Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should fireworks be banned from public sale?

168 replies

Toffeeappletoty · 01/11/2026 15:25

Last night a group of teens/young men were setting of fireworks on the central reservation of a dual carriageway they were running across the road, it was shocking to witness.

There was also an incident in the city centre with people throwing fireworks at members of the public.

Is it time to ban them altogether from public sale? I’ve long though that they should only be permitted for licensed organised displays.

But having said that I was talking to dh and I have many happy childhood memories of bonfire night with a few fireworks in the back garden, all done safely and finished by 8pm.

We were saying that lots of things are dangerous in the wrong hands, knives, alcohol, and there are laws around fireworks already. But some don’t follow the law, but that’s the same for lots of things.

I always find mumsnet is very anti fireworks anyway, and they are terrible for animals and wildlife.

Yanbu - ban them for public sale
Yabu - don’t ruin it for everyone just because a few can’t be responsible

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OonaStubbs · 08/11/2026 18:08

It's a lot harder to make homemade fireworks than it is to buy them from a shop. And you might as well say legalise all guns because people will just make them at home anyway with 3D printers.

LakieLady · 08/11/2026 18:06

Holeymoley28 · 01/11/2026 15:51

The fireworks are ultimately not the problem it’s twats buying them.

If you think making them illegal will actually stop the twats you’re not very bright. It’s not hard ultimately to make fireworks and much like other things they would be sold under counter back ally.

What you need is faster police response and harsher punishments for twats setting them off in dangerous ways.

I agree.

Home made fireworks are likely to be a lot more dangerous than bought ones, imo.

SinisterBiscuit · 08/11/2026 16:12

It's another yes from me. They're essentially explosives, and being sold to anyone over 18. They get into the wrong hands, and both people and animals are injured, sometimes with horrific consequences. If they were to be sold to the public, I think people should have to have some sort of license to say they've had appropriate training in the use of fireworks. It wouldn't eliminate the problem, but it might reduce the amount of injuries. But again, ideally they would only be sold to organisations and businesses for public displays.

mumumental · 08/11/2026 15:41

Yes. They should be in public displays only.

Anarchy99 · 08/11/2026 15:40

Quine0nline · 07/11/2026 15:16

They cause trauma and anxiety people with many disabilities and syndromes
They cause fear amongst the elderly and young
Veterans who suffer trauma from combat situations
Migrants who have suffered trauma in their home countries.

There are a lot of groups who may not seek collectivities for a common action but unity is strength.

Yes but apparently the need to see and hear the lovely whizz bangs is more important 🙄

Maverickess · 07/11/2026 15:43

HappiestSleeping · 06/11/2026 11:59

I find it amazing that we live in a world where a bottle of bleach has to have a label on it saying "do not drink" and yet we sell explosives over the counter.

Exactly, people apparently can't be trusted not to drink bleach, or recognise that a bag of peanuts does indeed contain peanuts, but if they're over 18 they can buy small explosives to do with what they please.
I think organised displays or drones would have far less impact, but we live in an increasingly individualistic society where people aren't interested in their impact on others, so I don't see it changing any time soon.

Quine0nline · 07/11/2026 15:16

They cause trauma and anxiety people with many disabilities and syndromes
They cause fear amongst the elderly and young
Veterans who suffer trauma from combat situations
Migrants who have suffered trauma in their home countries.

There are a lot of groups who may not seek collectivities for a common action but unity is strength.

TheFlandersPigeon · 07/11/2026 08:13

cloudtreecarpet · 07/11/2026 07:44

I agree and have for years.

The sale of fireworks seems to be something that is firmly rooted in the past and has for some reason escaped modern health & safety rules - but they are so dangerous!

Even organised displays are bizarre given the impact on the environment.

I thought drone light shows, which are spectacular, not dangerous, not noisy & not bad for the environment would be more popular by now.

It's like there is some kind of blind spot when it comes to fireworks. Very odd.

Luckily, where I live it has been the quietest year I can remember for fireworks. Long may that continue!

Organised displays aren't at all bizarre. They're a response to a cultural attachment to fireworks and are the best way of trying to make the practice safer. We obviously do vast numbers of things that are terrible for the environment, and nobody really thinks that's a reason to avoid something in itself: we make assessments depending on context.

As you acknowledge yourself, you were wrong about drone shows. You've plenty of company, as you'll see in this thread, but the noise is part of what people like. That means sound free alternatives aren't alternatives.

Some people certainly have blind spots about fireworks, but this isn't at all odd either. It's normal. This thread will also show you examples of people with blind spots about environmentally damaging things they like, hence for example pet owners talking about the environmental downsides of fireworks whilst ignoring that of pets, and trying to bat away points about how those impacted by dogs have to suffer it much more than those impacted by fireworks do. So this is actually quite typical behaviour, and to be expected. Would be the same if the thread were about unnecessary driving, meat consumption and so on. It's also why attempting cultural change in firework usage is the best way to try and address the problems.

Somewherenorthofhere · 07/11/2026 08:01

Aside from the shocking effect on wildlife which I am sure everyone knows about

They cause serious life changing injury/death from a distance. We have banned other things like this - guns, acid, pepper spray... pretty sure you cannot walk around with a taser in your pocket either. Other examples i cant think of

cloudtreecarpet · 07/11/2026 07:44

I agree and have for years.

The sale of fireworks seems to be something that is firmly rooted in the past and has for some reason escaped modern health & safety rules - but they are so dangerous!

Even organised displays are bizarre given the impact on the environment.

I thought drone light shows, which are spectacular, not dangerous, not noisy & not bad for the environment would be more popular by now.

It's like there is some kind of blind spot when it comes to fireworks. Very odd.

Luckily, where I live it has been the quietest year I can remember for fireworks. Long may that continue!

Anarchy99 · 07/11/2026 07:33

Leavemetonguetied · 06/11/2026 22:07

Also see things like local festivals. We have an arts festival which causes havoc on the local roads. It's annoying but the alternative is to say don't do it, let's all just stay inside.

I think a lot of this has been driven by covid actually.

I get it’s not possible to avoid everything but it should be possible to stay in and avoid things.

Instead you have the loud fireworks every evening for a couple of weeks.It is intrusive and unnecessary

Leavemetonguetied · 06/11/2026 22:07

TheFlandersPigeon · 06/11/2026 11:56

The list of celebrations that impact on people who don't want to participate goes well beyond Christmas, Halloween and Bonfire Night. Anything that celebrates a relationship with a loved one can be upsetting for people who don't have that for whatever reason. So that's Mother's, Father's and Valentines Day. And anything where people celebrating causes practical inconvenience to others.

This is quite aside from the normal day to day things that some people enjoy that cause negative impacts on others too. There's just not a way to frame Bonfire Night that allows it to be isolated in some silo, which is one of the main reasons why talking about banning it is a waste of time. It's not even possible to make it coherent in theory, let alone in practice.

Also see things like local festivals. We have an arts festival which causes havoc on the local roads. It's annoying but the alternative is to say don't do it, let's all just stay inside.

I think a lot of this has been driven by covid actually.

gabsdot45 · 06/11/2026 13:30

Sale is banned in Ireland, but you wouldn't have thought so last Saturday night. Fireworks were constant all evening. And we had an organized display too so it's not like people weren't going to see fireworks
( We do fireworks for Halloween, we don't have guy Fawkes night)

HappiestSleeping · 06/11/2026 13:17

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 12:58

England is not the world.

True, but many countries have similar.

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 12:58

HappiestSleeping · 06/11/2026 11:59

I find it amazing that we live in a world where a bottle of bleach has to have a label on it saying "do not drink" and yet we sell explosives over the counter.

England is not the world.

HappiestSleeping · 06/11/2026 11:59

I find it amazing that we live in a world where a bottle of bleach has to have a label on it saying "do not drink" and yet we sell explosives over the counter.

TheFlandersPigeon · 06/11/2026 11:56

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 11:43

I agree about Christmas too but unfortunately it’s too big to avoid. I would dearly love to.

Other celebrations don’t impact on people who don’t want to participate but it appears that everyone is forced to be impacted by Halloween and Bonfire Night, whether they want to participate or not.

So even before we have the long run up to bloody Christmas we are forced to be impacted by the disruption of random kids knocking for Halloween (the parents in my area apparently being too stupid to understand not to knock undecorated houses) and arseholes setting off fireworks which cause damage and stress (and even animal deaths) for about three weeks.

The list of celebrations that impact on people who don't want to participate goes well beyond Christmas, Halloween and Bonfire Night. Anything that celebrates a relationship with a loved one can be upsetting for people who don't have that for whatever reason. So that's Mother's, Father's and Valentines Day. And anything where people celebrating causes practical inconvenience to others.

This is quite aside from the normal day to day things that some people enjoy that cause negative impacts on others too. There's just not a way to frame Bonfire Night that allows it to be isolated in some silo, which is one of the main reasons why talking about banning it is a waste of time. It's not even possible to make it coherent in theory, let alone in practice.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 11:54

SiegfriedSassoon · 06/11/2026 09:41

I agree it should be kept to the 5th and/or perhaps the Saturday of that weekend.

But I do think it's incredibly sad there are those on this thread calling for the whole custom to be abolished. I find MN these days generally against so much that is traditional to the British Isles. There are those who seem to be under the impression that it makes them appear superior and educated to sneer at our old customs. When actually it has quite the opposite effect and makes them look ignorant in the extreme.

