Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 09:26

fairiesinthegarden1 · 29/10/2026 09:17

You’re essentially saying ‘why do we attach moral significance to their role’? I’m telling you why it is important to value them rather than extracting more money from them.

I'm not asking that. I'm saying that I'm seeing it used against people who are lower earning, as if earning more money somehow makes you a better person. But there are plenty on low wages who contribute to society in non-monetary ways. As I said upthread, it takes all sorts and we need both. Thanks for coming in to remind everyone of how valuable and amazing high earners are though, great contribution

OP posts:
fairiesinthegarden1 · 29/10/2026 09:17

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 09:07

Can you tell me where I said we don't need them or that we should tax them to death?

You’re essentially saying ‘why do we attach moral significance to their role’? I’m telling you why it is important to value them rather than extracting more money from them.

fieldofdoom · 29/10/2026 09:17

20 years of a state pension is now 250k, to pay that in tax means earning 55k ish for 20 years. We know that the majority don’t earn that or for that long and thats before you factor in the cost of healthcare which again increases significantly as you age & education costs. And yet people are surprised we have a high % of net takers.

fairiesinthegarden1 · 29/10/2026 09:15

randomchap · 29/10/2026 09:03

Society could not function without the lower paid workers too.

No one is disputing that?

Jellycatspyjamas · 29/10/2026 09:15

But then again, this post is a good illustration of why this country is a mess. Apparently these warm and fuzzy contributions which are not based on monetary value a good substitute for net contributing taxes. Who knew.

Except in the real world, the person caring for their loved one at home is saving untold amounts in formal care fees, often sacrifice their earning power to do so. The person working with disabled kids in school, being paid a pittance, enables the child to learn and gives parents the opportunity to work or simply to continue caring.

The person volunteering with cubs, or scouts or whatever enables that provision to continue which gives kids meaningful activity and social engagement making it less likely they’ll end up engaged in offending behaviour - which costs society a huge amount of money.

Yes, the books need to balance, but these “nice to haves, are provided from the contribution of people who may not have much to contribute in cold, hard cash but which saves society millions.

fieldofdoom · 29/10/2026 09:10

It’s also inevitable with an ageing population that that amount of net contributors decreases but many seem to overlook this.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 09:07

fairiesinthegarden1 · 29/10/2026 09:00

Society cannot function without net contributors. All of the things you mention cannot be financed without net contributors. If we tax them to death and drive high earners to become less productive we all lose. I think many people haven’t the foggiest idea how many hours are worked by many of those in this bracket and the stress they take on. If it is made less appealing then they won’t do it, tax receipts will fall and those enjoying their less stressful 9-5s with every evening off may find they have to work more!

Can you tell me where I said we don't need them or that we should tax them to death?

OP posts:
Thosestupidpopups · 29/10/2026 09:07

It attempts to place a notional, largely finctional financial value on people and completely disregards the non-financial contributions to society that individuals make. How is it possible to put a financial value on the work done by teachers, nurses, volunteers, carers or the low-paid workers without whom society would quickly cease to function?

This is spot on.

randomchap · 29/10/2026 09:03

fairiesinthegarden1 · 29/10/2026 09:00

Society cannot function without net contributors. All of the things you mention cannot be financed without net contributors. If we tax them to death and drive high earners to become less productive we all lose. I think many people haven’t the foggiest idea how many hours are worked by many of those in this bracket and the stress they take on. If it is made less appealing then they won’t do it, tax receipts will fall and those enjoying their less stressful 9-5s with every evening off may find they have to work more!

Society could not function without the lower paid workers too.

MidlifeMiseryGuts · 29/10/2026 09:00

Yes I hate it. I will never be a “net contributor”. I’ve never claimed benefits but I was born at 29 weeks and spend three months in NICU in an incubator and then had three major abdominal surgeries before I was age 5. I could be a hedge fund boss and probably still never pay back what I’ve taken out. It’s such a selfish and naive way to look at a social contract.

Thosestupidpopups · 29/10/2026 09:00

latetothefisting · 29/10/2026 08:45

Okay.....but when are people bringing the phrase up in a conversation that's NOT about economics?

It's not like Nigella is reviewing someone's cake on bake off and drops it into the conversation. Or you see on here "aibu to leave my DH, he's an absolute arsehole to me at the kids but he is a net contributor"?

I've only ever heard it in the context of finance/economics which by your own 'rule' is fine! So where else are you seeing it so often that its annoying you?

Well for me it’s the tone of how they’re using it in the context of these discussions.

They kind of attach a moral judgment to it like net contributor - good, superior and useful to society. Not a net contributor - bit iffy, not so useful. When really there’s a bit more nuance to it even economically speaking.

I will leave it there as I was going to go into more detail but pps have already went through this. For example the post above by @Havanananana explains it well.

fairiesinthegarden1 · 29/10/2026 09:00

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

Society cannot function without net contributors. All of the things you mention cannot be financed without net contributors. If we tax them to death and drive high earners to become less productive we all lose. I think many people haven’t the foggiest idea how many hours are worked by many of those in this bracket and the stress they take on. If it is made less appealing then they won’t do it, tax receipts will fall and those enjoying their less stressful 9-5s with every evening off may find they have to work more!

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 08:57

latetothefisting · 29/10/2026 08:45

Okay.....but when are people bringing the phrase up in a conversation that's NOT about economics?

It's not like Nigella is reviewing someone's cake on bake off and drops it into the conversation. Or you see on here "aibu to leave my DH, he's an absolute arsehole to me at the kids but he is a net contributor"?

I've only ever heard it in the context of finance/economics which by your own 'rule' is fine! So where else are you seeing it so often that its annoying you?

Plenty of people on this thread have said they've seen it all over MN/given examples, so I'd suggest reading the thread

OP posts:
Havanananana · 29/10/2026 08:56

"One reason that I dislike the concept is that it disregards the value of a person’s work and focuses solely on income tax."

It is a flawed concept, used by some in political discussions to divide people into "net contributors" and "benefit scroungers." It attempts to place a notional, largely finctional financial value on people and completely disregards the non-financial contributions to society that individuals make. How is it possible to put a financial value on the work done by teachers, nurses, volunteers, carers or the low-paid workers without whom society would quickly cease to function?

It ignores all of the other taxes and duties that people directly pay - e.g. VAT and alcohol duty - and the taxes collected from the income generated through the work that people undertake, i.e. the Corporation Tax paid by companies on the profits that they earn.

It also ignores the fact that from birth to death, people go through various stages of "contributing" and "benefitting." For the first 18 years of their lives people are benefitting from schooling, healthcare, public services and so on but are not contributing. For 50 years from the age of 18 they will be part of the pool that is mainly contributing, but there might be periods, for example when they are sick, unemployed or otherwise not working, when they temporarily "benefit" more than they "contribute." From retirement age onwards people might not financially be "net contributors" but the grandparents that look after grandchildren are contributing to society, and the people going about their daily business are driving on roads built by the previous generations, working in factories, hospitals, schools and offices built by the previous generations and benefitting from public services set up by the previous generations.

latetothefisting · 29/10/2026 08:45

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:59

In the first line of my post I said there's a time and place for this phrase. Conversations about economics is an example of that. Don't be so obtuse.

Okay.....but when are people bringing the phrase up in a conversation that's NOT about economics?

It's not like Nigella is reviewing someone's cake on bake off and drops it into the conversation. Or you see on here "aibu to leave my DH, he's an absolute arsehole to me at the kids but he is a net contributor"?

I've only ever heard it in the context of finance/economics which by your own 'rule' is fine! So where else are you seeing it so often that its annoying you?

Lemieux7 · 29/10/2026 08:38

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 00:04

Now back in the real world, here is how it goes.

No there are not so many ways to contribute. Ultimately everything costs money and someone has to pay for stuff. It doesn’t grow on trees and can’t be had for free.

So you being fed up doesn’t change reality. Net contributors pay for the nice things you want. Unless you can convince everyone to work for free and give you these things for free.

But then again, this post is a good illustration of why this country is a mess. Apparently these warm and fuzzy contributions which are not based on monetary value a good substitute for net contributing taxes. Who knew.

So, what are you saying? That everyone should give up jobs like nursing? Then you’d be screwed…

Flawed logic at its finest. If some people didn’t earn less, people like you wouldn’t be patting yourself on the back.

MJagain · 29/10/2026 08:19

MadameMaxGoesler · 28/10/2026 19:53

For reference, the (individual not household) income required to be a net contributor is £42,600.

Edited

Surely this depends on what you take out ?

chosen using state schools, chronic illnesses managed by NHS etc.

glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 07:30

Lurkingandlearning · 29/10/2026 02:15

I thought OPs point was that economics should be a tool used to benefit humans rather than humans being grist for the economic wheel.

What a great way to put it, thank you

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 29/10/2026 07:28

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 00:04

Now back in the real world, here is how it goes.

No there are not so many ways to contribute. Ultimately everything costs money and someone has to pay for stuff. It doesn’t grow on trees and can’t be had for free.

So you being fed up doesn’t change reality. Net contributors pay for the nice things you want. Unless you can convince everyone to work for free and give you these things for free.

But then again, this post is a good illustration of why this country is a mess. Apparently these warm and fuzzy contributions which are not based on monetary value a good substitute for net contributing taxes. Who knew.

Yikes

OP posts:
Lurkingandlearning · 29/10/2026 02:15

AralVorkosigan · 28/10/2026 18:51

Right. So what do you want? In conversations about economics do you want us to refer to “Net Contributors In A Strictly Financial Sense With No Judgments Implied On Their Overall Value To Society Relative To Others”? Or do you want the general public and politicians to just be able to have conversations about finance and assume people understand that we’re talking about finance?

I thought OPs point was that economics should be a tool used to benefit humans rather than humans being grist for the economic wheel.

SpiritAdder · 29/10/2026 02:04

I agree and it is never mentioned that every individual will spend much of their life not being a “net contributor”

Generally the first 20yrs and last 20yrs of life most people are not net contributers.

For many they will pass in and out of net contributor status during their working adult years depending upon the ups and downs of life.

The way it is talked about is very much an us versus them and never would one ever become the other.

echt · 29/10/2026 01:47

ProtestantTraybakeQueen · 28/10/2026 23:03

Wow how many times are you hearing the phrase? And how many of those times are in conversations not about the economy (the time and the place)? I barely ever hear the phrase personally so am not sick of it.

Edited

It’s used on MN as a rhetorical bludgeon by a certain kind of poster. It has a Gotcha! ring to it. It’s often paired up with “hard-working”, when how hard someone works can have zero to do with their income. I haven’t seen it around much lately.

Thank fuck.

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 00:09

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 21:47

I haven't assumed, it's how I (and others on this thread) have seen other people use it, particularly here on MN

What? So you don’t like facts?

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 00:05

nomas · 28/10/2026 23:11

I think the phrase is needed.

There is a thread by a pregnant OP who thinks she should be able to claim PIP because she has undiagnosed anxiety and wants to be a SAHM for her two kids because she has worked for a few years and paid tax.

She really seems to think she should be getting back in benefits what she has put into the system.

You’re kidding, right? So it’s basically a rant by someone who wants benefits.

WarmHiker · 29/10/2026 00:04

Now back in the real world, here is how it goes.

No there are not so many ways to contribute. Ultimately everything costs money and someone has to pay for stuff. It doesn’t grow on trees and can’t be had for free.

So you being fed up doesn’t change reality. Net contributors pay for the nice things you want. Unless you can convince everyone to work for free and give you these things for free.

But then again, this post is a good illustration of why this country is a mess. Apparently these warm and fuzzy contributions which are not based on monetary value a good substitute for net contributing taxes. Who knew.