Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people whinging endlessly about Halloween?

619 replies

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:30

No, it is not an American import. Yes, trick or treating was a thing 20 years ago. No, it is not begging. No, it is not terrifying. No, you are not legally obligated to take your children, but yes, you’re a bit of a misery if you don’t. Yes, teenagers are allowed to trick or treat. Yes, some elements are driven by consumerism, but you don’t have to join in.

Endless bloody whinging instead of just being content not to join in.

OP posts:
MidnightMeltdown · 01/11/2026 23:51

Right OP, and just because this is your opinion, everyone else must agree 🙄

What exactly is your point in starting this thread? To encourage more ‘whinging’ that you are apparently sick of?

JustAnotherWhinger · 01/11/2026 23:51

Then again it’s not surprise given this is the website where some folks adamantly insist, to people whose families have always used “Mom” for generations, that Mom is a complete Americanism as well.

Rather then an English import to the USA from specific areas that caught on there.

So it’s not just the Scots and Irish traditions that are rubbished, it’s certain English ones as well (mainly the Scots and Irish ones right enough).

SALaw · 01/11/2026 23:52

user1471522343 · 01/11/2026 22:35

Scottish here.
Every kid went ‘guising’ on Halloween. Guising was dressing up in fancy dress and going round friends and neighbours houses and performing something, usually a song, a joke or reciting a verse, in return for sweets or money. This was in the 60s and 70s. There was no ‘trick or treating’, you had to perform, so Halloween is not an American thing, but ‘trick or treating’ probably is an import.

Well every child I’ve ever had to the door still performs a joke or a song so it hasn’t changed at all, although they might preface it with “trick or treat” now which we didn’t in the 80s.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:52

Anarchy99 · 01/11/2026 23:49

Why shouldn’t people decide they don’t like an event? I fucking hate it, where I used to live, kids used to knock on every door regardless of having no decorations out.

Turns out that opening the door and saying ‘fuck off’ is quite effective though.

Get a grip. Ignore the door, put a sign up asking for no trick or treaters, or put some sweets out. All easy ways to deal with it without any fuss or whinging.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:53

MidnightMeltdown · 01/11/2026 23:51

Right OP, and just because this is your opinion, everyone else must agree 🙄

What exactly is your point in starting this thread? To encourage more ‘whinging’ that you are apparently sick of?

To whinge about the whingers.

OP posts:
PurpleMarshmallowSky · 01/11/2026 23:53

Illegally18 · 01/11/2026 23:44

Because. It. Is. America. That. Made. It. Such. A. Big. Deal.

Making it commercialised and making it a big deal are two different things. Halloween was already a big deal in many parts of the UK before the money making parts got added on.

montysmaw · 01/11/2026 23:54

naffogato · 01/11/2026 23:51

What utter nonsense. I’ve lived in Scotland all my life and guising is for Halloween and fuck all to do with guy Fawkes.

I am from Scotland and we didn't use the word "guising" for either.

MotherJessAndKittens · 01/11/2026 23:57

My mother calls it guising and she did it 60 odd years ago ( Scotland). You had to do similar to what the kids do now but not just tell a joke and you got nuts, apples and oranges not sweets. Usually ended in someone’s house where you had to eat treacle scones tied to a rope and dook for apples.

JoyChansey · 01/11/2026 23:57

People can refuse to participate by being busy on purpose.

As were you, by attending a party, you could have declined, stayed at home and participate in having trick or treaters coming to your door.

Same as I could've stayed at home and done the same, by going to the cinema and doing my shopping earlier on in the day, or on a different day.

Anarchy99 · 02/11/2026 00:00

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:52

Get a grip. Ignore the door, put a sign up asking for no trick or treaters, or put some sweets out. All easy ways to deal with it without any fuss or whinging.

If they don’t respect others enough to leave them alone when they have no obvious decorations out then why should I?

I shouldn’t have to get some shitty sign and I am entitled to answer my door - it might be something actually important.

Why is your attitude that it is up to those who don’t want to participate to be inconvenienced instead of the cheeky fuckers knocking on the doors of people when they aren’t welcome?

And why should people have to buy sweets to get them to fuck off?

Dontevenlookatme · 02/11/2026 00:01

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:39

You are just factually wrong. It is originally a Scottish and Irish celebration. I went trick or treating in the late 80s and all through the 90s. I am not sure why people are so obsessed with trying to pretend these things aren’t true.

Shove a box of sweets on your step and you won’t have a single interruption.

The origins are as you say but the means of celebrating it are definitely an American import.

We used to celebrate Bonfire Night, much more fun, Hallowe’en wasn’t a thing at all.

SALaw · 02/11/2026 00:01

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 20:41

No one in Ireland calls it guising - where did you think it came from other than Guy Fawkes?

This is very funny.

SALaw · 02/11/2026 00:02

Dontevenlookatme · 02/11/2026 00:01

The origins are as you say but the means of celebrating it are definitely an American import.

We used to celebrate Bonfire Night, much more fun, Hallowe’en wasn’t a thing at all.

What are the “means of celebrating it”?

Anarchy99 · 02/11/2026 00:02

JoyChansey · 01/11/2026 23:57

People can refuse to participate by being busy on purpose.

