Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to end a 30 year friendship over sparklers?

729 replies

Wotsitsbreath · 18/10/2026 17:50

I’ve known my friend for over 30 years, we both have children of similar ages (one secondary, one primary and then she has one younger as well). We’ve always been really close and take the kids out together at least once a month as well as meeting just us two. One thing I’ve noticed recently is that our parenting styles are different and it’s causing me to resent her. I am hyper organised with my children. If we are out then I have snacks, spare clothes, baby wipes, wellies in the car etc. she’s much more of a laid back go with the flow kind of parent. The issue is, her kids need these things, so she’s increasingly just young my stuff!
We went to the beach, she didn’t bring anything for her kids to play with, so they took my kids toys. Not an issue, mine are good at sharing, but one of my son’s favourite spades (don’t ask, he’s autistic and gets attached!) got broken. We went to the arcade and she had no change so I had to give them some of our change. We went to the cinema, she didn’t bring or buy snacks, so her kids share mine. I’ve started taking extras to cover what she doesn’t so my kids don’t miss out. To be clear, she’s not struggling, she has a nice house, nice car and does several foreign holidays a year. Even when I remind her, she accidentally forgets or runs out of time.

And the next issue- bonfire night is coming up. We always walk to the local display together. I’ve been to the shop today and bought sparklers. I bought three packs, partner asked why so many and I realised that she never remembers to bring her own. I texted her and told her where they’re on sale and she made a joke about how she always forgets to buy them. It can’t be an accident, she just doesn’t bother, so I have to buy extras as her kids just expect me to provide them. She never does. It’s really upset me. She’s much better off than I am, has more children and I’m basically supplementing her income by buying for her kids as well as mine.

So, if you’ve got this far, would I be unreasonable to take a step back from the friendship if she doesn’t bring sparklers this year? I can’t say no to her kids, that’s punishing them for her mistakes and that feels cruel. But it’s something that’s really upsetting me now I’ve realised it’s happening.

OP posts:
AralVorkosigan · 19/10/2026 15:36

AnonyMumAuDHD · 19/10/2026 14:43

It’s not that complicated - a bottle of water in her bag can be used to douse them and then they can be taken home and disposed of there.

If you just put a sparkler out, it will still stay hot enough to burn people for several hours. It has to be fully submerged in water or sand for hours in order to be safe according to the fire service guidelines.

AtIusvue · 19/10/2026 15:24

Perhaps she doesn’t need to create, cater to and curate, every moment with her kids.

Kids can go to the beach without plastic toys- theres water to play in, shells to hunt for, looking for crabs in rock pools etc

Kids can you to view the fireworks, without having their own sparklers.

If she was ASKING you to pay for her kids, provide snacks etc then you would have a point. But at the moment you’re playing the role of smug mum, who’s thought of absolutely everything….even for someone else’s kids.

Just drop it. You don’t have to provide anything, you don’t have to feel guilty if you see her kids without, you don’t have to be the martyr

Newname26 · 19/10/2026 15:20

AnonyMumAuDHD · 19/10/2026 14:43

It’s not that complicated - a bottle of water in her bag can be used to douse them and then they can be taken home and disposed of there.

You try it first and let me know how you get on.

I wouldn't want to try putting a bit of metal at a 1000°C into a plastic water bottle, with a tiny opening. If your going to try it maybe use a metal flask.

Imseriouslyyouguys · 19/10/2026 15:12

Yabu to just end the friendship.

Yanbu to object to her behaviour.

You need to speak to her about it. Say “this has been bothering me for a long time and it’s now built up to the point I need to say something. I’ve been providing for your kids as well as my own for a long time (give her all the examples you’ve given here). I can’t continue to do this with all take and no give because it’s not fair on me. Please can you make sure you remember your own sparklers for the fireworks and either make sure you bring your own stuff on future trips or not expect me to provide things when you forget”.

If she then doesn’t change, yes drop the friendship.

BoredZelda · 19/10/2026 15:11

Lampsandlightsandotherthings · 19/10/2026 12:50

It Would be unfair to frame this as sparklers break the friendship
not says you are wrong or unkind
but stand up for yourself ! If you keep giving resentfully but seemingly with free will, she is not a mind reader, a piss taker maybe.
I suspect it’s not the cost on the surface either. A baby wipe here, or biscuit there; it’s the expectation to continue carrying the mental and physical and financial load for a capable adult.
I get that ! Completely. It’s piss taking for adults, let alone long standing friends to see you as a facilitator for their kids needs.
However… give the gal a chance to put things right. Ghosting people ignoring people whilst silently seething, is silly. You allowed your end of this unfortunate dynamic. If you value her as a person, ignoring this issue, she is worth taking aside and saying listen lady, organise your kids, I’m a push over so I help with this and that,. But I ve had enough … or whatever you feel like saying to her

That’s not what’s happening though. OP is berating her friend for not having the same mental load as her, even though there is absolutely no proof she wants or need this stuff for her children.

