Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Coka · 05/10/2026 22:13

Would i sacrifice my child to save 10000 people? No. Would i kill 10000 so save my child? Also i think no. I dont think they would ever forgive me or understand that decision.

SleeplessInWherever · 05/10/2026 22:12

For my son - yeah, tomorrow.

It’s not a decision I’d want to make or enjoy making, but I’m confident I would make it.

I also understand that others making the same decision for their kids would potentially mean mine was in that 10,000. They’re not really obliged to care about that, he’s not theirs.

When the “chips are down,” I’d imagine most would prioritise their own.

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 22:10

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 22:06

Sure. I'm not sure how what you've written here is a response to what I've said. I'd far rather die than do either but that's not one of the options in this thought experiment.

Yes but it follows on from the scenarios because I would predict that my loved ones (children) would feel the same.Therefore we would all end up leading a miserable existence.

Duncantoldme2 · 05/10/2026 22:08

Nemorth · 05/10/2026 21:59

I’ve been trained to use weapons. Trained where to shoot at the body. This also means I’ve had a considerable amount of training about when and the legalities of “killing”. Also had training about ethics etc.

I’m not sure I could make that choice to kill 10,000 others to save one.

The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

I could absolutely kill one or two, maybe even up to 100 people to save my children…but 10,000? I’m not sure I could.

I even know how to use a rifle, bayonet and pistol.

Ross?

SumptuousPecanNougat · 05/10/2026 22:06

I don't think I would hesitate to kill 10,000 people if they were all intentionally an imminent threat to the life of a loved one, but I couldn't kill innocent people as some sort of trade.

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 22:06

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 21:58

Nonsense. I wouldn't want to live if I had caused the death of ten thousand people.

Sure. I'm not sure how what you've written here is a response to what I've said. I'd far rather die than do either but that's not one of the options in this thought experiment.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 05/10/2026 22:04

Kill 10,000 people to save one? You're barking at the moon.

ILoveListeningToRainAtNight · 05/10/2026 22:04

So, if you are given that choice, to kill 10,000 strangers to save one of your people, have you considered that someone else, who is a stranger to you, might also be given that choice? Then you could be among their 10,000.

Reminds me of the movie The Box, where they can push a button and someone unknown to them will die. Then the box is given to someone unknown to them to make the same decision.

VioletsTale · 05/10/2026 22:01

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 21:56

No of course I wouldn't, it would be completely morally repugnant. My children would be horrified and disgusted.

What sort of people are you that would do this. Actually I don't believe you.

I would happily sacrifice myself for my children, me and DH have had this discussion. But kill other peoples children. No.

Pragmatic?

XenoBitch · 05/10/2026 21:59

These questions are weird. Usually used to have a go at people over impossible hypothetical situations.
Find something else to get mad at people about.. like actual real life things.

Nemorth · 05/10/2026 21:59

I’ve been trained to use weapons. Trained where to shoot at the body. This also means I’ve had a considerable amount of training about when and the legalities of “killing”. Also had training about ethics etc.

I’m not sure I could make that choice to kill 10,000 others to save one.

The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.

I could absolutely kill one or two, maybe even up to 100 people to save my children…but 10,000? I’m not sure I could.

I even know how to use a rifle, bayonet and pistol.

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 21:58

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 21:56

I imagine these groups exactly the other way round- I find the idea of someone who could kill their own child on some sort of utilitarian calculation of greater happiness for the greater number absolutely chilling, and I'm confident that that person would be far more likely to torture a stranger to death at the behest of an authority figure- doing the "right thing" when every human impulse is to do the opposite.

(FWIW Milgram's work has been thoroughly discredited- the original experiment was full of flaws (including the fact that large numbers of the people who carried on "torturing" were aware that the set up was fake) and the results have not been replicated.)

Nonsense. I wouldn't want to live if I had caused the death of ten thousand people.

SuperMaria · 05/10/2026 21:58

Yesitsweird · 05/10/2026 20:28

Same, I'm shocked people wouldn't. I have never loved anything like i love my children and I would do anything for them

Not to pick on you specifically, but these answers are so unbearably cringe.