As were you, by attending a party, you could have declined, stayed at home and participate in having trick or treaters coming to your door.

Same as I could've stayed at home and done the same, by going to the cinema and doing my shopping earlier on in the day, or on a different day.

Or people could be allowed to carry on their days/evenings without having to be affected by this tacky crap.

tobeindoit · 02/11/2026 00:03

JoyChansey · 01/11/2026 23:57

People can refuse to participate by being busy on purpose.

As were you, by attending a party, you could have declined, stayed at home and participate in having trick or treaters coming to your door.

Same as I could've stayed at home and done the same, by going to the cinema and doing my shopping earlier on in the day, or on a different day.

I did participate. I carved a pumpkin and left a tub of sweets on the step. I also went trick or treating.

Stick a sign on the door saying no trick or treaters then. You just want an excuse to whinge and complain about it.

OP posts:
AutumnLeavesAndRaindrops · 02/11/2026 00:04

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

You’re quite wrong in its origins. Samhain originated from Scotland and Ireland around 2000 years ago, it was a Celtic festival to celebrate the end of the harvest. It’s not an American import at all. I’ve grown up with guising which goes back to the 16th century, have a wee look online at the history of Halloween and the traditions around it, it’s really interesting, I learned most of the traditions from my gran, it’s not about children “begging”. Absolutely no-one forces you to join with a tradition if you prefer not to, it’s personal choice isn’t it 😊.

Netcurtainnelly · 02/11/2026 00:05

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 01/11/2026 19:15

How is it not technically begging, though? Isn't the 'treat' bit of 'trick or treat' literally saying "Please give us some sweets/chocolate"? Especially when people turn up holding a bucket!

Or are people saying that, rather than begging, it's technically demanding with menaces - even though most people know that the 'trick' is almost always an empty threat?

Are people genuinely saying that, if children dressed as ghosts and witches knocked on somebody's door and said "Trick or treat!", they are truly not asking to be given some sweets, and wouldn’t be remotely surprised or disappointed if the householder exchanged a few pleasantries and then bid them Goodnight, completely empty-handed? It's all part of the tradition, and all great if everybody is happily taking part in it; but it's still a form of begging.

Edited

Gluttony. Do children need to be eating all those sweets too?

tobeindoit · 02/11/2026 00:06

Anarchy99 · 02/11/2026 00:00

If they don’t respect others enough to leave them alone when they have no obvious decorations out then why should I?

I shouldn’t have to get some shitty sign and I am entitled to answer my door - it might be something actually important.

Why is your attitude that it is up to those who don’t want to participate to be inconvenienced instead of the cheeky fuckers knocking on the doors of people when they aren’t welcome?

And why should people have to buy sweets to get them to fuck off?

Because it’s one night a year and a bit of fun.

Sure, you’re concerned it’s actually important to answer the door on Halloween when you know it’ll be trick or treaters. If you’re going to get up and answer the door every time there‘s a knock then just get some sweets in and give them out. Or be a misery and ignore the door. But stop whinging about it. You’ve got so many options.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 02/11/2026 00:07

Dontevenlookatme · 02/11/2026 00:01

The origins are as you say but the means of celebrating it are definitely an American import.

We used to celebrate Bonfire Night, much more fun, Hallowe’en wasn’t a thing at all.

We have always celebrated both.

No idea what the means of celebrating means.

OP posts:
JoyChansey · 02/11/2026 00:07

I'm not whinging or complaining about it.

I merely said I went out to the cinema and did some shopping, so I didn't need to stick a sign on my door.

You said you went to a party, and told me what my point was.

So I explained.

tobeindoit · 02/11/2026 00:08

Anarchy99 · 02/11/2026 00:02

Or people could be allowed to carry on their days/evenings without having to be affected by this tacky crap.

How affected can you be? It’s all just an excuse to whinge and complain.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 02/11/2026 00:09

Netcurtainnelly · 02/11/2026 00:05

Gluttony. Do children need to be eating all those sweets too?

Of course they don’t need to. It is a bit of fun.

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · 02/11/2026 00:09

tobeindoit · 02/11/2026 00:03

I did participate. I carved a pumpkin and left a tub of sweets on the step. I also went trick or treating.

Stick a sign on the door saying no trick or treaters then. You just want an excuse to whinge and complain about it.

We wouldn’t have to whinge if people respected the fact we didn’t want to participate.

Whatever its origins, it shouldn’t affect those who don’t want to be involved.

Its hard to avoid every event (Christmas takes over the whole fucking country) but surely it’s not difficult to respect that people dont want to have to put up signs or ignore their door.

JustAnotherWhinger · 02/11/2026 00:10

Dontevenlookatme · 02/11/2026 00:01

The origins are as you say but the means of celebrating it are definitely an American import.

We used to celebrate Bonfire Night, much more fun, Hallowe’en wasn’t a thing at all.

The means of celebrating it? You mean the guising that has been part of Scottish and Irish Halloween for considerably longer than it has in America?

In your area that may have been true. Not everywhere.

Suggesting your experience is the only correct one would be as ludicrous as DH’s 103yo granny insisting that Hogmanay is bigger and celebrated more than Christmas everywhere simply because that was true in the Scottish village (like many others) she grew up, while she was a child…