Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
CalledNeededYoga · 03/11/2026 12:56

The state the NHS has been allowed to get into is a disgrace to our country.

The immediate response is always to give more money. I appreciate that the NHS needs more funding, however, I don’t think it currently manages its finances well enough. There doesn’t seem to be enough accountability placed on the NHS to be efficient within its own spending.

Our evangelical defence of the NHS means we are unlikely to see any improvement.

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 12:51

MissyB1 · 03/11/2026 11:40

No they wouldn’t “carry on doing the work they were doing in private in the NHS” what on earth makes you think that? They already have to fulfill all their NHS responsibilities before they can do private, so if you stopped them doing private these patients would simply have to join the NHS queue.

My point is that the system allowing NHS consultants to move to part-time contracts needs to be reviewed. Where there is an ongoing business need for that individual to fulfil their role within the NHS, I question why a reduction in their NHS hours is seemingly so readily agreed, particularly when those hours can then be used to undertake private practice.

Of course, if someone is granted a part-time NHS contract, they are entitled to work within the terms of that arrangement. My comment isn’t with the individual exercising that entitlement it’s with the decision-making process that allows these arrangements in the first place, potentially at a time when the NHS still has a clear need for that person’s services.

I would argue that it is the system and the criteria for agreeing to these changes in working contracts that need closer scrutiny and review.

Erin1975 · 03/11/2026 12:40

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 12:05

Jersey is mostly rich people, isn't it? They don't have the badly nourished, non exercising vapers, drinkers, junk food eating smokers that we have?

Not everyone in Jersey is rich but it has a population of 100,000 people so comparing it to the NHS in the UK is not a great comparrison.

mugglewump · 03/11/2026 12:39

Every system has its advantages and disadvantages.

I would not like a system which depended on me having the right kind of insurance to get my health looked after. So often, people have policies which don't cover everything and they find themselves having to remortgage their homes to get treatment. Or, they have cover through work and lose their jobs. It's a nightmare. Also, to fund an insurance system wages would have to rise exponentially, which would be very inflationary. My niece, living in the States, pays her cleaner £50 per hour. That's the going rate because cleaners have to have health insurance. Imagine what that kind of wage increase would do to our economy?

Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 12:29

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 12:02

Since starting this thread, I've been reading into other healthcare models, and I looked into Jersey. They are a British Crown Dependency but entirely separate from the NHS, and they run a really interesting hybrid system that tackles time-wasting.

Over there, they actually keep A&E completely free for everyone. But you can’t just rock up with a cold or a minor cough to try and bypass a doctor. The triage nurses are incredibly strict and will literally turn you away and send you packing to a pharmacy. The government has even looked into slapping a £77 fine on anyone who tries to abuse A&E for non-emergencies.

Because you can't use A&E as a workaround, you have to use primary care, and a standard GP visit costs about £40 to £50 out of pocket.

Honestly, it completely cures the crisis we have in the UK where people flood the system for absolutely no medical reason. Because there is a literal price tag on a GP appointment and A&E won't entertain you for a minor issue, people stop treating healthcare like a free daytime social club.

Nobody drags themselves down there for a papercut or a mild cold if it's going to cost them fifty quid. It forces people to look after minor ailments themselves, which weeds out the unnecessary demand currently clogging the NHS. Getting a GP slot over there is almost instant because the time-wasters are completely priced out.

They do have a safety net built-in, so anyone on low-income benefits gets their GP visits heavily subsidized or completely free.

But the only reason Jersey can get away with this is because their economy is a total bubble. They have virtually zero unemployment, and their benefit system is strictly gatekept with harsh savings limits. Only about 5% of households there are on income support, meaning almost everyone is working and earning well enough to absorb a £40 fee.

If you dropped that exact system into a standard UK town, it would break down. But it's a fascinating example—it proves that when you attach a cost to seeing a GP and actually police the front door of A&E, you instantly stop people abusing the system for nothing, leaving the doctors free for people who actually need them.

Yes, but the problem really isn't just time wasters in A&E. The people waiting in A&E for 24/48 hours are often serious and waiting on trolleys in corridors for admission to wards, not people waiting for paracetamol.

There is also the stupid situation in our local hospital where people are moved back into A&E from admission and discharge wards overnight because they close at 8pm whereas A&E stays open 24 hours. There's literally no where else for them to go when the admission/discharge wards close at 8pm and the staff go home! So they're also sat/lying in A&E overnight, not necessarily receiving any care/attention unless obs are needed, and then moved back to the admission/discharge wards again when they re-open the next morning to carry on waiting, and maybe end up in A&E again the next night too!

Same with the default advice from 111, out of hours GP, and even my DH's oncology nurses 24/7 helpline - if they deem you to need medical assistance, they tell you to go to A&E. My DH has had it a few times with serious side effects from his chemotherapy or consequences of his cancer - the cancer nurses have two default answers on their helpline - it's either wait until the next consultant appointment which may be a month or two away, or go to A&E - there's nothing else they can offer! When DH has gone to A&E, they literally just park him in a corner, do basic Obs, and then he has to wait for the on call oncologist to come to see him which may be any time during the day -there's not even the facility to "book" an earlier consultation in the oncology dept ie at the end of their scheduled appointment session - the oncologist has to trail all the way from a different building at the opposite end of the site to A&E.

I'm not saying that A&E doesn't suffer time wasters - it clearly does, but the problems, delays, corridor care, etc has far more reasons than that - lots of people have been told to go there or have no where else to go.

I even had to be admitted via A&E once when I had severe stomach pains that the GP thought was "woman's problems" and wanted an urgent scan, but the only way, he said, to get an urgent scan was to be admitted via Maternity Unit, and to get there, you had to present yourself at A&E, be triaged, etc., even though Maternity was expecting me, there was apparently, no "route" to go straight to maternity, hence a 4 hour wait in A&E being triaged, tests done, etc., before they literally told me to go out of the front door, walk down the road, and go to Maternity ward - I could have done that 4 hours sooner and not been taking up space in A&E!

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 12:28

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 12:20

It wouldn’t. The funding model is the least of its problems.

It would if it reduced unnecessary visits, though.

Yetanotherone12 · 03/11/2026 12:21

Spaniels4Eva · 03/11/2026 11:37

DH has an ongoing cardiac issue, had surgery around 12 weeks ago at a regional specialist and was supposed to be booked in for a cardioversion this month back in our local hospital. We've chased the Consultant's secretary, Central booking and Cardiology outpatients, none of whom have any record of him needing it even though it's a huge part of his post operative care. It is sending both of us batshit trying to get anywhere with anyone.

On the other hand my DD is a midwife and comes home absolutely broken after a 12 hour shift due to the amount of patients that they are having to deal with.

I don't honestly know what the answer is, but we've taken to using a private GP service more and there needs to be a better system of information sharing available between that and the NHS. People using private services is taking the strain off NHS GP's and should be embraced, I feel.

See my earlier post.

Data shows private providers don’t take the strain off public services, in fact the opposite.

It’s use it or lose it. Fewer people using a service shows decreased demand, so those services are reduced to meet the lower demand.

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 12:20

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 11:54

How would that work differently from the current NI?

It wouldn’t. The funding model is the least of its problems.

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 12:18

I would support charging people 50 quid to see a GP or visit A and E.

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 12:17

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 12:11

Yes, it’s a small island tax haven.

Plus it's sunnier than the mainland, I struggle with the lack of sun in the UK winter. I am sure I would be happier if I lived there.

Yetanotherone12 · 03/11/2026 12:16

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 12:02

Since starting this thread, I've been reading into other healthcare models, and I looked into Jersey. They are a British Crown Dependency but entirely separate from the NHS, and they run a really interesting hybrid system that tackles time-wasting.

Over there, they actually keep A&E completely free for everyone. But you can’t just rock up with a cold or a minor cough to try and bypass a doctor. The triage nurses are incredibly strict and will literally turn you away and send you packing to a pharmacy. The government has even looked into slapping a £77 fine on anyone who tries to abuse A&E for non-emergencies.

Because you can't use A&E as a workaround, you have to use primary care, and a standard GP visit costs about £40 to £50 out of pocket.

Honestly, it completely cures the crisis we have in the UK where people flood the system for absolutely no medical reason. Because there is a literal price tag on a GP appointment and A&E won't entertain you for a minor issue, people stop treating healthcare like a free daytime social club.

Nobody drags themselves down there for a papercut or a mild cold if it's going to cost them fifty quid. It forces people to look after minor ailments themselves, which weeds out the unnecessary demand currently clogging the NHS. Getting a GP slot over there is almost instant because the time-wasters are completely priced out.

They do have a safety net built-in, so anyone on low-income benefits gets their GP visits heavily subsidized or completely free.

But the only reason Jersey can get away with this is because their economy is a total bubble. They have virtually zero unemployment, and their benefit system is strictly gatekept with harsh savings limits. Only about 5% of households there are on income support, meaning almost everyone is working and earning well enough to absorb a £40 fee.

