Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.... to not want lunch guests pitching up at 3. Or at least not for actual lunch.

310 replies

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 13:04

Original arrangement was for late lunch. The guests have a toddler who naps late morning, so I'd imagined they wouldn't turn up before 1. More likely 1.30ish. Maybe 2 at the latest.

We planned something that was easy to heat up, rather than a fiddly meal where timings would need to be exact.

I0 minutes ago we got a text saying, the toddler has only just gone for their nap, so they will turn up about 3.

My discussion with partner was that we'd eat the lunch we prepared now, freeze the stuff that the guests would have eaten, and text back saying, 'Oh you're coming for tea then. There'll be some cake.'

What would you do?

OP posts:
RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:26

CaptainCalm · 01/11/2026 17:23

I’m sorry that the relative has upset your DH. It can be disheartening to out lots of effort into something only to realise that it won’t go as planned, or that other people don’t value your effort and time as you do.

Given the timing of the last message they’ll arrive around 4pm which is late and rude even for a ‘late lunch’ and having a toddler is no excuse for this.

I do think next time having a confirmed time would help (I appreciate they don’t like times but in the real world this is what people do) and perhaps it’s simpler to lower your effort to match their lack of concern. Then your DH will be less hurt and less time wasted

What a strange response.

The OP says "they will turn up about 3".

Why are you trying to make out they'll arrive at 4?

CaptainCalm · 01/11/2026 17:23

I’m sorry that the relative has upset your DH. It can be disheartening to out lots of effort into something only to realise that it won’t go as planned, or that other people don’t value your effort and time as you do.

Given the timing of the last message they’ll arrive around 4pm which is late and rude even for a ‘late lunch’ and having a toddler is no excuse for this.

I do think next time having a confirmed time would help (I appreciate they don’t like times but in the real world this is what people do) and perhaps it’s simpler to lower your effort to match their lack of concern. Then your DH will be less hurt and less time wasted

MagneticSquirrel · 01/11/2026 17:20

Normal lunchtime on a Sunday 12-2pm to eat. Although 12 is early.

Late lunch = 2-3:30pm - 1:30pm would be early for a late lunch. But to me late lunch normally means having 1 big afternoon meal and no further food that day unless starving in the evening.

JustSawJohnny · 01/11/2026 17:19

The concept of lunch being at the latest 1pm would not fly in our house, I can tell you that for certain! A 3pm lunch would suit me perfectly most days.

Not everyone runs on an 8am/12pm/5pm food schedule, OP.

Maybe you shouldn't have given the impression you were flexible on times when in reality you weren't?

Eating the food then immediately freezing the rest was petty, IMO.

I do think your reply was a bit rude, too.

If I were your guests, I'm not sure I'd want to visit again.

BillieWiper · 01/11/2026 17:19

On Sundays lunch is the only meal and it happens at any point from 1pm to 9pm! That's just in my family.
I wouldn't pack away the cooked food and deny my friends a meal, that seems petty. Just reheat it. To me eating at 3 is perfectly civilized.

RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:16

Gwenhwyfar · 01/11/2026 14:28

If I couldn't wait till 3 I'd eat first then heat up the guests' portions when they arrive. 3pm isn't normal lunchtime, but it fits into 'late' lunch.

But why wouldn't you be able to wait?

What's going to happen? You feel a bit hungry?

Just wait.

Goldenbear · 01/11/2026 17:13

Tbh we are free spirits in my family and don't even have set lunchtimes, dinner times, breakfast. I wouldn't even bother trying to organise such a thing with extended family, too stressful for them.

nevernotmaybe · 01/11/2026 17:09

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 13:17

Well, the guests still in the 'perfect first baby' stage with a toddler that tends to wake early but nap for an hour at around 11.30. So if we'd said 1, we' d have got into this long, tedious conversation about 'Oh we don't know when toddler will go down for their nap, so it might be 1.30.'

It is my husband's side of the family and he was very keen for there to be a 'proper family meal.' He'd been cooking since 11, so the rhythm of the day was based around the idea that we'd be likely to eat at 1.30 or 2.

A bit of flexibility fine - but I think it's eating too far into the afternoon for lunch esp. at this time of the year, when it's getting dark at 4.

Maybe if it was some really big Christmas lunch thing, where there had been lots of nibbles, snacks etc late morning, but not otherwise.

No chance for walking to the park, playing in the garden etc.

Not the end of the world, but I've been sleeping really badly lately and often fade by mid-afternoon. Not the easiest time for me to exude sociability.

Shall let husband deal with the guests for the most part, I think.

The plan was for a late lunch, still well within the normal time for lunch that is between 12 and 2?

