Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up of the phrase 'net contributor'

246 replies

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 18:30

Obviously there is a time and place for this phrase because we need to have a realistic financial plan and a functioning economy.

But society is more than just money. And I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

There are so many ways to contribute. The people who look after our small children, teaching assistants and 1 to 1s who look after SEN children, many healthcare workers, the people who care for our elderly, they all get paid a pittance but that work is so valuable to our society.

We're more than just our finances and there are many ways to contribute to society, many of which are not reflected in the economy.

OP posts:
glitterpaperchain · 31/10/2026 14:15

yellowspanner · 31/10/2026 14:11

I am a net contributor and yes I think the term is appropriate. Some people choose to live on benefits as a life style choice, others work cash only and avoid paying tax, others refuse to do jobs that they consider beneath them or beneath their qualification level, others choose to have children they cannot support financially. These are the people that are not contributing and are the reason my taxes are so high . And yes I use the term and I resent them

Ok I didn't ask about which types of people you resent, I think it's telling you went right to that.

What about people who earn a low income and don't claim benefits? Do you resent them too? What kinds of people are acceptable to you?

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 31/10/2026 14:15

yellowspanner · 31/10/2026 14:11

I am a net contributor and yes I think the term is appropriate. Some people choose to live on benefits as a life style choice, others work cash only and avoid paying tax, others refuse to do jobs that they consider beneath them or beneath their qualification level, others choose to have children they cannot support financially. These are the people that are not contributing and are the reason my taxes are so high . And yes I use the term and I resent them

Plenty of people in jobs that are vital but are not paid enough to be a net contributor. Do you resent them too?
BTW, you have never always been a net contributor.

yellowspanner · 31/10/2026 14:11

I am a net contributor and yes I think the term is appropriate. Some people choose to live on benefits as a life style choice, others work cash only and avoid paying tax, others refuse to do jobs that they consider beneath them or beneath their qualification level, others choose to have children they cannot support financially. These are the people that are not contributing and are the reason my taxes are so high . And yes I use the term and I resent them

SevenYellowHammers · 31/10/2026 13:52

@glitterpaperchain I am half way through Gordon Brown’s new book. I appreciate that research will often support a hypothesis already held. However, his research and use of statistical information does seem thorough.

As I’ve long suspected, the demise of manufacturing means that there’s a significantly smaller amount to spend. It’s not just public service workers who appear to be not producing (of course they are producing, they are producing the means for others to make tangible production) but also those formally in production jobs.

We desperately need to produce in order for the economy to provide the means to support, be equitable and to care for the environment. Neoliberalism has been a bigger failure than anyone could ever have predicted.

Thosestupidpopups · 31/10/2026 12:55

Rockpunkdisco · 30/10/2026 18:55

That's quite difficult to gauge.

So if working FT, paid less than £45k, no DC, no hospital treatment, paying tax, NI etc, really? Surely this is contributing well and not using services, especially if not a parent?

What a stupid term.

You basically described me although I earn closer to 50K on a good year since I do so some self employment on the side.

But interestingly some would say me not having children makes me not a NC since kids are the future workforce or whatever.

And ironically the same people would also say my low earning single mother who raised 3 kids who now all earn upwards of 40k (one of them being a doctor) wasn’t a NC either. You can’t win!

It’s all crap really. All this labelling people and putting to place them into useful and less useful categories based on a ticklist which ignores nuance.

Rockpunkdisco · 30/10/2026 20:30

XenoBitch · 30/10/2026 18:58

That is why it is problematic, and also why it is a shitty way to gauge someone's worth to society.

Absolutely! The people who come up with these labels are vitriolic.

CloveRinse · 30/10/2026 19:20

AralVorkosigan · 28/10/2026 19:45

You asked if you were being unreasonable to be fed up of the phrase. I queried what you wanted people to say instead. You confirmed that in fact you don’t have any problem with people using the phrase in the only context I’ve ever seen it used in. That’s a summary of what’s going on from my perspective!

