Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people whinging endlessly about Halloween?

619 replies

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:30

No, it is not an American import. Yes, trick or treating was a thing 20 years ago. No, it is not begging. No, it is not terrifying. No, you are not legally obligated to take your children, but yes, you’re a bit of a misery if you don’t. Yes, teenagers are allowed to trick or treat. Yes, some elements are driven by consumerism, but you don’t have to join in.

Endless bloody whinging instead of just being content not to join in.

OP posts:
PurpleMarshmallowSky · 01/11/2026 23:07

JemimaTiggywinkles · 01/11/2026 22:32

Something can originate in Scotland, be exported to the US and then imported from there to England. So it is both a British thing AND an American import. I just wish England imported all the American rules tbh - such as no decoration means no knocking, and old enough to trick or treat alone means too old to do it at all. I quite like little kids dressing up and asking for sweets but don’t think it’s okay for teens.

Where I grew up in the 90s you’d go to a Halloween party when you were little and trick or treating was for older kids and young teens. We all went in groups with our friends. You wouldn’t see parents out with small children like you do now.

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:08

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:02

But you do now understand that guising is nothing at all to do with Guy Fawkes? Grin

Only ever heard it when I lived in Scotland and it was only ever used in connection with asking for money for Guy Fawkes night. It was never used in Ireland in connection with Halloween

Notinmyname2026 · 01/11/2026 23:11

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:08

Only ever heard it when I lived in Scotland and it was only ever used in connection with asking for money for Guy Fawkes night. It was never used in Ireland in connection with Halloween

It absolutely is used in Ireland, coming from an Irish person. It comes from wearing masks disGUISING yourself from evil spirits from the otherworld, and has zero to do with Guy Fawkes. A quick Google will confirm.

Delphiniumandlupins · 01/11/2026 23:11

GintyMcGinty · 01/11/2026 18:52

I went out guising in the 70s.

My parents went out guising in the 50s.

Never heard of either Duck Apple Night or Mischief Night.

Must be foreign imports. Cause they’ve never happened in my part of Britain.

I've went out guising in the 60s. We didn't call it Trick or Treat because playing tricks on people wasn't an option. It wasn't begging because we had to earn our reward, by singing a song or telling a joke etc. We only went to houses we knew and used to be invited in.

BigGra · 01/11/2026 23:12

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:05

Maybe your relatives brought it back from Ireland then.

Bright it back from where ? I’m Irish in Ireland where we have celebrated Hallowe’en for centuries, whereas England traditionally
did not, since the Protestant church rejected Catholic and re Christian festivals.
It’s all there in the history books.

edited as I think I misinterpreted what you
meant by ‘ maybe my relatives, took it back to England’ hmm not likely but irrelevant really to all this.

RafaFan · 01/11/2026 23:15

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 22:57

It’s a tell. I’m from from the north of Ireland. Irish people don’t say they’re from Ulster - or at least it’s a very rare thing if they do - they’ll be the sort who identify as Ulster Scots not Irish - I see the OP then tells us she’s English. As I said a tell - so I understood she had a different experience of what Irish was and therefore I felt she was not really qualified to give a legit opinion but I accepted the situation as it was, but no doubt I’ll now be accused of not having a clue about my own country’s dialect by someone who’s English!😂 And so it goes on - the colonialists always know better.🙄

Just like you knew better when you were confidently telling us that "guising" comes from Guy Fawkes? Jeez...

Ijwwm · 01/11/2026 23:18

BigGra · 01/11/2026 23:01

But the whole point is, it is an ‘ American’ import to England.

Whilst the Irish, Scottish, and Welsh celebrated Hallowe’en, in many different forms and ways and have done for centuries, it did not become a thing in England until it became popular via American movies.
And the imported commercial version is, frankly, a bit shit.
We had relatives visit us from England in the 80’s in Ireland and we were astounded that they had no idea what hallowe’en was and were delighted with our offerings of brack to find the ring, bobbing for apples, a few sparklers and ‘ trick or treating ‘ followed by a horror movie with all the neighbours.

And yes we did call it trick or treating …’ trick or treat, trick or treat, give me something nice to eat…’ can’t remember the rest but if you were feeling cheeky,… ‘no apples or nuts or I’ll punch you in the guts.’
Good times.

Must be regional then, I’m English and was definitely out trick or treating in the 70s (south east).

