Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
Barney16 · 03/11/2026 20:40

I find the NHS bizarre. I have had some really good experiences and some frankly awful brushes with it. It's so inconsistent. My elderly dad ended up in a and e for about ten hours because he was sent there by his GP who said oh all referrals through A and E now. That just doesn't make any sense. He didn't need emergency treatment he needed to be moved on to a specific department. I have sat in a and e with poorly people but been surrounded by very very sick people,generally very old people, who wait and wait. It's awful. It needs a massive overhaul and at the same time a huge remodeling of adult social care.

WarmHiker · 03/11/2026 20:32

Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 19:15

Just like the NHS in the UK then.

And?

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 20:27

5128gap · 03/11/2026 16:40

What do you suggest? I've already voted for the government I believe most committed to improve it. I don't complain about the tax I pay and wouldn't complain about paying more. I give my constructive feedback on patient surveys and I donate to fund raisers to purchase equipment etc.
I'm not going to start throwing chairs about and shouting at staff who have no power to do anything about it, and it's not like we can boycott it, or storm the hospital walls and stage a coup, helping ourselves to the tests, treatments and surgeries we need. So what form of revolt to you have in mind?

I have absolutely no idea which is why I asked the question

OP posts:
THisbackwithavengeance · 03/11/2026 19:51

My experience of the NHS has generally been good but given that we’ve become a nation of fat, mentally unwell, druggies and depressives. No wonder it’s fucked.

Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 19:15

WarmHiker · 03/11/2026 19:14

You did not get free healthcare abroad. Someone paid for it.

Just like the NHS in the UK then.

WarmHiker · 03/11/2026 19:14

You did not get free healthcare abroad. Someone paid for it.

IntentionallyAsymmetrical · 03/11/2026 19:07

Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

How can we not accept it - we have no choice, other than paying for private medical care/health insurance, which many who can afford it are now doing anyway.

You pose the question as though there were some route of appeal, or an alternative free healthcare choice - but there isn't.

I don't think you have thought your question through, OP.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 18:53

Mortgagedecisions · 03/11/2026 18:32

I have 30 years service in the NHS. Some reflections from me (long and garbled but cathartic!):

Basic care was better 30 years ago in many ways. Particularly if you were a patient on a ward ran by a ‘dragon’. The junior staff were usually scared of the dragon but all the patients were clean and had pain relief. Staff regularly worked 1-3 unpaid additional hours per day and you often didn’t get a break. Maybe the basic care was better because the staff were working in a way that isn’t acceptable today. Or maybe we need more staff plus the dragons back and the staff to have respect for them.

Most patients treated staff with respect and were in hospital because they needed to be. If as a nurse you suspected someone was under the influence of a substance they were treated kindly but firmly. You did not worry they would assault you, film you or complain about you.

People with mental health conditions were not on the acute wards generally. Today we seem to have people in acute hospitals who need a different type of care. It’s impossible to meet their care needs (mental health and substance misuse are just examples) on an acute ward or in an A&E department. We don’t want to go back to institutionalising people but it’s clear the current care in the community isn’t working for everyone. Acute NHS staff are spending ineffective hours trying to contain someone when what they need is specialist help.

Old, outdated practices which we do not want to go back to were used 30 years ago. People were lifted and handled, this meant sometimes patients were injured as were staff; but needs were met more quickly. People for example those with dementia who were distressed or wandering were sedated. This is illegal now, rightly, but safe, effective alternative treatments do not seem to be used in ward settings. Families were more involved in care 30 years ago particularly in the community. This doesn’t seem as possible now (probably as there isn’t a woman at home to do the unpaid caring work).

30 years ago staff ran hospitals to protect the system. Visiting was restricted to maintain privacy and dignity. If people attended A&E and were deemed not to need it they were firmly told this and directed elsewhere. Of course this meant sometimes people were sent away that shouldn’t have been.

People demanded less. People generally didn’t attend A&E or the GPs unless there was something very wrong with them. Sometimes this was the right decision. Sometimes people attended too late.

In 2026 the dragons have all been investigated for bullying. There aren’t enough managers to supervise the staff. Staff work the hours they are paid for. Staff will only follow policy and procedure because they have been trained to do this. Patients complain quite rightly if staff get something wrong so all decisions are made defensively.
There can’t be a policy or procedure for every scenario in the NHS so this means quite often patients bounce around between departments or professionals.

Patients are more demanding, sometimes rightly, you should have pain relief when you need it for example but also patients are asking staff who are very busy to do things like open the door for their deliveroo deliveries multiple times per shift. Staff do not feel able to refuse this or question how ill they are if they’re able to order and eat a takeaway from their bed on the acute ward.

Staff do not dare ask people who are under the influence of drink or drugs to behave appropriately or go elsewhere because what if they have an underlying medical condition and this is missed?

Health care advances are amazing and many more people survive illnesses and injuries than they did 30 years ago. However us humans seem to have started to take good health for granted rather than take responsibility for looking after ourselves.

I’ve worked with other health systems and our NHS is something we should be very proud of and something we should fight for.

A very interesting and, I think, balanced post.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 18:51

LetsDillyDally · 03/11/2026 16:59

I would argue that with all the issues I’ve seen with an ageing population and the difficulties accessing social care - IVF is important if we want enough people in the population to sustain our society, especially if they introduce huge limits to immigration

This is a fair point for a national conversation.

Mortgagedecisions · 03/11/2026 18:32

I have 30 years service in the NHS. Some reflections from me (long and garbled but cathartic!):

Basic care was better 30 years ago in many ways. Particularly if you were a patient on a ward ran by a ‘dragon’. The junior staff were usually scared of the dragon but all the patients were clean and had pain relief. Staff regularly worked 1-3 unpaid additional hours per day and you often didn’t get a break. Maybe the basic care was better because the staff were working in a way that isn’t acceptable today. Or maybe we need more staff plus the dragons back and the staff to have respect for them.

Most patients treated staff with respect and were in hospital because they needed to be. If as a nurse you suspected someone was under the influence of a substance they were treated kindly but firmly. You did not worry they would assault you, film you or complain about you.

People with mental health conditions were not on the acute wards generally. Today we seem to have people in acute hospitals who need a different type of care. It’s impossible to meet their care needs (mental health and substance misuse are just examples) on an acute ward or in an A&E department. We don’t want to go back to institutionalising people but it’s clear the current care in the community isn’t working for everyone. Acute NHS staff are spending ineffective hours trying to contain someone when what they need is specialist help.

Old, outdated practices which we do not want to go back to were used 30 years ago. People were lifted and handled, this meant sometimes patients were injured as were staff; but needs were met more quickly. People for example those with dementia who were distressed or wandering were sedated. This is illegal now, rightly, but safe, effective alternative treatments do not seem to be used in ward settings. Families were more involved in care 30 years ago particularly in the community. This doesn’t seem as possible now (probably as there isn’t a woman at home to do the unpaid caring work).

30 years ago staff ran hospitals to protect the system. Visiting was restricted to maintain privacy and dignity. If people attended A&E and were deemed not to need it they were firmly told this and directed elsewhere. Of course this meant sometimes people were sent away that shouldn’t have been.

People demanded less. People generally didn’t attend A&E or the GPs unless there was something very wrong with them. Sometimes this was the right decision. Sometimes people attended too late.

In 2026 the dragons have all been investigated for bullying. There aren’t enough managers to supervise the staff. Staff work the hours they are paid for. Staff will only follow policy and procedure because they have been trained to do this. Patients complain quite rightly if staff get something wrong so all decisions are made defensively.
There can’t be a policy or procedure for every scenario in the NHS so this means quite often patients bounce around between departments or professionals.

Patients are more demanding, sometimes rightly, you should have pain relief when you need it for example but also patients are asking staff who are very busy to do things like open the door for their deliveroo deliveries multiple times per shift. Staff do not feel able to refuse this or question how ill they are if they’re able to order and eat a takeaway from their bed on the acute ward.

Staff do not dare ask people who are under the influence of drink or drugs to behave appropriately or go elsewhere because what if they have an underlying medical condition and this is missed?

Health care advances are amazing and many more people survive illnesses and injuries than they did 30 years ago. However us humans seem to have started to take good health for granted rather than take responsibility for looking after ourselves.

I’ve worked with other health systems and our NHS is something we should be very proud of and something we should fight for.

mybiggreenfrog · 03/11/2026 18:27

NewGoldFox · 03/11/2026 09:51

Because people won’t / can’t afford more tax.

But we are paying more tax, every year, due to the tax threshold freeze.

rwalker · 03/11/2026 18:20

Blankscreen · 03/11/2026 09:02

I don't know amy other industry where you can moonlight to the detriment of your main job and get away with it yet somehow doctors are allowed to run their own practice on the side. Outrageous.

My friends wife is a rota coordinator for doctors and consultants
they literally hold the trust to ransom just please themselves because they know they can

Coeliacsmum · 03/11/2026 17:55

We have no choice in emergency but I know the politicians will never sort it out, so we pay for BUPA cover just in case. There is a BUPA GP we could use but it would be a long drive away for face to face, so tend to use the NHS one which is just all E Consult anyway. It feels like healthcare in the UK is impossible to access in a timely manner, so you only try when absolutely necessary.
I got a flu jab on NHS this year but got a private covid one at local pharmacy. I paid privately for gall bladder removal during covid.
It is a total mess and it needs some competition, throwing more money at it won't improve the service to the long-suffering patients on the ground.

