Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I shouldn’t be potty training my brother’s DD?

214 replies

AmpleFish · 02/11/2026 22:00

My brother recently asked me to look after his DD (3 yrs 7m) while he and SIL go away for the weekend to celebrate their wedding anniversary. I of course said I would as she’s really no bother and they don’t really have anyone else. I jokingly said something about getting her potty trained by the time they come back as they haven’t given it a full-hearted go yet. DB got all defensive before basically saying why don’t you give it a go, which took me aback slightly. Half of me thinks I should for DN’s sake so she’s not still in nappies at 4, but AIBU to think I shouldn’t be potty training my brother’s child??

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 03/11/2026 10:15

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 08:17

you make a good point. I get so embarrassed for her when taking her out and about as she looks way too old to still be in a nappy - she couldn’t care less though!

Edited

So when my GC had a bowel condition (that had to be corrected at AlderHey children's hospital), we should have felt ashamed, or embarrassed for her? Perhaps have her back, no-one knows if she does have a medical need, or is struggling in other ways. Just like your child is too old, by the same people's measure, for bottles.

Tulipsriver · 03/11/2026 10:16

AmpleFish · 02/11/2026 23:14

she does not

My mum really struggled to potty train my sister. She wasn't diagnosed with autism until university. You have absolutely no way of knowing whether she has any undiagnosed SEN at 3.

Floatlikeafeather2 · 03/11/2026 10:20

So, if you were to be honest, you would admit you made your quip to get back at him and his wife for comments they have made about your 4 year old still having a bottle. Tit for tat is never necessary or useful.
Why are you not offering to train their 2.5 year old too who, according to you, they also haven't "bothered" to potty train? You could present them with a double whammy and they would never dare to bring up your son and his baby bottle again. In fact, it's odd that you haven't mentioned this other child at all.

BertieBotts · 03/11/2026 11:03

Comeondoreen · 03/11/2026 09:54

Lots of interesting things in your post, I completely agree.

I’d also like to add that say 5 years ago I was hearing a LOT of the child-led, “wait until they’re ready, wait for their cues” type advice from SW, HV and other HCPs (not just given to me personally, and I’m glad I had the life experience to ignore it, but due to my work and some volunteering at the time I was present when lots of new mothers were getting advice from HCPs, especially disadvantaged mothers). On potty training but also a whole range of parenting issues. I don’t hear it so much at all now, but I definitely did from about 10 years ago to 5 years ago. It’s a bit much to place the blame solely at parents’ doors, especially if they were already vulnerable families and ime that meant they were likely to take the last HCP they saw’s word as gospel. If I think of, for example, a very young mum with no family support, likely not very well educated, who waited “until their child was ready” because that’s what her HV told her to do, I can hardly feel much blame for her. Especially when I think of how many of these mothers were involved with SS and so would be scared to go against whatever they’d been told.

I do think useless, lazy parents exist, I’ve seen plenty. But it’s not the entire story for every family with this issue.

As I say, I have seen that most HVs and other HCPs no longer give this type of advice, but it was definitely prevalent enough that I noticed it years ago.

Yes!! I completely agree with this. I think it's because I remember the "in their own time" thing being a really big shift in parenting norms back when DS1 was very young, and this has definitely come more into "official" advice, and I DO agree this is an important message when you're coming from a background of where the social norm seemed to be more to push DC faster, earlier, better, stronger, almost competitive and parents were worrying their DC would be behind? (Obligatory Bluey Baby Race reference.) Or just people not having very good understanding of young children's development and wanting them to be "easier" so trying to rush behaviour which wasn't developmentally expected yet. That's another context where "Give them time" could help.

I don't know whether social media has taken this message and distorted it into the idea that children will magically obtain all societal and behavioural rules without ever being taught, pushed or guided at all, or whether that's just social media algorithm slop doing its ever-more-polarised thing and it would have happened anyway, (there is another track which is more about optimising DC's intelligence/development to make them into some kind of superhuman, though more related to selling you expensive wooden toy subscriptions). But the advice "Give your child more time to develop" is only helpful when it's come from that worried/frustrated background of wanting DC to do things faster. If the parent is starting from a position of just waiting until something happens by itself, giving them more time isn't likely to be helpful at all, it's more likely to be counterproductive.

