Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
InterIgnis · 06/10/2026 21:49

Loopylambs · 06/10/2026 21:39

I can’t imagine the horror, the victims Mother has gone through for all these years .Not just her Daughters life but hers and other family members ruined. How can you judge her actions? Maybe some sort of closure ? We don’t know how we would react in situations. All those years of uncertainty and pain . You’re repulsed at the punishment whereas others are repulsed by what happened to the victim.

Yeah, that was a wild statement to me too. May Martinez had to see her daughter’s decapitated skull passed around the courtroom, in pieces because Christa Pike had literally broken her head apart. She had to hear about how her child was tortured and carved into for the best part of an hour before she died. Colleen Slemmer had over 300 knife wounds to her body, and her throat had been cut multiple times. She went to see Christa Pike legally executed, in a manner she was led to believe was going to be quick and humane. There is no comparison between the two.

In the name of empathy for Christa Pike, the PP has demonstrated a complete lack of it for the actual victims in this case. Even the most vehement and vocal death penalty opponents have been careful not to say anything approaching that, because even if they privately felt that way, expressing it would only hurt their cause.

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:47

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 21:46

Wait, what? She said she had already done it?! When, where, what time???

Yes! See her posts of 21.15 and 21.21.

DevastatingFinish · 06/10/2026 21:47

Of course I would. I find it chilling there’s those who wouldn’t.

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 21:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Wait, what? She said she had already done it?! When, where, what time???

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 21:44

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:16

Go on then, how did you defend your children? 🤣

Edited

😂

Blankitout · 06/10/2026 21:43

Loopylambs · 06/10/2026 21:39

I can’t imagine the horror, the victims Mother has gone through for all these years .Not just her Daughters life but hers and other family members ruined. How can you judge her actions? Maybe some sort of closure ? We don’t know how we would react in situations. All those years of uncertainty and pain . You’re repulsed at the punishment whereas others are repulsed by what happened to the victim.

Of course I'm repulsed by what happened to the victim!
Just because I don't believe in capital punishment doesn't mean to say I don't also abhor murder and violence!

Periperi2025 · 06/10/2026 21:43

I think i would be capable of killing someone if they delibrately or neglectfully killed my DD, but i don't think i'd be capable of active mass murder of inocents to save her.

I was watching a holocaust film recenlty and reflecting on it after and thinking, the decisions I would have made to protect and save others at the risk to myself would change now compared to when i was young and childfree as I would prioritise the protection of my own DD form torture and murder.

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Loopylambs · 06/10/2026 21:39

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

I can’t imagine the horror, the victims Mother has gone through for all these years .Not just her Daughters life but hers and other family members ruined. How can you judge her actions? Maybe some sort of closure ? We don’t know how we would react in situations. All those years of uncertainty and pain . You’re repulsed at the punishment whereas others are repulsed by what happened to the victim.

ThatLilacTiger · 06/10/2026 21:30

You don't want to know how far I'd go to save my children. Only them, though.

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 06/10/2026 21:29

I would do virtually anything for my children. But would consider doing anything for money if the price was right. Starting at about £10 million.

Any offers?

Cailleach1 · 06/10/2026 21:27

Goatsarebest · 06/10/2026 20:10

According to the Book of Genesis Noha took his wife and three sons and their wives and let literally everyone else in the world drown. So that's equivalent today of 8 billion deaths to save your family. That's a high bar set by Noha.
Goats get saved, so I'm comfortable with this.

But Noah himself didn’t cause the flood which killed everyone else. He uniquely got the tip off, that the Big Boss on High was going to press the fatal flood button, and Noah was able to save himself, kin, and non human creatures. Is God the baddie in this scenario?

Well, now that changes the lay of the land a bit. Instead of ‘what would Jesus do?’, it’s a bit of an ethical dilemma if you ask ‘what would God do?’ ‘Press the button, of course’ might just be the straightforward answer.

