Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people whinging endlessly about Halloween?

619 replies

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:30

No, it is not an American import. Yes, trick or treating was a thing 20 years ago. No, it is not begging. No, it is not terrifying. No, you are not legally obligated to take your children, but yes, you’re a bit of a misery if you don’t. Yes, teenagers are allowed to trick or treat. Yes, some elements are driven by consumerism, but you don’t have to join in.

Endless bloody whinging instead of just being content not to join in.

OP posts:
whyayepetal · 01/11/2026 20:47

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:39

You are just factually wrong. It is originally a Scottish and Irish celebration. I went trick or treating in the late 80s and all through the 90s. I am not sure why people are so obsessed with trying to pretend these things aren’t true.

Shove a box of sweets on your step and you won’t have a single interruption.

I grew up in the North East, with lots of neighbours who were Scottish. I remember our neighbours telling us about guising, and they expected any Halloween visitors to be able to tell a joke, sing a song, or some such to earn their treat. I once had a Halloween party (not my choice, but my mother’s, because she wanted to try out a recipe she had seen for a witch cake!).

This was in the early 1970s, so it is definitely not new. I do remember making what were called turnip lanterns in the NE (slight language barrier in our house as parents were southerners and what was at turnip in the NE was a swede in the SE!)

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 20:47

SaySomethingMan · 01/11/2026 20:44

.

Edited

Why does it matter whether Muslims do Halloween? What an odd question.

Weeelokthen · 01/11/2026 20:47

GintyMcGinty · 01/11/2026 18:52

I went out guising in the 70s.

My parents went out guising in the 50s.

Never heard of either Duck Apple Night or Mischief Night.

Must be foreign imports. Cause they’ve never happened in my part of Britain.

Absolutely not an imported thing. We used to dook for apples in the 80's, Scotland.

Cantgiveitaway · 01/11/2026 20:47

SaySomethingMan · 01/11/2026 20:44

.

Edited

Depends on the Muslim.

I know lots of people of different religions who do and lots who don't.

I'm a Christian who takes part, and so did my church when I was growing up but most members of my current church don't agree with it.

My son has several Muslim kids in his class and some take part and some don't. My Muslim friend gives out sweets to trick or treaters, he used to trick or treat as a kid.

Mathair2 · 01/11/2026 20:47

I agree with you OP. I have always hated halloween but I slap on a smile and do it for my kids. We dont entertain trick or treaters here, it seems to be an unspoken rule in our area that if theres no decorations / pumpkin out you dont knock so we dont get any. But we bring our kids and we attend a Halloween party with friends.

ThisWiseRobin · 01/11/2026 20:49

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:49

Yes, they’re being miseries.

If that is the case I expect you to be at Easter Eucharist. If not you are a misery.

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 20:50

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 20:46

You can’t be serious!! It’s got nothing to do with Guy Fawkes.

It's not an Irish term - are you scottish? Don't assume we are the same and use the same terms.

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 20:51

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 20:50

It's not an Irish term - are you scottish? Don't assume we are the same and use the same terms.

You need to learn a bit of history, you clearly have no idea what you’re talking about.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 20:53

ThisWiseRobin · 01/11/2026 20:49

If that is the case I expect you to be at Easter Eucharist. If not you are a misery.

Which part of Easter Eucharist is fun for anyone children?

OP posts:
allthingsprettyinpink · 01/11/2026 20:53

Well said 👏

ThisWiseRobin · 01/11/2026 20:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Luckily your opinion is of no interest. I'm only commenting because of the unwarranted confidence you make such a sweeping statement.
I would love to see you say the same to the next Muslim you find....now there's a party pooper for you.
Bet you won't.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 20:55

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 20:50

It's not an Irish term - are you scottish? Don't assume we are the same and use the same terms.

Guising absolutely was used in Ireland.

OP posts:
newrubylane · 01/11/2026 20:55

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

Well I'm 41 and went trick or treating as young child, so it definitely has been happening in England since at least the late 80s...

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 20:56

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 20:55

Guising absolutely was used in Ireland.

From where you lived - where is that?

AffableApple · 01/11/2026 20:56

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

Went trick-or-treating, not guising, in the mid 80s in Ireland. (Guising wasn't used amongst us, though I was aware of it as I got older.)

And yes actually saying "trick or treat", and collecting sweets. (With a carrier bag, not a fancy pumpkin bucket though, admittedly!)

It isn't begging.

Consider putting a note of non-participation on your door if you find yourself disturbed. (Though usually no decorations is enough in most places.)

Dameputtingonabraveface · 01/11/2026 20:59

I am in my 50s and remember having a little party when I was about 6 years old with apple bobbing etc. My dad was the village vicar in a village on the edge of the Chilterns, so Halloween is certainly not new or seen as evil by the whole Christian community. Som3 of our extended family are scottish and it certainly is not a new thing. I also have have family from central Europe and there are traditions including leaving lanterns for lanterns on graves for those we have lost etc. It is a night to remember the dead- who have shaped us and we will all join one day.

Dragonscaledaisy · 01/11/2026 21:00

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 19:26

Fair enough.
Everyone's been shouting "Trick or Treat" in the UK since 1890.
Your granny and your great granny passed down the family heirlooms of plastic tat pumpkins for the " candy" for the " trick or treaters"
Great grandpa was famous for his spooky house decorations in 1947.
Absolutely NOTHING to do with US films or culture.

It's only on MN where people are so familiar with plastic tat. It's certainly never been part of Hallowe'en in my world.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 21:00

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 20:56

From where you lived - where is that?

Edited

When I lived in Ireland it was Ulster.

That doesn’t really matter though. There are numerous sources outlining the history of the word guising and its use in Ireland. Just because it wasn’t used by you does not mean it has never been used in by anyone Irish.

OP posts:
Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 21:02

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 21:00

When I lived in Ireland it was Ulster.

That doesn’t really matter though. There are numerous sources outlining the history of the word guising and its use in Ireland. Just because it wasn’t used by you does not mean it has never been used in by anyone Irish.

Yep thought so. Thanks!

NotTerfNorCis · 01/11/2026 21:03

It wasn't an English thing until the eighties. We had Bonfire Night. For us Halloween was very much an American import.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 21:03

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 21:02

Yep thought so. Thanks!

Okay. Well I’m pleased you’ve learnt that guising is unrelated to Guy Fawkes and it gave me a chuckle that you didn’t connect it with disguising Grin.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 21:04

NotTerfNorCis · 01/11/2026 21:03

It wasn't an English thing until the eighties. We had Bonfire Night. For us Halloween was very much an American import.

It. Is. Not. American.

OP posts:
NotTerfNorCis · 01/11/2026 21:05

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 21:04

It. Is. Not. American.

It was spread by America. As it is now, it's an American cultural import.

Dragonscaledaisy · 01/11/2026 21:05

NotTerfNorCis · 01/11/2026 21:03

It wasn't an English thing until the eighties. We had Bonfire Night. For us Halloween was very much an American import.

It was definitely happening in the seventies.

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 21:06

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 21:02

Yep thought so. Thanks!

How did you “think so” when a second ago you were saying the poster must be Scottish 😂