I remember probably about 8ish years ago, I had gained this idea about the "gentle parenting" movement - how it was a useful narrative for people who were coming from a starting point of being too controlling/strict, but could be counterproductive if you (like me!) came from a natural starting point of being too empathetic/passive, because a lot of the gentle parenting advice just took unhelpful things I was doing naturally and exacerbated them, and I had to learn in many ways how to be more directive. I can't even remember which book I was reading now, it might have been one of Ross Greene's, but anyway I was reading something which was advocating for a more empathetic, bottom-up supportive approach in contrast to a more top-down, controlling approach, and there was a throwaway line about how the author had run parenting support services and noted that parents tend to naturally lean one way or the other (too controlling/too permissive) and they emphasised the same pattern I'd noticed for myself and other parents online, but their observation was that in their experience, the split was around 80/20 with 80% of parents (at least those who sought their help) being on the side of too controlling, with only 20% on the too permissive side. The impression I had was that this 80/20 observation was at least a decade old, if not older (so 20-30+ years old today) but as said, the reference is fuzzy.

I've always wondered since then, did it change? Is it still 80/20 or is it different today, since in the past perhaps authoritarian parenting was seen as more accepted/normal than permissive (whereas I think most would agree it is the opposite today). Or do parents who seek advice at behavioural clinics tend to be a totally different group to parents looking for advice online? IIRC, which I might not of course, but the stuff I was reading online in the 00s/early 10s was skewed much more towards "I don't want to smack/shout but I don't know what else to do??" and automatic assumptions that parents ought to directly control their child's behaviour through use of threat/intimidation and incentives primarily, and the idea that you could also have significant influence through more sideways/ supportive/ social or environmental means was often new or received with some doubt. Whereas over the last ~5-10 years I see those kinds of queries come up far less on parenting sites, and I see way more along the lines of "My child does whatever they want and I don't know how to stop them??" and the automatic assumptions which come up are that it is the parent's job to protect their child from experiencing anything uncomfortable or hard, but especially that the parent must not be the source of anything the child experiences as discomfort or difficulty.

It would make sense if HVs and other support staff working primarily with families in the most disadvantaged circumstances were encountering a sort of delay in this cultural shift compared to the wider population or people in higher income/education brackets (prob more represented online), because you do tend to see that as a pattern generally. And HV services have been cut back so much, and even 15-18 years ago I remember MNers complaining they were patronising, or gave out advice that they felt was really basic or perhaps aimed more at families who were really struggling even with basic interaction with their child, probably because even then that was the majority of their caseload, and it will be more so now.

But I also think that the COVID lockdowns, because of the isolation from other people IRL and because of the increased exposure to social media and the massive expansion of their algorithm-driven content, caused almost a tidal wave of people changing their social media consumption habits (stats exist on this), it's not a huge jump to wonder whether this also led to a cultural narrative shift which was much faster than those which have been seen before. And then it takes time for professional practice to 1. Notice these trends, that the underlying assumptions about parenting have changed, 2. Observe the effects of the combination of advice against the opposite-direction background assumptions, 3. Put two and two together and see what advice is actually needed, 4. Create and implement the training materials etc for professionals working with families.

MotherofPufflings · 03/11/2026 11:08

On the one hand you say your niece is no bother, but on the other you're having to change her nappies all week! I'd have said that I wouldn't look after her imunless she was toilet trained - I bet they'd have managed to do it themselves then!

ItsCloudyToday · 03/11/2026 13:41

Floatlikeafeather2 · 03/11/2026 10:20

So, if you were to be honest, you would admit you made your quip to get back at him and his wife for comments they have made about your 4 year old still having a bottle. Tit for tat is never necessary or useful.
Why are you not offering to train their 2.5 year old too who, according to you, they also haven't "bothered" to potty train? You could present them with a double whammy and they would never dare to bring up your son and his baby bottle again. In fact, it's odd that you haven't mentioned this other child at all.

Yes, this dig was absolutely in retaliation to the brother commenting on the bottle use weeks ago.

You said your son won’t be having a bottle forever - in the same vein, your niece won’t be wearing nappies forever.

You both need to sort your own children out without all the tit for tat, as you’re both as bad as each other.

ASandwichNamedKevin · 03/11/2026 14:02

AmpleFish · 02/11/2026 23:13

I suppose so but then I’m going to have to spend some of that time changing her nappies because DB and SIL cba to train her!

Whilst I don't doubt they could have tried to potty train earlier, at that age you'd likely be helping the child with the toilet sometimes anyway so for one weekend I wouldn't see it as a big deal to change the nappies.

And yes I have DC, and actually we left a potty out from about 12 months and used it sometimes randomly and never did any actual potty training, they basically just gradually used the potty more often than not and were out of nappies without really trying (younger than your DN).

Why don't you and your brother talk, tell him you shouldn't have taken a swipe at his parenting, you're happy to help if they are happy to accept.

Bamboozledbylife · 03/11/2026 14:06

Almost 4 and they've not tried? I know that's not your question but the amount of lazy parents today is unreal. I'd have been so embarrassed to have a child of that age, without any additional needs, in nappys. Go for it.

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · 03/11/2026 14:06

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 08:26

I think it’s a different situation. It’s not about infantilising, it’s about the fact that their lack of a backbone now means i, or anyone else who looks after her, has to change nappies on a child this old. DS’s bottle affects no one

Funny that they 'lack a backbone' in relation to potty training but you don't when it comes to parenting your DC from a bottle.

I'm not making that point to hurt you or pick at you, but I think you should reflect on the fact we judge others by their actions and ourselves by our intentions.

Maybe just think about yourself and how you think you should behave, not "getting back" at others for making you feel bad. Just do you. Be the nice auntie you want to be and leave it there.

Firefly100 · 03/11/2026 14:17

I think you were wrong to make the jibe, it’s always wise to stay out of other people’s parenting IMO. Having said that, I agree it is unreasonable to face the prospect of changing nappies for a 4 yo. In your position I would have made it clear I am not commenting on their parenting and they can make whatever choices suit them, however I am not prepared to change nappies on a 4 yo and would have to decline to babysit.

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 14:43

DeanElderberry · 03/11/2026 09:16

Why not make it a 'let's be a big girl/boy' weekend and include drinking from a cup (sippy cup if needed) as well as potty training.

Their schoolteachers next year will bless you.

A very good idea! I might just do that x

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 14:51

Ohnobackagain · 03/11/2026 09:29

@AmpleFish why don’t you talk to your SIL? If I were her and you were discussing potty training with someone else I’d feel a bit left out. She might be grateful of your support, or she might be annoyed you’re over-stepping. Depends on your relationship I suppose.

We have a fairly good relationship so would be worth a go I guess. It depends how badly she thinks it needs addressing, she may be grateful she may not!

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 14:53

BertieBotts · 03/11/2026 09:39

Honestly my DC are aged 5, 8 and 18 and the difference in parenting advice/attitudes in general over the last 15+ years is astonishing. It's like I've watched it in real time.

It used to be people got their advice from real people IRL like other parents, their own parents/siblings, their health visitor, the other mums at baby/toddler group etc. And there were books, some more controversial than others (SWMNBN Grin). Mumsnet obviously. The occasional TV programme. But even MN is (or was) discussion between (mostly) real people going through a similar experience to you IRL who are, or were, (mostly) fairly sane and sensible and 15-20 years ago it was posts displayed in real time without algorithms deciding which threads to display to anybody.

Barely any of this happens any more, because everyone is addicted to their phones and because social media aggressively targets attention (time spent on app, frequency of returning to app) and engagement (liking/sharing/commenting) and even traditional media like TV and news websites and so on are drawn into these kinds of loops about what content they prioritise (and we access most of that through our social media or are presented a personalised version of the news website).

Then in a chicken and egg sort of thing you get parenting advice coming onto those platforms, targeting people who are suddenly at home much more with much less opportunity to go out and meet people IRL, and the advice becomes ever more polarised and unhinged because polarising content for anything breeds engagement. And the slop. Dear lord the parenting advice slop!

The problem is that our brains don't really understand how to process the volume of "information" we are bombarded with. If you look at even 15 years ago you probably came across a fairly limited selection of views on parenting and most of them would broadly overlap - don't lock them in cupboards, do teach them to say please etc. When your Great Aunt Mary or the one unusually out of touch leader at playgroup suggested something batshit, it got compared to the general consensus of the other things you'd heard and got pretty quickly thrown out, and things sort of remained even. Change was pretty slow - it took decades for example for smacking to fall out of popular use after experts started advising against it in the 70s/80s, and the Back To Sleep SIDS prevention advice had a small effect at first and snowballed once the practices became much more widespread. But overall, everything maintained a sort of sense check.

This doesn't happen as much any more, because depending on which part of the algorithm has latched onto you, you get bombarded with endless variations on "Don't ever allow your child to experience a negative emotion, otherwise their mental health will be ruined for life" or "Baby sleep must be controlled scientifically and optimised to the minute otherwise you will be creating pathways for insomnia, obesity and ADHD" or "The world is full of risk, hazards and disease which can affect your child and maim or kill them" - and the problem is that you probably won't even notice that you're receiving so many of these messages, but your brain quietly absorbs all of them and builds the consensus, the one that 15 years ago was made up mainly of the parenting practices of your next door neighbour, your NCT course leader, your family members with DC, the books you were reading, maybe a few MN threads debating sleep training vs cosleeping.

Today, if you're on social media and the algorithm gets hold of the fact that you're a parent (esp a mum) at all, the volume of the batshit social media messages drowns out any kind of moderating effect from RL anecdotes/observations/experience. And there's a much lower bar for anybody wanting to create parenting social media content than somebody writing and publishing an entire book, or creating a name for themselves as an expert on TV/radio. It's become the norm now, so rather than ask for book recommendations, people ask for online course recommendations because every influencer is selling an overpriced video course which claims to have all the answers (they don't, of course) and it's become normalised.

Anyway all of this is a very long way to say that while I don't think it's as dire as the media tries to make out, parenting has become more passive and child centred in many ways because parents are increasingly being fed a load of slop which discourages actual involved parenting, to the point that a lot of parents are afraid to push issues with their DC in case it causes them discomfort, or because they have been sold a lie that it's somehow "better" or more organic if children do things for themselves, but as a result it tends to lead to DC who have excessive screen use and less time spent on more useful activities. I wouldn't even be surprised if media apps are detecting where multiple devices are being used to access the same account or in the same household at the same time and somehow sync both content which encourages passivity around parenting, and addictive screen based content for the DC at the same time, so that if parents try to change their DC's habits it becomes even more difficult and so the media companies win with more view time from both parent and child. I would have thought that was a mad conspiracy a few months ago, but I'm not convinced it's all that unrealistic now. It certainly wouldn't be impossible or hard for these patterns to be detected (though it might be more of a coincidence, and it's more that tech-addicted parents are tech-lax for their DC?)

So yes, I don't think it's especially surprising that parents could get to age 3.8 and have only had one half hearted attempt at potty training. You're right that it is their responsibility, but equally I expect it wouldn't be that difficult to train DC if you prefer that to changing nappies. Only you really know whether it's likely to be a wake up call to DB and SIL which might make them think oh, maybe DC is capable of more than we'd realised, or whether they are likely to think "Brilliant, completely escaped a nasty job, AmpleFish will do all the hard parts of parenting for us!!"

You make some very good points, especially about then expecting me to help her reach all her milestones!

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 14:54

user47639820987 · 03/11/2026 09:40

I find this quite shocking that a NT child would be kept in nappies for the parent’s convenience at nearly 4.
My kids were 18mths old when they stopped using nappies in the day time - it was quite normal 20yrs ago. It was a pain finding a loo quickly when we were out and about but think of the money they must be spending on nappies!
Mine could also drink out of a glass from about a year old - a bottle is very bad for their teeth.

They both have fairly good jobs so I don’t think are too worried about the cost but it’s a good point! Would definitely be an incentive to me to get my child out of them.

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 14:57

ItalianChips · 03/11/2026 09:50

Reading the replies I’m judging both of you, a nearly 4 year old not being potty trained a 4 year old being given a bottle is both not great. Why are you giving your 4 year old a bottle, way too old.

It’s just a comfort and we never really got rid of it. In hindsight it should’ve probably gone a while ago but it’s only once a day and it gets him to sleep so quickly so we decided to leave it

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 15:02

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2026 10:15

So when my GC had a bowel condition (that had to be corrected at AlderHey children's hospital), we should have felt ashamed, or embarrassed for her? Perhaps have her back, no-one knows if she does have a medical need, or is struggling in other ways. Just like your child is too old, by the same people's measure, for bottles.

Yes I understand there are reasons why some children might still be in nappies at her age which would be impossible for a member of the public to tell, but in her case there isn’t any reason which is why I’m embarrassed for her!

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 15:10

Floatlikeafeather2 · 03/11/2026 10:20

So, if you were to be honest, you would admit you made your quip to get back at him and his wife for comments they have made about your 4 year old still having a bottle. Tit for tat is never necessary or useful.
Why are you not offering to train their 2.5 year old too who, according to you, they also haven't "bothered" to potty train? You could present them with a double whammy and they would never dare to bring up your son and his baby bottle again. In fact, it's odd that you haven't mentioned this other child at all.

Because this child is within the normal range of needing nappies still so there’s nothing to mention?

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 15:12

MotherofPufflings · 03/11/2026 11:08

On the one hand you say your niece is no bother, but on the other you're having to change her nappies all week! I'd have said that I wouldn't look after her imunless she was toilet trained - I bet they'd have managed to do it themselves then!

Probably but I feel like that would be a step too far given they don’t have many other options! But yes she’s no bother apart from the nappies, so I guess I just have to get on with it and enjoy the time we spend together.

OP posts:
KilkennyCats · 03/11/2026 15:13

For a four year old? Not really.
What is wrong with the pair of you, to hold your children back like this?

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 15:13

ItsCloudyToday · 03/11/2026 13:41

Yes, this dig was absolutely in retaliation to the brother commenting on the bottle use weeks ago.

You said your son won’t be having a bottle forever - in the same vein, your niece won’t be wearing nappies forever.

You both need to sort your own children out without all the tit for tat, as you’re both as bad as each other.

It really wasn’t in respond to that at all! It’s a completely separate issue where their parenting choices now affect me

OP posts:
Nothavingagoodvalentinesday · 03/11/2026 15:14

I’d do it. If it works it will be a surprise when they get back, if it doesn’t work no one need know.
It’s a lot more useful to potty train a child than what my aunt did to her nieces which absolutely infuriated my Mum. - she taught us how to eat our pudding with a spoon and fork instead of just a spoon. 🤣

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 15:15

Bamboozledbylife · 03/11/2026 14:06

Almost 4 and they've not tried? I know that's not your question but the amount of lazy parents today is unreal. I'd have been so embarrassed to have a child of that age, without any additional needs, in nappys. Go for it.

I completely agree which is part of the reason why I said what I said!

OP posts:
AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 15:17

KilkennyCats · 03/11/2026 15:13

For a four year old? Not really.
What is wrong with the pair of you, to hold your children back like this?

Im confused at what you’re replying to.

OP posts:
Franjipanl8r · 03/11/2026 15:18

Pobblewob · 02/11/2026 22:38

I'd be a twat and do it to prove him wrong!

This 100%. I think it’s important to show lazy parents that other adults care about their kids and that people are judging.

Velumental · 03/11/2026 15:43

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 08:26

I think it’s a different situation. It’s not about infantilising, it’s about the fact that their lack of a backbone now means i, or anyone else who looks after her, has to change nappies on a child this old. DS’s bottle affects no one

Look up bottle rot, milk from a bottle at 4 is so bad for teeth. I say this as a child who had a bottle for too long and had all my teeth out at 4 years old as the enamel co.peltely rotted away.