People have given lots of examples on this thread on how it is used by high earners feel / seem superior to people who earn lower wages.

XenoBitch · 30/10/2026 18:58

Rockpunkdisco · 30/10/2026 18:55

That's quite difficult to gauge.

So if working FT, paid less than £45k, no DC, no hospital treatment, paying tax, NI etc, really? Surely this is contributing well and not using services, especially if not a parent?

What a stupid term.

That is why it is problematic, and also why it is a shitty way to gauge someone's worth to society.

Rockpunkdisco · 30/10/2026 18:55

VioletsTale · 30/10/2026 18:31

No. NC is only reserved for people who pay more in taxes than they receive in the form of benefits or services. I think the latest numbers were earning above 45k.

That's quite difficult to gauge.

So if working FT, paid less than £45k, no DC, no hospital treatment, paying tax, NI etc, really? Surely this is contributing well and not using services, especially if not a parent?

What a stupid term.

VioletsTale · 30/10/2026 18:31

Rockpunkdisco · 30/10/2026 16:54

Isn't a NC just someone who works and pays tax and NI?

No. NC is only reserved for people who pay more in taxes than they receive in the form of benefits or services. I think the latest numbers were earning above 45k.

InterIgnis · 30/10/2026 17:32

glitterpaperchain · 30/10/2026 17:13

I see your point but I'm not sure I entirely agree. I think we've had successive governments absolutely obsessed with money, austerity, get the economy going, live within your means - but we are seeing the outcome and it's not good. We've stopped investing in our own people, left people to fend for themselves without support, so now they need to push this narrative that puts blame on the people rather than the system, to stop us from turning round and holding the government accountable.

I think we need to focus less on making ourselves look 'attractive' for outside investors at the expense of our own people, and rather focus on generating wealth ourselves. Invest in our people, build an educated, skilled, healthy workforce. Change the system so that people starting local businesses is financially viable, start with rebuilding economies on a local, community scale. Local services, dog groomers, hairdressers, independent shops. Apprenticeships for trades.

Build up from there to creating wealth on a larger scale. Eg invest in researching and building ways to become self-sufficient as a country, like green energy. Create jobs in this industry, become an industry leader so it can be an export and we can reduce reliance on the international market.

What we've got is citizens run into the ground trying to keep the lights on, causing an increase in people signed off work for physical and mental health issues. Invest in good support systems, healthcare, education, create a strong population, and give them opportunities to create their own wealth.

I’m not talking only about foreign wealth, but also the wealth of those from the UK that have left. In the last two years alone individuals worth at least £160 billion have left the UK. Thats just the billionaires - if you add to that the worth of those other higher earners that have also left then it’s £200 billion +. That’s a lot of capital, tax revenue, investment, and jobs to lose. The net outflow of wealth has been a problem for at least ten years, and it’s only picking up pace.

None of what you want can happen without a strong economy and money to invest. That means making the UK an attractive prospect for the wealthy. Right now it’s a country high earners are avoiding.

Additionally, things like the £100k cliff edge are a huge problem. It actively discourages people from making above that amount.

glitterpaperchain · 30/10/2026 17:13

InterIgnis · 30/10/2026 15:29

Probably because all the infrastructure that provides care and support cannot survive without a strong economy. Without net contributors providing the foundation, the house crumbles. ‘Caring’ is the first thing that falls to the wayside when times get hard and it becomes a luxury people can no longer afford to extend.

It’s not the high earners that will suffer the consequences of this happening, either. Capital is mobile, and it will go elsewhere to countries actively trying to attract it. It already has done. It’s the people left behind, that don’t have the same options, that will have to bear an ever increasing burden until everything collapses.

If you want to attract wealth, then you need to value those providing it. The government needs pro business policies. It needs to be a place that wealthy expats want to move to and invest it. IMO this is the reason behind the shift in narrative, because it’s reached crisis point.

