Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
IdentifyingAsAWoollyMammoth · 03/11/2026 10:32

I've had brilliant treatment from the NHS the last three years both at my GPs and three times the hospital (including two surgeries). Conversely my partner has an ongoing condition and while GP has been good the hospital has been lousy. Same hospital, different issues, different departments.

My grandad received fabulous care whereas my grandmother was killed by negligence. Same hospital trust, different hospitals.

The NHS needs a root and branch reorganization but no government will grasp the nettle and take it on. It's a sacred cow and one of the largest employers in the world. It is rubbish at preventative medicine in so many conditions, where they could spend a little now to prevent spending shedloads down the road. They also fund things they shouldn't and which it was never set up to do.

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 10:32

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 10:21

Where I work, I can request to reduce my hours to part time but my employer is not obliged to agree if there is a business need to refuse. It’s not guaranteed just because say I fancy working somewhere else, and especially to the employers detriment. Are they ever asked to put forward a business case as to how their reduced hours will be managed? So their employer can continue deliver the same service?

It seems that in the nhs, they demand and get? Are they ever told no, sorry, we need you as you are valuable and needed by your main contracted employer?

Yes, sometimes.

however the nhs has a lot of employees. Some request part time hours after returning from maternity. If that request is refused some come back full time others just quit.

some request part time for looking after elderly parents/other family caring reasons. Again, if refused some go part time and others quit.

there’s a reason return to nursing/etc type courses are run and that’s because lots of people who are trained nurses/physios/doctors leave for a whole variety of reasons and the nhs would like to be able to use their skills if they want to come back.

quite a few of those people who quit because they want part time will then do eg supply gp by the day in the nhs or two days a week for a private gp surgery.

Mischance · 03/11/2026 10:29

too many left wing activists are wedded to the system. - why would they not be? Free health care at the point of use is a sound principle. It is not just left wing activists who share this view.

It may be that rich Tories do not care about it as they can afford private care. They have certainly done nothing to improve things over the last decade or so - quite the opposite.

The real issue is how the NHS should be funded in the context of people living longer and acquiring a multitude of conditions, and new expensive treatments and investigations emerging.

Every government faces the challenge of how this should be funded. None has fully grasped the nettle. But at least we now have a government that recognises that not everyone can top up with private care - that's a good starting point for discussion.

In the end it will either involve higher taxes or some sort of insurance system.

I had a full spine MRI and it needed interpreting by a consultant spinal surgeon and a decision as to treatment. What was on offer? - a 6 month wait to see one at a hospital 2.5 hours away as there is no-one nearer. Since I am not well enough to make that journey (for the same reason I had the MRI!) I opted for a private consultation - only over the phone was on offer - that cost me hundreds. Luckily I had had a small win on Ernie.

This is what so many people are doing now if they can afford it.

MyKindHiker · 03/11/2026 10:27

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 10:21

I am talking about Turkey. I have since returned to the UK, but while I had my Turkish residency, the system there was honestly a total eye-opener compared to what we have grown used to with the NHS.

To clear up any assumptions: no, this isn't high-end luxury private healthcare for wealthy expats. I was using their standard public state hospital system.

Here is how it actually works and why it moves so fast:

  • Incredibly low-cost public rates: Even if you don't have their state insurance and pay entirely out of pocket, the state-subsidised rates are peanuts compared to Western pricing. I needed an MRI. I walked into the public hospital, went to the cashier desk, paid exactly £10.15 out of pocket, and got the scan done almost immediately.
  • No GP gatekeeping for specialists: In the UK, you can wait weeks just to see a GP, who then has to refer you to a specialist, leading to months of further waiting. In the public system there, you can use a central app or website to directly book an appointment with a hospital specialist (like a cardiologist, dermatologist, or orthopedist) yourself.
  • Massive infrastructure & throughput: The state hospitals there are huge, highly modernised, and run like high-efficiency factories. They prioritise rapid diagnostics. Things like MRIs, blood tests, and scans are treated as immediate operational tasks rather than precious resources that need to be rationed.
  • Neighborhood Family Health Centres: For routine things, every neighborhood has a small, local walk-in clinic with family doctors. You can just walk in, get a ticket, and usually be seen the same morning for basic prescriptions or minor issues.
  • Everything is digital: They use a centralized health app. Every single blood test, X-ray, prescription, and MRI report is uploaded directly to your smartphone under your ID number within days. You don't have to chase doctors for results; you own your data.

It isn't a flawless system—there can be queues, and if you don't speak the language you definitely need a translation app to navigate the state hospitals—but experiencing it makes you realise that a public healthcare system doesn't have to mean waiting months in pain for a basic diagnostic scan.

I have used AI to write this as it explains it far more eloquently than I ever could.

