Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
Newname26 · 03/11/2026 14:22

Ghsqiw · 03/11/2026 14:08

Think of it less like the American "you're on your own" nightmare, and more like a highly regulated, compulsory safety net.

Here is the quick guide to how it works in places like Germany and the Netherlands:

You MUST have insurance by law: You aren't allowed to opt out and just hope for the best. Because literally everyone is forced to pay into the system, the financial pot is huge and stays stable.

How it's paid: You don't get a scary bill through the door. In Germany, it’s just sliced straight out of your monthly paycheck automatically, and your employer pays half. In the Netherlands, it’s a mix—some comes out of your wages and you pay a flat monthly fee (roughly €140) to your chosen provider.

The government acts like a strict referee: Insurance companies are heavily regulated. By law, they cannot reject you for having pre-existing conditions, they cannot charge you more for being older or sicker, and they must cover a massive legal list of basics (maternity, GPs, hospital stays).

You get to choose: Unlike our NHS where you generally get the hospital or GP you're given, you shop around for your insurance provider. Because they want your custom, they compete on things like shorter waiting times, better customer service, or nice little perks.

What about kids? For children and stay-at-home parents who don't earn a wage, they are usually covered completely for free under the working partner's policy.

OK, so essentially they are putting more money in.
And ensuring that less people are able to claim care if they haven't been paying,

It wouldn't surprise me if the UK has people who have been resident and left suddenly appear back living with friends when they need treatment.
I also suspect some of the cash only businesses have illegal workers etc too.

But lots of that could be resolved by checking NI stamps over the previous 2 years. The same as they do for contributions based unemployment element of UC

Ghsqiw · 03/11/2026 14:08

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 13:04

Well you seem to know hence I asked the question?

People always say like other European nations i can't work out how they actually work.

Think of it less like the American "you're on your own" nightmare, and more like a highly regulated, compulsory safety net.

Here is the quick guide to how it works in places like Germany and the Netherlands:

You MUST have insurance by law: You aren't allowed to opt out and just hope for the best. Because literally everyone is forced to pay into the system, the financial pot is huge and stays stable.

How it's paid: You don't get a scary bill through the door. In Germany, it’s just sliced straight out of your monthly paycheck automatically, and your employer pays half. In the Netherlands, it’s a mix—some comes out of your wages and you pay a flat monthly fee (roughly €140) to your chosen provider.

The government acts like a strict referee: Insurance companies are heavily regulated. By law, they cannot reject you for having pre-existing conditions, they cannot charge you more for being older or sicker, and they must cover a massive legal list of basics (maternity, GPs, hospital stays).

You get to choose: Unlike our NHS where you generally get the hospital or GP you're given, you shop around for your insurance provider. Because they want your custom, they compete on things like shorter waiting times, better customer service, or nice little perks.

What about kids? For children and stay-at-home parents who don't earn a wage, they are usually covered completely for free under the working partner's policy.

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 14:04

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 13:22

Happy to be educated! Is there no such thing then as a part time contracts? They all work, say, 40 hours a week?

Somewhat like teachers they are not contracted for x number of hours.

nurses and hcas etc are but the hours are put into shifts and you work shift patterns. So it’s not as simple as everyone does 8-5 Monday to Friday.

it’s the responsibility of the hospital directors to make sure there is a safe level of cover at all times and a standard role will come with a shift pattern to help make sure that happens.

however just like anywhere else if a role is vacant all the other team members wind up covering it. You can’t just shut a and e because there isn’t consultant cover - you just lean on the consultant to do more hours.

some roles involve being “on call” and coming in if your expertise is needed.

for GPs it’s certainly contracted by sessions which is in theory equivalent to a half day however very few GPs can manage ten sessions a week because the workload and paperwork per session is way more than half a day.

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 13:56

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 13:14

They could stop treating smokers and alcoholics.

I’m sure the three people left in the uk after that will have very good healthcare.

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 13:51

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 13:46

Does Jersey outsource treatments like the way the Isle of Man does?
Ie send people to the uk for things they can't treat?

I believe so from looking at Google but for very few cases. Some cancers or massive trauma.

OP posts:
Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 13:50

Passaggressfedup · 03/11/2026 12:11

Posts like this are infuriating due to its ignorance.

Oh, I only paid £10 out of pocket for an MRI. Out of pocket because there is insurance to pick up the rest....but most importantly, not considering for a second the difference in wages.

The average net monthly income in Turkey is just over £800. For them, insurance and £10 might not be as peanuts as it was for you!

I didn’t have insurance in Turkey. I totally agree with you on the wage difference although UK’s minimum wage is not even 5 times Turkey so a comparative cost would be less than £50.
Also the MRI machine runs 24/7. I saw the doctor at 9am and was booked in for an MRI at 00.30 that evening. I had surgery less than a week later. And all of my info is on an app. I can download my MRI scan as soon as it has happened, see all of my medications, doctor’s reports, every scan I may ever have had etc.

OP posts:
VickyEadie · 03/11/2026 13:50

mugglewump · 03/11/2026 09:13

There has been chronic underinvestment for decades.

But what do people want? Tax cuts.

The two are incompatible.

Either you want investment in our infrastructure, or you want to depend on private business, who will do very nicely for you if you can afford it.

THIS. Everyone wants better public services, almost everyone wants to pay less tax.

justteanbiscuits · 03/11/2026 13:47

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 12:51

My point is that the system allowing NHS consultants to move to part-time contracts needs to be reviewed. Where there is an ongoing business need for that individual to fulfil their role within the NHS, I question why a reduction in their NHS hours is seemingly so readily agreed, particularly when those hours can then be used to undertake private practice.

Of course, if someone is granted a part-time NHS contract, they are entitled to work within the terms of that arrangement. My comment isn’t with the individual exercising that entitlement it’s with the decision-making process that allows these arrangements in the first place, potentially at a time when the NHS still has a clear need for that person’s services.

I would argue that it is the system and the criteria for agreeing to these changes in working contracts that need closer scrutiny and review.

So you want part time working in the NHS banned? You realise an awful lot of these doctors don't need to be doing NHS work, right? So would just give that up and work permanently private sector for much better money.

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 13:46

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 13:44

The UK has nearly double the amount of hospitals per person than Jersey.

Does Jersey outsource treatments like the way the Isle of Man does?
Ie send people to the uk for things they can't treat?

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 13:46

Hatty65 · 03/11/2026 13:41

What is it you think people are 'accepting' of? Most people in this country are fully aware that the NHS is chronically underfunded and suffering from many years of Tory cuts. It's one of the reasons that a Labour govt got in at the last election.

What is it that you think ordinary people could do to show they are 'not accepting' this state of affairs? Riot?

People mostly tolerate wait times, etc in A&E because they have little choice. Those who can afford it may take out private health insurance, or pay to skip the waiting list and have an operation done privately.

No one thinks the state of the NHS is 'acceptable'. They are grateful for it and wish it was better funded, mostly.

This is just a question - not my view. But people riot or demonstrate for much much less. Look at the disruption a few weeks ago at the ports with the boats coming in with migrants. Are we just conditioned to accept our lot and get on with it in the typical British way?

OP posts:
Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 13:44

Erin1975 · 03/11/2026 12:40

Not everyone in Jersey is rich but it has a population of 100,000 people so comparing it to the NHS in the UK is not a great comparrison.

The UK has nearly double the amount of hospitals per person than Jersey.

OP posts:
Hatty65 · 03/11/2026 13:41

What is it you think people are 'accepting' of? Most people in this country are fully aware that the NHS is chronically underfunded and suffering from many years of Tory cuts. It's one of the reasons that a Labour govt got in at the last election.

What is it that you think ordinary people could do to show they are 'not accepting' this state of affairs? Riot?

People mostly tolerate wait times, etc in A&E because they have little choice. Those who can afford it may take out private health insurance, or pay to skip the waiting list and have an operation done privately.

No one thinks the state of the NHS is 'acceptable'. They are grateful for it and wish it was better funded, mostly.

mybiggreenfrog · 03/11/2026 13:36

Part of it is we are providing millions of pounds worth of treatment to foreigners who come here specifically for treatment. We need to just say "no" like they do in other countries. I had private surgery a few months ago ... had to pay up-front for treatment. Why can't they do the same with foreigners? Bloody madness.

Bushmillsbabe · 03/11/2026 13:33

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 03/11/2026 10:11

We’ve finally voted out the Tories who are mostly responsible for the chronic underfunding of the NHS. Why it took us so long is a mystery, as it will now take many years and a lot of money to turn it around. I agree that the current waiting times are unacceptable, but there’s not much that ordinary people can do about this.

The biggest cuts we have had are under this government. We have been told to cut our budgets 5% year on year. Each year that gets harder to do. Staff leave and we aren't allowed to replace them, and the current staff are under so much pressure that it's not long before they start going off with stress. I cut my hours to part time, so I could catch up on my admin on my non working unpaid days and have the weekends to spend time with my children. Fortunately my husband earns enough that I can do this, others can't, and are working until midnight/on weekends to catch up in what is supposed to be a 9-5 Monday to Friday job.

When I voted for Labour at the last election, I didn't expect them to fix the nhs straight away. But I didn't expect that they would make it even worse!

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 13:24

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 13:19

The NHS is in profit from smokers by quite a high margin. People lie anyway.

Edited

Except tobacco duties are so high, many smokers buy on the black market. Also, the NHS doesn't get the tobacco taxes anyway.

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 13:22

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 13:00

NHS consultants are contracted for a certain number of sessions per week. Most of those doing private work are working a full week in the NHS with private work at the beginning/end of the day or at weekends. My ophthalmologist did my cataract surgery at the end of a full day working for the NHS and my follow up in his lunch break. No time was taken away from the NHS in fact it gained because he had to reimburse it for the theatre time he used from his fee.

You clearly have no understanding of how this works.

Happy to be educated! Is there no such thing then as a part time contracts? They all work, say, 40 hours a week?

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 13:19

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 13:14

They could stop treating smokers and alcoholics.

The NHS is in profit from smokers by quite a high margin. People lie anyway.

x2boys · 03/11/2026 13:18

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 13:14

They could stop treating smokers and alcoholics.

Well they could but i would be very careful goung down that road.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 13:17

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 13:14

They could stop treating smokers and alcoholics.

I disagree. Next it will be the overweight (which will solve the NHS budget problem nicely), anyone who drinks, then those who participate in someone’s idea of risky sports. Etc etc.

Best not to start down that slippery slope.

RaggedRocks · 03/11/2026 13:14

They could stop treating smokers and alcoholics.

justteanbiscuits · 03/11/2026 13:12

Blankscreen · 03/11/2026 09:02

I don't know amy other industry where you can moonlight to the detriment of your main job and get away with it yet somehow doctors are allowed to run their own practice on the side. Outrageous.

Doctors do NOT work less hours in order to do private practice. They will work well over their contracted hours in the NHS. Everyone is allowed to do two part time roles - whether it be for more money or work life balance.

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 13:09

Postjurywoes · 03/11/2026 13:03

Jersey is hardly comparable to Salford A and E on a Saturday night is it!

😂

Newname26 · 03/11/2026 13:04

Ghsqiw · 03/11/2026 12:05

Actually look at how many other nations run their healthcare services

Well you seem to know hence I asked the question?

People always say like other European nations i can't work out how they actually work.

Postjurywoes · 03/11/2026 13:03

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 12:02

Since starting this thread, I've been reading into other healthcare models, and I looked into Jersey. They are a British Crown Dependency but entirely separate from the NHS, and they run a really interesting hybrid system that tackles time-wasting.

Over there, they actually keep A&E completely free for everyone. But you can’t just rock up with a cold or a minor cough to try and bypass a doctor. The triage nurses are incredibly strict and will literally turn you away and send you packing to a pharmacy. The government has even looked into slapping a £77 fine on anyone who tries to abuse A&E for non-emergencies.

Because you can't use A&E as a workaround, you have to use primary care, and a standard GP visit costs about £40 to £50 out of pocket.

Honestly, it completely cures the crisis we have in the UK where people flood the system for absolutely no medical reason. Because there is a literal price tag on a GP appointment and A&E won't entertain you for a minor issue, people stop treating healthcare like a free daytime social club.

Nobody drags themselves down there for a papercut or a mild cold if it's going to cost them fifty quid. It forces people to look after minor ailments themselves, which weeds out the unnecessary demand currently clogging the NHS. Getting a GP slot over there is almost instant because the time-wasters are completely priced out.

They do have a safety net built-in, so anyone on low-income benefits gets their GP visits heavily subsidized or completely free.

But the only reason Jersey can get away with this is because their economy is a total bubble. They have virtually zero unemployment, and their benefit system is strictly gatekept with harsh savings limits. Only about 5% of households there are on income support, meaning almost everyone is working and earning well enough to absorb a £40 fee.

If you dropped that exact system into a standard UK town, it would break down. But it's a fascinating example—it proves that when you attach a cost to seeing a GP and actually police the front door of A&E, you instantly stop people abusing the system for nothing, leaving the doctors free for people who actually need them.

Jersey is hardly comparable to Salford A and E on a Saturday night is it!

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 13:00

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 12:51

My point is that the system allowing NHS consultants to move to part-time contracts needs to be reviewed. Where there is an ongoing business need for that individual to fulfil their role within the NHS, I question why a reduction in their NHS hours is seemingly so readily agreed, particularly when those hours can then be used to undertake private practice.

Of course, if someone is granted a part-time NHS contract, they are entitled to work within the terms of that arrangement. My comment isn’t with the individual exercising that entitlement it’s with the decision-making process that allows these arrangements in the first place, potentially at a time when the NHS still has a clear need for that person’s services.

I would argue that it is the system and the criteria for agreeing to these changes in working contracts that need closer scrutiny and review.

NHS consultants are contracted for a certain number of sessions per week. Most of those doing private work are working a full week in the NHS with private work at the beginning/end of the day or at weekends. My ophthalmologist did my cataract surgery at the end of a full day working for the NHS and my follow up in his lunch break. No time was taken away from the NHS in fact it gained because he had to reimburse it for the theatre time he used from his fee.

You clearly have no understanding of how this works.

Swipe left for the next trending thread