Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocked that no one helped the girl on the train

700 replies

Ohhh1 · 04/11/2026 14:37

14 year old SA in trained

I am being unreasonable in think people need to stop being so absorbed on their phones whilst out in public. It seems no one helpped this child whilst she was being raped because they were too busy on their phones.

Autistic girl, 14, 'sexually assaulted on train by Afghan migrants'

Baryalai Rahimi, 25, and Mirebadurahman Sadat, 29, are said to have spotted the runaway teenager at a station in rural Kent before following her onto the London-bound train on February 5.

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-16264873/afghan-migrants-schoolgirl-14-raping-train-toilets.html

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 19:19

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 19:00

Yes, a Muslim woman can absolutely travel to Paris alone. Thousands of solo Muslim female travelers visit Paris every year safely and comfortably.

Yes but they are breaking the rules of Islamic theology if they do so. The same way if they don't wear a hijab around non-mahram men that's technically breaking Islamic rules as well.

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 19:00

Yes, a Muslim woman can absolutely travel to Paris alone. Thousands of solo Muslim female travelers visit Paris every year safely and comfortably.

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 18:48

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 18:32

What a load of absolute nonsense.

Does Fatima's husband accompany here where she does her shift as a consultant in a local hospital?

Across all traditional schools of thought, normal, everyday movements within one's home city or town are not legally considered "travel". A woman does not require a mahram for:

  • Commuting to work or school within her city limits.
  • Running daily errands, grocery shopping, or visiting local family.

International travel is quite different. The majority of the scholars will say travelling abroad just for holiday should be a to Muslim country only and should be with a male mahram.

Fatima wouldn't really be allowed (by islamic theology) to do a solo trip to Paris.

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 18:35

Assaulted or the pregnancy is going to kill you. Surely those are the main reasons anyway? I don't think people should be allowed to terminate pregnancies willy nilly as it's another life and human being after all.

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 18:33

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 18:24

I think Poland and also Hungary are wonderful countries to be (though I've only been to the latter). I do think the cultural homogeneity and hard stance on irregular migration helps.

I understand and respect Poland's abortion laws. I totally understand and can see it from their perspective.

Pop off there then.

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 18:32

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 13:30

But Fatima's husband and son don't want to travel and go there she can't go

What a load of absolute nonsense.

Does Fatima's husband accompany here where she does her shift as a consultant in a local hospital?

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 18:24

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 16:56

I am in way anti Poland. The point I was making was to counter another poster who was basically saying it's wonderful because everybody is white.

I think Poland and also Hungary are wonderful countries to be (though I've only been to the latter). I do think the cultural homogeneity and hard stance on irregular migration helps.

I understand and respect Poland's abortion laws. I totally understand and can see it from their perspective.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 17:52

Beeloux · 04/11/2026 18:55

Uhm, maybe because there is a higher proportion of white British males in this country than refugees? 🤔

Recently in my small northern town, a refugee attempted to rape a woman and a few streets away, one living in an HMO was exposing himself outside the local primary school. These are just recent cases.

Were the grooming gangs all made up by the DM aswell?

I’ve lived in numerous Islamic counties and was married to an Arab. Very often, European woman are seen as easy bait. Other nationalities too.

I’m sure you’re aware of the disgusting laws against woman in Afghanistan? It doesn’t take much common sense that many of these men will not integrate into a western society.

Edited

I'm really sorry you've had these things happening, it's disgusting.

Which Islamic countries have you lived in?

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 17:04

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 16:56

I am in way anti Poland. The point I was making was to counter another poster who was basically saying it's wonderful because everybody is white.

Wait, do you mean you are 'in no way' anti Poland?

I get that- I do think the image in the West can be unfairly negative but I don't agree with it being a poster country for idealised anti-immigration ideas either.

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 16:56

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:43

In Poland you can get an abortion if you are assaulted or in danger of death, which is bad but better than some US states which have bans even in the case of rape. The current law is really unpopular especially among younger generations. I am sure it will change on day, it's just our political system is polarised & gridlocked which doesn't help.

Re being gay : plenty of urban areas like Warsaw or Wroclaw are more accepting and liberal. Plenty of rural areas-not so much. Polls show support for civil partnerships and step child adoption especially in younger generations but again, gridlock.

I am in way anti Poland. The point I was making was to counter another poster who was basically saying it's wonderful because everybody is white.

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 16:54

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 15:43

We need more people like you.

I do think walking alone is a bit different in the sense that you are more likely to notice things though. On the train you're a passive passenger, may be thinking of the next stop, holding the rail etc. Some passengers surely could have intervened though. Especially the ticket inspector!

It was quite scary tbh. He was a very big bloke and all over the show.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:50

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 13:27

It's legal to be gay in Poland? Abortion is legal in Poland for medical reasons and if the pregnancy was from an illegal act. The women faces no criminal liability whatsoever so they just buy the pills they need to end the pregnancy.

It is difficult though for gay people with no civil partnership rights or step child adoption rights (and an adoption ban). Though I hope for change soon.

Re abortion, that is true. Not as simple as that though : • While the woman is exempt, anyone who assists her—a parent who drives her, or a doctor—faces up to 3 years in prison. Because authorities want to catch "helpers," women who order pills are frequently subjected to police scrutiny. There have been high-profile cases where police raided women's apartments, seized their phones, and interrogated them under the guise of looking for whoever helped them get the medication.
Women have to navigate underground networks or order pills from international non-profits.
If a woman has a complication and goes to a hospital, doctors are sometimes too afraid of prosecution to give proper follow-up care, leading to dangerous medical delays.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:43

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 13:14

How does it work if you are Gay or want to terminate a pregnancy?

In Poland you can get an abortion if you are assaulted or in danger of death, which is bad but better than some US states which have bans even in the case of rape. The current law is really unpopular especially among younger generations. I am sure it will change on day, it's just our political system is polarised & gridlocked which doesn't help.

Re being gay : plenty of urban areas like Warsaw or Wroclaw are more accepting and liberal. Plenty of rural areas-not so much. Polls show support for civil partnerships and step child adoption especially in younger generations but again, gridlock.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:36

Wantingachangeoflif3 · 05/11/2026 12:16

You cant beat your wife in islam fact. If someone choose to do so theyre scum. There's men who say their Christian and slap the wife across the face, theyre not representing jesus teachings

I thought in the Quran it says that you can strike your wife as a last resort?

: https://quran.com/an-nisa/34

Some people argue the same word means 'go away from' though. In the Hadith Muhammad seems more negative about it and is reported not to have beaten his wives.

Surah An-Nisa Ayah 34 on Quran.com

Surah An-Nisa Ayah 34 - Read, Listen, Translation, Tafsir - Quran.com

Surah An-Nisa Ayah 34 - الرجال قوامون على النساء بما فضل الله بعضهم على بعض وبما انفقوا من اموالهم فالصالحات قانتات حافظات للغيب بما حفظ الله واللاتي ...

https://quran.com/an-nisa/34

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Australia, Canada, US and to some extent UK did severely restrict Jewish immigration though. During the war the US also turned away a ship of Jewish refugees many of whom later were murdered in the camps.

Canada said when asked, 'None is already too many.' Australia thought it was against their 'White Australia' policy. If only they had jointly taken refugees, the situation in Palestine would have been far less desperate.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:24

Wantingachangeoflif3 · 05/11/2026 10:40

I dont even understand the whole led business. How was she calmly led to the train loo? My daughters would know to kick up a fuss and shes 13.

She was vulnerable-austistic and running away from home (we don't know why). Autistic teens can be trusting and sometimes act younger than their chronological age.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:22

Fluffyblackcat7 · 05/11/2026 10:26

Thank you for that.

I've been back to the text and to be fair, that's just an opinion of one disciple and if you read the verse before, it's in the context of a husband metaphorically being head of the wife, Jesus being head of the husband and God being head of Jesus, so nothing commanded by God or Jesus, just Paul's personal opinion which he may or may not have meant literally and will have been rooted in the customs of his time which were for women to cover their hair in public.

So no, I don't agree that modern Christian women are commanded to cover their hair in church.

It's an interesting point but I'm not at all sure that we are on topic with whether other passengers should have intervened to assist the girl raped on the train.

My opinion is that if fellow passengers had become aware that she was being coerced, abused and raped then of course they should have acted but I think that the girl's apparent compliance and the fact that she was raped in a toilet out of sight meant that they were probably unaware.

Maybe we should be considering whether if we witness PDA between a teen and an adult in future, we should be asking the young person if they are OK? Would they like to swap seats to be away from the adult? Would they like to speak to the guard?

Edited

I suppose they might not have thought she was 14 but best to err on the side of caution. One was 29, so SURELY looked older by some way, the other 24.

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:19

LiberteLynx · 05/11/2026 10:05

I agree. We should not bury our heads in our books or our podcast or music. We need to all have an awareness of what is going on around us. As bystanders we should aim to prevent and not continue this complacency that amounts to complicity. The not my business, look the other way, do not intervene attitude is part of British culture and dates back decades. It is time we start looking out for the safety of each other, especially vulnerable people like children, women, disabled, elderly. The least we can do is call or text transport police. Those willing to act - ie bang on a toilet door and say the police are coming we can all tie a purple, white, or teal ribbon to our bag so we do not have to consider acting alone as a vulnerable woman (potentially also elderly and/or disabled) ourselves- look for a ribbon and ask for backup. Together we are powerful.

Excellent post! And yes, the BTP could be texted even if people were scared to intervene verbally

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:17

JHound · 05/11/2026 09:51

I do think this is slightly undeserved for modern day Poland. But I do think it’s sad the the Social Media Far Right have latched onto Poland and have decided it has no problems because they “kept the d*rkies out”.