Again, yes better systems exist. But the one off amount of money it would cost to get to a system like this will not be palatable for the British public.

Sadcafe · 03/11/2026 10:25

I don’t think many people are happy with the current state of the NHS, but tackling the problem is massive, not enough resources,money spent on let’s be honest pointless things rather than frontline services, burnt out staff, the list is endless.

MaeshoweDragon · 03/11/2026 10:25

@Gizzasec "Re general practice, my surgery has recently switched to a mainly-online system & it's banished the old wait-for-40-minutes-in-a-phone-queue-at-8am malarkey. Brilliant! Though I wonder how older, non-techie patients are coping. "

We are in Gloucestershire. The computer services company supplying the software for our GP online system went bust last week (a lot of gps used this system).
Now no booking online. No phone booking either as they got rid of a lot of reception staff, so 2 hours on the phone queue or turn up in person and join the queue outside to book an appointment in 6 weeks.
System is great until something goes wrong.

DistantEarlyWarning · 03/11/2026 10:24

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 10:06

Review contracts then perhaps? I too wouldn’t be allowed to work elsewhere without permission from my employer. It’s in my contract. I’m nothing special, basic type job.

If doctors stopped the extra work, who would do the extra work? What impact would that have on patients?

ExpectMore · 03/11/2026 10:23

The NHS is incompetent. I’ve had them visit for a home appointment whilst being in hospital, had them visit for a home appointment at a time when I specifically said I couldn’t do and they said they’d avoid, had them invite me for an appointment only for no-one to be expecting me for said appointment nor anyone suitable be available when I turned up.
That’s just sheer incompetence at individual and organisational level. It will be blamed on “under funding” however it’s not. They’re literally wasting their resources (and my time) in many cases

Erin1975 · 03/11/2026 10:23

Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 10:19

If they made fewer mistakes, there'd be fewer wasted appointments and people would be seen quicker.

My DH has had cancer for 8 years, and recently needed a major leg operation due to his cancer. The lack of communication between departments literally opposite each other on the same hospital corridor led to several wasted appointments, a delayed operation (cancelled literally on the morning it was scheduled due to lack of communication between oncologist and orthopaedic surgeon), and wasted appointments/wasted prescriptions for very expensive chemotherapy drugs in the weeks afterwards. They just couldn't pick up the bloody phone and talk to each other and would rather waste stupid amounts of time and NHS resources whilst waiting for bloody letters to be typed up between departments! Until you've been in the thick of it and seen the sheer incompetence, it's hard to imagine just how disorganised it all is. And that's before we get to the useless GPs who ignore letters sent by the hospital specialists - again, the sods won't talk to each other meaning it's the cancer riddled patient who has to pass messages! It's utterly ridiculous.

I'm sure lots of people can cite specific examples of problems. But those will exist in any healthcare system which provides treatment to millions of people each year. If you think similar problems don't happen in Germany or France you are kidding yourself.

The biggest problem is still the massive increase in demand for healthcare services.

CuteOrangeElephant · 03/11/2026 10:22

People in the UK don't want to accept that healthcare costs money. A lot of money. And it will only get worse as the population is aging.

I'm in the Netherlands and I have to pay mandatory health insurance, all in it costs us over 400 euros per month, that is to cover a family of 4 with complete dental cover for the children and some for me. People with lower incomes do get a significant portion of this back.

I can see how much I have cost the insurance over the years and last year alone it was 35k. This year we are at 9k and counting. I certainly feel like I've had my money's worth. For that money I do get much better access to healthcare and also better quality. Dutch people like to grumble but I have lived in the UK and all my in-laws still live there and they don't know how good they've got it.

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 10:21

oviraptor21 · 03/11/2026 10:16

Yes they can have part time contracts. Nothing unusual there.
They've already paid for tuition and worked 10 years by the time they are able to get a private position.

Where I work, I can request to reduce my hours to part time but my employer is not obliged to agree if there is a business need to refuse. It’s not guaranteed just because say I fancy working somewhere else, and especially to the employers detriment. Are they ever asked to put forward a business case as to how their reduced hours will be managed? So their employer can continue deliver the same service?

It seems that in the nhs, they demand and get? Are they ever told no, sorry, we need you as you are valuable and needed by your main contracted employer?

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 10:21

I am talking about Turkey. I have since returned to the UK, but while I had my Turkish residency, the system there was honestly a total eye-opener compared to what we have grown used to with the NHS.

To clear up any assumptions: no, this isn't high-end luxury private healthcare for wealthy expats. I was using their standard public state hospital system.

Here is how it actually works and why it moves so fast:

  • Incredibly low-cost public rates: Even if you don't have their state insurance and pay entirely out of pocket, the state-subsidised rates are peanuts compared to Western pricing. I needed an MRI. I walked into the public hospital, went to the cashier desk, paid exactly £10.15 out of pocket, and got the scan done almost immediately.
  • No GP gatekeeping for specialists: In the UK, you can wait weeks just to see a GP, who then has to refer you to a specialist, leading to months of further waiting. In the public system there, you can use a central app or website to directly book an appointment with a hospital specialist (like a cardiologist, dermatologist, or orthopedist) yourself.
  • Massive infrastructure & throughput: The state hospitals there are huge, highly modernised, and run like high-efficiency factories. They prioritise rapid diagnostics. Things like MRIs, blood tests, and scans are treated as immediate operational tasks rather than precious resources that need to be rationed.
  • Neighborhood Family Health Centres: For routine things, every neighborhood has a small, local walk-in clinic with family doctors. You can just walk in, get a ticket, and usually be seen the same morning for basic prescriptions or minor issues.
  • Everything is digital: They use a centralized health app. Every single blood test, X-ray, prescription, and MRI report is uploaded directly to your smartphone under your ID number within days. You don't have to chase doctors for results; you own your data.

It isn't a flawless system—there can be queues, and if you don't speak the language you definitely need a translation app to navigate the state hospitals—but experiencing it makes you realise that a public healthcare system doesn't have to mean waiting months in pain for a basic diagnostic scan.

I have used AI to write this as it explains it far more eloquently than I ever could.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 03/11/2026 10:19

Erin1975 · 03/11/2026 10:13

The problems with the NHS do not stem from the type of system used to manage it. They stem from a massive increase in demand for healthcare provision combined with a lack of will to finance an increase in capacity.

You could change the model to an insurance based system and there still would not be enough resources (human and physical) to delivery the required level of care.

If they made fewer mistakes, there'd be fewer wasted appointments and people would be seen quicker.

My DH has had cancer for 8 years, and recently needed a major leg operation due to his cancer. The lack of communication between departments literally opposite each other on the same hospital corridor led to several wasted appointments, a delayed operation (cancelled literally on the morning it was scheduled due to lack of communication between oncologist and orthopaedic surgeon), and wasted appointments/wasted prescriptions for very expensive chemotherapy drugs in the weeks afterwards. They just couldn't pick up the bloody phone and talk to each other and would rather waste stupid amounts of time and NHS resources whilst waiting for bloody letters to be typed up between departments! Until you've been in the thick of it and seen the sheer incompetence, it's hard to imagine just how disorganised it all is. And that's before we get to the useless GPs who ignore letters sent by the hospital specialists - again, the sods won't talk to each other meaning it's the cancer riddled patient who has to pass messages! It's utterly ridiculous.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 03/11/2026 10:16

Does everyone realise that the European healthcare systems which some posters very much admire are more expensive per person than the NHS?

Whether we keep the current system or move to an insurance-based one, we will have to pay more. Bringing in insurance companies as expensive middlemen won’t automatically make the NHS more efficient. In fact, the reverse could easily happen due to the greater admin burden.

Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 10:16

A lot of the doctors in the uk were not trained in the uk.

the nhs has consistently taken doctors from other countries - India, Pakistan, etc, mostly commonwealth and other English speaking countries.

so only some of our doctors were trained in the uk.

these days as far as I can tell lots of Uk trained doctors go to Australia as working conditions are much better.

we don’t train enough doctors to meet nhs demand so we’re always going to be importing them.

these days getting positions in the nhs is increasingly difficult - doctors are required to move around between hospitals to make their way up the (very clearly defined) training routes if they are hospital doctors.

some have to drop out - unable or unwilling to move for family reasons (eg have a child) or otherwise. Training for hospital doctors continues up to age 35.

many working in private practice are GPs who simply cannot cope with the working conditions in the nhs which to be honest are fucking brutal.

there’s also the fact that a fair bit of private stuff is contracted to the nhs. My mum had her cataracts done last year - under the nhs but at a private place which only did cataracts and employed doctors there fully private.

oviraptor21 · 03/11/2026 10:16

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 10:03

I find this hard to believe. Unless the consultants have arranged part time contracts with the nhs?

And who are these private GPs and who trained them? Private practice doesn’t do this training, they take from the NHS.

The situation we have was obviously coming and for years, there are census every 10 years to help forecast need, supposedly.

there should be something that says contractually if you are trained by the NHS, you have to work in the nhs solely perhaps for, say, 10 years. In return for free medical tuition at uk universities. I’d do the same for nurses and any critical medical service that is losing resources to private, part time, fleeing to Dubai or whatever.

But overall yes we want scandi standards without the tax.

Yes they can have part time contracts. Nothing unusual there.
They've already paid for tuition and worked 10 years by the time they are able to get a private position.

Erin1975 · 03/11/2026 10:13

CraftyNavySeal · 03/11/2026 09:57

But why couldn’t we have an insurance based system like France or Germany or Australia or Japan?

Why are so many British doctors and nurses moving to Australia to work in their privatised system that has better patient outcomes.

The countries with the best performing healthcare systems have not copied the NHS.

The problems with the NHS do not stem from the type of system used to manage it. They stem from a massive increase in demand for healthcare provision combined with a lack of will to finance an increase in capacity.

You could change the model to an insurance based system and there still would not be enough resources (human and physical) to delivery the required level of care.

MyKindHiker · 03/11/2026 10:12

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 10:04

I have no idea what to do about it. It was a question to create a discussion. Other people will have far more knowledge and ideas than me. Health is the most important thing and imo we are being failed.

So it's not really that complicated. But it's still an impossible choice.

So what we need in order to fix the system and get it working properly - proper staffing, enough hospitals, hospitals that are clean, etc is probably a one off cash injection of £100bn plus an extra £30-50bn a year for a decade.

So where could we find that money from? No one likes the options. A government could raise absolutely every tax going to fund just this alone, when we already pay more taxes than almost any other country. Or they could cut education or armed forces spending. No one wants that either. The things Reform bang on about like people in boats or asylum seekers cost an absolute fraction of this - even if we stopped all illegal immigration it would be barely enough we'd save to cover the cost of some new bandages in the context of how much is needed.

UniquePinkSwan · 03/11/2026 10:12

I’m sick of how the NHS is put on a pedestal. It’s like you aren’t allowed to criticise it. I can’t wait until someone has the balls to put us on the European model

Makeyourownmister · 03/11/2026 10:11

MissyB1 · 03/11/2026 09:00

Well it would help if you told us where “abroad” was and how the healthcare system was set up and funded.

But in general British people are odd about public services, they want first class services, but won’t fight for them or make those services a priority when it comes to voting.

They won’t pay extra for them you mean?

I think we need to be pragmatic about this.

There is more demand on the NHS than ever before and the population is ageing.

Of course there are those in UK society who will always need to have their health care paid for them or heavily subsidised because of poverty, disability, chronic conditions etc or because they are very young or very old. They should always be a priority.

Equally there are many people who are prepared to pay thousands in vet bills for their pets who object to paying £20 to see their own NHS doctor.

Or they are prepared to pay and their money bypasses the NHS and goes in to the private system.

And people who are millionaires still rely on NHS emergency services and receive all of their care free, which seems madness to me.

I think it’s pretty obvious that we need a means-tested, non-profit, highly regulated obligatory health insurance, the opposite of the USA model and more like that of Spain or Belgium, rolled out to every household, with the result that if we are contributing, we won’t be so passive about standards, we will have more autonomy and choice, we will feel we have more invested in our own health and will hopefully take better care of it as a result, and people won’t miss appointments and trash A&E, and abuse the system and staff if they are contributing financially for the services they receive.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 03/11/2026 10:11

We’ve finally voted out the Tories who are mostly responsible for the chronic underfunding of the NHS. Why it took us so long is a mystery, as it will now take many years and a lot of money to turn it around. I agree that the current waiting times are unacceptable, but there’s not much that ordinary people can do about this.

ChrisTheBastard · 03/11/2026 10:10

GiaGia16 · 03/11/2026 08:59

YANBU but someone will be along in a minute to say what a positive experience they/partner/in-laws had.

And that the only alternative is a US style system where anyone who can't afford care is processed into Soylent Green

Mortgagedecisions · 03/11/2026 10:07

Interesting that OP hasn’t named where the amazing, almost free care was so we can compare health systems.

The NHS does need reform but some responsibility has to fall on the people using the systems too. I’ve spent a lot of time supporting unwell relatives recently in A&E and visiting them on the ward. There was a very high number of people in A&E who had clearly been misusing substances or who did not look unwell enough for A&E. If you can bring your whole crew in and be sat there laughing and swearing and filming yourself for social media - I’d like to bet you don’t need A&E.

Andandoporlasplayas · 03/11/2026 10:06

ThePelican · 03/11/2026 10:03

Different rules then. What doctors do is perfectly legal.

Review contracts then perhaps? I too wouldn’t be allowed to work elsewhere without permission from my employer. It’s in my contract. I’m nothing special, basic type job.

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 10:04

Dreadingtheday · 03/11/2026 09:51

@Pinkgorilla101 what do you want us to do about it? Protest and riots don’t help anybody so what do you want?

I think, if the government replaced it reformed it whatever people would welcome that

But fuck knows what they’re paying attention to at the moment. Europe or something.

so, I don’t know what’s the point of your post we accept it because we have to

I have no idea what to do about it. It was a question to create a discussion. Other people will have far more knowledge and ideas than me. Health is the most important thing and imo we are being failed.

OP posts: