Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.... to not want lunch guests pitching up at 3. Or at least not for actual lunch.

310 replies

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 13:04

Original arrangement was for late lunch. The guests have a toddler who naps late morning, so I'd imagined they wouldn't turn up before 1. More likely 1.30ish. Maybe 2 at the latest.

We planned something that was easy to heat up, rather than a fiddly meal where timings would need to be exact.

I0 minutes ago we got a text saying, the toddler has only just gone for their nap, so they will turn up about 3.

My discussion with partner was that we'd eat the lunch we prepared now, freeze the stuff that the guests would have eaten, and text back saying, 'Oh you're coming for tea then. There'll be some cake.'

What would you do?

OP posts:
Holidaymodeon · 01/11/2026 16:15

‘A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.’

oh my good god.
this sounds like a crappy play.
Get into the real world pronto, you sound like a couple who live above a secondhand bookshop in the league of gentlemen.

Holidaymodeon · 01/11/2026 16:13

This all sounds a bit overwrought. Cba to read the full thread but freezing something and completely withdrawing it from the table seems excessive when you’ve already said 1-2 would have been acceptable, it’s one hour later, not twelve, next time just eat yours earlier and give them theirs when they arrive.

maudelovesharold · 01/11/2026 16:05

I hope you opened the door and greeted them with “You’ll have had your lunch?” (in a Scottish accent) when they arrived!

Whaleandsnail6 · 01/11/2026 16:04

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

But you still could have had the sit down lunch, just later after having a snack to tide you both over.

I don't understand why you have frozen the food and got the hump when a) a time wasn't specified b) you purposely cooked reheatable food and c) it doesn't matter what time you eat if you wanted a sit down meal, have a sit down meal.

Why could you not have had the meal at whatever time they turned up?

BugJuice · 01/11/2026 16:04

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

I’m sorry your husband is upset, but the issue here is that he has built up a big plan in his head without actually communicating it to the others involved in the plan.
Next time ‘lunch will be served at 1.30pm’ would be a good idea.

IndigoBluey · 01/11/2026 16:03

Mooselove · 01/11/2026 15:29

Well it is surprising that anyone would think 3pm is lunchtime!

But a normal lunchtime is 12-2 so a late lunch would be post 2

Thereshewasjustwalkingdownthestreet · 01/11/2026 16:01

If you don’t know when someone is coming, why make a hot meal? Sandwiches would be easier! Sounds like you’ve not thought it through! I’d have replied at this point asking if they want to eat at 3 as you misunderstood and whatever you’re making won’t keep.

MitohMit · 01/11/2026 16:01

Snack now, proper meal when they arrive!

Then, in future, make it clear when you're expecting to see them, hopefully giving them a large window eg 1.30 - 2.30 pm.

Our Sunday lunch is 3pm fyi.

Cosyblankets · 01/11/2026 15:58

130 is not a late lunch. 130 is around lunchtime.

If you'd done something that was easy to heat up what was the issue?

Velumental · 01/11/2026 15:55

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 13:17

Well, the guests still in the 'perfect first baby' stage with a toddler that tends to wake early but nap for an hour at around 11.30. So if we'd said 1, we' d have got into this long, tedious conversation about 'Oh we don't know when toddler will go down for their nap, so it might be 1.30.'

It is my husband's side of the family and he was very keen for there to be a 'proper family meal.' He'd been cooking since 11, so the rhythm of the day was based around the idea that we'd be likely to eat at 1.30 or 2.

A bit of flexibility fine - but I think it's eating too far into the afternoon for lunch esp. at this time of the year, when it's getting dark at 4.

Maybe if it was some really big Christmas lunch thing, where there had been lots of nibbles, snacks etc late morning, but not otherwise.

No chance for walking to the park, playing in the garden etc.

Not the end of the world, but I've been sleeping really badly lately and often fade by mid-afternoon. Not the easiest time for me to exude sociability.

Shall let husband deal with the guests for the most part, I think.

It sounds like you have children? Do you? If so you'll know some babies won't nap away from home? Then the day is ruined for their family. And their night sleep. I had bad sleepers and I literally wouldn't jeopardize their sleep for anything. Mine are 5 and 8 now so not an issue at this point. However id be very sympathetic to this. One of mine slept great on the go so was easy to transport the other a nightmare for day sleep and more dependant on their nap.

