Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Limiting length of visits to see baby despite journey time

428 replies

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 13:27

Am I being unreasonable to limit how long people visit my baby even if they have travelled over an hour to see us?

I moved away from the town where I grew up about 5 years ago and I now live about 75 mins car journey away from my family now.

I’ve not long had a baby and we told everyone prior to coming that we were limiting visits to 30 minutes so it didn’t get too overwhelming for me / the baby and also because we want to adjust to being a family of 3 as well. No one had any objections and my sister said she had found a local park that she was taking her children to after so they weren’t getting straight back in the car.

The next time they all came we upped the visit to an hour and then the last time they visited it was also supposed to be an hour but my baby was quite fussy and I was getting a bit stressed so they left after probably about 40 minutes.

Anyway I’ve just messaged my sister about finding a date to come around again and she’s messaged back essentially saying that an hour’s visit isn’t enough given the journey time and until I’m ready for longer visits, she won’t be coming to see us again.

I know some of this will be the hormones but I just feel really upset by her message. When she had her babies I always made the effort to go to see her.

OP posts:
pinkdyno · 03/11/2026 20:53

I wouldn’t have been able to cope either OP. I wouldn’t have set a boundary but would have been distraught afterwards. I had serious post natal anxiety. I know that now, but did not at that moment.

i would echo the half way trips and walks. Two year old twins is wild. Get you all out for some air.

re the car seat. I live 80 minutes from the hospital and 50 on a good day from the shop. As do many others.

Cariadm · 03/11/2026 20:50

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 13:27

Am I being unreasonable to limit how long people visit my baby even if they have travelled over an hour to see us?

I moved away from the town where I grew up about 5 years ago and I now live about 75 mins car journey away from my family now.

I’ve not long had a baby and we told everyone prior to coming that we were limiting visits to 30 minutes so it didn’t get too overwhelming for me / the baby and also because we want to adjust to being a family of 3 as well. No one had any objections and my sister said she had found a local park that she was taking her children to after so they weren’t getting straight back in the car.

The next time they all came we upped the visit to an hour and then the last time they visited it was also supposed to be an hour but my baby was quite fussy and I was getting a bit stressed so they left after probably about 40 minutes.

Anyway I’ve just messaged my sister about finding a date to come around again and she’s messaged back essentially saying that an hour’s visit isn’t enough given the journey time and until I’m ready for longer visits, she won’t be coming to see us again.

I know some of this will be the hormones but I just feel really upset by her message. When she had her babies I always made the effort to go to see her.

OMG!!! Forgive me for presuming and this might be totally out of character for you normally but the whole notion of pre arranging, almost booking, when and how long a 'visit' will be 'granted' comes across as precocious, self important and totally OTT! 🙄
Perhaps up to a point 'staggering' visits is understandable but when you say your baby was being 'fussy' do you mean they were crying and/or just being a normal newborn baby? 🤔Basically most people will surely realise and respect when you have had enough but the baby will not care or be affected by how many people are there or, within reason, how noisy/busy it is, as long as you or your partner are providing milk and a clean nappy when necessary baby will be fine!
Just chill a little maybe...?😊

OhWhatToDoAboutThis · 03/11/2026 20:46

Don’t mean to sound harsh but that sounds a bit mad. It is ridiculous to expect people to travel that far and only be ‘allowed’ to stay for 30 minutes or an hour. You’re lucky your family care enough to come. I know how it feels to be a new mum and to be really tired. My first baby didn’t sleep at night for the first 2 weeks but would then sleep all morning, but I still never said to anyone they could only stay for 30 minutes if they wanted to visit. Sure I didn’t have visitors every day and would say no if I genuinely needed to sleep and it wasn’t someone close enough that I could have a nap whilst they were there. Like my mum for example wouldn’t mind at all caring for baby whilst I went and had an hour if that’s what I needed. Your family are more than happy to help you I’m sure. Maybe you’re feeling like you have to host them and don’t want to deal with anything other than baby?

You can set whatever rules you like of course. But don’t be upset if people don’t want to follow them. Just accept that your sister will see you and baby when you’re feeling able to actually spend proper time with her. it’s not fair on your niece/nephew. I would never drive that far with my kids for such a short time for anything unless I absolutely needed to, regardless of how old they are. But defo not if they’re young. Be careful that you don’t become too isolated if you’re not having any visitors or going out to see people.

