Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to wonder why we accept the state of the NHS?

337 replies

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 08:56

Having spent time living abroad and having top quality almost free healthcare (state, not private) I genuinely cannot believe that there hasn’t been a revolt or more done about the state of the NHS. Just this week I have heard of an 80 year old man with heart failure sitting in A&E for 17 hours then being told to go home as they had no beds and they would make him a routine appointment with a cardiologist. Seeing a GP is almost impossible. There are 2 at my NHS practice but both also run private clinics elsewhere. Why do we accept this or am I unreasonably unrealistic in my expectations?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dogdilemma01 · 11/11/2026 10:02

Jopo12 · 03/11/2026 21:31

I agree it's shit. I have nothing nice to say about it.

It's not underfunded at all. We have worse health outcomes than western countries that spend similar or less than we do per capita.

But there is realistically nothing the public can do about it

We are far from the top ranking countries if you are looking at per capita healthcare spending, and some of the countries you are likely comparing us to have additional charges levied for specific healthcare interventions so not a level playing field.
We are a nation, generally speaking of ageing, overweight, poor dietary intake, bingedrinking and often vaping/ smoking individuals not to mention the huge social issues contributing towards poor mental health. The NHS CANNOT fix all of this!!

ladykelvin · 10/11/2026 02:22

Netcurtainnelly · 03/11/2026 10:39

Stop moaning. The NHS does some really great things. Without the NHS slot of us would be dead.
Maybe humans should stop having babies and adding to the pressure.

Do you understand the concept of an aging population??

What a stupid comment.

Jimmyjumpy · 09/11/2026 19:56

Lets have a revolution. Do you want to organise it?

BIossomtoes · 09/11/2026 19:30

Ghsqiw · 09/11/2026 14:54

And so? Viability doesn't make the babys life any less valuable. Both lives are valuable and should be cherished. She has no right at all to kill another innocent human being.

She has every right to remove a collection of cells from her body. If it’s unviable outside its mother’s uterus she has every right and has had for the last 59 years.

NotSoHotupNorth · 09/11/2026 19:21

Ghsqiw · 09/11/2026 14:51

I fully support a welfare state

Yeah, I bet you are. Just how knowledgeable are you about the life of a child born to poor, or single parents, or to children in the care system because their parents can't look after them. And then there are the severely disabled.

On that note I'm not getting into the argument that any of these groups don't deserve life, what I am arguing that the childbearer aka the mother should have choice and that the choice should be supported the NHS - not you or I.

Badbadbunny · 09/11/2026 18:47

stymaster · 09/11/2026 18:40

Also, what people forget about opting out and using private care: as a cancer patient, you're now fucked for private health insurance. If you thought you couldn't afford it before, well, you now don't have that problem, because you won't get it.

Under our current system, yes, but in some other European countries, the insurance is available regardless of pre existing conditions without extra charges - we'd just need to impose such a rule if (when) we move to an insurance based alternative.

stymaster · 09/11/2026 18:40

IwanttoWFH · 09/11/2026 17:24

I was having this exact conversation last week, after being told I have an eight week wait for an urgent suspected cancer appointment (on the two week pathway). How has it happened that we just accept this?!
I was looking at some of the waiting times and one particular speciality was a 68 week wait! That’s absurd!

I have partial private healthcare and use that whenever I can. I paid for my mammogram privately, which highlighted the issue. Unfortunately, I couldn’t afford the £3,000 bill for a biopsy, so was referred via the NHS pathway. If they can’t honour the two week wait, they should change the name of it!

I would love to be able to “opt out” of paying into the NHS and use the money for full private healthcare, but that would leave others, who aren’t able to afford this, vulnerable. Unfortunately, I can’t afford the monthly payments of comprehensive health insurance.

I really don’t know what the answer is, but something needs to be done.

Also, what people forget about opting out and using private care: as a cancer patient, you're now fucked for private health insurance. If you thought you couldn't afford it before, well, you now don't have that problem, because you won't get it.

BruFord · 09/11/2026 18:27

38thparallel · 09/11/2026 18:07

Where I live, you can also be charged for missing appointments, it's at the surgery's discretion. When I've called with a reasonable excuse such as an ill child, I haven't been charged, but it does make us keep track of appointments!

@BruFord what happens if the person can’t or won’t pay the fine?

@38thparallel I can't remember, tbh. When you register with a practice, you sign a form acknowledging that you understand their missed appointment policy, they legally have to declare it to patients.

I presume they could decline to see you again if the missed appointments charges started stacking up, and you'd have to find a different doctor. As I said, I've never been charged because I've only ever missed an appointment for a good reason (and I ring them as soon as I realize that I will).

38thparallel · 09/11/2026 18:07

Where I live, you can also be charged for missing appointments, it's at the surgery's discretion. When I've called with a reasonable excuse such as an ill child, I haven't been charged, but it does make us keep track of appointments!

@BruFord what happens if the person can’t or won’t pay the fine?

Kate0726 · 09/11/2026 17:33

Our local hospital seems good. There isn't a long wait for appointments. The calibre of the staff is very varied - some very caring and efficient, others don't speak good enough English, others just don't seem to care and do a tick-box job. The standard of hygiene and infection control is shocking. I watched a cleaner in a ward last week and it didn't pass any standard of cleaning!

boredandgrand · 09/11/2026 17:31

Pinkgorilla101 · 03/11/2026 13:46

This is just a question - not my view. But people riot or demonstrate for much much less. Look at the disruption a few weeks ago at the ports with the boats coming in with migrants. Are we just conditioned to accept our lot and get on with it in the typical British way?

People will not be accepting of the need to pay massively to correct the current situation. Rioting will not help as there is no quick fix.

BruFord · 09/11/2026 17:26

Newname26 · 09/11/2026 17:18

The issue with charging is half the population will be free anyway and you say it yourself its about gatekeeping appointments. Which the receptionist do an exceptionally good job of.
Nobody is hanging on the phone hitting redial for 45mins unless they need to

BTW my scenarios above,
1, Might be alive if they did
2, Was Op & 10 days in hospital
3, Was a week.

@Newname26 I'm completely open to better ideas, what would you do instead?

Where I live, you can also be charged for missing appointments, it's at the surgery's discretion. When I've called with a reasonable excuse such as an ill child, I haven't been charged, but it does make us keep track of appointments!

IwanttoWFH · 09/11/2026 17:24

I was having this exact conversation last week, after being told I have an eight week wait for an urgent suspected cancer appointment (on the two week pathway). How has it happened that we just accept this?!
I was looking at some of the waiting times and one particular speciality was a 68 week wait! That’s absurd!

I have partial private healthcare and use that whenever I can. I paid for my mammogram privately, which highlighted the issue. Unfortunately, I couldn’t afford the £3,000 bill for a biopsy, so was referred via the NHS pathway. If they can’t honour the two week wait, they should change the name of it!

I would love to be able to “opt out” of paying into the NHS and use the money for full private healthcare, but that would leave others, who aren’t able to afford this, vulnerable. Unfortunately, I can’t afford the monthly payments of comprehensive health insurance.

I really don’t know what the answer is, but something needs to be done.

Newname26 · 09/11/2026 17:18

BruFord · 09/11/2026 17:01

@Newname26 The patient will decide whether it's worth it to them to pay the £10 fee, for example, to be seen. Just as the poster who paid £10.15 in Turkey did.

Obviously, there'd need to be exemptions for people on a low income - but ultimately, the NHS can't go on as it currently is, can it?

I'm not suggesting that a small payment upfront is the ideal solution, it's one idea among many.

The issue with charging is half the population will be free anyway and you say it yourself its about gatekeeping appointments. Which the receptionist do an exceptionally good job of.
Nobody is hanging on the phone hitting redial for 45mins unless they need to

BTW my scenarios above,
1, Might be alive if they did
2, Was Op & 10 days in hospital
3, Was a week.

BruFord · 09/11/2026 17:01

Newname26 · 09/11/2026 16:23

How do you define a time waster?
Is someone with a tiny mark on their skin a time waster?

Is someone with a sore stomach a timewaster?

Is a heavily pregnant woman whos got no pain but short of breath a time waster?

It issue if fees is not only will you weed out time wasters you'll weed out people who havegenuine issues.

@Newname26 The patient will decide whether it's worth it to them to pay the £10 fee, for example, to be seen. Just as the poster who paid £10.15 in Turkey did.

Obviously, there'd need to be exemptions for people on a low income - but ultimately, the NHS can't go on as it currently is, can it?

I'm not suggesting that a small payment upfront is the ideal solution, it's one idea among many.

Newname26 · 09/11/2026 16:23

BruFord · 09/11/2026 16:12

I agree that the NHS needs an overhaul, but I also think that there's a huge reluctant to pay upfront for services - I can see people baulking at even the £10.15 that you paid for a scan. Personally, I think that a small upfront fee would weed out many timewasters.

A model similar to the Dutch one that @CuteOrangeElephant uses would probably be the best to transition to...but again, people will baulk at paying.

My elderly Dad needs some help with changing dressings at home for an ongoing condition. The NHS covered a certain number of weeks but has now referred him to an agency. He'd pay about £30 a week for the service, he can afford it, and he really needs it...but he really doesn't want to pay!

I can't understand his mindset, because I live abroad and accept that sometimes we have to pay for services. But he's never had to and it's a big shock!
I expect I'll end up paying for it.

How do you define a time waster?
Is someone with a tiny mark on their skin a time waster?

Is someone with a sore stomach a timewaster?

Is a heavily pregnant woman whos got no pain but short of breath a time waster?

It issue if fees is not only will you weed out time wasters you'll weed out people who havegenuine issues.

BruFord · 09/11/2026 16:12

I agree that the NHS needs an overhaul, but I also think that there's a huge reluctant to pay upfront for services - I can see people baulking at even the £10.15 that you paid for a scan. Personally, I think that a small upfront fee would weed out many timewasters.

A model similar to the Dutch one that @CuteOrangeElephant uses would probably be the best to transition to...but again, people will baulk at paying.

My elderly Dad needs some help with changing dressings at home for an ongoing condition. The NHS covered a certain number of weeks but has now referred him to an agency. He'd pay about £30 a week for the service, he can afford it, and he really needs it...but he really doesn't want to pay!

I can't understand his mindset, because I live abroad and accept that sometimes we have to pay for services. But he's never had to and it's a big shock!
I expect I'll end up paying for it.

stymaster · 09/11/2026 15:29

The problem, as others have said, is chronic underfunding for far too long.

Not just in the NHS, but in care systems in general- so A&E, being the last resort, gets loads of case that don't really need A&E. Add to that people that got to A&E for a splinter.

But we've collectively got what we deserved. Far too many of us subscribe to keeping taxes very low, which disproportionately aids the very wealthy, who, of course, have no need of the NHS. We continue to vote in governments that don't fund things properly all to save a % on PAYE.

Also- and I hate to give the NHS a kicking because I wouldn't be here without it- the NHS is full of inefficiencies and incompetencies, and little fiefdoms within it that don't communicate.

I've had excellent care from the NHS but it needs radically changing and people need to accept that they need to pay tax. We need to raise the PAYE basic rate, re-introduce the highest rate, increase the higher (40%) rate, and raise the personal tax allowance to help the lowest earners. We also need to clamp down on tax evasion by everyone from the small businesses trading in cash to avoid it through to large corporations. We need to get away from the Thatcherite culture of "fuck everyone except me".