Agree about goats. They always look so much fun, and not a little mischievous. A nanny and a billy near me had two kids about a year ago. The little family are still together. They have a lovely big field, and places to shelter. Their owners have a picnic table, and they love jumping up on it.

elm26 · 06/10/2026 21:25

For my children, without hesitation.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 21:24

The netmums takeover is complete 😂

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 21:24

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:21

So you killed people for your children?

No I did not but I defended them . But again people died so it’s not something I’m bringing here. .

namechangetheworld · 06/10/2026 21:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 06/10/2026 21:22

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:41

Well what actually inspired it was reflecting on the limitations (or lack thereof) of the national welfare state (any nation that has one). You can help 10,000 people from another country and refuse at least some lifesaving but expensive treatments or services domestically or you can do the opposite. Someone is going to die in either situation and you have the power to choose who. You're actually choosing whether you press the button or not.

I was just curious about who would rather the strangers or the loved one. It might have been a better example if I'd said one stranger to save a loved one, on reflection.

This is a very poor and contentious example. Is this thread just a click bait?

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:21

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 21:21

Not the post for it and it’s identifiable by the event . It’s not funny by the way people died , it’s not something I wish on anyone . I’m not replying to you anymore , for someone claiming a higher moral ground you should maybe not laugh about children in danger .

So you killed people for your children?

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 21:21

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:16

Go on then, how did you defend your children? 🤣

Edited

Not the post for it and it’s identifiable by the event . It’s not funny by the way people died , it’s not something I wish on anyone . I’m not replying to you anymore , for someone claiming a higher moral ground you should maybe not laugh about children in danger .

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 21:19

BloomingXmas · 06/10/2026 21:18

I would strangle someone with my bare hands for my children

You'd remove your Marigolds recognising the solemnity of the occasion.

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:19

BloomingXmas · 06/10/2026 21:18

I would strangle someone with my bare hands for my children

But would you strangle a chicken with bare hands for a dinner party? That’s the mark of a real,woman.

BloomingXmas · 06/10/2026 21:18

I would strangle someone with my bare hands for my children

nomas · 06/10/2026 21:16

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 21:15

Don’t be ridiculous please just because you don’t agree don’t show how petty and silly you can be ! We dont all love the same way , we don’t all react the same way , we don’t all have the same courage or cold blood . I would do anything to protect my children . I have been in a position where they where in direct danger ( 2 of them not all 4 ) I know fully well how I react and how fast and without hesitation , o know it’s not the norm to everyone and that is fine maybe life took me there . Would I feel bad about killing innocent people ? 100% , would I even question it if the option was to see my children die ? No . And yes it is fine you don’t agree with it . We don’t all have to agree .

Go on then, how did you defend your children? 🤣

iggy azalea GIF by Vevo
nomas · 06/10/2026 21:15

Chocolattecoffeecuppaa · 06/10/2026 21:05

You'd better hope you're not on the other side of that one day

Well, since the chances of @ThatLemonBee having access to a nuclear weapon that would kill 9 billion people is practically zero,I don’t think we need to ‘hope’ for anything except not to cross paths with people who think like this.

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 21:15

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 21:08

I don’t think loving your loved ones unconditionally is abnormal in any way .

Your post where you said you'd kill nine billion people with your bare hands is though.

hint: only 8.3 billion on the planet, so good look with that hun!

Don’t be ridiculous please just because you don’t agree don’t show how petty and silly you can be ! We dont all love the same way , we don’t all react the same way , we don’t all have the same courage or cold blood . I would do anything to protect my children . I have been in a position where they where in direct danger ( 2 of them not all 4 ) I know fully well how I react and how fast and without hesitation , o know it’s not the norm to everyone and that is fine maybe life took me there . Would I feel bad about killing innocent people ? 100% , would I even question it if the option was to see my children die ? No . And yes it is fine you don’t agree with it . We don’t all have to agree .

Swipe left for the next trending thread