Which is funny when you think of how they reacted to mass migration from Poland to Western EU countries in the early 2000s….

Poland has a lot of people - as a part Pole, imo like a lot of places it depends hugely where you go. It's also really politically & generational polarised.

Minorities like Vietnamese & Tartar Muslims are generally popular as they're perceived to have integrated, and likewise for the Indonesian priests who're trying to plug the recruitment gap . I'd hope if black immigrants also do that they would be accepted (more likely in urban areas). I was actually watching a video on this a while ago on black expats who'd moved to Warsaw, and there was quite a lot of positivity though they did also report some bad experiences. People there are generally quite direct so racist people will be more obvious than somewhere like UK.

The SM far right obsession with Poland is weird : they have a similar thing about Japan being a haven of 'traditional gender roles' when the reality is clearly a bit different!

Ladybarnaby · 05/11/2026 16:07

In a train toilet? There’s barely room to turn round! What happened immediately after the attack when they all left the toilet cubicle?

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:03

chirrupybird · 05/11/2026 09:38

She sat on his knee and he was kissing her and they had been hugging and kissing on the platform it would all have looked perfectly normal behaviour. I would have looked and looked away no one had any reason to assume she was in danger, she wasn't screaming or pushing him off, you would just assume they were boyfriend/girlfriend. And everything else happened in the toilet where she went apparently willingly. If she had shouted for help I'm sure people would have. I hope the rapists get locked up for a long time, but you can't blame the other passengers.

She was only 14. I suppose she might have looked potentially older especially if they didn't look close (many don't) but I still think something should/could have been done

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 16:00

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 09:20

Poland loathes anybody who is different.

I'm part Polish and imo this is unfair.

We do have an aggressively nationalistic right and racist far right. But we have plenty of people who aren't like that at all. There's lots of issues, urban vs rural as well as several others. Poland has a long-standing Vietnamese community who came over in the communist era, as well as a Tartar Muslim minority who came over centuries ago. They are generally popular because they're hardworking, loyal and peaceful.

https://www.rferl.org/a/poland-lipka-tatars-coexistence/25059637.html

There are definite and longstanding issues with anti Semitic political factions but at the same time many people are rediscovering their Jewish heritage after families having to hide it, and Poland has several major Jewish cultural festivals as well as one of the only 2 Yiddish theatres in Europe. These are popular with many non Jews as well as Jews. Physically, Jews are probably less likely to encounter aggression or attacks on the street than in many European countries with higher unintegrated Muslim migrant populations (eg. Germany, France) - online would unfortunately be more the place where that happens, but it's not straightforwardly jingoistic the way it might appear in headlines.

Personally I think the border situation is tragic and aid must be given but I also think the policy of turning them away is correct.

Sorry, that was rather long!

CakeAndEats · 05/11/2026 15:56

WarmAleAndBlackLabrador · 05/11/2026 15:05

I don't know, but I wish we could try!

We can't. There's no way we can. Who would take them??

Jane3212 · 05/11/2026 15:43

baftaagain · 05/11/2026 09:13

People notice what they want to notice.

I noticed a young person who had used ketamine and was in the road.
I did something about it, even though I was a lone female on a cold winters night.

We need more people like you.

I do think walking alone is a bit different in the sense that you are more likely to notice things though. On the train you're a passive passenger, may be thinking of the next stop, holding the rail etc. Some passengers surely could have intervened though. Especially the ticket inspector!

Keeptoiletssafe · 05/11/2026 15:30

AnswerIsNo · 05/11/2026 15:04

You thought it was clear?

Nope, it needed flushing

Russell Brand chose to use a toilet rather than a bar?

Are there many rape cases that occur in full view of a bar, where people onlook and say nothing? Much like the OP of this thread is implying

The answer is no

What next? Toilets made out of glass? CCTV cameras inside? An attendant outside with a sign-in sheet, plus cup they can put next to the door to listen in?

If you want someone to go around the U-bend with discussing the validities of 'word-matching', you might need to choose another gold-plated pedestal to preach from

Edited

You obviously have a different agenda to me.

Regarding the original post. The equivalent to a bar would be for the rape to happen in the carriage full of people. It would be incredibly unusual for this to happen. I only know of one case.

Yes there are toilets made out of glass in Japan. Men have turned the opaqueness off and masturbated inside them when lone women have walked past.

There are ‘sound’ alarms designed specifically for gender neutral toilets in schools - they alert when someone shouts ‘stop it’ or ‘help me’. Children muck about with them so they get switched off. There’s also been trials with private toilets and heat sensors to detect how many bodies are in the toilet. But of course, hidden cameras are a big problem too in many toilets. That epidemic started in Korean countries, though worldwide doctors and teachers (all male) seem to have a disposition for them. The odd politician too.

In contrast, when I entered the ladies toilet washroom years ago, I could see there was a young woman who had turned blue on the floor of her cubicle. Because of the 15cm door gap. So we got her out and cleared her airway and got her breathing again.

You aren’t posting in good faith.