00

I would feel bad but not sure if the children would! Depends on the school my daughter’s old school. When she did go she loved them both. Pancakes for breakfast! ASC play play play and snacks. I must admit it was well funded and facilitated as it was used so much by parents and highly in demand. She used to complain when I collected her early as she missed out on games etc. I used to collect her early some days because I felt bad but it wasn’t needed. Also I guess it depends what they would be doing if home? If just sat there watching TV etc then may as well they go.!

Pandaball · 05/11/2026 23:00

My eldest is in reception and goes to after school club 3 days. They are visibly annoyed when we say it is a day mummy/daddy/granny are picking up and ask to go to after school club. They have also started asking to go to breakfast club (which we don't need and don't get up early enough for!) No judgement at all. I also worried about them going but needs must and if you have a good provider then they will like it. .my eldest has come on leaps and bounds through socialising with the older children.

Parker231 · 05/11/2026 22:57

BySnugGreenBeaker · 05/11/2026 22:50

One 10 year old, sibling ds deceased.

My DT’s are in their 20’s so I have the advantage of having seen them through the decisions we made for them growing up . Full time nursery from six months (less maternity leave then), breakfast and after school clubs until age 11. Senior school had a mandatory homework hour after school Monday to Thursday. These were all positives rather than negative.
We have happy confident young adults who are a pleasure to be with secure in their family relationships. They haven’t been damaged by being in nursery or school clubs.

HeyThereDelila · 05/11/2026 22:57

Yes, it’s far too long a day and too tiring. School is more tiring than nursery. Get a part time nanny or childminder.

OtterlyAstounding · 05/11/2026 22:55

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 22:52

You had a dc, you are leaving them with another safe person rather than caring for them yourself.

By your own terms - why have a child and then "farm them out to be raised by others"? Surely you should be with them 100% of the time?

I'm just trying to point out the wild hypocrisy.

I don't think parents sharing the parenting load equally is 'farming out', as the children are always with a parent. In fact, it makes a lot of sense to share the load equally if possible, as otherwise the father doesn't get to parent as much, and is missing out!

I don't see the hypocrisy there at all. Unless you're saying fathers shouldn't be actively parenting their children?

Stompythedinosaur · 05/11/2026 22:52

Nylonflares · 05/11/2026 22:42

How is their dad looking after them comparable?

You had a dc, you are leaving them with another safe person rather than caring for them yourself.

By your own terms - why have a child and then "farm them out to be raised by others"? Surely you should be with them 100% of the time?

I'm just trying to point out the wild hypocrisy.

babyproblems · 05/11/2026 22:52

Being totally honest, yes I would. I think it’s a very long day if they’re young. I think a day this long for my son at 5yo would be detrimental overall day to day. I think I would consider it when he was older though. I’m aware many parents have no choice.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 05/11/2026 22:51

Parker231 · 05/11/2026 22:48

Neither DH or I had careers which we wanted to do on a part time basis.

It is not easy to find part time work either. Most jobs expect full time employees.

BySnugGreenBeaker · 05/11/2026 22:50

Parker231 · 05/11/2026 22:46

How old are your children?

One 10 year old, sibling ds deceased.

Parker231 · 05/11/2026 22:48

Nylonflares · 05/11/2026 22:44

True, I took a hit there with my days, but it’s what I wanted to do and meant the balance was better

Fine if you disagree

Neither DH or I had careers which we wanted to do on a part time basis.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 05/11/2026 22:48

Nylonflares · 05/11/2026 22:30

I don’t really get why you’d have children then farm them out all day

Every family is different and the majority cannot afford to take time off around their other half. Most households on the average income need two incomes coming in. It’s not like after school is open overnight, the children come home in the evening.

Parker231 · 05/11/2026 22:46

BySnugGreenBeaker · 05/11/2026 22:44

Yes. I feel very sorry for them. They are exhasuted & want to be cosy at home. I include up teenage kids, I used to work in a private day school where teenagers were dropped off at 7.45am & collected around 6pm. An exhausting long day. And competetive tiredness amongst middle class.
Let alone very small children who should be a home cosy and relaxing for most days. I am totally against again type of creche or nursery. Not only is it an awfully artificial way of looking after large numbers of children but dont be naive abouut what they're really like. I also believe children shouldn't begin school earlier than 6. They should be at home with at least one parent for the majority of their day. The only people who I wouldn't judge are single mothers in low paid jobs. For middle class professionals, there is usually a way around it by paying extra for childminder, working part time and cutting back on luxuries (yes coffees lunches Netlix takeaways random Amazon hauls are luxuries)

The saddest & most judgement I feel is for children in boarding schools. They should be banned. Eg Prince George should now be at home with his parents, his siblings, his own bedroom & privacy when still a child. It is wrong. And no 'memories' of nice weekends or long expensive holidays makes up for opting out of parenthood.

How old are your children?