I have an autistic child and when she was younger I carried all sorts of crap I knew I would need to avoid meltdowns. I was the parent with the magic bag that catered for every eventuality. When I was with other parents it never once occurred to me I was expected to provide anything from my magic bag, nor that they should have brought their own. If the other children wanted something my daughter had, I would just say “no, that’s hers” and let the parents deal with it. Making yourself a martyr then complaining other parents don’t do what you do is a weird thing to do.

BoredZelda · 19/10/2026 14:58

You don’t have to share any of this stuff with her children, you are making that choice. Her kids won’t starve without snacks. They won’t be harmed by not having sparklers. Just hand your kids the stuff and let her worry about her kids.

Lemieux7 · 19/10/2026 14:50

When I was a child my parents had ‘friends’ like this who never brought stuff for their children so they’d take mine and it pissed me off. I really resented it.

Im sure it gets to your children. And YANBU to step back from the friendship because she’s sponging off you.

Insense · 19/10/2026 14:49

Wotsitsbreath · 19/10/2026 13:40

A few people have said this, so I’m not picking on you spherically :) but if we’ve agreed to meet at an arcade and then walk on the beach, then she has the option to skip the arcade, or bring money? She didn’t do either in this particular situation.
also people saying about constant snacks. That’s not what’s happening. When we go to the cinema I bring snacks, I think that’s reasonable? I usually bring or buy water for the kids if they’re thirsty and we are out for a walk or bike ride, again, I don’t think that’s unreasonable?
as I’ve said, one of my kids is autistic so I definitely over plan to avoid a meltdown, but I’m not forcing this onto her and her kids. Just providing for mine (and by extension hers).

OP, you're tweaking the info a bit. You said initially that you 'went to the arcade,' now it's that you had planned to actually meet at the arcade. Was it just a meeting place for the beach walk? Did your friend expect that you'd be going in? You also made a a fairly big thing out of all the 'hyper organised' things you do, now it's a snack at the cinema and a bottle of water on a bike ride.

These aren't necessarily big departures, but a very gentle tweaking of the language that makes your friend appear a little bit more unreasonable.

You haven't addressed the posts asking about the previous 20-odd years of friendship, when I assume your friend wasn't a total loser/user freeloader?

I would probably end the friendship, on the basis that for whatever reason, you're happy to have a bunch of people call your friend names, rather than expand on the wider friendship dynamics and her character away from wipes and sparklers. I'm not sure that amounts to a terrific friendship anyway, and your parenting styles seem to cause this friction.

But if you do decide to talk to her, maybe take on board the list of comments where people have urged you to consider that she finds your parenting hard to manage and frustrating. Her side of all of this would probably be enlightening.

Creamteasandbumblebees · 19/10/2026 14:47

Just stop, you are enabling her behaviour.
Next time "sorry xxxx I don't have any spare snacks/food/sparklers/money etc..I only bought enough for what we need" I bet a few times of her kids going without and she'll soon start 'remembering'

Jimmyjumpy · 19/10/2026 14:45

If she is a good friend show her your post!

AnonyMumAuDHD · 19/10/2026 14:43

Newname26 · 19/10/2026 12:47

How are you safely disposing of sparklers at a public display?

Are you holding on to them, with the risk someone walks or bumps into you?

Are you putting them on the ground with the risk a child will pick them up while still roasting hot?

Are you actually taking a bucket 🪣?
Remember they stay hot for hours.

Edited

It’s not that complicated - a bottle of water in her bag can be used to douse them and then they can be taken home and disposed of there.

AssortedWords · 19/10/2026 14:41

It’s illegal to burn sparklers in a public place.

Stepsisterfromhell · 19/10/2026 14:39

It sounds like you are just different personalities and you are much organised than her. If you want to stay friends, can't you just say to her that you realise she often forgets things - give examples of snacks, water, sparklers, etc - and you are happy to cover and bring them along but it would be nice if she could make a financial contribution as you can't afford to supply them all the time. She could pay half of all trip outgoings? This is what I would do but I would not even consider ditching a friend over this, so I wonder whether you just don't want to be friends with her anymore and are looking for an out. If you don't wan't to be friends anymore, just slow fade or tell her directly.

Dogmum6 · 19/10/2026 14:38

What would she say if you messaged and said you had bought enough for all of you? Would she offer to pay? If a friend kept doing this for me (which tbh has happened in the past 🙈) I would be paying for them. Maybe even all of them to make up for stuff I've forgotten In the past.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 19/10/2026 14:34

Insense · 19/10/2026 11:28

Exactly. One person's 'hyper organised' is another parent's 'oh God, here comes the avalanche of unnecessary snacks/toys/whatever again.'

You've been friends for 30 years, OP. As I said upthread, if she a CF freeloading user, you'd have clocked it long before you both had kids.

Have you considered the possibility that she's repeatedly NOT bringing snacks/plastic toys/extras because she doesn't want her kids having them?

When they do stuff without you, they probably manage very happily without the boot full of everything, and the friend doesn't want to suddenly start producing all this stuff JUST because she knows you're going to?

But then, it's really awkward, because her kids see the mountain of stuff your kids are used to, and kids are kids, and she doesn't want to sound critical of your way of parenting.

Maybe she'll start her own thread about not wanting to meet up anymore because she's constantly dreading the boot of everything opening and her kids mithering for stuff that she thinks is completely unnecessary! Grin

Yes i agree with this. At first I thought she was being unfair but now I think its more likely this. There she is at the cinema, everyone happy and out comes your snack bag and suddenly her kids are wanting some and she has to either choose to have a big public argument with her kids or just let them share. It might be worth asking her straight up if she preferred if you didn't bring snacks at all and see what she says. I'm probably somewhere between the two of you, I'd hate someone taking my stuff all the time but at the same time I'd be thinking 'ffs here we go again..' if someone constantly arrived with bags of highly organised stuff that creates issues with the kids.

Serene135 · 19/10/2026 13:58

In some friendships there are givers (who give more in the friendship than their fair share; the takers who are happy to take more that their fair share (in some cases to save money and grow their own wealth); and the equal friendships where friends give and take in fairly equal measures. It sounds like OP’s friendship is fairly unbalanced. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to provide children with something to eat and drink at the cinema, for example. Some take their own food/drink and others buy at the venue. It sounds like the friend likes the fact that OP saves the friend money and is happy to take all the extras - food, drink etc. OP, why don’t you get your kids their own little mini backpacks. Fill their little bags with their food/drink so it is clear that anything you have brought is for your children.

YourLoudEagle · 19/10/2026 13:56

She is so laid back as she has a friend organising everything for her. You are not her PA. I would just stop compensating. Sorry, that's Xs spade, I only have enough snacks for mine etc. If her kids get upset, that is on her. But I would have a conversation with her if you are good friends.

SparkleHorse82 · 19/10/2026 13:54

ChildrenOfTheQuorn · 18/10/2026 17:58

Exactly. Talk about throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Put on your big girl pants and have a proper conversation with her rather than this dramatic "taking a step back" nonsense.

Well said.

I bet she’s not a total CF or you would have noticed years ago. She’s probably just extremely disorganised/type B and you are very type A. There’s no right way to parent. No child died because their mum forgot snacks. You sound a little superior here tbh.

Insense · 19/10/2026 13:54

OP, you've seen the posters asking if this is different parenting styles, and she might be feel equally frustrated with your way of doing things?

You can see people calling your friend some pretty harsh names. Does she really deserve them? You were friends for 20-odd years before having children. Wouldn't you have clocked her user/freeloading/cheapskate tendencies earlier?

I honestly think it sounds as though she simply does not WANT to furnish her kids with toys/snacks/extras the whole time when they're out, but when you're around, her kids suddenly want all this stuff. They probably manage very happily without it all when they're not with you.

I think you should absolutely have an honest chat with her if you're finding it intolerable, but you might need to brace for her own POV on it. Steaming in with 'buy your own snacks for now on, Doris, stop nicking OURS' might be a little counterproductive.

EvieBB · 19/10/2026 13:51

Wotsitsbreath · 19/10/2026 13:40

A few people have said this, so I’m not picking on you spherically :) but if we’ve agreed to meet at an arcade and then walk on the beach, then she has the option to skip the arcade, or bring money? She didn’t do either in this particular situation.
also people saying about constant snacks. That’s not what’s happening. When we go to the cinema I bring snacks, I think that’s reasonable? I usually bring or buy water for the kids if they’re thirsty and we are out for a walk or bike ride, again, I don’t think that’s unreasonable?
as I’ve said, one of my kids is autistic so I definitely over plan to avoid a meltdown, but I’m not forcing this onto her and her kids. Just providing for mine (and by extension hers).

