Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have booked this for me and dh?

351 replies

CherrysyrupCoffee · 02/11/2026 17:22

Dh has been saying for ages that he wants to start a particular hobby/activity. He hasn’t made any move to actually start but talks about it a lot.

Recently he had mentioned it to a friend (female) and said to me he might ask her if she wants to do it with him? I said ‘why haven’t you asked me?!’ He said he didn’t think it was my sort of thing despite the fact I’d said it sounded fun.

Anyway I’ve booked it for us both. He isn’t happy! Said how he has to let down his friend I said ‘so ? She can still do it if she really wants to?’ He said I shouldn’t have muscled in ??!!!

OP posts:
MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 18:51

CherrysyrupCoffee · 02/11/2026 17:22

Dh has been saying for ages that he wants to start a particular hobby/activity. He hasn’t made any move to actually start but talks about it a lot.

Recently he had mentioned it to a friend (female) and said to me he might ask her if she wants to do it with him? I said ‘why haven’t you asked me?!’ He said he didn’t think it was my sort of thing despite the fact I’d said it sounded fun.

Anyway I’ve booked it for us both. He isn’t happy! Said how he has to let down his friend I said ‘so ? She can still do it if she really wants to?’ He said I shouldn’t have muscled in ??!!!

OP I think most people commenting like you’re being unreasonable are lying to themselves that they’d be ok with it. I would not want my DH to start up a hobby with a female. I think it does depend on the history and how long they’ve known each other? Because thinking about it, there are maybe one or two females I’d not mind. But there is obviously a reason you aren’t comfortable with this and that is ok.

He’s been mentioning it for months and then randomly wants to do it with said female. Sounds quite dodgy to me, I’d be suspicious. Personally.

Rachelshair · 03/11/2026 18:53

I would have done the same OP.
I think it's very suss that he let you think he was going to do it by himself, rather than having this friend lined up all along, who he's now saying he'll have to "let down," despite never mentioning her potential involvement previously. All very convenient.
Was it all a cover story to do something dodgy, and he never actually wanted to do this activity at all?

Wildfairy · 03/11/2026 18:54

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 18:51

OP I think most people commenting like you’re being unreasonable are lying to themselves that they’d be ok with it. I would not want my DH to start up a hobby with a female. I think it does depend on the history and how long they’ve known each other? Because thinking about it, there are maybe one or two females I’d not mind. But there is obviously a reason you aren’t comfortable with this and that is ok.

He’s been mentioning it for months and then randomly wants to do it with said female. Sounds quite dodgy to me, I’d be suspicious. Personally.

Are you being Serious, why would anyone lie, irs an online forum,

some of us are secure in our relationships and not suffering jealousy and insecurity, no one is lying about that,Confused

but it’s really tragic you fhink every relationship is like yours.

ivy4iona · 03/11/2026 18:55

I think your gut feels that it’s not OK.
I used to be very liberal about sharing my late partner with other women so liberal and sister trusting was I, till these women just took it as a green light. What can you do? I dunno.
There’s another old saw that says ‘when love becomes a demand hatred becomes a pleasure.’ Even so tell him you are not happy about it snd that’s that. Let him argue his way out of it and convince you you are wrong….. and you may become convinced. But be warned. I don’t think you are being controlling just careful I wish I’d have been. Men can be very naive ( when they want).

Myli1 · 03/11/2026 19:09

Sorry OP but this does sound rather controlling behaviour I’m afraid. The hobby has been talked about for months but no-one has bothered arranging anything, yet the minute DH mentions seeing an old female friend to do the hobby with you have immediately muscled in and arranged an alternative booking. I think more context is needed. If the hobby was life drawing with the female friend as the naked model then that might be different than meeting up for a book club for example.

BillieWiper · 03/11/2026 19:11

Why can't he do it with you both?
And the hobby 😜

No seriously, can you three not all do it? Or he does it separately with her/you another time?

It seems a bit like you don't trust him to spend time with his female friend. And if I was him I'd consider that a bit insulting. Like you think that I'll just be compelled to rip her clothes off the moment we are alone together?

Metalmotha · 03/11/2026 19:18

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 18:51

OP I think most people commenting like you’re being unreasonable are lying to themselves that they’d be ok with it. I would not want my DH to start up a hobby with a female. I think it does depend on the history and how long they’ve known each other? Because thinking about it, there are maybe one or two females I’d not mind. But there is obviously a reason you aren’t comfortable with this and that is ok.

He’s been mentioning it for months and then randomly wants to do it with said female. Sounds quite dodgy to me, I’d be suspicious. Personally.

Christ, I’m glad my husband doesn’t think this, I’ve flown all over with male friends to watch gigs, off to a weekend with a male friend to do this soon! He trusts me because can be trusted. If he wanted to do the same with a female friend I’d have no issues!! Everyone is different but some peoples relationships sound very claustrophobic

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:19

Wildfairy · 03/11/2026 18:54

Are you being Serious, why would anyone lie, irs an online forum,

some of us are secure in our relationships and not suffering jealousy and insecurity, no one is lying about that,Confused

but it’s really tragic you fhink every relationship is like yours.

lol I’m not insecure in my relationship, but thanks for the assumption, as if you know me or my DH.

if my DH came to me and for months wanted to do a hobby and then randomly names a female, yes I would be suspicious. But precisely why I said it depends on backstory to this female and their friendship, first.

you sound defensive ! Maybe you should think about why?

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:21

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:19

lol I’m not insecure in my relationship, but thanks for the assumption, as if you know me or my DH.

if my DH came to me and for months wanted to do a hobby and then randomly names a female, yes I would be suspicious. But precisely why I said it depends on backstory to this female and their friendship, first.

you sound defensive ! Maybe you should think about why?

Also you can really tell you’re that mumsnet commenter that’s always looking for a fight and acting like they’re perfect 🤣🤣

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:22

Metalmotha · 03/11/2026 19:18

Christ, I’m glad my husband doesn’t think this, I’ve flown all over with male friends to watch gigs, off to a weekend with a male friend to do this soon! He trusts me because can be trusted. If he wanted to do the same with a female friend I’d have no issues!! Everyone is different but some peoples relationships sound very claustrophobic

Oh darling, exactly why I said it depends on backstory of said friend.

Donnaslayer · 03/11/2026 19:22

YANBU. Sod that, OP! I’d be watching this very carefully - are you sure there isn’t more going on with this woman?

It honestly sounds like he’s been softly-softly mentioning this "hobby" for a while just to lay the groundwork, so when they eventually started spending time alone together, you wouldn't think twice about it. Would the hobby eventually result in daytrips / nights away by any chance?

Its sad to see women picking at you. You expressed interest and explicitly told him it sounded fun, so for him to completely exclude you and look outside the marriage to do it with another female friend first is exceptionally odd and plain disrespectful!
Backed up by the fact that he’s now sulking and accusing you of "muscling in" when his wife has lovingly taken the initiative to organise something he’s been blathering on about for ages. It shows you’ve completely pissed on his chips! His reaction is a massive red flag. If it was just about the activity, he’d be thrilled you’re going together. The anger proves it was all about the women he wanted to do it with. Keep your eyes wide open, OP. Watch this clip from Matt Rife - he aint wrong! https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1Fg2KHCsgT/

Metalmotha · 03/11/2026 19:27

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:22

Oh darling, exactly why I said it depends on backstory of said friend.

I’m not sure why you thought you’d try and be condescending- that basically undermines any argument you’re trying to make! You also said there would be “one or two females” you wouldn’t mind. This suggests you would mind about the vast majority of women. Do they all have questionable backstories???

MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:27

Donnaslayer · 03/11/2026 19:22

YANBU. Sod that, OP! I’d be watching this very carefully - are you sure there isn’t more going on with this woman?

It honestly sounds like he’s been softly-softly mentioning this "hobby" for a while just to lay the groundwork, so when they eventually started spending time alone together, you wouldn't think twice about it. Would the hobby eventually result in daytrips / nights away by any chance?

Its sad to see women picking at you. You expressed interest and explicitly told him it sounded fun, so for him to completely exclude you and look outside the marriage to do it with another female friend first is exceptionally odd and plain disrespectful!
Backed up by the fact that he’s now sulking and accusing you of "muscling in" when his wife has lovingly taken the initiative to organise something he’s been blathering on about for ages. It shows you’ve completely pissed on his chips! His reaction is a massive red flag. If it was just about the activity, he’d be thrilled you’re going together. The anger proves it was all about the women he wanted to do it with. Keep your eyes wide open, OP. Watch this clip from Matt Rife - he aint wrong! https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1Fg2KHCsgT/

Edited

Yes exactly this!

CherrysyrupCoffee · 03/11/2026 19:31

DeftGoldHedgehog · 03/11/2026 18:41

What is the hobby? Surely it's no that unique or identifying.