Like @nomas said, yours and nobody else’s kids are worth 10,000 other people dying. This is such a stupid hypothetical scenario, but even so, it’s insanely selfish. Other innocent men, women, children, babies. Bonus points for anyone who has ‘no qualms’ about it either, I mean fgs.

Saying you’d do this doesn't mean you love your kids so much more than anyone else.

LindorDoubleChoc · 05/10/2026 21:57

Why do people even give brain space to stupid questions like this? It's morbid and depressing. Live in the present in the real world!

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 05/10/2026 21:57

To save my children. Yes.

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 21:56

No of course I wouldn't, it would be completely morally repugnant. My children would be horrified and disgusted.

What sort of people are you that would do this. Actually I don't believe you.

I would happily sacrifice myself for my children, me and DH have had this discussion. But kill other peoples children. No.

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 21:56

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 21:43

Interesting that the roughly two-thirds of people on here who would commit mass-murder at the press of a button corresponds with the equivalent number who would torture a stranger to death at the behest of an authority figure, via the press of a button, in the Stanley Milgram experiment.

I would deem this significant majority those lacking a strong moral compass or backbone.

I imagine these groups exactly the other way round- I find the idea of someone who could kill their own child on some sort of utilitarian calculation of greater happiness for the greater number absolutely chilling, and I'm confident that that person would be far more likely to torture a stranger to death at the behest of an authority figure- doing the "right thing" when every human impulse is to do the opposite.

(FWIW Milgram's work has been thoroughly discredited- the original experiment was full of flaws (including the fact that large numbers of the people who carried on "torturing" were aware that the set up was fake) and the results have not been replicated.)

VioletsTale · 05/10/2026 21:54

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 21:49

No, but in the Stanley Milgram experiment(s), people were actually doing the thing. Or at least they thought they were, which is the important part.

I'd suggest reading about it if you haven't. It's very illuminating about human behaviour.

And as a result, a lot of the participants suffered severe distress and negative emotional responses. What does that tell you?

steppemum · 05/10/2026 21:52

For me the answer is a firm no.
It is really an issue of ego and selfishness. I cannot consider myself or my family more important than those 10,000 who had to die.
And while there is an important discussion to be had around what that looks like in terms of overseas aid etc, it is not the same scenario at all, your question was directly killing people.

For me, I wonder how you could look you child in the eye as an adult and say 10,000 people died so you could be here. They would not want that. They would live with the guilt of that. It is not a decision that has no consequences for the person saved.

I would not want someone to do that for me either.
But I am not afraid of death. I don't think living at all costs is the goal.

Duncantoldme2 · 05/10/2026 21:52

Surroundedbyfools · 05/10/2026 19:37

Tough one but yes.

I would kill to save my children,

Kill ten thousand other peoples' children?

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 21:49

Gengha · 05/10/2026 21:45

Och away you go

People saying they’ll do something on a daft internet chat are not comparable to people actually doing something IRL

No, but in the Stanley Milgram experiment(s), people were actually doing the thing. Or at least they thought they were, which is the important part.

I'd suggest reading about it if you haven't. It's very illuminating about human behaviour.

BirmaBright · 05/10/2026 21:49

You can help 10,000 people from another country and refuse at least some lifesaving but expensive treatments or services domestically or you can do the opposite. Someone is going to die in either situation and you have the power to choose who. You're actually choosing whether you press the button or not.

Why do you think that helping 10,000 people means lifesaving or expensive treatments will be curtailed ? 240,000 Ukrainians moved to the UK, are you suggesting that by helping them, people in the locality they moved to died as a result ?

VioletsTale · 05/10/2026 21:49

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 21:47

That's a generous interpretation. Sounds more like clinical psychopathy to me. Or perhaps just "showing off" while hiding behind the internet. Though it seems strange thing to brag about.

I’d say the detachment helps. It’s a button , you don’t have to witness anything, you don’t know any of those people etc.

Duncantoldme2 · 05/10/2026 21:48

50Balesofgrey · 05/10/2026 19:39

I would do anything for love,
But I won't do that

I wonder if that's what he had in mind.

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 21:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That's a generous interpretation. Sounds more like clinical psychopathy to me. Or perhaps just "showing off" while hiding behind the internet. Though it seems strange thing to brag about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread