I'm in my 60's and I am a senior manager. At 40 I was reasonably high up the chain and constantly found people I was training were on more than me simply because they had a degree. And I ran rings around them.
So at 40 I went to Uni, I held down a full time job at the same time as doing a full time Uni degree course because the Uni worked with me and allowed me to do a mixture of daytime and evening lectures. I got a good degree and somehow still didn't get the same pay as my colleagues, as my bosses said it was post qualifying experience that counted even though I had worked my way through the ranks and had been doing the job for years. And apparently, I was good enough to be selected instead of someone with a degree, to train the university graduates that were coming in.
Being academically bright should not be confused with possessing the practical skills needed to apply that knowledge effectively in real-world situations.
My husband is a senior engineer and recruits staff with degrees at various stages of their career and they go for graduates as it evidences they have the ability to learn to the standard required for continual development. But he says some of his best performers are those that came up through the ranks, who have no academic qualifications but are fantastic hands on.
I used to work for a company and we had a marketing manager, he was terrible, he could talk the talk but not walk the walk, he didn't have the practical skill set needed to put his knowledge into effect He got sacked. So imagine my surprise when I finally got to Uni myself and walked into the marketing module and found our old marketing manager - and he rocked it. He was a great academic conversationalist, very thought provoking and he knew his stuff, but he just couldn't bring what was needed to the table in the real world. He found his niche and I totally revised my opinion of him.
True geniuses maybe rare but not everyone has to have a degree to succeed - Just look at Richard Branson (Virgin Group), Steve Jobs (Apple), John Caudwell (Phones 4u), Deborah Meaden (Dragons' Den, Weststar Holidays), & Lord Alan Sugar (Amstrad). Many of these left school at 16. They all rose above the norm. If intelligence were measured only by exams, we'd have to conclude that the most academically gifted people are always the most effective people, and real life clearly shows that isn't true.
Exams often fail to capture other forms of intelligence and competence, such as:
Practical problem-solving, emotional intelligence, social awareness, creativity and innovation, leadership, adaptability, common sense and judgement, mechanical or spatial aptitude. So given that, how do you suppose we assess that type of intelligence? The difficulty isn't that exams are worthless. It's that many people mistake one form of intelligence for the whole of intelligence.