Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
VioletsTale · 05/10/2026 20:04

nomas · 05/10/2026 20:01

Exactly. Most people who prefer death themselves than bear the survivor guilt.

At least with death, you die once but if others die for you, you die every day

Edited

Does the child have to know what happened?

Uricon2 · 05/10/2026 20:03

I will say only this.

Advanced search is a useful and beautiful thing.

SmallDFartyCarNRG · 05/10/2026 20:03

Just no, if that situation were ever to be happening I would suspect AI had run rogue and we would both be better off out of it.

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 20:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

nomas · 05/10/2026 20:01

BIossomtoes · 05/10/2026 19:29

No. Nobody I love would want that. And I certainly wouldn’t want anyone to do it to save me. Ridiculous idea.

Edited

Exactly. Most people who prefer death themselves than bear the survivor guilt.

At least with death, you die once but if others die for you, you die every day

MCF86 · 05/10/2026 20:01

Fishwife2 · 05/10/2026 19:34

Absolutely not and also shocked by the result.

I wondered if people had pressed the wrong button, as the options are listed in the opposite order.

Biker47 · 05/10/2026 20:00

Yes, easily.

LancashireButterPie · 05/10/2026 19:58

OP, Have you seen the play or read Arthur Miller, All my sons? You might find it interesting.

hobbledyhoy · 05/10/2026 19:57

I would do it immediately to save my children and if I had to I’d do it twice.

blubberyboo · 05/10/2026 19:56

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

Irrelevant to the thread but I'm sure she doesn't give a flying f what you think of her.

Regardless of opinions on the death penalty this is part of the justice she has waited for for 31 years which has exacerbated her own torture and created an expectation of closure. If she had never been promised it she would likely not be looking for that closure. Dont judge until you've walked in her shoes.

tripleginandtonic · 05/10/2026 19:53

BorgQueen · 05/10/2026 19:25

Absolutely. There are 3 people I would kill or die for.
I’d put a bullet in peoples’ heads myself if I had to, no qualms at all.

You'd kill innocent women and children?

Persephonia1966 · 05/10/2026 19:51

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:41

Well what actually inspired it was reflecting on the limitations (or lack thereof) of the national welfare state (any nation that has one). You can help 10,000 people from another country and refuse at least some lifesaving but expensive treatments or services domestically or you can do the opposite. Someone is going to die in either situation and you have the power to choose who. You're actually choosing whether you press the button or not.

I was just curious about who would rather the strangers or the loved one. It might have been a better example if I'd said one stranger to save a loved one, on reflection.

That's a false dilemma though...

For one thing it's not possible to follow the cause/effect chain that closely. If I knew for certain that denying X amount of spending on X amount of people in Africa would mean the UK could afford expensive treatment for my son when he gets ill in a years time and that this would be the thing that saved his life I might make that trade. But outside of thought experiments like the trolley problem it's never that certain. In fact, in the case of overseas spending it can be the opposite. If we fund anti ebola programmes there is less chance of it developing into an epidemic which spreads worldwide. Vaccination programmes against TB, Polio etc build up herd immunity that makes it less likely antibiotic resistant mutations will occur and spread to the UK. One of mankinds biggest achievements, eradicating small pox, only happened because of a huge global effort. Maybe there's an alternative reality where we didn't collectively spend the resources to do that and my son died of smallpox? Maybe in the future a child in a refugee camp who had their education payed for by the UK will grow up to be a scientist who saves everyone including my children. By not spending the money we condem everyone to death. I can't see the future so I don't know.

Of course a lot of overseas aid is about soft power anyway. And some of it builds unhealthy dependencies (but that makes America's sudden withdrawal of aid even worse). But real life isn't like the trolley problem. So even though it's an interesting thought experiment you can't really transfer it to real world debates.

caringcarer · 05/10/2026 19:51

I love my DC more than anything but no I wouldn't murder 10,000 people for them.

PeasOff · 05/10/2026 19:50

Yes, without any hesitation.

HelsinkiLights · 05/10/2026 19:49

Yes for my DC & the scary thing is I would still sleep peacefully at night, probably because of the anonymity.

Itsbeensevenhours · 05/10/2026 19:47

God, I don’t think my child would want me to, but I would want to do anything to save them. But then they may never forgive you for going against their wishes and murdering 10,000 people so you’d lose them anyway.
I don’t think you’d be on grandma duties anyway

Weeellokthen · 05/10/2026 19:43

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:23

I am unmoved by your dislike.

Nice!!

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:43

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 19:41

I think the honest answer must be yes, when you consider what else we do eg I've spent the best part of £1m just on my children's education alone so far- how many children would that have saved in sub Saharan Africa?

Others may not have such an extreme example to share but the principle still applies- how many lives could you have saved just for the cost of non-essentials spent on your children? If it's a large number (and I'm sure it is) how likely is it really that you'd put 10000 lives over your child's life?

And yes precisely. Who even gives up a family holiday to send money to save an African school from malaria. Basically nobody.

I would kill the whole world to save my children. I know that the aftermath would be really really bad and thus probably an overall wrong move but I still would (sorry everyone).

OP posts:
CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:41

Lonelycrab · 05/10/2026 19:37

What a lovely idea for a thread OP

Well what actually inspired it was reflecting on the limitations (or lack thereof) of the national welfare state (any nation that has one). You can help 10,000 people from another country and refuse at least some lifesaving but expensive treatments or services domestically or you can do the opposite. Someone is going to die in either situation and you have the power to choose who. You're actually choosing whether you press the button or not.

I was just curious about who would rather the strangers or the loved one. It might have been a better example if I'd said one stranger to save a loved one, on reflection.

OP posts:
Shrigley · 05/10/2026 19:41

I think the honest answer must be yes, when you consider what else we do eg I've spent the best part of £1m just on my children's education alone so far- how many children would that have saved in sub Saharan Africa?

Others may not have such an extreme example to share but the principle still applies- how many lives could you have saved just for the cost of non-essentials spent on your children? If it's a large number (and I'm sure it is) how likely is it really that you'd put 10000 lives over your child's life?

MrsPernicious · 05/10/2026 19:40

Gengha · 05/10/2026 19:37

also no idea why anyone is getting their knickers in a twist over it, it’s just a stupid thread, not a scenario that’s ever going to be tested

I think a few politicians have tested it over the years.

Tap into someones emotional fears and let the killing be anonymous. Has worked well in the past and will no doubt work well in the future. Just need to be those dead people to be others

50Balesofgrey · 05/10/2026 19:39

I would do anything for love,
But I won't do that

Gengha · 05/10/2026 19:37

also no idea why anyone is getting their knickers in a twist over it, it’s just a stupid thread, not a scenario that’s ever going to be tested

Lonelycrab · 05/10/2026 19:37

What a lovely idea for a thread OP

Bringemout · 05/10/2026 19:37

Yes but only for my DC, I would suffer extreme anguish for the rest of my life but yeah I don’t think I would be able to stop myself.