Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.... to not want lunch guests pitching up at 3. Or at least not for actual lunch.

310 replies

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 13:04

Original arrangement was for late lunch. The guests have a toddler who naps late morning, so I'd imagined they wouldn't turn up before 1. More likely 1.30ish. Maybe 2 at the latest.

We planned something that was easy to heat up, rather than a fiddly meal where timings would need to be exact.

I0 minutes ago we got a text saying, the toddler has only just gone for their nap, so they will turn up about 3.

My discussion with partner was that we'd eat the lunch we prepared now, freeze the stuff that the guests would have eaten, and text back saying, 'Oh you're coming for tea then. There'll be some cake.'

What would you do?

OP posts:
thisismeithinkorisit · 01/11/2026 18:29

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 13:17

Well, the guests still in the 'perfect first baby' stage with a toddler that tends to wake early but nap for an hour at around 11.30. So if we'd said 1, we' d have got into this long, tedious conversation about 'Oh we don't know when toddler will go down for their nap, so it might be 1.30.'

It is my husband's side of the family and he was very keen for there to be a 'proper family meal.' He'd been cooking since 11, so the rhythm of the day was based around the idea that we'd be likely to eat at 1.30 or 2.

A bit of flexibility fine - but I think it's eating too far into the afternoon for lunch esp. at this time of the year, when it's getting dark at 4.

Maybe if it was some really big Christmas lunch thing, where there had been lots of nibbles, snacks etc late morning, but not otherwise.

No chance for walking to the park, playing in the garden etc.

Not the end of the world, but I've been sleeping really badly lately and often fade by mid-afternoon. Not the easiest time for me to exude sociability.

Shall let husband deal with the guests for the most part, I think.

so he's been cooking for 2 hours or he prepped something easy that could be warmed up?

I think given you didn't specify a time and late lunch is later than 1.30, I'd be gracious and just heat it up before they get there / once they're there. does it really matter that the meal is called?

I would ask given the time if they were going to eat, but in a "food is prepped but if you need to eat before you get here I understand and I'll sort dessert instead" rather than "well then we shall not let you eat our food!"

Woollyguru · 01/11/2026 18:27

Why didn't you agree an actual time! How bizarre to leave it vague and then get miffed about timings!

UniDaysAcoming · 01/11/2026 18:26

Hope you had a nice time @AlteFrau and it all worked out after all!
Your DH wants to make nice memories... don't resent them, go with the flow so there's no stress on either side and he successfully makes happy innter-generational memories.
He anyway cooked something that can be heated up. Hopefully he ate some on time for his health and had some too when the guests came!

Givemeausernamepls · 01/11/2026 18:21

I mean assuming I actually liked them and wanted to see them (and you never know with Mumsnet). I’d say, lovely see you when you get here.

Leopardspota · 01/11/2026 18:19

‘“Late lunch’ to me is between 2-3.30… anything before that is normal lunchtime, after that is early tea/tea time on a Sunday …

NeedSomeHeadspace · 01/11/2026 18:16

Do they expect you to go hungry and wait for them till 3pm? I would do soup and ovenbaked bread, and a lasagne. Then it’s there, you can easily keep it warm/re-heat and plate when they get there.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 01/11/2026 18:13

MandemChickenShop · 01/11/2026 18:04

it's one Sunday. does it really matter? why worry, just eat something or don't. there's enough real problems in the world that you don't need to turn this into another one.

Well, that's not patronizing, is it?
🙄

JustSawJohnny · 01/11/2026 18:12

RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:26

What a strange response.

The OP says "they will turn up about 3".

Why are you trying to make out they'll arrive at 4?

Plus Op stated they'd purposefully made something 'easy to reheat' so they were absolutely capable of reheating it at 3.

They froze the extra portions just so they could refuse food because they were salty about waiting.

So, SO petty and utterly devoid of the empathy they were trying to show by agreeing to the visit happening post-nap in the first place.

MandemChickenShop · 01/11/2026 18:04

it's one Sunday. does it really matter? why worry, just eat something or don't. there's enough real problems in the world that you don't need to turn this into another one.

Gwenhwyfar · 01/11/2026 18:04

RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:16

But why wouldn't you be able to wait?

What's going to happen? You feel a bit hungry?

Just wait.

I don't have breakfast so 3pm is a bit late for me for lunch.
Personally, I probably would wait in this scenario, my comment was about OP's situation where she apparently couldn't wait. In that situation, I'd eat my lunch at my preferred time and then have something small with the guests when they arrive.

Soontobe60 · 01/11/2026 18:04

If we were having Sunday lunch either at home or in a restaurant we would usually eat late afternoon to be fair. That being said, if I’d invited someone over I’d have clarified the timings beforehand and not just assumed!

Bah11 · 01/11/2026 18:02

3pm would be a normal time for late lunch in my family/friends. Anytime between 12-2 is a normal lunch. So later that 2 is a late lunch, probably up to 3:30-4pm would be a normal late lunch, particularly on a Sunday.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 01/11/2026 17:58

You really fo need to agree on a time and say "okay we're cooking and lunch will be ready at 1pm. If your day is going sideways give us a call to reschedule."

Since they always run late, actually plan food to be ready a bit later so you have a cushion.
Just reschedule, buy perhaps don't plan with them. Their priorities are different and now it's even more difficult to schedule with them.

Rabbitinahabit · 01/11/2026 17:47

This is all just very strange. Guests were not given a time. OP seems like she doesn't want them there into the evening so withdraws lunch invite and gives them a cup of tea so they will go on their merry way quicker. She also gets to freeze the food they would have eaten rather than ask them if they would like it when they arrive. Just mental carry on.

CuteHANDBAG · 01/11/2026 17:46

I think you and your DH have been a little unreasonable. You know the guests are known for being late and you know they have a little kids so it was a bit daft to expect them to suddenly mend their ways and pitch up on time.

You guests are obviously rude and daft to except the invite with a definite yes.

BugJuice · 01/11/2026 17:40

InLawTwats · 01/11/2026 17:34

I’ve rarely eaten at all before 3pm and am amazed at how people expect such rigidity around when meals are eaten. It’s a very weird thing concept. Why would everyone be hungry at the exact same time of day?!

Agreed. I eat when I’m hungry/when I’m not busy doing something else. Some days lunch will be at 1, some days at 4. Sometimes dinner will be at 6, sometimes at 9. I can’t personally imagine being so rigid about mealtimes… if you are busy/out doing something at 1pm would you immediately stop doing it/go and get lunch just because it’s lunch time?
If the OP and her husband wanted to serve the meal at a particular time, they should have actually told the guest that time, instead of expecting them to mind read.

InLawTwats · 01/11/2026 17:34

RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:31

3pm isn't lunch in anyone's book.

It is for many people on this thread, especially "late lunch" and especially on a Sunday.

I’ve rarely eaten at all before 3pm and am amazed at how people expect such rigidity around when meals are eaten. It’s a very weird thing concept. Why would everyone be hungry at the exact same time of day?!

Fast800goingforit · 01/11/2026 17:31

BitOutOfPractice · 01/11/2026 13:06

so neither of you said an actual time? Not surprising then really.

I agree. You should have set a time. If they hadn't arrived by then you should have just gone ahead.

RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:31

AmnesiacDream · 01/11/2026 17:29

I think your message is fine. 3pm isn't lunch in anyone's book. But you should also be prepared for them to cancel or be even later because they have to eat.

The real issue was trying to get them to commit to lunch when, it sounds, you knew the toddler's nap would disrupt timings. Your DH really wanting them to come to you and have a sit down lunch when you live so far away and they have a toddler lacked consideration for their situation. Would the toddler really have wanted a sit down lunch anyway?

Go to them and take them out for lunch next time if a sit down lunch is pinnacle of family connection for DH.

3pm isn't lunch in anyone's book.

It is for many people on this thread, especially "late lunch" and especially on a Sunday.

InLawTwats · 01/11/2026 17:30

Mooselove · 01/11/2026 15:29

Well it is surprising that anyone would think 3pm is lunchtime!

Really?! I’ve rarely eaten anything at all before then so wouldn’t bat an eye. Even as a small child my DD ate her packed lunch after school (3:30pm).

even if you think lunch happens between 12 and 2pm, OP agreed to a late lunch, so 3pm should be fine, no?

RikthePoet · 01/11/2026 17:30

CaptainCalm · 01/11/2026 17:29

@RikthePoet at 3.45 ish she wrote “Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way.” So I’ve assumed 4pm, of course it could be later or a bit earlier

Why is my response strange?

Sorry, I misread the follow-up message.

AmnesiacDream · 01/11/2026 17:29

AlteFrau · 01/11/2026 15:44

I think the issue is partly with my husband who wishes to placate his relative who was a notoriously bad timekeeper even before they became a parent. Requests to come for a particular time never worked. There would be a vague resentment about being pinned down. They'd turn up significantly later or there'd be a series of messages about a change of plan.

But my husband also really really wanted a sitdown family lunch. In his wider family, this always used to be around 1 - not mid-afternoon - and there are a lot of happy memories of cross-generational meals.

I think over the last few decades there has been a shift towards everything being much more informal - microwaves make it easier to heat something up. But I think something has been lost

My husband is older and he is prediabetic. Obviously he can keep himself going with snacks. He is disappointed because he would so much like his relative - who is of a younger generation - to be better at juggling different needs.

A toddler is a priority, but it is useful to be able to think about others too, and try and balance things.

I feel a bit sad for my husband because what is happening is so different from what is in his head. A bit like the woman who has planned the perfect Xmas and then there are hitches.

Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way. It is going to be afteroon tea.

We will probably stick to more casual teas, coffee etc for the time being. As Mumsnet sometimes likes to say, 'Our house. Our rules.'

I think your message is fine. 3pm isn't lunch in anyone's book. But you should also be prepared for them to cancel or be even later because they have to eat.

The real issue was trying to get them to commit to lunch when, it sounds, you knew the toddler's nap would disrupt timings. Your DH really wanting them to come to you and have a sit down lunch when you live so far away and they have a toddler lacked consideration for their situation. Would the toddler really have wanted a sit down lunch anyway?

Go to them and take them out for lunch next time if a sit down lunch is pinnacle of family connection for DH.

CaptainCalm · 01/11/2026 17:29

@RikthePoet at 3.45 ish she wrote “Relative has just messaged to say they are on the way.” So I’ve assumed 4pm, of course it could be later or a bit earlier

Why is my response strange?

Notonthestairs · 01/11/2026 17:27

You are not being flexible by not stipulating lunchtime but also having a secret deadline.

You are setting everyone up to fail.

State when you want to eat.

If the timing doesn't work then the lunches don't happen.

CharlieEffie · 01/11/2026 17:27

Wild your annoyed with their timings when you never actually specified a time that lunch would be ready??