Ignore the anti snack brigade. I always brought (healthy) snacks and water when mine were little. It saved me a fortune and also my sanity from any meltdowns. Good to be organised. You're doing great. Hope your friends gets the message! 🙏

ToKittyornottoKitty · 19/10/2026 13:47

Newname26 · 19/10/2026 13:13

I didn't see a post saying you wouldn't taken them.
The post I replied to said you'd supervise kids to avoid them hurting themselves or others.

Actually the post you replied to was me saying the carrot is more secure than a small child wearing a glove if done properly. I previously said I wouldn’t take them to a firework display as they’re just unnecessary when already at an event.

Wotsitsbreath · 19/10/2026 13:41

I also never realised there were so many issues with sparklers! Just to add- in my specific circumstance, they have a bucket for sparklers to be put in when they’ve been used. It is a small local display in a landowners field so no one would consider leaving mess that could harm the animals later

OP posts:
Wotsitsbreath · 19/10/2026 13:40

Aliceintheattic · 19/10/2026 09:18

True, but have you tried saying "no" to an arcade when a kid's friends are getting to play? Sometimes we have to, but sometimes discretion is the better part of valour.

Yes, OP's friend should be "making good" the money, but it irks to be continualy forking out for stuff you didn't really want your kids to have in the first place.

Edited

A few people have said this, so I’m not picking on you spherically :) but if we’ve agreed to meet at an arcade and then walk on the beach, then she has the option to skip the arcade, or bring money? She didn’t do either in this particular situation.
also people saying about constant snacks. That’s not what’s happening. When we go to the cinema I bring snacks, I think that’s reasonable? I usually bring or buy water for the kids if they’re thirsty and we are out for a walk or bike ride, again, I don’t think that’s unreasonable?
as I’ve said, one of my kids is autistic so I definitely over plan to avoid a meltdown, but I’m not forcing this onto her and her kids. Just providing for mine (and by extension hers).

OP posts:
HeyThereDelila · 19/10/2026 13:30

YANBU. She’s not a friend, she’s a freeloader.

Disorganised my foot- she’s a cheapskate more like. What kind of parent doesn’t take beach stuff or snacks out with them on a day at the beach?

Wonderfrau · 19/10/2026 13:28

I’m loving the posts that are suggesting, maybe she has ADHD or maybe you should send her a text to remind her, or maybe she is struggling financially, or maybe her husband is controlling?

Maybe, just maybe, she doesn’t agree with OPs parenting style either, but is too polite and values the friendship to not pull OP up on it.

We are not talking about a friend who fails to feed, clothe or emotionally support her children. There is a strong possibility that this lady doesn’t agree with all the, in her view, greedy and unnecessary consumption and baggage that the OP gives to her children.

If my super organised 🙄 friend text me to remind me to bring, in my view, unnecessary junk for my chidren, I’d eventually tell her to fuck right off. I’d hope that this wouldn’t be necessary though, as I would have already had multiple meet ups where I did not subscribe to this nonsense, even though she did, and I tried to spare her embarrassment by saying I’d forgotten. I would not want my friend of 30 years to feel so judged.

All the hand wringing on here about the friend’s children being upset that they didn’t get a sparkler, sweets, snacks etc. Do people really try and give their kids absolutely everything that they see others having? Don’t they ever say no to their children? That must be exhausting. Are their children any happier or are they actually less resilient, as when they grow up they struggle to understand why they can’t have everything? Some people are even suggesting that friend is failing to provide for her children!

OP.

  • Are you really providing extra bags of sweets for friend’s children or do your children simply offer the friend’s children a dip? So, do your friend’s children have one/two sweets from your child’s bag, or are they asking your children to divide the sweets out equally.
  • Do they take your children’s drinks from them, or are you providing extra?
  • Are friend’s children taking your children’s sparklers off them or are you giving them extra?
  • Sharing toys is a non issue unless they are taking the toys away from yours and playing alone/separately, but you could ask her children to help carry/ pack them up if they are playing with your children.
  • You haven’t said that you are out eating lunch and friend does not provide food for her children. Is this often the case, or is it just snacks in between meals that are not given?

Blimey, don’t let my relatively balanced and happy children read this thread!