Inside the NHS trusts they need to embrace technology, employ enough non-medical staff to run switchboards, call centres and receptions (contacting my local hospital is an endurance test) and let medics do medical stuff- another trust a bit further away manages it.

The NHS is great, but it could be so much better, and it was better in my lifetime.

Ghsqiw · 09/11/2026 14:54

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 15:38

It’s not viable without hers. @NotSoHotupNorth is absolutely right. Nobody wants to read your Bible Belt propaganda.

And so? Viability doesn't make the babys life any less valuable. Both lives are valuable and should be cherished. She has no right at all to kill another innocent human being.

Ghsqiw · 09/11/2026 14:51

NotSoHotupNorth · 08/11/2026 15:29

Oh sod off with your faux pro life sentiment. Bet you wouldn't be willing to pay or look after these "children" as the alternative.

I fully support a welfare state

BlueSherbet · 09/11/2026 14:31

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2026 12:18

It’s not a child at the point where a termination is carried out.

Its a scientific fact that a new person is created at the moment of conception.

At that moment, a new life is observable with 46 chromosomes, 23 each from his/her mother and father.

A form of life with 46 chromosomes is called a human being.

(I believe dolphins also have 46 chromosomes, but I have yet to meet anyone who has managed to conceive a dolphin!)

Makeyourownmister · 08/11/2026 18:37

Btw I have just looked it up and that monthly payment in The Netherlands of €170 per month seems high. It is lower in France, Spain and Belgium for example.

Makeyourownmister · 08/11/2026 18:04

FunnyDoginLahLahLand · 08/11/2026 14:02

The minimum cost for the most basic level of health insurance next year in Netherlands is going to be 170 euros per person per month (it's free for under 18s), with a 400 euro yearly excess. And it's compulsory. That's only for the basic level. You need to pay more for additions like dental etc

Can you imagine what would happen to any political party in the UK that tried to introduce that?

Politicians can’t of course ever say blatantly that they won’t provide resources for the NHS as it would be political suicide.

What they do instead is lie about building fifteen new hospitals and it turns out that seven were already under construction by a previous administration or whatever.

In other words political commitments to fund the NHS are wholly unreliable and the benefit of a closed health insurance scheme is that if everyone is required to pay the minimum, then they know 100 per cent it has to be put in to health care and they come to know the figures necessary to run the service.

Say that the same figure , the equivalent of €170 euros a month has to be paid in to the NHS to fund it, then the corollary is that general tax goes down for everyone by the same amount or near it?

And if you have a separate entity entirely for health out of direct government hands then it become more accountable.

And of course, if the mutual insurance companies running the system are heavily regulated as not-for-profit entities, unlike the USA system, payments are means tested as are other social benefits.

The point is that taxes in the UK are high but costs like public transport to take one example are frankly extortionate compared to many countries in the EU, ditto tertiary education and childcare. Obviously this whole question is like moving deck chairs around on the deck of the Titanic but things in the UK could be organised more efficiently if we could escape political dogma.

You say €170 a month is extortionate and the sterling equivalent would be impossible for some but not for others. Currently millionaires, use our NHS emergency health units and you will find plenty of people in NHS waiting rooms who earn over £250,000 a year; I was talking to one of them in an oncology unit waiting room the other day in fact.

According to the Nationwide Spending Report, on average, a pet owner in the UK spends approximately £126 per month on their animal’s needs such as food, insurance, treats, toys, clothing, bedding, and that cost doesn’t including emergency or vet bills not covered by insurance. I guess it’s a question of priorities?

Badbadbunny · 08/11/2026 15:56

Soreenmaltloaf23 · 08/11/2026 15:52

Because we don't want to pay for it. We want everything without the higher taxes.

Because more and more people can't afford to pay higher taxes, which are increasing anyway due to fiscal drag etc.

Soreenmaltloaf23 · 08/11/2026 15:52

Because we don't want to pay for it. We want everything without the higher taxes.