Metalwork sculpture

OP posts:
MostlyHoldingItTogether · 03/11/2026 19:32

Metalmotha · 03/11/2026 19:27

I’m not sure why you thought you’d try and be condescending- that basically undermines any argument you’re trying to make! You also said there would be “one or two females” you wouldn’t mind. This suggests you would mind about the vast majority of women. Do they all have questionable backstories???

lol this post isn’t about me, but don’t worry, I’m very secure in my relationship. Thank you. You’re entitled to your opinion as am I. You can disagree and that’s ok. I don’t come on mumsnet for arguments or to act perfect in my life. But you’re clearly that kind of mumsnet poster. Bless you. Enjoy!

displayedg · 03/11/2026 19:48

vicj69 · 03/11/2026 18:24

For me it would depend if they ever shared a drunken kiss etc at uni

Surely a drunken uni kiss cant be held against anyone?!

displayedg · 03/11/2026 19:49

DeftGoldHedgehog · 03/11/2026 18:42

Agree. The usual doormats.

Or just secure in our relationships?

Livelovebehappy · 03/11/2026 20:40

I’d be the same OP. As would many others I suspect. I’d be upset that he hadn’t given me, his wife, first refusal. Quite often those who are so secure and smug in their relationships, and think it ‘cool’ to have lots of friends of the opposite sex, are the ones who are stunned when their partners have affairs.

Cranx · 03/11/2026 20:47

Sometimes you just want a hobby without your partner muscling in? Metalwork sculpture is expensive, and why would you want to pay for that twice and have two pieces of (likely shit) sculptures cluttering your home?

Loub1987 · 03/11/2026 21:13

Maybe I’m controlling (as this thread should suggest). I would not be happy with my husband doing a hobby activity with another woman, without me having the first opportunity to do it. And to be fair I think I would be uncomfortable generally with it.

SeenYourArse · 03/11/2026 21:23

Yeah those saying it’s fine that he goes with someone else are the ones who are shocked when their DH falls in love with the woman they’ve been hobbying with happily for the last 6 months 😂 they are so busy being cool and trusting that’s they can’t see that encouraging their DH to spend 1:1 quality time with another female that he already has affection for is a recipe for him to develop stronger feelings for her OR her for him and either way it’s going to be a problem at some point. It’s not appropriate at all and his reaction says it all.

Goditsmemargaret · 03/11/2026 21:23

I have three individual male friends, they are good friends of mine. I'm friendly with their respective spouses, they are friendly with mine but ultimately they are my friends. Usually we meet up in foursomes or as part of a group but have been known to have dinner alone or done a hobby.

I would be massively turned off if DH objected to this or tried to insert himself. Don't get me wrong I'd listen to his objections but the fact he knows there is nothing to worry about is very attractive.

Tell us more about this friend of his. Is she interested in you, is she married herself, do they have any romantic history etc?

GreenFritillary · 03/11/2026 21:30

There are times when we need to protect our relationships. A phrase from childhood comes to mind, about 'avoiding the occasion of sin'.

Vitany · 03/11/2026 21:38

I would have felt similarly to you, sort of left out. Irrespective of if whether it was a female friend or a male, especially If I had been interested. But I would have insisted on that friend joining us, not taken no for an answer and would try to enjoy time bonding with her too as it can be a way possibly to make you feel less fussed about her? Have there been any signs or incidents indicating you should worry about that friendship? I think it is strange you wouldn't do stuff all together if she's been such as long standing friend.

LoyalTurtle · 03/11/2026 21:41

CherrysyrupCoffee · 02/11/2026 17:22

Dh has been saying for ages that he wants to start a particular hobby/activity. He hasn’t made any move to actually start but talks about it a lot.

Recently he had mentioned it to a friend (female) and said to me he might ask her if she wants to do it with him? I said ‘why haven’t you asked me?!’ He said he didn’t think it was my sort of thing despite the fact I’d said it sounded fun.

Anyway I’ve booked it for us both. He isn’t happy! Said how he has to let down his friend I said ‘so ? She can still do it if she really wants to?’ He said I shouldn’t have muscled in ??!!!

I think you're fine to book it and you never know to what extent that hobby will take them to.
Protect your husband as denying you to be there might mean that he has some interest with the lady. Men usually like to be surrounded by the women they like.
Dh should be happy you're joining him

Swipe left for the next trending thread