Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think giving someone a birthday card with money in it is a cop out?

181 replies

HonestTealPoster · 04/11/2026 18:11

I appreciate that money is useful and that some people genuinely prefer receiving it, but I’ve always found giving someone a birthday card with cash inside rather impersonal. To me, part of the point of giving a gift is putting some thought into what the person might actually like or enjoy. Giving money just feels like the easiest option, requiring very little thought or effort. Obviously, it’s different if someone has specifically asked for money but otherwise I think it takes something away from the sentiment of gift-giving.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
XelaM · 09/11/2026 16:50

MyFavouriteGame · 09/11/2026 16:23

As a child I was always asked for a Christmas list and then it being completely ignored and was bought everything elephant related because one time I said I quite liked them. I’d rather have had money. This went on for years.

All I ever wanted since I was a child was money, but always received random presents of stuff I may have mentioned vaguely years ago. It was/continues to be very frustrating as my family spend a lot of money on gifts (i.e. I was given an expensive trip to Prague to watch the figure skating world champions. It must have cost my parents at least £1000. I was skint and would have absolutely loved to get a fraction of that in cash instead of an expensive trip). They always say "you will just spend the money". 😒 Well, that's the whole point.

Lifeomars · 09/11/2026 16:38

Cash is a great gift, I loved it as a child as it gave me the freedom to get whatever I was into as the time or put it towards something I wanted . I give cash to friends' kids and it is always welcomed and appreciated

TheAbsentRoyalUmberella · 09/11/2026 16:30

No money in a card is perfect ! The best voucher in the world !

MyFavouriteGame · 09/11/2026 16:23

As a child I was always asked for a Christmas list and then it being completely ignored and was bought everything elephant related because one time I said I quite liked them. I’d rather have had money. This went on for years.

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 11:15

BusyGreySnail · 09/11/2026 09:19

If you are talking about children, I think it's more of a cop out to ask the parents to think of a lovely thoughtful gift you can then gift, which in my experience is what happens more of the time. It puts a huge mental load on the parents and shows no more thought from the gift giver than putting money in a card.

My kid love to receive money that they can then save/ put together to buy what they want.

If you are talking about adults then yes I think it's odd unless there's some huge financial disparity. Except for a wedding where giving money is normal. But i have never in my adult life received a card with a tenner in.

Mine is more likely to be £100+, to be fair.

I buy for others because I have to but it just seems a bit pointless.

There is one person who knows me well enough to buy suitable presents but that’s it.

BusyGreySnail · 09/11/2026 09:19

If you are talking about children, I think it's more of a cop out to ask the parents to think of a lovely thoughtful gift you can then gift, which in my experience is what happens more of the time. It puts a huge mental load on the parents and shows no more thought from the gift giver than putting money in a card.

My kid love to receive money that they can then save/ put together to buy what they want.

If you are talking about adults then yes I think it's odd unless there's some huge financial disparity. Except for a wedding where giving money is normal. But i have never in my adult life received a card with a tenner in.

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 09:16

Krevlornswath · 08/11/2026 17:02

I love gift giving, actively enjoy the whole process of choosing, shopping and wrapping things for people I care about so yes money in a card as a preference is a bit of a let down in that respect but at the same time that highlights the principle point I think. A gift is for the person who is receiving it, not to provide pleasure to the giver.

If people prefer money or gift cards I'm happy to do it, in reality I find this is generally a request from people that in all honesty I don't know well enough or see often enough to actually nail the gift anyway (eg: kids, teenagers, rarely seen in laws). I'd rather they just had the enjoyment of choosing something they actually want than having to unwrap something they don't just because I prefer that idea.

I know people who refuse to give money because, like you; they enjoy the whole ritual of choosing and preparing gifts. But for them, their wish to choose and wrap something is more important than the enjoyment of the recipient so fair play to you as you clearly understand the spirit of gift giving!

Anarchy99 · 09/11/2026 09:03

TorroFerney · 08/11/2026 16:31

Don’t worry my child already knows that grandma has absolutely no interest in her (by her actions I don’t need to say anything - other than to explain to a sad child that grandmas lack of interest is not down to anything my daughter has done). Luckily her paternal granddad adores her.

Then you should stop accepting the money. That way the child will learn that if you don’t like or respect someone, you don’t accept money from them.

UnjustifiedAncient · 08/11/2026 17:09

Have you met any teenagers? 🤣

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/11/2026 17:08

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 14:41

So don’t you bother with adults?