Scrimblescromble · 03/11/2026 20:45

Someone else has probably said this but both of you have agency in this and can do what works for you and your families, feelings might get hurt and that’s the nature of these kind of situations.

Also context is key here…are they expecting to be entertained/hosted or are they making you a cup of tea, running the hoover round, putting a wash on and leaving you with a lasagne to put in the oven? Either way you’re both within your rights to decide what does and doesn’t work for you and be adults about it

stichguru · 03/11/2026 20:37

You are limiting the visit to the time you want. That's fine - not unreasonable.
Your sister doesn't want to drive for 3 times the length of time she visits you for - that's fine too.

Clearly she could do the drive, but she clearly doesn't want to see you enough to be bothered. You could put the effort in to let them come for 3 hours, but you don't want to put the effort in. Neither of you is wrong, but don't be angry/hurt that she doesn't want to put more effort into the visit than you do.

Iwishicouldflyhigh · 03/11/2026 20:37

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 14:55

Ok seems I am being unreasonable.

We just wanted to manage expectations and make sure there is plenty of time for resting etc. Also I love them lots but my nephews are 2 & very active & noisy and it’s exhausting enough just watching them !! But perhaps we need to rethink meetings moving forwards

Resting? Wait until you have baby number 2 and number 3!!

IfYouNeedMeAskYourFather · 03/11/2026 20:34

Neverendingsummer26 · 02/11/2026 14:45

Newborn aren’t supposed to be in their car seats for more than an hour I don’t think so no I haven’t yet.

OMG you sound just like my sister in law. they're absolutely fine. Some people also live more than hour away from hospital. How do you think they get home?! I've had my kids as babies for 2 hours in the car - if we were driving and they slept, I let them. and both are healthy, happy and alive. car seats are so safe now compared to what they used to be and babies were in them for over an hour. You really need to loosen up a bit. If you're finding you have overwhelming anxiety and you didn't before, maybe speak to your midwife about it, but from the scenario you described, YABU. The longer people stay, the more help you'll have with the baby. Enjoy it. Like another poster said, it takes a village - don't burn yours.

August1980 · 03/11/2026 20:25

havingoneofthosedays · 02/11/2026 13:32

As they say, it takes a village…
Be careful you don’t burn yours down…

I was thinking this!

the new baby phase was a delight for me! Everyone coming around to help clean, cook, bathe and carry the baby! Aside from the nighttime feeds/lack of sleep, I looked fresh as a daisy everyone said! It’s the toddler stage that got me! Once she turned 1 the fussiness ramped up for her and I began on get overwhelmed! Wish more people would stop by now so I could duck to the loo by myself without my little person trying to push me off!!!

op, your baby won’t be a baby for long, you too will have to factor in car time with kids once your baby is grown up so you can appreciate were your sister is coming from!

Mumtobabyhavoc · 03/11/2026 20:18

Everyone is different. Do what works for you.
I'd be limiting everyone significantly with a newborn.

Flymyprettiesflies · 03/11/2026 20:13

With your sister on this one. Doesn’t the baby sleep?? You can’t just have them around during a lunch or similar and put the baby down upstairs as usual?
honestly the best thing you could probably do is try to not get sucked into scheduling your baby and try to get the baby used to being in a normal household routine with people
around, napping when out and about, being in the car etc

localnotail · 03/11/2026 20:07

I dont get it - so you kick her out after 30 minutes after they drove to see you for over an hour? That's really weird. I doubt baby cares much if they are there or not... I would not be visiting, too.

DroopyEyelids · 03/11/2026 19:58

I can so relate to this. I think you are exhausted and maybe have a bit of post partum anxiety. You are clinging to the length of the visits as something to control in your new completely chaotic parental life. All normal. Most of us have been there. If you can, just let it happen-. The longer visit. The chaos. It’ll all be fine. And retreat to your bedroom if and when you need too. Get your sister to come and sit in bed with you and take a nap while she holds the baby. Her kids can be downstairs with their dad. It’s going to be ok. You’ll be overwhelmed even if she doesn’t come and doesn’t spend 0mins. You are so lucky to have a sister. X

Meand2Ls · 03/11/2026 19:51

Postpartum skews a lot of thing especially with the first baby where you are worried about a lot of rules.
But the fact your sister has already travelled an hour each way 3 times during your baby’s newborn period with two toddlers to only be allowed to stay 30m-1hr is absolutely incredible of her and no small feat. I think it’s wild for you to suggest otherwise

tinyspiny · 03/11/2026 19:40

@Neverendingsummer26 YABU but why don’t you meet them somewhere midway where her children / child can run round and you can have a coffee and a chat .

