Since starting this thread, I've been reading into other healthcare models, and I looked into Jersey. They are a British Crown Dependency but entirely separate from the NHS, and they run a really interesting hybrid system that tackles time-wasting.
Over there, they actually keep A&E completely free for everyone. But you can’t just rock up with a cold or a minor cough to try and bypass a doctor. The triage nurses are incredibly strict and will literally turn you away and send you packing to a pharmacy. The government has even looked into slapping a £77 fine on anyone who tries to abuse A&E for non-emergencies.
Because you can't use A&E as a workaround, you have to use primary care, and a standard GP visit costs about £40 to £50 out of pocket.
Honestly, it completely cures the crisis we have in the UK where people flood the system for absolutely no medical reason. Because there is a literal price tag on a GP appointment and A&E won't entertain you for a minor issue, people stop treating healthcare like a free daytime social club.
Nobody drags themselves down there for a papercut or a mild cold if it's going to cost them fifty quid. It forces people to look after minor ailments themselves, which weeds out the unnecessary demand currently clogging the NHS. Getting a GP slot over there is almost instant because the time-wasters are completely priced out.
They do have a safety net built-in, so anyone on low-income benefits gets their GP visits heavily subsidized or completely free.
But the only reason Jersey can get away with this is because their economy is a total bubble. They have virtually zero unemployment, and their benefit system is strictly gatekept with harsh savings limits. Only about 5% of households there are on income support, meaning almost everyone is working and earning well enough to absorb a £40 fee.
If you dropped that exact system into a standard UK town, it would break down. But it's a fascinating example—it proves that when you attach a cost to seeing a GP and actually police the front door of A&E, you instantly stop people abusing the system for nothing, leaving the doctors free for people who actually need them.