Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of people whinging endlessly about Halloween?

619 replies

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:30

No, it is not an American import. Yes, trick or treating was a thing 20 years ago. No, it is not begging. No, it is not terrifying. No, you are not legally obligated to take your children, but yes, you’re a bit of a misery if you don’t. Yes, teenagers are allowed to trick or treat. Yes, some elements are driven by consumerism, but you don’t have to join in.

Endless bloody whinging instead of just being content not to join in.

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · 01/11/2026 23:47

SALaw · 01/11/2026 23:41

So they weren’t saying the words “trick or treat” in Scotland as it is called “guising” but otherwise they were doing exactly what they do now - knocking on doors whilst dressed up and getting a wee sweet or often 20p etc.

Not in many parts of England in the 70s.

JustAnotherWhinger · 01/11/2026 23:46

5foot5 · 01/11/2026 23:38

If you read my post my point was that, for many people in the UK, there was no strong Halloween tradition and ToT was unheard of apart from American films and TV. Hence those people assuming it was an American import when it turned up on their own doorstep.

The wrong assumptions aren’t the main issue. Nobody knows everything.

The issue is the folks that the rudely double-down and insist their incorrect assumptions are in fact correct. What happened in their town/family is what must have happened UK wide and anything else is wrong.

Its incredibly common on here and shows a real lack of both manners and intelligence in many.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:46

Illegally18 · 01/11/2026 23:44

Because. It. Is. America. That. Made. It. Such. A. Big. Deal.

That the USA celebrates it does not make it an American celebration. If it was 4th July you’d have a point.

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · 01/11/2026 23:45

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 18:39

You are just factually wrong. It is originally a Scottish and Irish celebration. I went trick or treating in the late 80s and all through the 90s. I am not sure why people are so obsessed with trying to pretend these things aren’t true.

Shove a box of sweets on your step and you won’t have a single interruption.

Wow. So everyone should join in just because you like it? And how do you know there won’t be a single interruption?

Do you always struggle to accept that others have a different opinion to you?

TicklishReader · 01/11/2026 23:45

This thread is a study on doubling down.

JustAnotherWhinger · 01/11/2026 23:44

Used to love Halloween as a child. Our village went for it in a huge way. Would end up with enough sweets to do my play pieces until after Christmas, when selection box ones took over.

Brilliant times.

Illegally18 · 01/11/2026 23:44

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 19:50

It. Is. Not. An. American. Festival.

Why are people so unable to grasp this?

Because. It. Is. America. That. Made. It. Such. A. Big. Deal.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:43

5foot5 · 01/11/2026 23:38

If you read my post my point was that, for many people in the UK, there was no strong Halloween tradition and ToT was unheard of apart from American films and TV. Hence those people assuming it was an American import when it turned up on their own doorstep.

I just think it’s odd that people would know about Halloween in the US but not know about parts of their own country which celebrate it.

OP posts:
SALaw · 01/11/2026 23:41

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:53

It really wasn't until the US films of Halloween came out.

Not a single UK child was knocking on doors saying Trick or Treat in the 60s or 70s.

So they weren’t saying the words “trick or treat” in Scotland as it is called “guising” but otherwise they were doing exactly what they do now - knocking on doors whilst dressed up and getting a wee sweet or often 20p etc.

Crikeyalmighty · 01/11/2026 23:41

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

I hate the whole thing but trick or treating was around when I was a kid- and I’m 64!!!

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:41

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:35

Confident statement no one in Britain has ever…
I’ll leave it there.

I am 100% absolutely 💯 confident. They are completely and utterly unrelated. It would be like calling Ash Wednesday your birthday because they both contain the syllable day. No one has ever made that mistake.

Amused at some poor Scottish family you knew knocking on doors dressed as a witch with their pumpkin basket as everyone else watched fireworks round a bonfire.

Or being a lone figure waiting for the firework display at the local park whilst all their mates are out trick or treating.

You got mixed up with the term, and you’ve never heard of the term guising being used in your area. Fair enough.

OP posts:
User3353821614 · 01/11/2026 23:40

RaininSummer · 01/11/2026 18:48

It wasn't a thing in England in the nineties though. I had young kids then and nothing happened at Halloween.

It was - I was a child in the 90s and yes, lots happened for Halloween.

Notinmyname2026 · 01/11/2026 23:40

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:35

Confident statement no one in Britain has ever…
I’ll leave it there.

Hahaha considering you've been confidently speaking for all of Ireland saying no one here has ever used the term guising 😂😂😂

VividPinkTraybake · 01/11/2026 23:39

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:47

In 70s and 80s most of us had Duck Apple night or mischief night.
Trick or treating is an American version of Samhain. The UK just imitates the American movie version.

It is the capitalist bastardisation of a Celtic tradition.
And yes, I am proud of that phrase, and no, I don't have any sweets.

Still utterly wrong when you daid it had only started a few years ago, unless you yhink 34 years ago is recent which I would love from a self esteem point of view

User3353821614 · 01/11/2026 23:38

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 18:43

No idea what you are talking about, I was trick or treating in the early 90’s. It’s absolutely not something that started a few years ago, and not Halloween an American import.
I’m assuming you’re English and can’t see past the end of your own nose.
For some reason English people seem to think anything that isn’t English must be American, it’s so bizarre.

Er, we don’t all think like that thanks 😂

5foot5 · 01/11/2026 23:38

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:29

I’d expect people living in the UK not to call a tradition that started in the UK an American import to the UK.

If you read my post my point was that, for many people in the UK, there was no strong Halloween tradition and ToT was unheard of apart from American films and TV. Hence those people assuming it was an American import when it turned up on their own doorstep.

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:37

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:31

I assumed it was guy fawkes because it wasn’t part of my local dialect. No one spoke of it, it had no relevance and I connected it with Guy Fawkes because it was used in relation to begging “Penny for the Guy” by my Scottish friends in the days before google - it’s not the weirdest connection is it?

Your Scottish friends did not say guising to refer to Penny for the Guy. No one ever would. It would be like calling Christmas Day Shrove Tuesday.

Guising is a term which has been used for many years in Scotland and parts of Ireland, albeit not where you are from.

OP posts:
User3353821614 · 01/11/2026 23:37

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

I’m 44 and trick or treating was definitely a thing. Not as popular, but it definitely happened. When was your childhood? 60s?

BigGra · 01/11/2026 23:37

Ijwwm · 01/11/2026 23:18

Must be regional then, I’m English and was definitely out trick or treating in the 70s (south east).

Well exactly, but let’s not let common sense get in the way of a good old Mumsnet cat fight.

This whole thread is littered with posters getting seriously wound up and making claims of “ this NEVER EVER happened in England, or NO WAY, did we do that ever in whatever place. It’s such silly nonsense.

The point of my post was to point out that hallowe’en was rejected in the 17th century in England when the Protestant church rejected Catholic and pre Christian festivals, which is what Hallowe’en is an ancient Celtic festival.

Ireland and Scotland are Celtic countries with Celtic languages , England is not, bar some regional areas Isle of Man and an area in Cornwall ? I believe.
Thus it stands to reason why there is such a vast difference in how Hallowe’en is celebrated, or not, across the geographical area of the British Isles.

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:35

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:31

You are confused. No one in Britain has ever referred to guising as asking for money for Bonfire Night. You’re mixing it up with Penny for the Guy.

You may never have used the term guising, but people who are Irish are clearly telling you that they did.

Confident statement no one in Britain has ever…
I’ll leave it there.

VividPinkTraybake · 01/11/2026 23:35

Suspicioustoenails · 01/11/2026 18:36

Yes it IS an American import.
Yes trick or treating was only started here a few years ago..not in our childhoods.
Yes it is absolutely begging.
Yes it's a massive pain in the arse when you are forced to " join in" by other people's kids hammering on your front door.

Trick or treating has been going on scotland for at least 34 years...having done it myself at that point so that's utter nonsense, never mind the rest of your points

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:31

Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:23

I’m not confused in the slightest. We never used guising, but thanks for updating me. No surprise there!

You are confused. No one in Britain has ever referred to guising as asking for money for Bonfire Night. You’re mixing it up with Penny for the Guy.

You may never have used the term guising, but people who are Irish are clearly telling you that they did.

OP posts:
Cushionthefloor · 01/11/2026 23:31

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 01/11/2026 23:24

You're obviously confused because you assumed that guising was linked to Guy Fawkes. Which it isn't.

I assumed it was guy fawkes because it wasn’t part of my local dialect. No one spoke of it, it had no relevance and I connected it with Guy Fawkes because it was used in relation to begging “Penny for the Guy” by my Scottish friends in the days before google - it’s not the weirdest connection is it?

tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:29

5foot5 · 01/11/2026 23:22

Well the arguments on threads like this will go round and round because people can't seem to accept that there are regional and generational differences so everybody posting is "speaking their own truth".

Quite clearly some regions of the UK, most notably Scotland and Ireland, have always had a strong Halloween tradition. In England it seems to vary but, over time, we have developed a more homogenised culture. This probably accounts for older posters who genuinely had no experience of ToT when young while people 20 or so years younger declaring that of course it has always been a thing because they remember doing it back in the 90s!

I am from a generation and part of the country where Halloween really wasn't much recognised and absolutely definitely hadn't heard of ToT until we saw it on American films or TV. So of course when it started happening on our own doorstep the first reaction is to think it is an American import.

Now, listening to other people's experiences, I can see that is not necessarily the case but surely you can see how it would appear so to many people not brought up with it.

I do genuinely think that much of the spread of it's popularity is down to it being so commercialised. Supermarkets etc. seeing the retail opportunity to sell costumes,decorations and so on which all fuels the idea that it is a major event that everyone should participate in.

I’d expect people living in the UK not to call a tradition that started in the UK an American import to the UK.

OP posts:
tobeindoit · 01/11/2026 23:28

JoyChansey · 01/11/2026 23:21

My point is that I wasn't in to be bothered by trick or treaters.

And if anyone else is bothered by them, they can also choose to go out and not be in, too.

As were you.

Edited

Do you were busy, not refusing to participate. Obviously people will be busy.

OP posts: