Honestly my DC are aged 5, 8 and 18 and the difference in parenting advice/attitudes in general over the last 15+ years is astonishing. It's like I've watched it in real time.
It used to be people got their advice from real people IRL like other parents, their own parents/siblings, their health visitor, the other mums at baby/toddler group etc. And there were books, some more controversial than others (SWMNBN
). Mumsnet obviously. The occasional TV programme. But even MN is (or was) discussion between (mostly) real people going through a similar experience to you IRL who are, or were, (mostly) fairly sane and sensible and 15-20 years ago it was posts displayed in real time without algorithms deciding which threads to display to anybody.
Barely any of this happens any more, because everyone is addicted to their phones and because social media aggressively targets attention (time spent on app, frequency of returning to app) and engagement (liking/sharing/commenting) and even traditional media like TV and news websites and so on are drawn into these kinds of loops about what content they prioritise (and we access most of that through our social media or are presented a personalised version of the news website).
Then in a chicken and egg sort of thing you get parenting advice coming onto those platforms, targeting people who are suddenly at home much more with much less opportunity to go out and meet people IRL, and the advice becomes ever more polarised and unhinged because polarising content for anything breeds engagement. And the slop. Dear lord the parenting advice slop!
The problem is that our brains don't really understand how to process the volume of "information" we are bombarded with. If you look at even 15 years ago you probably came across a fairly limited selection of views on parenting and most of them would broadly overlap - don't lock them in cupboards, do teach them to say please etc. When your Great Aunt Mary or the one unusually out of touch leader at playgroup suggested something batshit, it got compared to the general consensus of the other things you'd heard and got pretty quickly thrown out, and things sort of remained even. Change was pretty slow - it took decades for example for smacking to fall out of popular use after experts started advising against it in the 70s/80s, and the Back To Sleep SIDS prevention advice had a small effect at first and snowballed once the practices became much more widespread. But overall, everything maintained a sort of sense check.
This doesn't happen as much any more, because depending on which part of the algorithm has latched onto you, you get bombarded with endless variations on "Don't ever allow your child to experience a negative emotion, otherwise their mental health will be ruined for life" or "Baby sleep must be controlled scientifically and optimised to the minute otherwise you will be creating pathways for insomnia, obesity and ADHD" or "The world is full of risk, hazards and disease which can affect your child and maim or kill them" - and the problem is that you probably won't even notice that you're receiving so many of these messages, but your brain quietly absorbs all of them and builds the consensus, the one that 15 years ago was made up mainly of the parenting practices of your next door neighbour, your NCT course leader, your family members with DC, the books you were reading, maybe a few MN threads debating sleep training vs cosleeping.
Today, if you're on social media and the algorithm gets hold of the fact that you're a parent (esp a mum) at all, the volume of the batshit social media messages drowns out any kind of moderating effect from RL anecdotes/observations/experience. And there's a much lower bar for anybody wanting to create parenting social media content than somebody writing and publishing an entire book, or creating a name for themselves as an expert on TV/radio. It's become the norm now, so rather than ask for book recommendations, people ask for online course recommendations because every influencer is selling an overpriced video course which claims to have all the answers (they don't, of course) and it's become normalised.
Anyway all of this is a very long way to say that while I don't think it's as dire as the media tries to make out, parenting has become more passive and child centred in many ways because parents are increasingly being fed a load of slop which discourages actual involved parenting, to the point that a lot of parents are afraid to push issues with their DC in case it causes them discomfort, or because they have been sold a lie that it's somehow "better" or more organic if children do things for themselves, but as a result it tends to lead to DC who have excessive screen use and less time spent on more useful activities. I wouldn't even be surprised if media apps are detecting where multiple devices are being used to access the same account or in the same household at the same time and somehow sync both content which encourages passivity around parenting, and addictive screen based content for the DC at the same time, so that if parents try to change their DC's habits it becomes even more difficult and so the media companies win with more view time from both parent and child. I would have thought that was a mad conspiracy a few months ago, but I'm not convinced it's all that unrealistic now. It certainly wouldn't be impossible or hard for these patterns to be detected (though it might be more of a coincidence, and it's more that tech-addicted parents are tech-lax for their DC?)
So yes, I don't think it's especially surprising that parents could get to age 3.8 and have only had one half hearted attempt at potty training. You're right that it is their responsibility, but equally I expect it wouldn't be that difficult to train DC if you prefer that to changing nappies. Only you really know whether it's likely to be a wake up call to DB and SIL which might make them think oh, maybe DC is capable of more than we'd realised, or whether they are likely to think "Brilliant, completely escaped a nasty job, AmpleFish will do all the hard parts of parenting for us!!"