Edited

I see your point but I'm not sure I entirely agree. I think we've had successive governments absolutely obsessed with money, austerity, get the economy going, live within your means - but we are seeing the outcome and it's not good. We've stopped investing in our own people, left people to fend for themselves without support, so now they need to push this narrative that puts blame on the people rather than the system, to stop us from turning round and holding the government accountable.

I think we need to focus less on making ourselves look 'attractive' for outside investors at the expense of our own people, and rather focus on generating wealth ourselves. Invest in our people, build an educated, skilled, healthy workforce. Change the system so that people starting local businesses is financially viable, start with rebuilding economies on a local, community scale. Local services, dog groomers, hairdressers, independent shops. Apprenticeships for trades.

Build up from there to creating wealth on a larger scale. Eg invest in researching and building ways to become self-sufficient as a country, like green energy. Create jobs in this industry, become an industry leader so it can be an export and we can reduce reliance on the international market.

What we've got is citizens run into the ground trying to keep the lights on, causing an increase in people signed off work for physical and mental health issues. Invest in good support systems, healthcare, education, create a strong population, and give them opportunities to create their own wealth.

OP posts:
Rockpunkdisco · 30/10/2026 16:54

Isn't a NC just someone who works and pays tax and NI?

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 30/10/2026 16:10

topcat2014 · 30/10/2026 15:18

Minimum wage is 2 thirds of average wage. How much are people wanting these lower skilled jobs to pay?

Enough for the employees to pay their rent/mortgage, Council Tax, food and bills. Ideally, they would have some extra to spend as they chose, as much of it would go back into the local economy, one way or another. Low earners don’t tend to have offshore bank accounts.

usernamealreadytaken · 30/10/2026 15:41

glitterpaperchain · 28/10/2026 19:28

Again, in my OP I said:

I feel like this phrase is really making people view each other in a nasty way, purely focused on whether they provide economic value or not.

But surely it’s only said in the context of an economic conversation? I can’t think of any other context where you would discuss an individual’s fiscal contribution… I think the first response nails it, really.

InterIgnis · 30/10/2026 15:29

glitterpaperchain · 30/10/2026 07:25

I think there's been a general push from some politicians and the media to place incredible value on the economy at the expense of other important aspects of society like caring, in a general move towards conservatism and individualism.

This is also done to benefit businesses as it makes people highly value them for their tax contributions rather than be sceptical of poor pay or poor labour practices.

Plus of course it's just another way to pit people against each other. In the grand scheme of billionaires and giant corporations, people on 30k and people on 300k matter just as little to them.

So generally pushing this narrative that one's value is determined by their wealth makes the ultra wealthy look good and aspirational rather than explotative.

Probably because all the infrastructure that provides care and support cannot survive without a strong economy. Without net contributors providing the foundation, the house crumbles. ‘Caring’ is the first thing that falls to the wayside when times get hard and it becomes a luxury people can no longer afford to extend.

It’s not the high earners that will suffer the consequences of this happening, either. Capital is mobile, and it will go elsewhere to countries actively trying to attract it. It already has done. It’s the people left behind, that don’t have the same options, that will have to bear an ever increasing burden until everything collapses.

If you want to attract wealth, then you need to value those providing it. The government needs pro business policies. It needs to be a place that wealthy expats want to move to and invest it. IMO this is the reason behind the shift in narrative, because it’s reached crisis point.

ACynicalDad · 30/10/2026 15:24

Maybe it should be a net financial contributor, but I do think it is quite helpful when looking at things like immigration in particular.

topcat2014 · 30/10/2026 15:18

Minimum wage is 2 thirds of average wage. How much are people wanting these lower skilled jobs to pay?

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 30/10/2026 14:47

It depends how you want to frame it.

”I’m a net contributor. I took the risk of setting up my own business and worked extremely hard to get it off the ground. My efforts paid off and I now support the local economy by providing several jobs, as well as subsidising our public services through my high taxes. The UK needs more people like me.”

Or

”I’m a high earner, partly because I pay my staff low wages. These aren’t enough for them to live on, so they rely on Universal Credit top-ups.

My business is perfectly legal, but it isn’t great for the environment as it involves importing tens of thousands of cheap plastic goods from China and distributing them around the UK by lorry. Luckily, the pollution created by the manufacture of these products is considered to be part of China’s carbon footprint, not the UK’s. Occasionally, I have to remove one or two of my lines from sale, because they turned out to contain asbestos or high levels of benzine. But that isn’t my fault.”

glitterpaperchain · 30/10/2026 07:25

Electra10E · 30/10/2026 07:14

@glitterpaperchain

Why do you think use of the label ‘net contributor’ has gained currency?

I think there's been a general push from some politicians and the media to place incredible value on the economy at the expense of other important aspects of society like caring, in a general move towards conservatism and individualism.

This is also done to benefit businesses as it makes people highly value them for their tax contributions rather than be sceptical of poor pay or poor labour practices.

Plus of course it's just another way to pit people against each other. In the grand scheme of billionaires and giant corporations, people on 30k and people on 300k matter just as little to them.

So generally pushing this narrative that one's value is determined by their wealth makes the ultra wealthy look good and aspirational rather than explotative.

OP posts:
Electra10E · 30/10/2026 07:14

@glitterpaperchain

Why do you think use of the label ‘net contributor’ has gained currency?

glitterpaperchain · 30/10/2026 07:05

Totallyfedupnow · 30/10/2026 01:56

I feel like this thread has become derailed because the OP is moving the goalposts. OP started out by arguing that value to society can take different forms. Fair enough.

But now OP says they mean that net contributors think they are morally superior to everyone else. Whether or not these people think so (and I don’t think OP has provided any evidence of this), that’s a total non sequitur. Working for £200 per hour does not make you less morally virtuous than someone working for £10 per hour. Or vice versa. There are many reasons why someone ends up working for £10 an hour rather than £200, and most of them are not moral choices.

Furthermore, even if you define “value” as social contribution, rather than financial contribution, that’s still not equivalent to moral superiority. It is possible to be a very morally principled person but to contribute nothing to society, financially or otherwise - think a cloistered monk or nun - or the reverse.

I can explain more clearly because I think my argument is quite clear.

Some people who are net contributors seem to think that makes them better than other people. Nowhere did I say all. I've seen this attitude here on MN. What I'm fed up of is seeing the phrase used in this way.

And I'm saying that being a financial net contributor doesn't make someone better or more valuable than someone else, because there are many non-financial ways to contribute.

Hope that helps

OP posts:
Friendlygingercat · 30/10/2026 02:15

When you assess what someone has contributed to society it should include as well as tax

The actual value of the work
Research work or publications
Time spent training or studying (after secondary school)
Voluntary work done
Unofficial caring

Totallyfedupnow · 30/10/2026 01:56

I feel like this thread has become derailed because the OP is moving the goalposts. OP started out by arguing that value to society can take different forms. Fair enough.

But now OP says they mean that net contributors think they are morally superior to everyone else. Whether or not these people think so (and I don’t think OP has provided any evidence of this), that’s a total non sequitur. Working for £200 per hour does not make you less morally virtuous than someone working for £10 per hour. Or vice versa. There are many reasons why someone ends up working for £10 an hour rather than £200, and most of them are not moral choices.

Furthermore, even if you define “value” as social contribution, rather than financial contribution, that’s still not equivalent to moral superiority. It is possible to be a very morally principled person but to contribute nothing to society, financially or otherwise - think a cloistered monk or nun - or the reverse.

Totallyfedupnow · 30/10/2026 01:07

@socialdilemmawhattodo I don’t really understand your point, or that of the other poster.
There are very few jobs in the tobacco industry in the UK these days but they do pay pretty well. Salary levels reflect the fact that many people have a red line when it comes to tobacco, limiting the supply of labour and increasing its price.
The defence industry, however, is a huge employer within the UK with a lot of crossover into civilian areas of STEM and a good record of offering apprenticeships and other training. Thousands of people are very happy to work in the sector, and don’t need significant salary premiums.