Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Year 7 (who is very good at maths) has been put in the bottom sets.

445 replies

ReevesJeeves · 20/10/2026 22:00

My DD has always been very good at Maths. In Year 6, she achieved Greater Depth in her Maths SATS (achieving 115/120). Since joining Year 7, she has been in a mixed ability Maths Set. In the work that has been sent home from Secondary and that is set on Sparx, she is getting 80% - 90% correct, independently.

We have just had a letter home today, advising that Maths will be set after half term, and my DD will be in Set 5 of 6! The letter also explains that she has been assessed as finding Maths challenging and not to worry about sets, every child will be assisted individually. AIBU to think the school doesn’t know my DD at all, and to send an email querying how they came to this decision? I fail to see how she can now be finding maths challenging and in Set 5 of 6, having achieved 115/120 in her SATS only months ago. Maths has always been a subject she has excelled in, right down to her KS1 Times Tables test where she scored 100%. BTW this is not a selective school or grammar, it’s mainstream state, so it’s not as though the department will be awash with Maths geniuses (in the least offensive way). I also don’t want to appear as a trouble maker or someone the school will be fed up with, but I think this needs to be questioned to find out what has gone wrong so to speak.

My husband thinks I shouldn’t say anything as the school will just think I’m a neurotic mum, I disagree and I think it needs to be dealt with and questions asked pronto - something has clearly gone drastically wrong either with the teachers assessment of DD or in the way DD is presenting herself in class?!

OP posts:
ReevesJeeves · 21/10/2026 21:17

I haven’t had a reply today, should I chase tomorrow? It’s their last day before half term.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 21/10/2026 21:16

No harm in asking

Wondwr if she fluffed computer tests that schools seem fond of

JustMarriedBecca · 21/10/2026 21:15

Ours did tests at the start of the year out of 60 on Sparx to determine gaps. DD got 120 and then 60/60 on the Sparx test. She said some kids had gotten 110 on SATS but 40/60 on the Sparx initial test (average about 35/60)

I've already emailed our Head of Maths and I don't give a crap if I'm THAT parent. Email. Ignore your DH.

clary · 21/10/2026 20:51

TeenToTwenties · 21/10/2026 18:31

Absolutely not.
Because maths builds there is no point teaching grade 9 stuff to pupils struggling with grade 6 content.
Maths is a bit of an outlier for this, though I guess MFL may have some aspects of this @Clary ?

Yeh maths is very much usually set from year 7 (mainly bc it would be impossible to teach mixed ability in secondary maths). And yes, it’s quite likely that lower sets will not learn the content needed for grades 7-9. Tbf tho that might not be evident until later than year 7 if that makes sense; but the bottom set would be covering the basics, whereas higher sets might skip past those as DC would have mastered them.

A DC who moved up to a set that would take higher would be able to catch up in year 8 or even 9 if able tho IMHO.

In MFL at KS3 I would teach the same content really to all abilities, if the class was mixed. We did set KS3 for French with one year which was helpful. We certainly went into greater depth with things like the perfect tense with the higher sets (I taught set 1, 2 and 8). We usually had enough takers for GCSE MFL to set them so I would either be teaching a group of higher or a group of foundation – so yes, the content and skills would definitely be different.

ETA @ReevesJeeves that sounds like an admin error to me so I hope it gets sorted.

SaltNVinegarRyvita · 21/10/2026 20:40

@ReevesJeevesI’ve had the exact same problem at my Dad’s school y7. She’s at a comp, excellent at maths. She was in the lowest set - this took time to understand as they didn’t number the sets but DD could tell based on the pace of the class, the homework and the topic tests. I let it flow for a while and we got past few topic tests in which she did exceptionally well.
at this point I wrote to the school asking if they could review her placement given her scores. They’ve swiftly moved her to the top set. Looks like it was an admin error to put her there (we got a seat very late) rather than anything else.

Just want to say that there will be room for movement even if it doesn’t happen before lessons start. If nothing else there will be tests which will prove she needs to move, even if they don’t choose to act immediately.

Helppleasestuck · 21/10/2026 20:38

iforgotthepickles · 20/10/2026 22:04

Yes you are right this sounds like an administrative cock up
I would send a factual email clarifying this is correct as your daughter had previously scored x y z. And if it is the case that she is now performing at bottom you would like a meeting to discuss wjay has happened for such a sudden change in progress.

This happened to my child only with English, and this approach is exactly what I did since either there was an admin error that needed addressing, or their trajectory had altered dramatically in which case i also wanted to know about it.

Head of dept called me and said they could see there had been an error, and it was sorted fairly quickly. Raise it, nicely and politely of course, but do raise it.

BooBooDoodle · 21/10/2026 20:34

Im surprised they have been put in sets already. My son has just started in year 7. Aced his SATS but they aren’t setted until year 8. This year they are focussing on adjusting to new school routines and getting to know one another. All the classes have been split up for different lessons but not based on academic ability, it’s so they can make new friends and adjust. They have been assessed already and their last assessments are next year when they will be setted ready to go into year 8.

OneFunBrickNewt · 21/10/2026 20:01

Must be an admin error- raise it.
Unless all the other kids got 120/120 in SATS....

likeafishneedsabike · 21/10/2026 19:58

Just an admin error, OP. So please don’t worry. They CANNOT put her on bottom set Maths because her target for GCSE will be 8 or 9 on the basis of her SATS score. Top grade for foundation Maths is 5. So she will miss her target significantly and they will be accountable for the shortfall. Ignore your husband and get this error sorted out before half term.

Violinist64 · 21/10/2026 19:58

Grammarnut · 21/10/2026 18:55

Good at times tables and arithmetic does not equal good at maths, although those skills are necessary for maths. You say she gets 80 to 90% of her homework correct but you may not be aware at what level the homework is set i.e. you can be top of set 5 and not very good at maths. Nevertheless, I'd check with the school. If they turn out to be wrong they will notice, too.

For goodness’ sake. From @ReevesJeeves’ posts, it is obvious that this is not in question. A child would not have scored so highly in the SATs without the understanding necessary for that level. She has also had a flair and enthusiasm for maths since early childhood. Why are so many people doubting @ReevesJeeves‘ knowledge of her own daughter? She has been very objective and concerned, as anyone else would be. I am joining the chorus in thinking there has been an administrative mistake somewhere and if the email is unanswered by, say, 8.30 tomorrow morning, I would be phoning the school and asking to talk to the maths teacher and/or head of department.

N3WN8ME · 21/10/2026 19:55

With the opposite view to your husband, I'd say it would be irresponsible to not look into what has happened here? Clearly maths is/was her strength so you need to get to the bottom of what has happened here for her sake. Either she is struggling in the new school or they have made some huge error. Hope you get some insight and good luck!

riceuten · 21/10/2026 19:37

You can reasonably ask the question why they have been put in this set, but unless you are a (maths) teacher, then I would leave it alone. If she excels in set 5, they will amend this in future allocations. What do you know about other children in this particular group and her relative performance compared to them. If you demand she be resetted, then yes, you will come across as a neurotic mum

Thunderdcc · 21/10/2026 19:36

ReevesJeeves · 21/10/2026 14:42

I don’t disagree, but I’d hope the school would look at more than one test before making a judgment and determining sets. If they’d looked at the data, it should raise a red flag for 115/120 SATS score to now be in set 5. It raises questions to say the least.

This is the thing isn't it - if you take it at face value the question is how, as a school, have you failed so badly in the first 5 weeks of term that she's gone so far backwards?

DD2 is naturally good at maths and really struggles to show her workings. She doesn't need workings, she instinctively knows the answer. Possibly it is something along these lines <clutching at straws>

TeenToTwenties · 21/10/2026 19:16

Grammarnut · 21/10/2026 18:58

This happens all the time. I don't disagree with setting but I do disagree with not teaching every set the entire syllabus for the higher paper. Everyone should have the chance to do well on the day, not have their results stymied in this way.

They would end up with a worse result if teaching time was given over with too much grade 8/9 stuff before they have mastered grade 6/7.

I can't remember what is at grade 8/9 but for example why waste time teaching 3D trig problems to pupils who haven't mastered 2D ones yet?

(At DD's school sets overlapped so you could move up. DD1 started y7 in something like set 6 or 7 and ended up in set 3, even moving up between y10 and y11.)

(It reminds me of y6 SPaG. Total waste of time the school 'teaching' DD2 about 'fronted adverbials' when she couldn't yet do Capitals and fullstops properly. Would have been so much more beneficial to het to focus on those.)

ColdWaterDipper · 21/10/2026 19:14

Sounds like they have got her muddled with another child - I would query it and make sure you speak to her actual maths teacher, not the head of year or anything who won’t have a clue about her maths ability!

I work in a school and this sort of thing happens more frequently than you’d think. No-one will mind you querying it at all.

Crazybigtoe · 21/10/2026 19:12

Bloau · 21/10/2026 18:55

It is utterly futile to teach someone something knowing they don't have the prerequisite skills. You can't teach short multiplication if a child has no understanding of times tables, for example, even if it is on the curriculum. You could stand at the front and explain it, but you would be as well teaching PhD standard maths for all it matters and they would not be able to attempt a single question independently. A teacher will know what level their pupils are at. They won't be denying them information unnecessarily.

So, if you are capable of a 6, you can't be taught the syllabus that is deemed to be standard of a 7?

It's kinda wild really.

That teacher absolutely is denying the child. Their chances are being limited by the teaching.

ThanksItHasPockets · 21/10/2026 19:11

Grammarnut · 21/10/2026 18:58

This happens all the time. I don't disagree with setting but I do disagree with not teaching every set the entire syllabus for the higher paper. Everyone should have the chance to do well on the day, not have their results stymied in this way.

I'm not a mathematician but there are some topics which were added to the post 2017 GCSE in order to distinguish the grade 9 students which are notoriously difficult and which previously were not introduced until A level, e.g. function notation, and composite and inverse functions. I can understand why it might be decided that learning some of this content does not best serve a pupil who is likely to achieve towards the lower end of the scale on the Higher paper.

Wonderfulstuff · 21/10/2026 19:10

Definitely raise it. You have the stats from her SATs to evidence your concern. Even if they come back and provide evidence of a test with poor performance, I'd then go back and question why she is suddenly performing below her potential i.e. is it a transition issue? I'd ask if there's any additional support and also when she'll be re-tested and if there's then an opportunity to move sets. As per PP, look into getting her some additional tutoring.

LongTimeLurker264 · 21/10/2026 19:08

This could definitely be an admin error! I loved maths at school and was put in bottom set in year 7/8. I went home so upset about this (because I was such a geek!) that my sister ended up asking the head of maths about it. It turned out I had the same surname as another student and they'd switched us round. Fingers crossed it's sorted!

biscuitmouse · 21/10/2026 19:06

happened to my DD in another subject. A query (and I had to be persistent about getting to the root reason) asking why she had been set in this specific test, and what her grades / test results were relative to others, repeatedly asked, eventually led to teacher admitting a mistake, and being moved up again.

Be persistent and ask for the actual reason why, if related to tests or reslience or something like that. If they fob you off ask for the actual grade.

Melancholyflower · 21/10/2026 19:05

GoodChocolate · 21/10/2026 12:34

Firstly SATs results are already nearly 6 months out of date by this stage.
Secondly SATs and CATS measure different things.CATs is much more geared to measuring a students mathematical potential -reasoning, spatial ability etc whereas SATS more reflects how well your child has been drilled in following and applying primary mathematics techniques,.
It mught be your daughter has worked hard and mastered the things she has been taught at primary, but she doesnt have as much innate ability to grasp new mathematical concepts and needs a bit slower pace of learning.

As somebody who works in Y6, the difference in mathematical understanding between a child who achieves greater depth and one that I would expect to end up in the second to bottom set, is quite significant. Even if she went to a school that taught to the test and performed slightly above her natural ability in SATS, there's no way you can bump it that much. We have children that even if we spent all year just practising maths SATs questions with them, they still would not achieve GD.
I wouldn't necessarily expect someone who got 115 to be in the top set, as plenty of children across the year group will have got 119-120, but I would probably expect set 2 depending on the cohort.

TeethAreImportant · 21/10/2026 19:04

ReevesJeeves · 20/10/2026 22:00

My DD has always been very good at Maths. In Year 6, she achieved Greater Depth in her Maths SATS (achieving 115/120). Since joining Year 7, she has been in a mixed ability Maths Set. In the work that has been sent home from Secondary and that is set on Sparx, she is getting 80% - 90% correct, independently.

We have just had a letter home today, advising that Maths will be set after half term, and my DD will be in Set 5 of 6! The letter also explains that she has been assessed as finding Maths challenging and not to worry about sets, every child will be assisted individually. AIBU to think the school doesn’t know my DD at all, and to send an email querying how they came to this decision? I fail to see how she can now be finding maths challenging and in Set 5 of 6, having achieved 115/120 in her SATS only months ago. Maths has always been a subject she has excelled in, right down to her KS1 Times Tables test where she scored 100%. BTW this is not a selective school or grammar, it’s mainstream state, so it’s not as though the department will be awash with Maths geniuses (in the least offensive way). I also don’t want to appear as a trouble maker or someone the school will be fed up with, but I think this needs to be questioned to find out what has gone wrong so to speak.

My husband thinks I shouldn’t say anything as the school will just think I’m a neurotic mum, I disagree and I think it needs to be dealt with and questions asked pronto - something has clearly gone drastically wrong either with the teachers assessment of DD or in the way DD is presenting herself in class?!

Query it. She may be a quiet student, meaning she gets overlooked, or there's just been some mistake that means they've got this incorrect. This happened to me, both being moved down in Maths so the max you could get was a C, plus wasn't put forward to do an additional GCSE that lots of other pupils who the teachers knew because they were more forward were offered. Got A's across the board, except for the Maths, which still irritates me now, all these years later. Friends who were put forward for the additional GCSE got D's, E's and U's in all/most subjects, I remember I felt so cheated and just invisible. Wondered why they hadn't thought I was good enough, despite previous excellent test results. Sometimes schools just get it wrong. My parents didn't have a clue and wouldn't have been interested if they had. Query it, who cares what the school thinks. Squeaky hinge gets the oil is my experience.

Grammarnut · 21/10/2026 18:58

Crazybigtoe · 21/10/2026 18:49

Thanks. I never knew this. My kids are all so different and all go to different schools I'd never would have thought to check this.

I had assumed if they were sitting Higher, they were taught every element of the higher paper- IE to arm them to get a 9. Even if 'not capable ' they would still be actually taught the content, and then ability would determine what they end up with.

I didn't realise they may not be taught it in the first place.

Yup and mine all go to bog standard comps.

And Sparx is still woeful.

This happens all the time. I don't disagree with setting but I do disagree with not teaching every set the entire syllabus for the higher paper. Everyone should have the chance to do well on the day, not have their results stymied in this way.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 21/10/2026 18:58

ReevesJeeves · 21/10/2026 14:42

I don’t disagree, but I’d hope the school would look at more than one test before making a judgment and determining sets. If they’d looked at the data, it should raise a red flag for 115/120 SATS score to now be in set 5. It raises questions to say the least.

The most likely explanation is a technical glitch.

In order to allocate to classes, it's necessary to

1a. Export an allocations file, put Ts in the column (for true), save the file, upload the file, remember to set it to overwrite existing class memberships from the effective date and run the update class memberships routine. Whoever is either copying from a spreadsheet - which can have typos or errors - or putting Ts in the columns direct can make an error. Or they could have a really helpful email or five with Jess A, Jessica A, JezA, JesikaAA and Ajess featuring in those emails.

OR

1b. Manually click each kid's group box in the curriculum management module whilst flipping between spreadsheets/emails, save and run update class memberships.

This is assuming that there hasn't been a new timetable that needs to be applied first, as that adds a whole new level of complication and opportunity for things to go wrong.

2a. Then there will be a flurry of emails where people are asking that JessA and JerramyB aren't in the same classes as there has been a few problems, that JamieC and Jolene are moved to class 3 because that's got a TA in there, JackR has broken his leg in six places so needs to be in the class that isn't up five flights of stairs, the Maths class determines the science and tech ones and although a standard class can accommodate 33, the tech block can only fit in 25 so a whole bunch need to be moved. And now JuneF's mum has found out that she's in a class with AprilG, she now needs to be shifted across bands in order to ensure that they never meet in a classroom environment at any point following some very unpleasant events over the summer holiday between her, June's Dad and April's Auntie.

2b. There are a bunch of leavers and joiners around the end of September who have also needed to find the KS2 data for and put in for CAT4s. This means another go around of the updating.

2c. The roof in one of the Maths classrooms is leaking. The intended 6 classes has therefore shrunk into 5 and at the same time, it's been decided that actually, one of those classes needs to be a bit smaller than the others so the allocations need to be done again.

There are many pinch points where something can go wrong completely aside from it being a deliberate decision of staff or down to a kid deciding they don't want to stand out, not speaking up when taking online CAT4s and the screen has frozen on the quantitative reasoning set or behaving in a way that means their assessment scores are significantly lower than their actual ability.

In short, there is absolutely no harm at all in checking and it may have absolutely nothing to do with inadequate assessment and everything to do with it being a seemingly simple but technically complex process to create a new timetable. I prefer having a moveable structure in place from the outset to minimise the opportunities for problems, but sometimes you just have to deal with what you've been given.

Bloau · 21/10/2026 18:55

Crazybigtoe · 21/10/2026 18:49

Thanks. I never knew this. My kids are all so different and all go to different schools I'd never would have thought to check this.

I had assumed if they were sitting Higher, they were taught every element of the higher paper- IE to arm them to get a 9. Even if 'not capable ' they would still be actually taught the content, and then ability would determine what they end up with.

I didn't realise they may not be taught it in the first place.

Yup and mine all go to bog standard comps.

And Sparx is still woeful.

It is utterly futile to teach someone something knowing they don't have the prerequisite skills. You can't teach short multiplication if a child has no understanding of times tables, for example, even if it is on the curriculum. You could stand at the front and explain it, but you would be as well teaching PhD standard maths for all it matters and they would not be able to attempt a single question independently. A teacher will know what level their pupils are at. They won't be denying them information unnecessarily.

Swipe left for the next trending thread