Except for dh, dds, and the Gdcs, other adult family members will usually get some sort of edibles, of the more luxury sort that they probably wouldn’t buy for themselves. I’ve just bought Bendicks Bittermints to send to a sister in the US, since I know she really likes them.

Postage will be eye watering, but 🎄comes but once a year, and all that…

Krevlornswath · 08/11/2026 17:02

I love gift giving, actively enjoy the whole process of choosing, shopping and wrapping things for people I care about so yes money in a card as a preference is a bit of a let down in that respect but at the same time that highlights the principle point I think. A gift is for the person who is receiving it, not to provide pleasure to the giver.

If people prefer money or gift cards I'm happy to do it, in reality I find this is generally a request from people that in all honesty I don't know well enough or see often enough to actually nail the gift anyway (eg: kids, teenagers, rarely seen in laws). I'd rather they just had the enjoyment of choosing something they actually want than having to unwrap something they don't just because I prefer that idea.

TorroFerney · 08/11/2026 16:31

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 12:25

Why don’t you just ask her not to bother then? You sound incredibly ungrateful. You don’t want the money but you don’t like any gift she gets for you. Perhaps you could march her to the shops and make her buy exactly what you want?

The whole point of cash is that you can spend it on something you want.

You choose to spend it on household stuff and your and your husband’s attitude will rub off on your child.

Don’t worry my child already knows that grandma has absolutely no interest in her (by her actions I don’t need to say anything - other than to explain to a sad child that grandmas lack of interest is not down to anything my daughter has done). Luckily her paternal granddad adores her.

TorroFerney · 08/11/2026 16:26

XelaM · 08/11/2026 12:31

You sound horrible. With the money you can treat yourself (or your child) to whatever you or they want. What's wrong with what your mum is doing?

I think where I’ve struggled is when she repeatedly promises my child a certain present, asks her what she wants with absolutely no intention of buying it, I find that quite odd. she does the same to me sometimes, she had elaborate ideas of what she’d buy me for my 50th which didn’t come to fruition but I know to ignore it, she once asked my child if she wanted a really fancy Easter egg she’d (my mum) seen in marks and Spencer, child says yes , we go round on Easter Sunday and she says - I didn’t get you an egg. So odd, appreciate she may have not got her the fancy one but you can buy them for a couple of quid in Tesco. I don’t think it’s nice to promise a child stuff. Or anyone really.

but don’t worry it’s my mums birthday soon and she’s got from me a warm padded coat from fat face , chocolates and a bottle of fizz. I’ve not inherited the odd present gene. In fact I’ve been buying her presents since I was a very small child, she was very clear it was my job to make her happy. So she’ll never know just how horrible I am!

Oh another treat is her obvious regifting of stuff to my fil, unwrapped and her not really knowing what the thing is when she hands it over. Best was her about to hand four cans of beer to him unwrapped in quite a fancy restaurant but thankfully I had a gift bag. It was like a teenager at a party!

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 14:41

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/11/2026 12:49

I wouldn’t give cash to adult family, unless I knew they were seriously skint, but IMO older children/teens usually really welcome it.

In any case, unless you know of something specific that an adult would really like, it’s far too easy to get it wrong, and lumber them with something they would never have chosen for themselves.

One Christmas that went down in history for then mid teen dds, was the one where the youngest BiL - who had never given them ANYthing ever before, turned up and dished out 2 x crisp £50 notes each.

And this was over 20 years ago!

So don’t you bother with adults?

2chocolateoranges · 08/11/2026 14:34

Moonnstarz · 08/11/2026 13:06

Interested in what you give adult family instead or if you just don't bother with adults?

The only adults I buy for are my children, my dh and my mum.

other family adults all have children and we buy for the nieces and nephews now instead of our siblings.

Moonnstarz · 08/11/2026 13:06

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/11/2026 12:49

I wouldn’t give cash to adult family, unless I knew they were seriously skint, but IMO older children/teens usually really welcome it.

In any case, unless you know of something specific that an adult would really like, it’s far too easy to get it wrong, and lumber them with something they would never have chosen for themselves.

One Christmas that went down in history for then mid teen dds, was the one where the youngest BiL - who had never given them ANYthing ever before, turned up and dished out 2 x crisp £50 notes each.

And this was over 20 years ago!

Interested in what you give adult family instead or if you just don't bother with adults?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/11/2026 12:49

I wouldn’t give cash to adult family, unless I knew they were seriously skint, but IMO older children/teens usually really welcome it.

In any case, unless you know of something specific that an adult would really like, it’s far too easy to get it wrong, and lumber them with something they would never have chosen for themselves.

One Christmas that went down in history for then mid teen dds, was the one where the youngest BiL - who had never given them ANYthing ever before, turned up and dished out 2 x crisp £50 notes each.

And this was over 20 years ago!

ToadRage · 08/11/2026 12:37

I had money in a card from my Nana yesterday. She is 88 and not very mobile. She struggles to go out shopping and we don't see each other often so she hasn't a clue what i might like. When someone doesn't know and doesn't ask i would prefer money so i can choose something i would like.

WearingBeautifulShoes · 08/11/2026 12:36

I'm very fussy with what I like and don't like. I'd be delighted with money (or gift cards, but money is more flexible) to spend on myself.

XelaM · 08/11/2026 12:31

TorroFerney · 07/11/2026 18:10

my mum won't buy presents so she gives me, husband and child a card with cash in. £30 each last year but she's not consistent so who knows this year. Husband hands it straight to the child as he says he'd rather she got the child something decent (only grandchild) and not get him anything and for me it just goes on household stuff rather than myself.

Usually same for birthdays although last year she forgot husbands so he got no card and then she gave him a £20 note when we next took her out for a meal. This year for my birthday I didn't get money so was excited - got a bottle of wine a type I have never drunk, I order Sauvignon Blanc that is the only wine I drink, and a very small packet of chocolate eggs. Because I like to torture myself I looked how much they cost. £9.50 - so I think I prefer the cash now! Oh she does get my fil a gift but usually something someone has bought her which is embarrassingly obvious.

You sound horrible. With the money you can treat yourself (or your child) to whatever you or they want. What's wrong with what your mum is doing?

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 12:29

It does make me laugh that some people are so convinced of their gift giving skills that they would rather buy something they THINK the recipient would like than give them the choice to buy something they will like.

There have been numerous times when someone who apparently knows me well has bought me something they think I want. Of course they think it’s correct because I smile and thank them. Inside I am deeply disappointed.

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 12:25

TorroFerney · 07/11/2026 18:10

my mum won't buy presents so she gives me, husband and child a card with cash in. £30 each last year but she's not consistent so who knows this year. Husband hands it straight to the child as he says he'd rather she got the child something decent (only grandchild) and not get him anything and for me it just goes on household stuff rather than myself.

Usually same for birthdays although last year she forgot husbands so he got no card and then she gave him a £20 note when we next took her out for a meal. This year for my birthday I didn't get money so was excited - got a bottle of wine a type I have never drunk, I order Sauvignon Blanc that is the only wine I drink, and a very small packet of chocolate eggs. Because I like to torture myself I looked how much they cost. £9.50 - so I think I prefer the cash now! Oh she does get my fil a gift but usually something someone has bought her which is embarrassingly obvious.

Why don’t you just ask her not to bother then? You sound incredibly ungrateful. You don’t want the money but you don’t like any gift she gets for you. Perhaps you could march her to the shops and make her buy exactly what you want?

The whole point of cash is that you can spend it on something you want.

You choose to spend it on household stuff and your and your husband’s attitude will rub off on your child.

Everlygreen · 07/11/2026 18:26

I loathe thinking of gifts for anyone. Loathe it. Money in a card or a voucher is fine with me.
every single gift you can think of goes down a
rabbit hole. Scarf- what pattern, does it suit them. Candle- what scent. Book - what author or genres. Toys - minefield. Loathed it, everyone’s getting money or a voucher from me.

TorroFerney · 07/11/2026 18:10

my mum won't buy presents so she gives me, husband and child a card with cash in. £30 each last year but she's not consistent so who knows this year. Husband hands it straight to the child as he says he'd rather she got the child something decent (only grandchild) and not get him anything and for me it just goes on household stuff rather than myself.

Usually same for birthdays although last year she forgot husbands so he got no card and then she gave him a £20 note when we next took her out for a meal. This year for my birthday I didn't get money so was excited - got a bottle of wine a type I have never drunk, I order Sauvignon Blanc that is the only wine I drink, and a very small packet of chocolate eggs. Because I like to torture myself I looked how much they cost. £9.50 - so I think I prefer the cash now! Oh she does get my fil a gift but usually something someone has bought her which is embarrassingly obvious.

jmh740 · 07/11/2026 17:11

I love money in a card. My mum was very hit and miss with presents she would ask what I wanted then get something vaguely in that area that I wouldn't use.