SP2024 · 01/11/2026 17:08

Sunday late lunch 3pm is still very much within those boundaries. Also toddlers tend to nap between 12.30-2.30pm depending on how old they are. Mine never got up earlier than 2.30pm but might have gone down a bit later as they got older. Otherwise they have a very short window after getting up and a very long window until bedtime. And then have to get to you. We often ate at family about 3pm when the kids were little. It doesn’t last long.

FiveEightNine · 01/11/2026 17:04

Your language is rather dismissive - placate?

With a young baby, the arrangement of "late lunch" without specifying the time would sound to me exactly as "after the nap, no need to aim for a specific hour.

He needs to manage his own expectations first, as 1pm just isn't a "late lunch", so the plan was doomed from the beginning.

GoodGirlFaith · 01/11/2026 17:02

Roast is very easy to keep warm. Wouldn’t bother me in the slightest especially family with young children.

Username19893847477374 · 01/11/2026 17:02

I agree with everyone else, too much drama from you. The pass agg "oh you're coming for tea" comment is just completely unnecessary. Get a grip

Goodwitchglenda · 01/11/2026 17:00

Holidaymodeon · 01/11/2026 16:15

‘A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.’

oh my good god.
this sounds like a crappy play.
Get into the real world pronto, you sound like a couple who live above a secondhand bookshop in the league of gentlemen.

It is all a bit mad, isn’t it? They sound control freaky/a bit batty. Freezing food you’ve cooked for a relative because they are an hour late is not normal behaviour.

Createausername1970 · 01/11/2026 16:48

The problem is that your DH is trying to achieve the unachievable.

If this relative already objects to being pinned down to timings, then not even having any timings was never going to work out for DH.

I understand where he is coming from and why family traditions are important, but tradition sometimes have to evolve or die. So as you say, do something more flexible next time that doesn't involve a lot of cooking.

VanquishedColston · 01/11/2026 16:46

So no much drama and musing over nothing.

I doubt your husband is hugely upset by this change, yes it's annoying but you all should have specified a time. "Late lunch" to me is 2 at least...1/1.30 is just lunch.

islingtontrial · 01/11/2026 16:44

I don't know why, but 2.30 is standard for Sunday lunch with people I know so 3 would be completely reasonable as a late lunch.

thestudio · 01/11/2026 16:37

As lots have said - your DH might just have to accept that there is never going to be a replay of his family's historic Sunday lunches.

If his sibling/relative has always been bad with and resentful of attempts to make them punctual, they probably have ADHD.

No excuse - the relative sounds like a massive PITA either way, and maybe it's not ADHD but massive selfishness (though the resentment sounds like ADHD to me, based on experience - you know you're either going to fail or the pressure will be properly stressful. Again, no excuse, just reality.)

So if he wants to have a nostalgice family meal (which i completely understand) he's going to have to factor that in. Do something which can be reheated (as it sounds like he's already done) and enjoy the fact that the pressure is off to have a picture perfect Sunday lunch. Lean into going with the flow, tell himself that being a good host is having the confidence to do so, and pat himself on the back for giving sibling what they actually will appreciate (while you fume in the background Wink)

Kez145 · 01/11/2026 16:36

3pm would be a late lunch in my eyes so perhaps that’s where the confusion lies.

localnotail · 01/11/2026 16:31

I hate it when people say "lunch time" "tea time" "midday" - ffs, just say what time??

RelievedNoYouTubeMum · 01/11/2026 16:29

Agreed this is a whole load of drama.

why does it matter that your husband is pre diabetic? You just say we’ll be sitting down to eat at x time. If they are late they either get cold or reheated food and don’t get another invite.

catabhaile · 01/11/2026 16:29

I think if you agree on a late lunch on a Sunday but not on an actual time then 3pm sounds fine to me

WhatNoRaisins · 01/11/2026 16:28

It doesn't sound like a sit down lunch will work well with this family member. Would your DH be open to something more casual like a drop in with snacks available? Is there someone else who might be a better bet for a meal at a set time?

Chickpeacurrywithrice · 01/11/2026 16:25

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

They’re an hour later for lunch, such high drama!!

Piche · 01/11/2026 16:19

OP, if you wanted them there at 1.30 you needed to tell them that. If they didn’t want to be pinned down to a time they could have then communicated that. But this one is on you. You didn’t seem to set a specific time (just organised a late lunch) but are resentful because their understanding of that doesn’t match what’s in your head.

Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 16:16

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

Prediabetic is really no need for him to only eat lunch at 1pm.
Your husband is being overly rigid conflating past happy memories of lunches to mean a strict start time of 1pm.