English people rolling thier eyes about 'outdated' bonfire night while doing performative seal clapping over Diwali or some other celebration that has nothing to do with them, is beneath contempt.

Edited

It’s not about it being traditional. It’s about selfish people taking things too far and dragging it out for weeks, which I think you agree with.

i spend the entire last three months of the year looking forward to January.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 11:43

Leavemetonguetied · 06/11/2026 09:24

You could say the same about Xmas. Yet I have to suffer xmas music for over 2 months every time I want to go into a shop.

Celebrations do impact others. That's part of living in a society rather than an isolated pod.

Edited

I agree about Christmas too but unfortunately it’s too big to avoid. I would dearly love to.

Other celebrations don’t impact on people who don’t want to participate but it appears that everyone is forced to be impacted by Halloween and Bonfire Night, whether they want to participate or not.

So even before we have the long run up to bloody Christmas we are forced to be impacted by the disruption of random kids knocking for Halloween (the parents in my area apparently being too stupid to understand not to knock undecorated houses) and arseholes setting off fireworks which cause damage and stress (and even animal deaths) for about three weeks.

SiegfriedSassoon · 06/11/2026 09:41

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 08:43

If things were kept to one night then it would be less of an issue perhaps.

Peopke can keep traditions alive but it’s when it impacts others that it is unreasonable.

I agree it should be kept to the 5th and/or perhaps the Saturday of that weekend.

But I do think it's incredibly sad there are those on this thread calling for the whole custom to be abolished. I find MN these days generally against so much that is traditional to the British Isles. There are those who seem to be under the impression that it makes them appear superior and educated to sneer at our old customs. When actually it has quite the opposite effect and makes them look ignorant in the extreme.

English people rolling thier eyes about 'outdated' bonfire night while doing performative seal clapping over Diwali or some other celebration that has nothing to do with them, is beneath contempt.

Leavemetonguetied · 06/11/2026 09:24

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 08:43

If things were kept to one night then it would be less of an issue perhaps.

Peopke can keep traditions alive but it’s when it impacts others that it is unreasonable.

You could say the same about Xmas. Yet I have to suffer xmas music for over 2 months every time I want to go into a shop.

Celebrations do impact others. That's part of living in a society rather than an isolated pod.

TheFlandersPigeon · 06/11/2026 09:07

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 08:43

If things were kept to one night then it would be less of an issue perhaps.

Peopke can keep traditions alive but it’s when it impacts others that it is unreasonable.

One day is not very realistic for Bonfire Night. It would have to be at least the weekend before and/or after depending on when the days fall, if we wanted people to actually observe it rather than getting dodgy ones and letting them off in their gardens/local green space.

I'm not necessarily against some compression, but people will need to understand that there'd need to be a lot more fireworks on the designated nights than there are now in order to meet the demand. There would be people who have more fireworks happening near their home than they currently do, or the same amount but in shorter periods of time. That might be preferable to what we've got now, but I don't get the impression most people recommending this have necessarily understood what would happen.

Couching it in an impact on others argument isn't a particularly wise idea either, because then it's inevitably going to become an argument about why some things that do harm to others are left unscathed. Well, it's ok if you're happy to open wider cultural discussions about inessential driving, meat, imported food, pets, flying and all that, but it'd get in the way of attempts to mitigate the more anti-social aspects of fireworks.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 08:43

SiegfriedSassoon · 06/11/2026 07:56

Yes boring and homogeneous. It's like people won't be happy until they have eradicated every quirky, historic, eccentric British tradition. It's really sad.

If things were kept to one night then it would be less of an issue perhaps.

Peopke can keep traditions alive but it’s when it impacts others that it is unreasonable.

Anarchy99 · 06/11/2026 08:38

FriggadyDiggady · 05/11/2026 23:16

More presumption.
Why do you call yourself "Anarchy"?

I don’t. I call myself Anarchy99 which is a reference to a specific thing.

Feel free to explain why I am wrong rather than just having a dig at my name

SiegfriedSassoon · 06/11/2026 07:56

Leavemetonguetied · 06/11/2026 07:45

Have you been to a drone show? They are so dull. They have to be supplemented by very loud musical soundtracks and other tricks like projections onto water fountains to make them vaguely interesting. Not many venues can host a huge water plume to project images where a whole crowd can see. So you're left with some lights in the sky like a neon road sign.

The whole point of the fireworks is to emulate parliament blowing up. The lights and bangs are literally the point of it.

As a country we are becoming so boring!

Yes boring and homogeneous. It's like people won't be happy until they have eradicated every quirky, historic, eccentric British tradition. It's really sad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread