Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked that no one helped the girl on the train

700 replies

Ohhh1 · 04/11/2026 14:37

14 year old SA in trained

I am being unreasonable in think people need to stop being so absorbed on their phones whilst out in public. It seems no one helpped this child whilst she was being raped because they were too busy on their phones.

Autistic girl, 14, 'sexually assaulted on train by Afghan migrants'

Baryalai Rahimi, 25, and Mirebadurahman Sadat, 29, are said to have spotted the runaway teenager at a station in rural Kent before following her onto the London-bound train on February 5.

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16264873/afghan-migrants-schoolgirl-14-raping-train-toilets.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Laurmolonlabe · 05/11/2026 08:59

6,500 is a drop in the ocean ,the vast majority into London over the last 2 years have been Russian men of conscription age and their families.

CruciallyFour · 05/11/2026 07:59

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 04/11/2026 16:38

The court case details are shown online.

PP said ‘I SEE a few a week’.

This read as - I physically see ‘a few a week’ - as in around me. This is linked to the discussion which is focussed on a real life rape that took place with people around.

PP did not say online, no clarification of this and no evidence provided at all of ‘a few a week’ rapes by asylum seekers.

A BS statement to inflame and divide.

Eristealviper · 05/11/2026 07:34

She replied: 'No one was really looking at us. Everyone was just on their phones’.

There can be problems with false memory following traumatic or accidental events.
Obviously some of the other passengers will have been using their phones, but probably better to take a look at CCTV & similar equipment to get more precise info about what they appeared to be doing.

Emilesgran · 05/11/2026 06:50

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:41

Why do you assume fundamentalists in Iran have the 'true' and definitive interpretation of Islam? There's different schools and interpretations do vary quite widely across countries on various things. Past Muslim States like the Spanish Nasrids, Mughals and Ottomans were less strict than Iran in quite a few ways (and probably not coincidentally, more successful)

Well religion is all man made anyway IMO so there is no “true” version of it but that’s hardly the point really. The point is that Islam IS used to oppress women, and an anonymous randomer on Mumsnet denying that is sort of laughable really.

Just because Christianity has been used in that way, and mainly in the past, doesn’t make all religions equally bad in that respect. Mainstream Islam in the 20th C is provably worse than mainstream Christianity, and finding some tiny sect in Africa or even the US doesn’t change that.

(I’m also dubious that anyone can say that the Ottomans were basically decent people - the heir traditionally began his reign by strangling all his brothers and half brothers to remove any possible opposition. I don’t expect such a practice could possibly arise in a society respectful of the rights of one’s social inferiors!)

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:53

CakeAndEats · 04/11/2026 23:49

She completely loves her life and feels very very safe and finds the local Italians to be very helpful.

I'm not gonna say there's no issues but Italy is a better place to be than the third world.

Both can have problems. The data show they are not the same problems at the same scale.

Can I ask what part of Italy she lives in?

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:51

Lifetsuck · 04/11/2026 22:48

Yes life in Amsterdam is better than Kabul what a stupidly obvious thing to say

But let’s not pretend life is all fine in the U.K. or that British men are better

Thousands if not more British men go to rape children in south east Asia

Rape convinction rates are so low in the U.K., we’ve practically given men the go ahead to rape without punishment

I am harassed by men virtually every day and have been since the age of 12 in the U.K.

Lets not pretend we live a good life free from abuse and harrassment because that’s doing a disservice to women and girls in this country

Of course there are worse places but how low do we have to go to compare ourselves to places like fucking Kabul

This all just reeks of racism and Islamophobia

Pathetic

Edited

'I am harassed by men virtually every day and have been since the age of 12 in the U.K.'

  • this is terrible, I'm really sorry. Can I ask what area of the UK you live in? I understand if not.
Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:49

nomas · 04/11/2026 22:38

Well these men were armed and trained by the USA. So go figure.

Bacha bazi wasn't begun though by the mujahideen- was it?

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:47

CakeAndEats · 04/11/2026 22:26

By Italian men?

There are many of us who love Italy and have great experiences there.

I'm sorry that you experienced this..but would you rather be in Rome/Milan or Kabul?

I love Italy too, it was the first country I ever went to, but it's disingenuous to be blind to its historical (and to some extent present) faults. The macho culture of 1980s Italy was well-known, as well as the abovementioned north-south divide in attitudes to women, so the pp's experience is believable to me, especially if she was in a Southern area.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:43

Lifetsuck · 04/11/2026 22:10

The worst harassment I’ve ever experienced as a young woman was in Italy

What on earth are people talking about !

How awful, I'm sorry. Was this south or north? Generalising but south is to some extent more sexist. Things probably have improved since, at least to some extent, though.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:41

Emilesgran · 04/11/2026 22:08

You should probably explain that to all the imams in Iran then - it's truly fascinating that you understand islam better than they do.