Pippa12 · 03/11/2026 17:55

BCBird · 03/11/2026 17:53

For me the logistics are the issue. There are two software systems in use not one. Despite the fact that we all have an NHS number if you move to an area that is not using the same system your new area cannot access your records. This is madness. Departments don't talk to each other- madness. People within the nhs seem resigned to this madness too. I find the individuals i v
come into contact with pleasant and professional.

It would literally bankrupt the nhs to rectify this now unfortunately. We do have shared care in my area that links hospitals in the area, but I think that’s as good as it gets. It’s not two separate softwares, it must be 100’s.

BCBird · 03/11/2026 17:53

For me the logistics are the issue. There are two software systems in use not one. Despite the fact that we all have an NHS number if you move to an area that is not using the same system your new area cannot access your records. This is madness. Departments don't talk to each other- madness. People within the nhs seem resigned to this madness too. I find the individuals i v
come into contact with pleasant and professional.

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 17:45

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 17:42

Speak for yourself. You don’t speak for me.

Maybe I don't, but I think you'll find I speak for a lot of people. I have a lot of friends who are higher rate taxpayers and they are all fed up to the backteeth with this country.

LetsDillyDally · 03/11/2026 17:42

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 17:37

It's because doctors aren't paid enough. They should be paid twice or three times what they are. The system will end in my lifetime.

many doctors are paid very well actually. But you want to be a specialist nurse? You have to spend half your time filling out forms that same the same thing explaining the processes to some one with no clinical experience and get told to actively say no to doctors. Oh and you’ll have friends working more sociable hours earning ten times what you do. My friend is a retail manager earning double what I do with half as much experience in that industry.

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2026 17:42

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 17:38

We want our taxes being well spent, not on funding people having endless kids and propping up too many poorly paid immigrants.

Speak for yourself. You don’t speak for me.

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 17:38

mugglewump · 03/11/2026 09:13

There has been chronic underinvestment for decades.

But what do people want? Tax cuts.

The two are incompatible.

Either you want investment in our infrastructure, or you want to depend on private business, who will do very nicely for you if you can afford it.

We want our taxes being well spent, not on funding people having endless kids and propping up too many poorly paid immigrants.

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 17:37

Blankscreen · 03/11/2026 09:02

I don't know amy other industry where you can moonlight to the detriment of your main job and get away with it yet somehow doctors are allowed to run their own practice on the side. Outrageous.

It's because doctors aren't paid enough. They should be paid twice or three times what they are. The system will end in my lifetime.

Pippa12 · 03/11/2026 17:35

LancashireButterPie · 03/11/2026 17:31

Nah, not buying this. I've worked in the NHS for 35 years and there is still a ridiculous amount of money wasted on "managers" who do bugger all.
The worst are the Band 7 "quality initiative" or QI teams. Honestly it's well known among clinicians that if you want an easy ride you move to that nonsense team. I watched one of them spend months establishing a portal for all local mental health services, except this already exists as the national "Hub of Hope" App.
She won a local award for reinventing the wheel.
All the managers were doing masters degrees and getting staff to do their research for them. Vanity projects really but it really eats into your clinical time.
There was a whole "research" team set up during COVID (a place to relocate vulnerable staff) it's still running today and it has not produced one piece of published research yet, I mean what on earth are those 17 people doing?
In my last workplace, admin, management, QI and HR etc outnumbered the clinical staff by 4 to one.
There is nothing worse than seeing two full clinics of patients, struggling to find time to do onward referrals and proper documentation while watching your managers doing an Ocado shop or sat gossiping.
If we have to have so many managers
at least employ proper managers with degrees and experience in management, my last manager was a 25 year old with just 3 years clinical experience, no management qualifications but an amazing willingness to fully enforce upper management decisions without question about how those decisions would impact our service delivery.
It's the clinician's who knows how their service works and how it needs to develop, the managers need to listen to them.
They don't.

Agree with this. Please don’t bring anymore ‘managers’ on board that want to tell me how to do my job ‘effectively’ with absolutely no clinical experience whatsoever.

LancashireButterPie · 03/11/2026 17:31

helpfulperson · 03/11/2026 09:33

This.

And people complain about the number of managers despite us having the lowest manager to clinician ratio in Europe. Efficient running of anything needs managers but we don't want to pay for what is needed. Same applies to upkeep of buildings.

Nah, not buying this. I've worked in the NHS for 35 years and there is still a ridiculous amount of money wasted on "managers" who do bugger all.
The worst are the Band 7 "quality initiative" or QI teams. Honestly it's well known among clinicians that if you want an easy ride you move to that nonsense team. I watched one of them spend months establishing a portal for all local mental health services, except this already exists as the national "Hub of Hope" App.
She won a local award for reinventing the wheel.
All the managers were doing masters degrees and getting staff to do their research for them. Vanity projects really but it really eats into your clinical time.
There was a whole "research" team set up during COVID (a place to relocate vulnerable staff) it's still running today and it has not produced one piece of published research yet, I mean what on earth are those 17 people doing?
In my last workplace, admin, management, QI and HR etc outnumbered the clinical staff by 4 to one.
There is nothing worse than seeing two full clinics of patients, struggling to find time to do onward referrals and proper documentation while watching your managers doing an Ocado shop or sat gossiping.
If we have to have so many managers
at least employ proper managers with degrees and experience in management, my last manager was a 25 year old with just 3 years clinical experience, no management qualifications but an amazing willingness to fully enforce upper management decisions without question about how those decisions would impact our service delivery.
It's the clinician's who knows how their service works and how it needs to develop, the managers need to listen to them.
They don't.

Pippa12 · 03/11/2026 17:02

I’m nhs. Revolt, kick up a stink,,, whatever it takes, we want you to do it!! We don’t think it’s acceptable either.

The last strikes were about patient safety, work load, lack of job opportunities, poor working conditions and of course, pay. The strike were not well received by the public in this area. Front line staff can do absolutely nothing about the conditions/work load waiting times.

It’s a bloody mess.

LetsDillyDally · 03/11/2026 16:59

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 16:56

@BlueSherbet Weight loss is a huge medical issue. I am fairly ignorant in this area, but I have accomplished friends and relatives who struggle badly. I know there are entire research journals and prestigious academic conferences devoted to the subject of shifting stubbornly clinging weight amongst the obese population, and professors in this specialism can talk endlessly about how frustrating it is that the public regard weight loss as a matter of willpower. So I think WLI are a medical advance, likely to save the NHS loads of £££ as cases of diabetes, heart attack, stroke and other complications of obesity are prevented.

I would classify helping to prevent medical harm as part of a doctor’s moral mandate (and I do not think it is restricted to gay men).
Terminating pregnancy is clearly a medical procedure. I can see the argument that it isn’t morally neutral, but it is hard to argue that lawful terminations should not be provided by a national health service.

I would argue that surgical change of gender (if we accept that sex is determined at birth) is a grey area. It may be necessary fo the mental health of some, to the point that without it they could be suicidal. I think then we pay. What about other cases? I don’t know, and it is hard to draw a line, but perhaps they should be part of the conversation. However I don’t think all the NHS transgender medical care in the country is a huge expense.

IVF is trickier. It is hugely sympathetic, but hugely expensive. In a national conversation we may decide it is important to fund IVF, but then we should be honest about the cost and increase taxes accordingly. Infertility is heartbreaking, but it is not the same order of magnitude as cancer or other life threatening diseases that we aren’t getting right.

Really, though, how many of these issues are there? Mt impression is that getting diabetes under control would have a much bigger impact on the NHS budget.

I would argue that with all the issues I’ve seen with an ageing population and the difficulties accessing social care - IVF is important if we want enough people in the population to sustain our society, especially if they introduce huge limits to immigration

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 16:56

@BlueSherbet Weight loss is a huge medical issue. I am fairly ignorant in this area, but I have accomplished friends and relatives who struggle badly. I know there are entire research journals and prestigious academic conferences devoted to the subject of shifting stubbornly clinging weight amongst the obese population, and professors in this specialism can talk endlessly about how frustrating it is that the public regard weight loss as a matter of willpower. So I think WLI are a medical advance, likely to save the NHS loads of £££ as cases of diabetes, heart attack, stroke and other complications of obesity are prevented.

I would classify helping to prevent medical harm as part of a doctor’s moral mandate (and I do not think it is restricted to gay men).
Terminating pregnancy is clearly a medical procedure. I can see the argument that it isn’t morally neutral, but it is hard to argue that lawful terminations should not be provided by a national health service.

I would argue that surgical change of gender (if we accept that sex is determined at birth) is a grey area. It may be necessary fo the mental health of some, to the point that without it they could be suicidal. I think then we pay. What about other cases? I don’t know, and it is hard to draw a line, but perhaps they should be part of the conversation. However I don’t think all the NHS transgender medical care in the country is a huge expense.

IVF is trickier. It is hugely sympathetic, but hugely expensive. In a national conversation we may decide it is important to fund IVF, but then we should be honest about the cost and increase taxes accordingly. Infertility is heartbreaking, but it is not the same order of magnitude as cancer or other life threatening diseases that we aren’t getting right.

Really, though, how many of these issues are there? Mt impression is that getting diabetes under control would have a much bigger impact on the NHS budget.