MrsBananaman · 01/11/2026 15:54

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

Can you not see that it is unreasonable to expect DH’s relatives to meet his expectations when they haven’t been properly communicated? This sounds like he has a vision in his head and you didn’t manage anyone’s expectations. It also sounds like a lot of “in my day” when actually if you want to spend time with younger relatives you probably need to accept that things aren’t done the same and other families have their own priorities.

And it’s still unreasonable to expect them to work to his schedule when he/you won’t do the same for their child.

ratatouillemousesqueak · 01/11/2026 15:49

I think OPs response is rude when a time wasn’t agreed! Fair enough if they’d agreed 1-2 ish.

i wouldn’t mind delaying until 3 especially as it’s an easy heat up. I’d probably need a snack to keep me going though. But I do get annoyed with parents who think everything should revolve around their preferences and time scales. That’s why agreed times are best.

FancyKitten · 01/11/2026 15:46

1.30 / 2pm are lunchtime. 3pm is late lunch, I think that’s fine? Where I live, it would be.

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

OP posts:
Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 15:43

Mooselove · 01/11/2026 15:29

Well it is surprising that anyone would think 3pm is lunchtime!

The majority of this thread think 3pm falls into the “late lunch” bracket.

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 01/11/2026 15:42

Mooselove · 01/11/2026 15:29

Well it is surprising that anyone would think 3pm is lunchtime!

Is it?

Livpool · 01/11/2026 15:39

GrapeBaby · 01/11/2026 13:37

Or seeing as the OP actually issued an invitation to ‘late lunch’ without specifying a time, and said they would work around the toddler’s nap, the hosts suck it up for once, have a snack and eat with their guests, rather than saying ‘Oh, you’re too late for lunch, have a piece of cake’?

I know - so rude of OP. Very churlish to say you are too late for the LATE lunch - when we didn’t specify the time. They will end up with a detention!

Holiday24 · 01/11/2026 15:38

I don't think 3pm is unreasonable, as they had specified a "late lunch".

BugJuice · 01/11/2026 15:38

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 15:20

Not the end of the world, but I've been sleeping really badly lately and often fade by mid-afternoon. Not the easiest time for me to exude sociability.

OP is grouchy and anti social because she didn’t get enough sleep but would expect more from a toddler.

Exactly this! Sometimes people expect more from toddlers than from themselves/other adults.

BugJuice · 01/11/2026 15:37

Mooselove · 01/11/2026 15:29

Well it is surprising that anyone would think 3pm is lunchtime!

I’d think 3pm was ‘late lunch’ time, which is what the OP told them. Well I actually grew up in Spain so it would be bang in the middle of lunchtime for me (usually 2-4pm), but now I’m in England it would be very much ‘late lunch’.

Whaleandsnail6 · 01/11/2026 15:32

I genuinely don't understand your problem. You were going to reheat the food anyway, and to me 2-3 is late lunch time. Don't see why you couldn't serve the food whatever time they turned up.

You're clearly put out and wanting to punish your guests for not sticking to your imaginary and not-shared with them timescales

Mooselove · 01/11/2026 15:29

BitOutOfPractice · 01/11/2026 13:06

so neither of you said an actual time? Not surprising then really.

Well it is surprising that anyone would think 3pm is lunchtime!

MrsBananaman · 01/11/2026 15:25

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 15:20

Not the end of the world, but I've been sleeping really badly lately and often fade by mid-afternoon. Not the easiest time for me to exude sociability.

OP is grouchy and anti social because she didn’t get enough sleep but would expect more from a toddler.

This! And if you start to flag in the afternoon, why invite people for lunch? Presumably they’d have stuck around for a bit of socialising after. Or Was it literally lunch at 1.30 leave by 2.30?

IamnotSethRogan · 01/11/2026 15:24

Is it like a sunday lunch ? Because 3 pm is a completely reasonable time for sunday lunch so if it was all a bit vague I can see why they think that isn't unreasonable.

CatA27 · 01/11/2026 15:21

If you arranged for late lunch and didnt agree a specific time then 3pm is exactly that, if you are annoyed then thats on you for not agreeing with your guests what time you'd be serving lunch 🤷‍♀️