Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Hoppinggreen · 07/10/2026 14:59

nomas · 07/10/2026 13:50

How long would your dc last roaming around an empty world with everyone dead.

What a cruel fate to subject them to.

So they would be better dead then?
They are now 17 and 21 so i think they could last quite a long time if they had to

CloudyWithAChanceOfCustard · 07/10/2026 14:58

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

I genuinely don’t understand your answer. How is this comparable in any way…and what has it got to do with the OP’s question?

Many, many families of murder victims in the USA go to watch the execution of the perpetrators. You don’t have to like it…or understand it (I don’t either)…but they obviously have their reasons to be there. It’s still got nothing to do with this thread!!

Blankitout · 07/10/2026 14:48

Clydebuilt · 07/10/2026 14:27

So hide it.

Of course i have the option to hide it.
I also have the more constructive option to leave a comment and give feedback to the OP. WhichI have done

Clydebuilt · 07/10/2026 14:27

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

So hide it.

LostThestral · 07/10/2026 14:16

yes, I would without a second thought

nomas · 07/10/2026 13:50

Hoppinggreen · 07/10/2026 13:46

I don't think that there is any number of people that I would not wipe out to save my DC

How long would your dc last roaming around an empty world with everyone dead.

What a cruel fate to subject them to.

Hoppinggreen · 07/10/2026 13:46

I don't think that there is any number of people that I would not wipe out to save my DC

sunshinestar1986 · 07/10/2026 13:42

Noshowlomo · 07/10/2026 10:29

I totally understand the situation would never actually happen, but why are 10000 strangers more precious to you than your own children?

I would hate to murder innocent people more than I love my children.

nomas · 07/10/2026 12:50

namechangetheworld · 06/10/2026 20:19

Any mother saying no and feigning outrage over this hypothetical situation is a virtue signaler of the highest order.

I'd do it and feel no guilt whatsoever.

Yes, because 'I would kill 9 billion people for my child' is not virtue signalling at all, it's totally objectively possible 🙄

nomas · 07/10/2026 12:46

Goatsarebest · 07/10/2026 09:17

Yes. Agree it's different but it's the nearest actual life event that I know of where someone had to make this sort of decision. It actually had quite profound impacts on both the father and son and, like you say, it was not an active action of ending someone's life, just an omission with consequences. So whilst most are saying they would save their loved one, they might be underestimating the long term consequences of actively causing the death of 10000 children of other people, which is what they are.

Poor man, poor kids, poor every victim and their family.

Real life hits differently and is much more meaningful than a bunch of people saying they would kill '9 billion' people to save their child.

nomas · 07/10/2026 12:41

Noshowlomo · 07/10/2026 09:15

Yes, when the whole point is saving your own child. SAVING!
Again, this is all very made up, but who doesn’t look at their own children and think that you’d go to the ends of the earth for them. I don’t think I’d feel guilt if it meant saving my own child. I could look into his eyes until the end of my days then

The opening post didn't say 'child'. Of course for most people people their child will be the most loved, but you've made up what you think the OP says.

AllTheToddlers · 07/10/2026 12:14

50Balesofgrey · 05/10/2026 19:39

I would do anything for love,
But I won't do that

Bravo!

MissFancyDay · 07/10/2026 12:12

Noshowlomo · 07/10/2026 10:29

I totally understand the situation would never actually happen, but why are 10000 strangers more precious to you than your own children?

Well obviously 10,000 strangers are not more precious to me than my own children, who I would happily sacrifice myself for without thinking twice.

However I am evolved enough to know that not everything in this world revolves around me and my wants and needs.

LizzyA123 · 07/10/2026 10:51

There have been psychological dilemma films exploring similar themes, for eg “The Box” and “ The Belkin experiment.” Generally the idea is do you choose to press a button or take a course of action knowing that your action will result in other people dying in order to benefit yourself or prevent harm to a loved one. Could you live with the guilt?

Noshowlomo · 07/10/2026 10:29

sunshinestar1986 · 07/10/2026 09:57

Just no, why is your 1 loved one any less precious than those 10000 people to their loved ones, can't stand evil selfish people

I totally understand the situation would never actually happen, but why are 10000 strangers more precious to you than your own children?

sunshinestar1986 · 07/10/2026 10:00

namechangetheworld · 06/10/2026 20:19

Any mother saying no and feigning outrage over this hypothetical situation is a virtue signaler of the highest order.

I'd do it and feel no guilt whatsoever.

Wow
Nice to know you live amongst us

sunshinestar1986 · 07/10/2026 09:57

Just no, why is your 1 loved one any less precious than those 10000 people to their loved ones, can't stand evil selfish people

Gossipisgood · 07/10/2026 09:33

The day I gave birth to my first child was the day I realised I was capable of murder. I'd do anything to keep my two kids safe so yes if I had to press a button to kill thousands to save my own I'd do it without too much thought. Yes I'd feel bad & would prefer not to but if it meant i'd lose one off mine if I didn't, it'd have to be done.

Goatsarebest · 07/10/2026 09:28

So we solved the problem of why people are prepared to enable the mass slaughter of thousands even their neighbours and friends, in history. Just tell them they are a threat to their family and there's no consequences if you kill them. If you can get usually reasonable people on MN to do it then no problem getting the masses to do it.
Concerning, tbh.

Goatsarebest · 07/10/2026 09:20

Of course he knew the children and families, so that would add another level to a traumatic event.

Goatsarebest · 07/10/2026 09:17

Cailleach1 · 06/10/2026 19:54

That is slightly different. Would you aim to save your child first, if 10,000 others were in equal danger? You wouldn’t be killing them, or putting them in danger. You would be choosing to rescue your own child first.

That sounds horrendous, though. The alternative possible scenario was if the man rescued the two poor children (who subsequently drowned), and his own child might have drowned instead whilst he was doing that.

Yes. Agree it's different but it's the nearest actual life event that I know of where someone had to make this sort of decision. It actually had quite profound impacts on both the father and son and, like you say, it was not an active action of ending someone's life, just an omission with consequences. So whilst most are saying they would save their loved one, they might be underestimating the long term consequences of actively causing the death of 10000 children of other people, which is what they are.

Noshowlomo · 07/10/2026 09:15

Fairy25 · 06/10/2026 20:28

Wow… half of you would be happy to murder other people’s children to save your own.

Yes, when the whole point is saving your own child. SAVING!
Again, this is all very made up, but who doesn’t look at their own children and think that you’d go to the ends of the earth for them. I don’t think I’d feel guilt if it meant saving my own child. I could look into his eyes until the end of my days then

SuperMaria · 07/10/2026 09:10

Yesitsweird · 07/10/2026 08:17

Most of us aren't saying we love our kids more than others.
We are saying that we love our kids as much as most other mothers, which is the normal standard, and the ones who wouldn't save their own children fall below that standard.

HTH

Apt username. What other atrocities are you willing to commit for your children? Bravado on a MN thread means you’re a better parent, sure.

Step aside Adolf Hitler and Pol Pot, you haven’t seen nothing yet, MNers really love their kids!

MarilynMerlot · 07/10/2026 09:04

No, but only because he wouldn’t want that. In my heart I’d rather see him live than 10,000 strangers.

Sunbringer · 07/10/2026 08:37

No. He wouldn’t want me to. Not when it would add so much pain into the world. I wouldn’t be able to live with it either. It’s not a good question because both results are too painful.