Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Year 7 (who is very good at maths) has been put in the bottom sets.

445 replies

ReevesJeeves · 20/10/2026 22:00

My DD has always been very good at Maths. In Year 6, she achieved Greater Depth in her Maths SATS (achieving 115/120). Since joining Year 7, she has been in a mixed ability Maths Set. In the work that has been sent home from Secondary and that is set on Sparx, she is getting 80% - 90% correct, independently.

We have just had a letter home today, advising that Maths will be set after half term, and my DD will be in Set 5 of 6! The letter also explains that she has been assessed as finding Maths challenging and not to worry about sets, every child will be assisted individually. AIBU to think the school doesn’t know my DD at all, and to send an email querying how they came to this decision? I fail to see how she can now be finding maths challenging and in Set 5 of 6, having achieved 115/120 in her SATS only months ago. Maths has always been a subject she has excelled in, right down to her KS1 Times Tables test where she scored 100%. BTW this is not a selective school or grammar, it’s mainstream state, so it’s not as though the department will be awash with Maths geniuses (in the least offensive way). I also don’t want to appear as a trouble maker or someone the school will be fed up with, but I think this needs to be questioned to find out what has gone wrong so to speak.

My husband thinks I shouldn’t say anything as the school will just think I’m a neurotic mum, I disagree and I think it needs to be dealt with and questions asked pronto - something has clearly gone drastically wrong either with the teachers assessment of DD or in the way DD is presenting herself in class?!

OP posts:
CatSquirrelDuck · 22/10/2026 17:48

I also don’t believe it’s possible to get 115 on the SATS without natural aptitude - it consists of 3 papers. She also got Greater Depth in English so is a good all rounder.

It's not natural aptitude necessarily ... a lot of primary schools, including ours, to a lot of SATS mocks and work very hard on maths reasoning papers. They're not 'difficult' papers, it is just the entirety of the primary school curriculum, usually one question from each area of study on the reasoning papers.

Zigzag99 · 22/10/2026 16:30

My DS got a low maths score when he was in year 7. He came home in tears as he was certain he did really well.
I emailed the school to ask for a copy of papers, both my sons answers and the correct answers.
The following day the papers were handed out in class so the students could see where they went wrong.
Turns out the teacher had added the sections up incorrectly. Luckily my son noticed and challenged the teacher during class. The teacher apologised and said he had marked my sons paper late at night when he was tired.
Needless to say my son always checks the papers now when they are handed out.

janoo · 22/10/2026 16:18

Quine0nline · 22/10/2026 13:51

Does the school have form for putting the high achieving pupils into the classes with low achieving pupils " to make it fair for the lower achiever"

That’s not going to happen in a setted maths class where the OP has been told her DD needs extra support.

fashionqueen0123 · 22/10/2026 15:42

ReevesJeeves · 22/10/2026 14:53

I phoned this morning following my email asking for a phone call back which they said would happened today.

Is tomorrow an inset day?

BirdLandedonmyHead · 22/10/2026 15:30

If tomorrow is an Inset day, the teachets will be working.

They cant ring in lesson time, they are teaching.

raffiablonde · 22/10/2026 15:29

3WildOnes · 22/10/2026 09:38

Bottom set in a very academic private school is completely different to the bottom set at a state comp. At the very academic private school close to me the lowest grade in gcse maths was a 6, only 11 pupil achieved less than an 8. So the bottom set would be achieving grades 6-8. In the bottom set at a state comp they wouldn't be learning any of the higher level content and would be put in for foundation so wouldn't be able to achieve higher than a 5. It's a completely different kettle of fish.

Sure, and it does seem like this was some kind of admin error ultimately...but my point is, sets don't necessarily stay fixed. All the sets in my DS's school got rejigged over years 7/8/9 I think. As it was, my DS got a 9 in GCSE in the end.

Of course OP should follow up with the school, but because the OPs DC is only in year 7, being in the 'wrong' set at the very beginning isn't necessarily a disaster in the grand scheme of things.

Longtimelurker1980 · 22/10/2026 15:04

ReevesJeeves · 22/10/2026 14:53

I phoned this morning following my email asking for a phone call back which they said would happened today.

Ring again! Ask to hold til head of year or someone in SLT can talk.

Mcoco · 22/10/2026 15:00

Make an appointment to see the head of year it sounds like a mistake. You are not being neurotic at all. My youngest is in year 13 and if I am concerned about anything I still email them. Your her mum and you know she is about to go in the wrong set.

ReevesJeeves · 22/10/2026 14:53

Zerosleep · 22/10/2026 14:51

I wouldn’t be emailing. I would be calling them several times until they reply to you.

I phoned this morning following my email asking for a phone call back which they said would happened today.

OP posts:
MesaVerde · 22/10/2026 14:53

I know you have already done it OP, but just to add to the people saying absolutely right to query it. And I say that as the daughter of a pushy mum who would demand a meeting with the headmistress every time I was put in set 2 of 5, because I wasn't in set 1. It was mortifying.. and there really was no need for the pushiness, because set 2 was just where I deserved to be. But at no point did I ever feel I was treated differently by the teachers because of my mum's pushiness.

In your situation it's not pushy at all, it is advocating for your child - and it really does seem like a mistake has been made.. and if it isn't them something drastic has changed in your daughter's performance in class and that needs to be addressed anyway.

Definitely don't stew on it over the holidays, but go in there first thing after half term to get this resolved.

Your DH reminds me of my DH and his family, very non-confrontational, don't want to make a fuss.... it's maddening.. if you won't advocate for your own child, who will?

Zerosleep · 22/10/2026 14:51

ReevesJeeves · 22/10/2026 14:37

The thing is, it’s not just her SATS. It’s her results throughout primary school and the work she’s been doing so far - they did a test which the teacher said DD had done well on and was easy topics - factors, multiples, prime numbers etc. All of which DD had already covered at primary school and knows well.

I also don’t believe it’s possible to get 115 on the SATS without natural aptitude - it consists of 3 papers. She also got Greater Depth in English so is a good all rounder.

I followed up my email with a request for a phone call and haven’t heard anything, given the school closes for half term in 30 minutes I’m not holding out much hope. I think they time it deliberately with these sets / reports so that parents can’t complain right at the end of the half term and they have 2 weeks to stew or sit on the information. If they don’t phone me back today I’ll be going to reception first thing when they go back after half term and saying I need to hear back from the maths teacher that day.

I wouldn’t be emailing. I would be calling them several times until they reply to you.

ReevesJeeves · 22/10/2026 14:37

ThanksItHasPockets · 22/10/2026 13:49

I'm absolutely not defending this and it is not my view but I work in education and have a big focus on KS2-KS3 transition. It's worth knowing that SATs are regarded as largely worthless in many secondary settings and are ignored as far as possible in favour of internal baseline testing or CATs. It's quite possible that OP's DD's SATs result has not factored into this decision at all - although if she has a very common name then an admin error is highly likely.

The thing is, it’s not just her SATS. It’s her results throughout primary school and the work she’s been doing so far - they did a test which the teacher said DD had done well on and was easy topics - factors, multiples, prime numbers etc. All of which DD had already covered at primary school and knows well.

I also don’t believe it’s possible to get 115 on the SATS without natural aptitude - it consists of 3 papers. She also got Greater Depth in English so is a good all rounder.

I followed up my email with a request for a phone call and haven’t heard anything, given the school closes for half term in 30 minutes I’m not holding out much hope. I think they time it deliberately with these sets / reports so that parents can’t complain right at the end of the half term and they have 2 weeks to stew or sit on the information. If they don’t phone me back today I’ll be going to reception first thing when they go back after half term and saying I need to hear back from the maths teacher that day.

OP posts:
Quine0nline · 22/10/2026 13:51

Does the school have form for putting the high achieving pupils into the classes with low achieving pupils " to make it fair for the lower achiever"

ThanksItHasPockets · 22/10/2026 13:49

I'm absolutely not defending this and it is not my view but I work in education and have a big focus on KS2-KS3 transition. It's worth knowing that SATs are regarded as largely worthless in many secondary settings and are ignored as far as possible in favour of internal baseline testing or CATs. It's quite possible that OP's DD's SATs result has not factored into this decision at all - although if she has a very common name then an admin error is highly likely.

Credittocress · 22/10/2026 13:12

I had been put in the bottom set for maths based on my test results at the end of year 7. When my mother challenged this they relooked at the paper and I’d dropped all the points for showing your working and just put down all the right answers. They moved me straight into the top set with strict instructions to show my working in future.

Greengage1983 · 22/10/2026 13:12

ReevesJeeves · 21/10/2026 21:17

I haven’t had a reply today, should I chase tomorrow? It’s their last day before half term.

I'd ring them up and ask to speak to the maths teacher or whoever's in charge of the sets, rather than waiting for an email reply. Just so you're not spending the whole half term ruminating.
It could very well be a simple clerical error.
When I was at school I was one of the best in my year at Biology, but I was also extremely shy, hated participating in class, and rarely did any homework. In years 9-11 I had a biology teacher who decided I was rubbish at biology based on my lack of class participation and low homework results rather than my actual test results (every time I got a good result in a class test, SATs or mock GCSEs, she put it down to luck, a sympathetic marker, or insinuated I had been copying from my neighbour). I left with an A*. So it could be that they're judging her based on some other criteria rather than her actual abilities...

Absolutely DO NOT listen to your husband!! Whatever the reason for putting her in 5th set, it's a massive cause for concern! She's either struggling massively, in which case it needs addressing urgently, as a drop that steep can only have come from something serious (including mental health concerns, bullying, not adjusting well to the new school); or (much more likely from everything you've said) she's been put in the wrong set, in which case she'll spend the next couple of terms bored out of her absolute mind, as well as getting really far behind, missing out on learning the higher-level concepts she should be learning, which will make it harder when they eventually move her back up.

Just ring them and say you'd like to talk to them because you're very concerned that she's been put in set 5 when she previously was at greater depth, and seems to be getting good scores in her homework, so you wanted to check if there had been a mistake, and if not, you'd like to discuss whether something else is wrong because it's such a dramatic drop that you're very concerned about what has caused it.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 22/10/2026 13:07

Gengha · 20/10/2026 22:02

Presumably if she was in the wrong class it would quickly come to light after they’ve been streamed, but I don’t think it would do any harm to just ask - I suppose they may have made a mistake.

You'd hope so, but I moved schools, had been in set 2, new school decided to put me in 4 to see how I went and said they'd move me up if appropriate, and they never did despite the fact I was flying through all the work in class and doing all the homework in the lessons as well and getting excellent marks because I found it all so easy.

Fortunately I moved back to my previous school.

smilingontheinside · 22/10/2026 13:01

Had simulat with my DC some years back but in English.Queried with the teacher at parents evening why they had gone from a probable A/A* to a C/D in mocks and was being moved down a set. I was told I was overreacting! I asked what we could do to get their grade back up and again was told not to worry! Spoke to the head about changing teachers as we seemed to be getting nowhere. Turns out I was not the only parent with a problem and it was discovered that the teacher had spent a whole term on the wrong syllabus, this in the run up to GCSE exams!!!! Teacher decided to "retire" not long after and DC got their original projected grades. Sometimes mistakes are made 🤔

pollymere · 22/10/2026 12:06

I'd be asking the Head of Maths how this was determined. My DC achieved 115 but wasn't in a high set for maths at secondary either. However the fact they've referred to sets 4-6 as bottom has me concerned. 80-90% for homework is okay but it isn't exceptional. I tutor a student who is doing lower than expected for Maths but usually scores 95% or more for homework.

If you genuinely feel your DD is capable of 6-9 in maths then you need to flag this. I'd anticipate Set 1 being 7-9, Set 2 5-7, Sets 3 and 4 4-6 Set 5 3-4 and Set 6 1-3 (Functional Skills maths).

whattothinkhere · 22/10/2026 11:51

Yes chase it up OP because this kind of setting at this age (especially in the case of girls) could well entrench a "maths is not my thing" mentality in your DD, veering her away from potentially reaching her potential in maths and, by extension, other STEM subjects (if this is her inclination). Schools will always do frame setting 'children working at their individual pace' etc etc - and, of course, there is truth in this - but students do categorise themselves according to the set they are put in.

labtest57 · 22/10/2026 11:48

JuliaAgrippina · 22/10/2026 11:23

Thats surely very unusal or a more flexible school that my DC went to.

Maths here an usual three teir system compared to usual two- you can only get the higher grades on top paper and only first two sets really sat higher.

That's not new either - friend of mine at secondary in 90s sitting GCSE was in third group was put on a paper that capped highest score at C - she did really well but they wouldn't let her take maths A-level as she hadn't been taught the higher content - it was pain for her as degree she wanted often specified maths a-level so resticted her choices.

I know boards very hugely and school attitudes vary but sitting higher papers in lower sets is very unsual base on DC and DN and their mates experiences especially in a comprehsive school like OP DD in. It's probably less unusal in any sort of selective school.

It could well be a Sparx issue - they switched to it for DD2 and she lasted longest in her year with it but it was not a helpful peice of software at the time.

I would ring or e-mail again today becuase it is so close to half term - and politely ask what going on - is she suddenly struggling or is there an error in setting.

I would if she stays in the lowest set - do extra maths either on-line with you or with an external turtor at home so she doesn't fall behind and that becomes a reason to keep her in lower sets later on.

I doubt very much that poster is talking about a comprehensive school. No way are bottom set pupils in a comp getting maths grade 9s!

JuliaAgrippina · 22/10/2026 11:23

AMillionPeopleCheering · 21/10/2026 23:37

DS did a GCSE (as did all the bottom set) and got grade 9. Went onto maths A level, got an A. Did an engineering degree and masters. Now doing a mathematical modelling PhD at Imperial. But thanks for explaining his journey to me.

Thats surely very unusal or a more flexible school that my DC went to.

Maths here an usual three teir system compared to usual two- you can only get the higher grades on top paper and only first two sets really sat higher.

That's not new either - friend of mine at secondary in 90s sitting GCSE was in third group was put on a paper that capped highest score at C - she did really well but they wouldn't let her take maths A-level as she hadn't been taught the higher content - it was pain for her as degree she wanted often specified maths a-level so resticted her choices.

I know boards very hugely and school attitudes vary but sitting higher papers in lower sets is very unsual base on DC and DN and their mates experiences especially in a comprehsive school like OP DD in. It's probably less unusal in any sort of selective school.

It could well be a Sparx issue - they switched to it for DD2 and she lasted longest in her year with it but it was not a helpful peice of software at the time.

I would ring or e-mail again today becuase it is so close to half term - and politely ask what going on - is she suddenly struggling or is there an error in setting.

I would if she stays in the lowest set - do extra maths either on-line with you or with an external turtor at home so she doesn't fall behind and that becomes a reason to keep her in lower sets later on.

Sartre · 22/10/2026 11:01

Yes chase it and I’d call the office too. It’s obviously an administrative error.

Longtimelurker1980 · 22/10/2026 10:59

ReevesJeeves · 21/10/2026 21:17

I haven’t had a reply today, should I chase tomorrow? It’s their last day before half term.

Let us know what happens op!

WearyAuldWumman · 22/10/2026 10:42

CatSquirrelDuck · 22/10/2026 10:24

Yes, chase it. You want it sorted before they go back after half term.

Agreed. The sooner this is dealt with, the better.