Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to end a 30 year friendship over sparklers?

729 replies

Wotsitsbreath · 18/10/2026 17:50

I’ve known my friend for over 30 years, we both have children of similar ages (one secondary, one primary and then she has one younger as well). We’ve always been really close and take the kids out together at least once a month as well as meeting just us two. One thing I’ve noticed recently is that our parenting styles are different and it’s causing me to resent her. I am hyper organised with my children. If we are out then I have snacks, spare clothes, baby wipes, wellies in the car etc. she’s much more of a laid back go with the flow kind of parent. The issue is, her kids need these things, so she’s increasingly just young my stuff!
We went to the beach, she didn’t bring anything for her kids to play with, so they took my kids toys. Not an issue, mine are good at sharing, but one of my son’s favourite spades (don’t ask, he’s autistic and gets attached!) got broken. We went to the arcade and she had no change so I had to give them some of our change. We went to the cinema, she didn’t bring or buy snacks, so her kids share mine. I’ve started taking extras to cover what she doesn’t so my kids don’t miss out. To be clear, she’s not struggling, she has a nice house, nice car and does several foreign holidays a year. Even when I remind her, she accidentally forgets or runs out of time.

And the next issue- bonfire night is coming up. We always walk to the local display together. I’ve been to the shop today and bought sparklers. I bought three packs, partner asked why so many and I realised that she never remembers to bring her own. I texted her and told her where they’re on sale and she made a joke about how she always forgets to buy them. It can’t be an accident, she just doesn’t bother, so I have to buy extras as her kids just expect me to provide them. She never does. It’s really upset me. She’s much better off than I am, has more children and I’m basically supplementing her income by buying for her kids as well as mine.

So, if you’ve got this far, would I be unreasonable to take a step back from the friendship if she doesn’t bring sparklers this year? I can’t say no to her kids, that’s punishing them for her mistakes and that feels cruel. But it’s something that’s really upsetting me now I’ve realised it’s happening.

OP posts:
Newname26 · 19/10/2026 09:05

ToKittyornottoKitty · 19/10/2026 08:35

A sparkler properly shoved in by an adult will be far more secure than a kids hand in a slippy glove.

A carrot 🥕 only removes part of the danger, the child who's holding the sparklers hand getting burnt.

It doesn't remove the risk of someone walking into the child or another child getting in the way of the very hot stick they are waving around.

Nor does it get round the issue of what do you do with the hot metal rod once its burnt, they stay hot for hours.
Its well documented that kids get burnt by trying to pick up burnt sparklers from the ground that are still hot.

ItsCloudyToday · 19/10/2026 08:59

It might be that she can be disorganised, doesn’t see snacks for the cinema or change for the arcade as essential or that she doesn’t agree with the OP’s parenting style - which are all fine.

However, in any of those cases she shouldn’t be allowing her children to take from others without being reciprocal in some way. If she doesn’t want her children having snacks, then they don’t have them. If she doesn’t want them spending money in the arcade, she doesn’t let them. She can’t say it’s ok to do only at the cost of someone else 🤷🏻‍♀️

Aliceintheattic · 19/10/2026 08:57

Just read second op post. You say "she just needs to tell her kids they can't have my kids stuff". Yes, this is true, but can you see that you have put her in a tricky situation? Inadvertently set her up for an upset child?

I hate sparklers at these types of events. They are a nusiance. Faffing around with ensuring safety. But if you are going with her, and bring them, it's much harder for her to say no to them without ruining the event for her and her child.

Aliceintheattic · 19/10/2026 08:47

Moonnstarz · 18/10/2026 20:24

Those people who are suggesting maybe she doesn't take these things because she doesn't need them are ignoring that the children may like them. If she disagrees with snacks at the cinema then she needs to say to her children when @Wotsitsbreath gives hers the treats, sorry we aren't having snacks at the cinema today, you have dinner waiting for you when we get home. The same with the arcade. She needs to say to her kids I don't have any change and I am not getting any because we are saving that money for when we do xyz.
The reason she probably doesn't do this is because she is being cheeky and knows her children will be covered by @Wotsitsbreath and she is happy to let her fund it knowing she will feel guilty if the children do a sad face.
@Wotsitsbreath needs to be firm when these things happen and just say there is a change machine if your children want to join in the arcades, it takes cards, or no snacks today? We don't have any spares.
I think as she is constantly given the items she knows not to bother.

I agree that the friend needs to speak up, but it can be tricky, and I can understand why someone might let it slide.

It can be hard to say "no, you don't need snacks for a 90 minute movie" to a primary aged child when their friend has sweets, without ruining the whole experience.

It can also be hard to do this without sounding really negative and judgemental.

MummyJ36 · 19/10/2026 08:46

I would genuinely do an experiment, and the next time you see her don’t bring anything. Make it a short trip so you’re not unduly upsetting the kids but just don’t bring anything and see what she does!

ToKittyornottoKitty · 19/10/2026 08:35

GoodChocolate · 19/10/2026 08:27

I think the carrot thing sounds dangerous. The carrot isnt going to grip a thin piece of medal very tightly like a hand would. Once the kid starts waving it about,the sparkler might fly out.

A sparkler properly shoved in by an adult will be far more secure than a kids hand in a slippy glove.

GoodChocolate · 19/10/2026 08:27

NiftyKoala · 18/10/2026 21:43

I've never heard of the carrot trick. This is absolutely genius!

I think the carrot thing sounds dangerous. The carrot isnt going to grip a thin piece of medal very tightly like a hand would. Once the kid starts waving it about,the sparkler might fly out.

Aliceintheattic · 19/10/2026 08:15

It does sound like she is being cheeky, however;

I am the "laid back" one, and I am wondering if all this is really necessary?

I hate it when my " organised" friends overdo snacks. I don't want my kids having snacks all the time, but if they see other kids eating biscuits, they want them!

I also don't want to take a pile of plastic rubbish / sparklers etc everywhere I go. But if you bring these things, the other kids will want them.

Perhaps you need more direct discussion before events about who is bringing what?

Orders76 · 19/10/2026 08:11

Bobbie12345678 · 19/10/2026 01:09

I have a friend who could have said similar of me when the kids were young. She might have said I was a CF. The other side is that I sometimes found her rather over the top.

She was always bringing out home made cookies (when we were meeting soon after lunch), juice boxes for everyone (when we were at a park with a water fountain), hand sanitiser (because we were about to eat the cookies, but hey, if you hadn’t brought the cookies you wouldn’t need the clean hands)
I wouldn’t have loved my kids hanging out at the arcade and in that situation might have said I had no money even if I did (then rolled my eyes if she had started handing out cash to mine as well as hers).

I had no desire to start trying to level up and parent how she did, so would just smile sweetly and tell my kids to say thank you. My take on it was if she didn’t want to bring it she really didn’t need to.

When she wasn’t around my kids and I had a different sort of day that in many ways I preferred ( hence why I parented like that).

I am not saying this is you, but it might be.
You have different styles so maybe the friendship fades while you are in this stage.
Maybe it comes back again later when life isn’t all about managing small kids.
But no, I wouldn’t end a 30 year friendship over it.

Edited

Agree and was going to say similar, maybe do a few events with nothing. A walk on the beach or in the woods, trip to playground and just don't bring anything.

Newname26 · 19/10/2026 08:06

WheresMyHatGone · 19/10/2026 07:39

A young child at a local display a couple of years ago got horrific facial burns after another child was waving a sparkler around and accidentally caught them.
Now banned at our village display.

Oh no!

I don't think people realise how hot they actually get.
1000deg C seriously you just wouldn't give a small child a hot coffee to hold at a fraction of that temperature. Or let them play with a hot oven yet people happily hand these to small children.

Another risk is people putting the hot spent ones on the ground, and other people often kids picking them up thinking they have been dropped 🫳 and getting burnt that way.

Public displays is not the place for sparklers

Maybe they should say on the packet how hot they actually burn. Make people think. Not just that they are hot, but how hot.

SiegfriedSassoon · 19/10/2026 07:59

WheresMyHatGone · 19/10/2026 07:39

A young child at a local display a couple of years ago got horrific facial burns after another child was waving a sparkler around and accidentally caught them.
Now banned at our village display.

I agree with this. We only do sparklers in our garden at home. I can keep my lot under control but how can I risk access everyone elses random kids who are possibly not even being supervised.

BeatrizBoniface · 19/10/2026 07:49

AralVorkosigan · 19/10/2026 07:45

Yes you’re right, I’d love to be able to be really clear and direct without getting flustered or anxious about it, unfortunately that’s a hard skill to learn! I’ve been on mumsnet for donkeys years and have often thought that MNHQ should run some kind of “polite assertiveness” course, a lot of us on here would benefit from it.

Ah, I learned to do it, but that's after decades as a teacher in non selective state secondary schools! Not just the students, but as a pastoral lead and dealing with parents! It is a skill, I understand that not everyone finds it easy!
Friends always get me to return things to shops or complain in restaurants...

AralVorkosigan · 19/10/2026 07:45

BeatrizBoniface · 19/10/2026 07:35

I do understand what you're saying, @AralVorkosigan and going nuclear is rarely a good solution, you're right, a 30 year friendship is something. Either this woman has changed or she's always been like that. I still think that a direct conversation would benefit, although I know that's easier said than done!

Yes you’re right, I’d love to be able to be really clear and direct without getting flustered or anxious about it, unfortunately that’s a hard skill to learn! I’ve been on mumsnet for donkeys years and have often thought that MNHQ should run some kind of “polite assertiveness” course, a lot of us on here would benefit from it.

WheresMyHatGone · 19/10/2026 07:39

LemonRedwood · 18/10/2026 18:20

Why is it unreasonable to take sparklers to a display?

A young child at a local display a couple of years ago got horrific facial burns after another child was waving a sparkler around and accidentally caught them.
Now banned at our village display.

Sartre · 19/10/2026 07:35

Well it’s a classic case of weaponised incompetence. She doesn’t need to remember any of this shit because you always will.