Why do you assume fundamentalists in Iran have the 'true' and definitive interpretation of Islam? There's different schools and interpretations do vary quite widely across countries on various things. Past Muslim States like the Spanish Nasrids, Mughals and Ottomans were less strict than Iran in quite a few ways (and probably not coincidentally, more successful)

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:39

CakeAndEats · 04/11/2026 21:49

The Vatican isn't a member of the UN in its own right.

Also I've actually met some lovely happy nuns in Rome. They are absolutely so lovely and full of joy.

It is effectively a sovereign state though.. thus it can be hard for the Italian police to investigate stuff there as they are a separate state.

I agree plenty of nuns are happy people who contribute a lot. It's still a sexist system though, even if not Afghan levels by any means. Pope Francis did help women have more authority but as long ad the priesthood stays male, the power women can have is strictly limited.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:35

CakeAndEats · 04/11/2026 21:45

Would you rather be a woman in the most bible belt of bible belt states in the USA or Afghanistan?

Also look at Italy, the home of the Roman Catholic church but such an amazing country and nice to be in

I think women in Italy have a pretty good situation all things considered, especially in the northern parts. It's worth noting though that Italian gender roles are still arguably stricter, especially in the South and until quite recently it was very hard to be a woman in some parts of the South in several ways. But this was more due to Southern honour-based codes than religion (I'd argue this is a similar pattern to Afghanistan in some ways).

Until the 1965 case of Franca Viola, who refused to do so, it was common for rape victims in Southern Italy (places like Sicily, Calabria, Campania, and Apuli) to be pressured to marry their rapists, whose crime would be expunged if they did so (thus often tied in with the mafia, which had thankfully also weakened quite a lot since then).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franca_Viola

Franca Viola - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franca_Viola

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 04:22

Fluffyblackcat7 · 05/11/2026 02:09

Here's what's puzzling me, do we even know that the Afghan rapists in this story are Muslim?

If they are Muslim, where does it say that their abusive behaviour driven by their religious beliefs?

I suspect that their religion is irrelevant, they are just abusers who saw that poor girl as an opportunity to gain their sexual satisfaction at her expense.

The prevailing attitude to women in their country of origin might be relevant but this should not be confused with race or religion.

I am so glad that they are being charged under UK law and hope they 'throw the book at them.'

My thoughts remain with that poor girl and wish her well as she struggles to cope with what they did to her.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Afghanistan
Most Afghans are Muslim, nearly 100%. And unsurprisingly other religions are highly oppressed under the tender mercies of the Taliban..

Imo the main problem with Afghan rural (especially) men is pre-Islamic tribal codes, not Islam. Pashtunwali is one, hugely restrictive of women. Malala Yousafzai is a Pashtun, (many also live in the Swat Valley of Pakistan) and she has spoken of the good things but also the severe gender inequality the code enforces, as well as the violent honour culture it encourages.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pashtunwali

I also suspect a lot of these Afghan are not simply a random selection but existing criminals fleeing since I'd imagine Taliban prisons are harsh.

Religion in Afghanistan - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Afghanistan

user1492757084 · 05/11/2026 02:09

So sad that the girl did not call out, refuse to go, kick them away or say, "please help".
She noticed the bystanders on their phones.
So sad that she did not put effort in to alert the other passengers.

Did camera's catch them?
Outrageous that rapists search for girls and women in broad daylight on trains.
They should be sent straight back to the Afghani prisons.

Fluffyblackcat7 · 05/11/2026 02:09

ThreadGuardDog · 04/11/2026 20:52

Nobody is saying that ALL Muslim men are bad. And nobody is judging purely on religion. But you’re going to the opposite extreme and trying to pretend that many Muslim men don’t present a threat to women. Which is nonsense. Otherwise we wouldn’t be having this conversation would we ? Because this child wouldn’t have been raped would she ?

Here's what's puzzling me, do we even know that the Afghan rapists in this story are Muslim?

If they are Muslim, where does it say that their abusive behaviour driven by their religious beliefs?

I suspect that their religion is irrelevant, they are just abusers who saw that poor girl as an opportunity to gain their sexual satisfaction at her expense.

The prevailing attitude to women in their country of origin might be relevant but this should not be confused with race or religion.

I am so glad that they are being charged under UK law and hope they 'throw the book at them.'

My thoughts remain with that poor girl and wish her well as she struggles to cope with what they did to her.

Fluffyblackcat7 · 05/11/2026 01:58

Apotofrealcoffee · 04/11/2026 20:43

Oh my God I absolutely despair

Seriously just read the thread

Your reply is so fluffy and glib it’s actually awful

Is it really so awful to respond with empathy for the victim and serious consideration of how we can better support people in this situation?

What would you suggest, ignore her suffering and use her case as a political football?

Okay, you do that and I'll do me.

Fluffyblackcat7 · 05/11/2026 01:15

Lifetsuck · 04/11/2026 19:40

Do you think white British men should be banned from going to Vietnam, Thailand etc ?

Yes, it's a very similar issue, isn't it?

IMO, men of all races and nationalites should be prevented from travelling if they are doing so for the purposes of commiting sex crimes against children.

If only they could be screened at the border and educated as to the cultural attitude and expectation in their destination country towards the exploitation of children. Perhaps border forces could look into their digital footprint before deciding whether to let them in?

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 00:25

WeDid2 · 05/11/2026 00:21

After being sexually assaulted as a child, I am one of those people who would ring the transport police if I felt something was not right. But sorry I think you are being a bit harsh. It’s normal for people to be reading a book / be on their phones during travel. The horrific sitting on the knee start of everything - for someone to notice they would have had to be in the proximity and be watching it unfold, have their spidery senses triggered and then be watching for body language of the girl to check she was not ok with it.
I have a lot of autism in my family including myself having traits - unfortunately due to social confusion our facial expressions and body language might not be obvious enough to passerbys that we are in distress.
What happened to this poor girl is horrific and changes need to be made but I don’t think you can assume the general public were aware and ignored it.
I think it might be helpful for the transport systems to better promote how people can ask other passengers for help to ask them to call the transport police and what other passengers can do if they sense another passenger needs help - and it’s socially acceptable to double check with a stranger they are ok.

Edited

If people noticed , and especially staff, but ignored, I would judge. But a lot of ordinary commuters are busy etc and may simply not have noticed.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 00:24

Arbourimage · 04/11/2026 21:29

In what way is Islam worse than Christianity for women specifically?

Islam allows polygamy for one.

But my opinion is that Islam isn't uniquely bad for women. The problems are 1. It has not undergone a liberalisation process like Christianity and Judaism have, at least not in most places. 2. A lot of Muslim societies are poor and tribal. The problems in Afghanistan and places like Mirpur where the Pakistani grooming gangs came from are primarily caused by tribal/clan-based attitudes which harm women wherever they are.

Islam varies a lot. For cultural & historical reasons, SE Asian, Eastern European and Omani forms tend to be more coexisting and peaceful.

nomas · 05/11/2026 00:23

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 00:23

Im offering at least something that means we don't have excessive sex attacks by foreigners

And what is that?

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 00:23

nomas · 05/11/2026 00:19

What will stop it?

You're not offering any solutions!

Im offering at least something that means we don't have excessive sex attacks by foreigners

WeDid2 · 05/11/2026 00:21

After being sexually assaulted as a child, I am one of those people who would ring the transport police if I felt something was not right. But sorry I think you are being a bit harsh. It’s normal for people to be reading a book / be on their phones during travel. The horrific sitting on the knee start of everything - for someone to notice they would have had to be in the proximity and be watching it unfold, have their spidery senses triggered and then be watching for body language of the girl to check she was not ok with it.
I have a lot of autism in my family including myself having traits - unfortunately due to social confusion our facial expressions and body language might not be obvious enough to passerbys that we are in distress.
What happened to this poor girl is horrific and changes need to be made but I don’t think you can assume the general public were aware and ignored it.
I think it might be helpful for the transport systems to better promote how people can ask other passengers for help to ask them to call the transport police and what other passengers can do if they sense another passenger needs help - and it’s socially acceptable to double check with a stranger they are ok.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 00:20

1dayatatime · 04/11/2026 18:35

Actually this is an excellent idea. The majority of illegal migrants are male because it is unsafe for females make a similar journey due to sexual assaults and rape.

Yet at the same time there are thousands of women and girls stuck in refugee camps in Jordan and Turkey and Syria.

So how about a forcible one for one return policy or even a one for two on a regulated numbers basis. This way you are providing refuge for the refugees most at risk and reducing the risk of sex crimes in the UK by male refugees with very different cultures to women's rights.

Sounds like a win win.

Yes, the problem isn't Afghan PEOPLE per se. It's Afghan MEN. Men are not the only people. Women would not be assaulting teen boys if they came over here...

I would like to help women. I also think it's worth noting a lot of the more secular and educated Afghans will have fled in prior years : the men coming now are likely to be the ones with more misogynistic attitudes. I suspect also criminals are overrepresented (rather than just being the 'average rural man') as they want to escape justice in their own country.

nomas · 05/11/2026 00:19

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 00:17

Won't save us from the local rapists but at least we aren't bringing anymore in.

What will stop it?

You're not offering any solutions!

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 00:17

Fluffyblackcat7 · 05/11/2026 00:14

The damage that rapists and abusers do to their victims is the same wherever they abusers come from.

Racism and migration issues are red herrings. Pulling up our drawbridge isn't going to save us from our home-grown rapists and abusers, is it?

Violent pornography and the manosphere have a lot to answer for and we need to do more as a society to counter that.

We need to put more into screening and educating migrants regarding our cultural attitudes to women, violence and consent.

We need to do the same with our homegrown predatory males too. Schools have a role to play with boys, as well as Police and the courts who need to root out and come down hard on domestic abusers, flashers, upskirters and the like, take them out of our houses, off our streets and re-educate them at His Majesty's pleasure.

Let's focus on how society can remove the threat of sexual violence and how we as individuals might support someone in an abusive situation.

Won't save us from the local rapists but at least we aren't bringing anymore in.