Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
ZeStreoving · 03/11/2026 10:37

without hesitation that button would be pressed.

Sartre · 03/11/2026 10:07

I’d kill anyone if it meant saving my DC.

SuperMaria · 03/11/2026 10:06

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 03/11/2026 09:05

Everytime we spend £2.5m on treating one child with cancer in the UK we decide not to spend the money saving 800 children from Malaria in Nigeria. I've never heard any parent say that they would rather not treat their own child from cancer to stop others from dying (and who would in reality?). These questions alway be to sound moral when in practice the day to day decisions we make place very different value on the lives of different people based on the lottery of where they are born. I'm sure many Ukrainians on the front line are actively trying to kill 1,000 Russians to save their children for example.

Except NHS money was never going to be spent on another country’s health system.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 03/11/2026 09:05

Everytime we spend £2.5m on treating one child with cancer in the UK we decide not to spend the money saving 800 children from Malaria in Nigeria. I've never heard any parent say that they would rather not treat their own child from cancer to stop others from dying (and who would in reality?). These questions alway be to sound moral when in practice the day to day decisions we make place very different value on the lives of different people based on the lottery of where they are born. I'm sure many Ukrainians on the front line are actively trying to kill 1,000 Russians to save their children for example.

sillyrubberduck · 03/11/2026 08:49

Yes just to save my DS. It would not be easy though and I would feel terrible but I could not , not save my son . I would not do it for DH although I love him and would not expect him to do it for me. Nor do I expect DS to save me either. But a Mums love knows no limits in my opinion.

StarCourt · 03/11/2026 08:38

Yes I would for DD

Matildatoldsuchdreadfullies · 03/11/2026 08:14

12 Monkeys (TV show) goes round in circles as the various protagonists choose whether to save billions or their child.

Spoiler: they all choose their child.

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · 03/11/2026 08:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LostittoBostik · 03/11/2026 05:27

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:41

Well what actually inspired it was reflecting on the limitations (or lack thereof) of the national welfare state (any nation that has one). You can help 10,000 people from another country and refuse at least some lifesaving but expensive treatments or services domestically or you can do the opposite. Someone is going to die in either situation and you have the power to choose who. You're actually choosing whether you press the button or not.

I was just curious about who would rather the strangers or the loved one. It might have been a better example if I'd said one stranger to save a loved one, on reflection.

Every single one of us is going to die. Hate to break it to you.

OtterlyAstounding · 03/11/2026 00:53

Squirrelsnut · 03/11/2026 00:41

This, 100%.

But that's not right. In this scenario, the child wouldn’t know, so no survivor's guilt. And it wouldn’t be about my emotional pain at all. It would be about wanting my child to be able to live a full and long life.
It’s ridiculous to suggest that not wanting your child to die is actually all about avoiding your own emotional pain, not because you want them to have the chance at a life that isn't cut horribly short. If it were possible, I'd choose to suffer the equivalent emotional pain of them dying if it meant they were alive, because it's not about me, it's about them.

OtterlyAstounding · 03/11/2026 00:47

I'd kill 8 billion quite happily, without a moment’s regret. Hell, given those parameters (a button, anonymity) I'd quite happily murder great swathes of people just to get rid of them, even without the life of someone I love hanging in the balance – rapists, child abusers, and wife beaters, for starters.

But then I don’t particularly like humans as a demographic.

Squirrelsnut · 03/11/2026 00:41

TheDisillusionedAnarchist · 02/11/2026 13:39

No. My child has died and I know that grief. I wouldn’t kill one person to save the other two, let alone 10000. But this is so hypothetical it’s essentially pointless.

I’d kill for my child is sentimental nonsense, it’s not about your child who will either be dead and won’t care or will be alive and living with survivor’s guilt. It’s about you and your imagined ability to live with the pain of their loss. It’s selfish. You wouldn’t be killing for your child, you’d be killing for you. Would you really murder 10000 people to avoid emotional pain?

This, 100%.

FriggadyDiggady · 03/11/2026 00:36

OK, hear me out...
Imagine that a small percentage of DC had psychic gifts, and by torturing those DC to death you could drink their essence and extend your life indefinitely (as long as you kept killing). You could also store their essence in a flask and give it to someone else. Would you take on a life as an undead serial murdering ghoul to keep your DC alive forever? Added bonus is that if you got them at the right age they would stay that age forever. Do it young enough and you get an eternity of dependency!
On another note, I'd recommend the film "Mother" to people on this thread (the Korean one, not the American one with J. Lawrence)

nomas · 02/11/2026 21:52

FriggadyDiggady · 02/11/2026 20:19

I wonder if there's a line we can hit with the people who would do "anything" for their kids?
Would you kidnap 10000 women, on the understanding that they would be raped, to save your kids? We'll escalate from there.

No point, they will say they would do anything.

One person said they would bomb the whole world.

FriggadyDiggady · 02/11/2026 20:19

I wonder if there's a line we can hit with the people who would do "anything" for their kids?
Would you kidnap 10000 women, on the understanding that they would be raped, to save your kids? We'll escalate from there.

SometimesthingsMatter · 02/11/2026 18:35

You know what I'd die myself, because I wouldn't press the button.

Sdpbody · 02/11/2026 13:46

Cailleach1 · 02/11/2026 13:40

But that wasn’t the question. The question was ‘would you KILL 10,000 people to save the person you love most?’ Not would you simply let people die.

True! I doubt I would be able to do it.

Cailleach1 · 02/11/2026 13:40

Sdpbody · 02/11/2026 13:35

I would let a million people die, if I knew my children would be saved. I also believe I would kill or choose to be killed for them.

But that wasn’t the question. The question was ‘would you KILL 10,000 people to save the person you love most?’ Not would you simply let people die.

TheDisillusionedAnarchist · 02/11/2026 13:39

No. My child has died and I know that grief. I wouldn’t kill one person to save the other two, let alone 10000. But this is so hypothetical it’s essentially pointless.

I’d kill for my child is sentimental nonsense, it’s not about your child who will either be dead and won’t care or will be alive and living with survivor’s guilt. It’s about you and your imagined ability to live with the pain of their loss. It’s selfish. You wouldn’t be killing for your child, you’d be killing for you. Would you really murder 10000 people to avoid emotional pain?

EmeraldShamrock000 · 02/11/2026 13:37

Sdpbody · 02/11/2026 13:35

I would let a million people die, if I knew my children would be saved. I also believe I would kill or choose to be killed for them.

If such a choice existed, you better hope it is your choice or you may be part of the million exterminated to save one family.
I don’t think I could do it. Even to save my children.

Sdpbody · 02/11/2026 13:36

Sdpbody · 02/11/2026 13:35

I would let a million people die, if I knew my children would be saved. I also believe I would kill or choose to be killed for them.

I would feel guilty, but I would probably still do it.

Sdpbody · 02/11/2026 13:35

I would let a million people die, if I knew my children would be saved. I also believe I would kill or choose to be killed for them.

WhatMyNameis · 02/11/2026 12:41

fumingrightnow1 · 06/10/2026 18:45

I'd tell them everytime they refused to clean their room or didn't eat their peas

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

WhatMyNameis · 02/11/2026 12:16

MandemChickenShop · 05/10/2026 20:20

I draw the line at 9,999.

🤣🤣🤣

PrettyLittleRose · 09/10/2026 08:25

Comtesse · 09/10/2026 08:19

AND I wouldn’t feel guilty AND that makes me a better mum than you. Lollll…..

😆 to this post too!