If you dropped that exact system into a standard UK town, it would break down. But it's a fascinating example—it proves that when you attach a cost to seeing a GP and actually police the front door of A&E, you instantly stop people abusing the system for nothing, leaving the doctors free for people who actually need them.

There was a study done once that showed the most effective way of reducing a&e wait times was to have a consultant on triage.

someone with the authority and experience to say go home/to your gp/pharmacy.

as you’d expect though consultants didn’t agree triage was the best use of their time and expertise.

Passaggressfedup · 03/11/2026 12:11

Posts like this are infuriating due to its ignorance.

Oh, I only paid £10 out of pocket for an MRI. Out of pocket because there is insurance to pick up the rest....but most importantly, not considering for a second the difference in wages.

The average net monthly income in Turkey is just over £800. For them, insurance and £10 might not be as peanuts as it was for you!

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 12:11

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 12:05

Jersey is mostly rich people, isn't it? They don't have the badly nourished, non exercising vapers, drinkers, junk food eating smokers that we have?

Yes, it’s a small island tax haven.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 03/11/2026 12:11

The main problem is that people want decent health, education and social care but they also want low taxes. We can either have one or the other.

My son costs the NHS a lot of money each year. But to not treat him would be wrong. There are a lot of people who cost the same and more than my son.

There are also people who avoid paying tax, absent parents who refuse to financially support their children. People on universal credit who get an inheritance and ask how they can avoid having their universal credit stopped. People who try and spend as much as they can to avoid having to pay social care costs. People giving their houses and savings to their children to avoid paying for social care. People who employ people as self employed so they can pay them less than minimum wage.

All of this contributes to not being enough money for things like the NHS and social care. And lack of funding in the NHS means spending needs to happen elsewhere. I imagine there are lots of people claiming sickness and disability benefits because they are waiting for NHS treatment. My son has been refused medication to help him sleep. Which means he gets high rate care dla and the severely disabled child rate of universal credit. If he slept through the night he would be on middle rate care dla. I would get a lot more sleep and I'd probably be able to get a part time job while he is at school. My other son was refused treatment from CAMHS. I'm not saying it would have been a miracle cure but he would be better than he is now, I'm sure of it.

Something needs to change but I don't know what we can do about it. Our MP keeps raising the issues in parliament but nothing is done and the situation gets worse.

bababamama · 03/11/2026 12:11

what abroad and how much a month is is costing you from your taxes eg Germany is typically twice the cost of the uk, France is similar. So it’s a case of pay more get more I’m afraid plus I’ve heard complaints from French friends who say that unless you live in Paris some care costs you a fortune to access because you have to pay to get to Paris, even if it’s regionally available it can be expensive in rural areas to travel. Also complaints about charges etc

Yetanotherone12 · 03/11/2026 12:07

Interestingly I read a study the other day- Alberta in Canada has passed legislation so doctors can now work privately alongside their public jobs.

it compares to Quebec, and the UK which already allows this. Stats show that it actually adversely affects public services and increases wait times. The people worst affected are low income - the ones that need it most.

it suprised me. I would have thought people choosing to go private would be a relief to an overburdened system. I do remember I read ages ago that it can take funding out of the NHS.

presumably it means private dr’s are doing less public work, so there are fewer dr’s available, particularly specialists or niche areas, increasing waits. Add that if many hip replacements, for example, now go private, the public services will be greatly reduced, so much smaller depts, increasing wait times.

i think it was NIH via pubmed if anyone’s interested. But in summary private medicine is not good for the NHS.

eta- thinking about it the classic example in the uk is dentistry. More people are private, now dentists aren’t getting nhs funding, aren’t taking on nhs patients, so the reality is nhs dentistry doesn’t really exist any more.

Ghsqiw · 03/11/2026 12:05

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 11:54

How would that work differently from the current NI?

Actually look at how many other nations run their healthcare services

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 12:05

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 11:25

In theory the uk system was supposed to be social insurance - people paid national insurance and it paid for the nhs.

so it was like health insurance but done at a population level.

most of Europe has moderately similar systems but with varying levels of co-pay (individual pays towards appointments/operations etc) and in Europe the money paid towards health has largely been kept separate so people know how much they are paying for it as opposed to the uk where it’s just vanished into general taxation.

Yes, this is what I meant. I think the Continental system builds a greater sense of personal responsibility.

I strongly support state assistance for costs to those who are struggling. (Most countries offer this.) I am of two minds towards the argument that co-pays will discourage those who can afford them from seeking care. Ultimately my feeling is that this doesn’t seem to happen in other countries, because they have better health outcomes than we do, so why would it happen here?

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 12:05

Jersey is mostly rich people, isn't it? They don't have the badly nourished, non exercising vapers, drinkers, junk food eating smokers that we have?

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 12:02

Since starting this thread, I've been reading into other healthcare models, and I looked into Jersey. They are a British Crown Dependency but entirely separate from the NHS, and they run a really interesting hybrid system that tackles time-wasting.

Over there, they actually keep A&E completely free for everyone. But you can’t just rock up with a cold or a minor cough to try and bypass a doctor. The triage nurses are incredibly strict and will literally turn you away and send you packing to a pharmacy. The government has even looked into slapping a £77 fine on anyone who tries to abuse A&E for non-emergencies.

Because you can't use A&E as a workaround, you have to use primary care, and a standard GP visit costs about £40 to £50 out of pocket.

Honestly, it completely cures the crisis we have in the UK where people flood the system for absolutely no medical reason. Because there is a literal price tag on a GP appointment and A&E won't entertain you for a minor issue, people stop treating healthcare like a free daytime social club.

Nobody drags themselves down there for a papercut or a mild cold if it's going to cost them fifty quid. It forces people to look after minor ailments themselves, which weeds out the unnecessary demand currently clogging the NHS. Getting a GP slot over there is almost instant because the time-wasters are completely priced out.

They do have a safety net built-in, so anyone on low-income benefits gets their GP visits heavily subsidized or completely free.

But the only reason Jersey can get away with this is because their economy is a total bubble. They have virtually zero unemployment, and their benefit system is strictly gatekept with harsh savings limits. Only about 5% of households there are on income support, meaning almost everyone is working and earning well enough to absorb a £40 fee.

If you dropped that exact system into a standard UK town, it would break down. But it's a fascinating example—it proves that when you attach a cost to seeing a GP and actually police the front door of A&E, you instantly stop people abusing the system for nothing, leaving the doctors free for people who actually need them.

OP posts:
CuteOrangeElephant · 03/11/2026 11:59

MissyB1 · 03/11/2026 11:53

To be honest as a family we are paying a lot just for our private dental fees (no NHS dentists in our town), so £400 for healthcare and dental sounds reasonable. I mean don’t get me wrong that’s a lot of money for anyone, but if lower incomes get it cheaper or virtually free that would be great. Does it cost more though if you have chronic conditions or have had a serious illness?

No there is a basic insurance package that is the same price for everyone.

Unfortunately not all dental care is included. I got my braces fully paid for, but have to pay for an implant and crowns myself.

Postjurywoes · 03/11/2026 11:57

ExpectMore · 03/11/2026 10:23

The NHS is incompetent. I’ve had them visit for a home appointment whilst being in hospital, had them visit for a home appointment at a time when I specifically said I couldn’t do and they said they’d avoid, had them invite me for an appointment only for no-one to be expecting me for said appointment nor anyone suitable be available when I turned up.
That’s just sheer incompetence at individual and organisational level. It will be blamed on “under funding” however it’s not. They’re literally wasting their resources (and my time) in many cases

Edited

Or could just be human error.

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 11:54

Ghsqiw · 03/11/2026 11:46

It's so bad. We just accept this and clap for it. Social insurance model is the way to go.

How would that work differently from the current NI?

Solaire18381 · 03/11/2026 11:54

I can't speak of being a hospital patient ATM, touch wood but my GP surgery, whenever we've needed them have been fantastic. You can phone or complete a form, and they get back you the same day, either with an appointment or whatever else you might need. We don't have to wait weeks like some stories you hear of. Can't fault them.

MissyB1 · 03/11/2026 11:53

CuteOrangeElephant · 03/11/2026 11:07

This is exactly what I was saying. We pay over 400 euros per month in the Netherlands as a family. My husband's share of 200 per month is for basically nothing as he never needs care. I have more than made up for it though, me and our two children (who are on my health insurance) have cost 35k last year, and 9k this year so far.

The Germans and the Dutch pay more but there's also shorter waiting lists, more nurses, doctors and beds per capita, better IT systems. It's all possible in the UK but it costs money. And no one wants to have this conversation in the UK right now. There is no vision, only talk about cutting costs and getting rid of managers.

To be honest as a family we are paying a lot just for our private dental fees (no NHS dentists in our town), so £400 for healthcare and dental sounds reasonable. I mean don’t get me wrong that’s a lot of money for anyone, but if lower incomes get it cheaper or virtually free that would be great. Does it cost more though if you have chronic conditions or have had a serious illness?