BeatrizBoniface · 19/10/2026 07:35

I do understand what you're saying, @AralVorkosigan and going nuclear is rarely a good solution, you're right, a 30 year friendship is something. Either this woman has changed or she's always been like that. I still think that a direct conversation would benefit, although I know that's easier said than done!

AralVorkosigan · 19/10/2026 07:31

Yes @BeatrizBoniface you may be right, I’m trying to give the benefit of the doubt to the friend as it’s a 30 year friendship, so OP would probably have noticed before now if she’s just an all round selfish taker!

In my experience people can get into patterns without really thinking about it or analysing it. So not consciously thinking “I don’t need to pack snacks, Wotsits will bring snacks for my children”, but also not really thinking about snacks because you’re meeting Wotsits and you’ve never needed to bring snacks when you meet Wotsits so snacks don’t even occur to you. Does that make sense?

And yes you can go nuclear (“you never bring snacks! Obviously you’re assuming I’ll feed your kids and I’m sick of it!”) or you can state but in a polite way that you’re not going to be providing snacks, which is less awkward and may save the friendship.

Of course it may not save the friendship in which case I agree going for the nuclear option or just cutting ties is all you have left.

BeatrizBoniface · 19/10/2026 07:25

In all honesty, @AralVorkosigan, that's too subtle for someone like this. I know you're trying to be kind, but the OP can't hide behind her DC. Something has to change and she's going to have to be direct.
It could be that this friend has serious money problems, it could be that she is just a CF, but the OP needs to talk to her and be very clear.

AralVorkosigan · 19/10/2026 07:16

Ah I’ve read your reply now, and yes I am leaning towards her being cheeky/having got used to the idea of you providing things! I don’t know whether she’s actually selfish/a taker or if she’s just being a bit oblivious and has not questioned the pattern she’s got in to with you.

It sounds like you’ve tried prompting her/dropping hints that she’s ignoring or not picking up on.

So as a next step I think you’ll have to be direct, but if you’re finding that uncomfortable (and I know a lot of people do!) you could try sort of hiding it behind speaking up for your kids?

Can you just say to her “your kids always ask to share my kids snacks and toys, and of course my kids normally like to share with their friends, but they’re getting frustrated that they’re not getting to eat their whole snacks and play with their own toys, especially as their toys get broken sometimes. So from now on I think it’s best if we each bring our own snacks and toys”.

And then pack snacks that are obviously single serving rather than for sharing (like a whole apple rather than a bag of apple slices, a single muffin not some sweets for example).

And if her kids then ask to share you can intervene and say “oh no that one’s just for X, ask your mum what she brought for you.”

Would that be a more comfortable first step? If she then continues and her kids keep asking then you’d have to either start pulling back from the friendship or have a direct conversation.

OrangeSlices998 · 19/10/2026 05:23

If her kids genuinely don’t need a snack I wouldn’t, as the parent who didn’t bring one, let my kids ASK the children to share their snacks and then watch them eat someone else’s food. I’d be intervening at that point and diverting attention elsewhere - doesn’t sound like OPs friend is doing that.

MysticalStatistical · 19/10/2026 04:36

I’d start promoting her ahead of meeting with “I think it’s your turn to bring….”

TheBlueKoala · 19/10/2026 04:21

Thirteenblackcats · 18/10/2026 21:44

Oh yeah and I agree with the snacks thing mentioned above.. My kids don’t need constant grazing they will wait for a meal if we’re out and about.

Edited

Where did OP mention that her kids were "constantly grazing"?
For young children a snack between lunch and dinner can be essential if they are physically active. Prevents them from being hangry. Also, a snack can be a fruit or whatever you want so not necessarily unhealthy.

mathanxiety · 19/10/2026 04:18

Are you sure her life is as peachy as you think it is?

Does she have access to money? Does she have to have expenses - even small ones - approved by her H or partner?

I'd continue to share - all of your examples are small potatoes, apart from the favourite spade. Even added up, you're talking about small amounts of money and items you'd buy or bring anyway.

theearthsayshello · 19/10/2026 03:18

She's a cheeky cow. Couldn't be bothered with her at all.

HoppityBun · 19/10/2026 03:04

Kokonimater · 19/10/2026 02:56

Sorry, I don’t know what that means

Read The Thread

Many public fireworks displays forbid people to take sparklers.

Sparklers are often thought of as being safe, but they generate heat levels comparable to a welding torch, 20 x temperature of boiling water.

It is recommended that sparklers are not given to under-5s.

  • Make sure everyone who handles sparklers wears gloves.
  • Sparklers should be held at arm’s length while being lit and only light one at a time.
  • Don’t wave sparklers around close to other people
  • Never hold a baby in your arms while you’re holding a sparkler.
  • When the sparkler has burned out, place it, hot end down, in a bucket of cold water or sand and leave it there for several hours – they stay hot for a long time. They’re highly dangerous because they remain burning hot even when they look as though they’ve cooled.
Swipe left for the next trending thread