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 01/11/2026 23:18

I grew up in the 70s and 80s, and I remember dressing up as a witch or a ghost and going out trick or treating. It was much worse then as there wasn't the etiquette of only going to houses with decorations. And the "tricks" were a real thing too. I remember being heartbroken one year when my witch's black cat got sprayed with some kind of weird foam. And I remember being given some sweets which tasted like soap etc.

Yes, we did apple bobbing and eating donuts off a string as well, but trick or treating was most definitely a thing.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:19

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:08

Only ever heard it when I lived in Scotland and it was only ever used in connection with asking for money for Guy Fawkes night. It was never used in Ireland in connection with Halloween

You are completely confused. Guising is Halloween. Guy Fawkes is Bonfire Night. Penny for the Guy is Bonfire Night. Penny for the Guy is asking for money for Bonfire Night. It is completely unrelated to guising, except that the first syllable of guising sounds like the name Guy. No one would ever use guising in relation to Bonfire Night. It has no role in Bonfire Night. Guising comes from disguise and is trick or treating.

I have heard trick or treating referred to as guising in Ireland. Irish people on this thread have explained to you that they also know it as guising.

OP posts:
Ijwwm · 01/11/2026 23:21

When and where I grew up in the 70s, bobbing for apples and sparklers were for Guy Fawkes Night, not Halloween.

JoyChansey · 01/11/2026 23:21

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 21:53

I went to a party last night. What’s your point?

My point is that I wasn't in to be bothered by trick or treaters.

And if anyone else is bothered by them, they can also choose to go out and not be in, too.

As were you.

5foot5 · 01/11/2026 23:22

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 22:46

The absolute determination to make Halloween an American import despite vast evidence to the contrary is so weird.

Well the arguments on threads like this will go round and round because people can't seem to accept that there are regional and generational differences so everybody posting is "speaking their own truth".

Quite clearly some regions of the UK, most notably Scotland and Ireland, have always had a strong Halloween tradition. In England it seems to vary but, over time, we have developed a more homogenised culture. This probably accounts for older posters who genuinely had no experience of ToT when young while people 20 or so years younger declaring that of course it has always been a thing because they remember doing it back in the 90s!

I am from a generation and part of the country where Halloween really wasn't much recognised and absolutely definitely hadn't heard of ToT until we saw it on American films or TV. So of course when it started happening on our own doorstep the first reaction is to think it is an American import.

Now, listening to other people's experiences, I can see that is not necessarily the case but surely you can see how it would appear so to many people not brought up with it.

I do genuinely think that much of the spread of it's popularity is down to it being so commercialised. Supermarkets etc. seeing the retail opportunity to sell costumes,decorations and so on which all fuels the idea that it is a major event that everyone should participate in.

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:23

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:19

You are completely confused. Guising is Halloween. Guy Fawkes is Bonfire Night. Penny for the Guy is Bonfire Night. Penny for the Guy is asking for money for Bonfire Night. It is completely unrelated to guising, except that the first syllable of guising sounds like the name Guy. No one would ever use guising in relation to Bonfire Night. It has no role in Bonfire Night. Guising comes from disguise and is trick or treating.

I have heard trick or treating referred to as guising in Ireland. Irish people on this thread have explained to you that they also know it as guising.

Edited

I’m not confused in the slightest. We never used guising, but thanks for updating me. No surprise there!

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:24

BigGra · 01/11/2026 23:12

Bright it back from where ? I’m Irish in Ireland where we have celebrated Hallowe’en for centuries, whereas England traditionally
did not, since the Protestant church rejected Catholic and re Christian festivals.
It’s all there in the history books.

edited as I think I misinterpreted what you
meant by ‘ maybe my relatives, took it back to England’ hmm not likely but irrelevant really to all this.

Edited

Yes, that’s what I meant. Plenty of English people have been trick or treating for decades and it’s much more likely they got it from Scotland and Ireland than the US. And within Scotland and Ireland themselves it is certainly not a US import.

Halloween is not an American import to the UK.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 01/11/2026 23:24

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:23

I’m not confused in the slightest. We never used guising, but thanks for updating me. No surprise there!

You're obviously confused because you assumed that guising was linked to Guy Fawkes. Which it isn't.

Delphiniumandlupins · 01/11/2026 23:24

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:08

Only ever heard it when I lived in Scotland and it was only ever used in connection with asking for money for Guy Fawkes night. It was never used in Ireland in connection with Halloween

The word "guising" has nothing to do with Guy Fawkes. In the Shetland Islands they celebrate Up Helly Aa at the end of January (in Lerwick, other areas in February and March). They dress up and burn a replica longship. The people in costumes are called "guisers", the leader is the Guiser Jarl (Earl)

Olive123456 · 01/11/2026 23:25

Ally886 · 01/11/2026 23:00

I'll join in if it's kids enjoying themselves but three fourteen year olds knocking on the door and not even saying anything is certainly not what I want to see on a Saturday night. Just the blank stare of expectation. Felt like giving them all a satsuma

With that I agree. I wouldn't mind if they at least made some effort but they just rock up in their normal clothes not even a shop bought mask.

FKAT · 01/11/2026 23:26

I'm 52 and from the West Midlands and remember trick or treaters coming to the door when I was 5 or 6. It was a couple of young boys wearing old man masks and scared the shit out of me.

It's amazing to live as long as I have and read the absolute nonsense coming from people about what life was like for my generation. MN today containing confident assertions that divorce and pre-marital sex were frowned on in 1996, children didn't have pharmaceutical pain relief in the 80s, no-one from past generations EVER wore revealing clothes to nightclubs and Trick or Treat didn't exist until Americans brought it over in the 2000s.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:27

Ijwwm · 01/11/2026 23:21

When and where I grew up in the 70s, bobbing for apples and sparklers were for Guy Fawkes Night, not Halloween.

Sparklers are definitely for Bonfire Night. They’re not a good mix with the costumes of Halloween.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:28

JoyChansey · 01/11/2026 23:21

My point is that I wasn't in to be bothered by trick or treaters.

And if anyone else is bothered by them, they can also choose to go out and not be in, too.

As were you.

Edited

Do you were busy, not refusing to participate. Obviously people will be busy.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:29

5foot5 · 01/11/2026 23:22

Well the arguments on threads like this will go round and round because people can't seem to accept that there are regional and generational differences so everybody posting is "speaking their own truth".

Quite clearly some regions of the UK, most notably Scotland and Ireland, have always had a strong Halloween tradition. In England it seems to vary but, over time, we have developed a more homogenised culture. This probably accounts for older posters who genuinely had no experience of ToT when young while people 20 or so years younger declaring that of course it has always been a thing because they remember doing it back in the 90s!

I am from a generation and part of the country where Halloween really wasn't much recognised and absolutely definitely hadn't heard of ToT until we saw it on American films or TV. So of course when it started happening on our own doorstep the first reaction is to think it is an American import.

Now, listening to other people's experiences, I can see that is not necessarily the case but surely you can see how it would appear so to many people not brought up with it.

I do genuinely think that much of the spread of it's popularity is down to it being so commercialised. Supermarkets etc. seeing the retail opportunity to sell costumes,decorations and so on which all fuels the idea that it is a major event that everyone should participate in.

I’d expect people living in the UK not to call a tradition that started in the UK an American import to the UK.

OP posts:
Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:31

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 01/11/2026 23:24

You're obviously confused because you assumed that guising was linked to Guy Fawkes. Which it isn't.

I assumed it was guy fawkes because it wasn’t part of my local dialect. No one spoke of it, it had no relevance and I connected it with Guy Fawkes because it was used in relation to begging “Penny for the Guy” by my Scottish friends in the days before google - it’s not the weirdest connection is it?

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:31

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:23

I’m not confused in the slightest. We never used guising, but thanks for updating me. No surprise there!

You are confused. No one in Britain has ever referred to guising as asking for money for Bonfire Night. You’re mixing it up with Penny for the Guy.

You may never have used the term guising, but people who are Irish are clearly telling you that they did.

OP posts:
VividPinkTraybake · 01/11/2026 23:35

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

Trick or treating has been going on scotland for at least 34 years...having done it myself at that point so that's utter nonsense, never mind the rest of your points

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:35

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:31

You are confused. No one in Britain has ever referred to guising as asking for money for Bonfire Night. You’re mixing it up with Penny for the Guy.

You may never have used the term guising, but people who are Irish are clearly telling you that they did.

Confident statement no one in Britain has ever…
I’ll leave it there.