Nursegladys2 · 03/11/2026 19:31

Look at social media, all about push presents, meal trains, etc etc
How ever did we manage, or our mums manage. 🙄

Will Ferrell GIF
Nursegladys2 · 03/11/2026 19:26

You're exhausted OP, hormonal and I sort of get where you're coming from. ( I was 2 days post partum, with youngest, then husband family came and camped out all bloody day, they all lived within a 5 mile radius btw) However, your sister drove an hour. To see you and your baby. The time limit, is an issue. There's nothing to stop you going for a kip and putting little one down if you're tired.

JustMeAndTheFish · 03/11/2026 19:15

I find this weird. I know I’m older but when did this level of controlling visits happen?

lauraloulou1 · 03/11/2026 19:13

Hand the baby to the relatives and go spend some time alone and have a shower and listen to music. This whole "no one visit for too long" mothering vibe is limiting people of their support and isolating women at an already scary time.

Endorewitch · 03/11/2026 19:11

Xon't be surprised if people stop visiting you. How unwelcoming you seem. If you arr likely to be tired after half an hour,forget about visitors.
You haven't been seriously ill. You have had a baby. !Yout poor sister. She was brilliant coming twice.can't believe you think anyone will agree with you.

Anotherdisposableusername · 03/11/2026 19:00

This is like a destination wedding.

Completely your choice, and your right. And the choice on whether that works for the people making all the effort to join you? That's theirs.

You have the right to set boundaries, and so do other people.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 03/11/2026 18:58

One day you will look at yourself now and realise how ridiculously precious you were being. Id not drive to see someone over an hour for an allocated 30 min slot. Way to alienate family. If your by fusses once a month for a bit, it will be fine. Also not sure why you were exhausted after them being over for an hour- they probably saw you were hostile and that's why they left.

Also you mentioned a number of times managing their expectations. People come to see you and actually bother, I do hope next time you will put the Countdown music as soon as they get through the door, like this their expectations will be perfectly managed.

OneHazelBird · 03/11/2026 18:51

How close are you to your family?

My sister has a baby and would have me there all day every day if she could.

What are you struggling with?

If it’s things like BF then you can take baby to your room and they can sit and watch TV.

Id be asking them to bring me treats and getting them to do things for me.

I remember feeling really overwhelmed, tired and anxious with mine but you have a DP to help and you are basically just sitting there with a baby in your arms, that may occasionally need feeding or changing.

I think it will help to know why you’re struggling so much.
E.g are you trying to get the baby to sleep and they keep waking it up etc.

Have you thought about taking the baby out with them in the pram?

ItsWoudHaveNotWouldOf · 03/11/2026 18:27

It's fine for you to have your boundaries, though very PFB behaviour imo. I would be saying the same as your sister though. Being given an hour after travelling that far is not very welcoming. You should be grateful they're willing to travel that far to see you.

exaltedwombat · 03/11/2026 18:25

What if you all lived as an extended family and everyone saw everyone ALL the time? Don’t be so controlling.

CptnJaneway420 · 03/11/2026 18:19

"New borns arent supposed to be in a carseat longer than an hour"
honestly insufferable.
Uuuh stop driving after 15/30 minutes take baby out carseat, obviously bring pushchair or baby carrier, have a 15 minute walk around, plan it for somewhere nice, scenic, expose your baby to fresh air and some nature - anything, use your imagination. You are not stuck at home because of the carseat rule thats just the most stupid excuse I've ever heard.
Meet in the damn middle for lunch somewhere or at a bloody park or museum or fun place. 30 minutes driving for each of you and the kids can play without you losing your mind because they are "a lot". Then you can leave after 30 minutes on your vocation. No carseat rule in sight. Smh.

Expecting her to do what you want because you said so is vile behaviour. You can ask and she can say bloody no. Shes already tried multiple times and it sounds like you were a nightmare tbh. Have some grace and let her know when you can accept normal visits.