Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
McSilkson · 05/10/2026 22:43

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 21:56

I imagine these groups exactly the other way round- I find the idea of someone who could kill their own child on some sort of utilitarian calculation of greater happiness for the greater number absolutely chilling, and I'm confident that that person would be far more likely to torture a stranger to death at the behest of an authority figure- doing the "right thing" when every human impulse is to do the opposite.

(FWIW Milgram's work has been thoroughly discredited- the original experiment was full of flaws (including the fact that large numbers of the people who carried on "torturing" were aware that the set up was fake) and the results have not been replicated.)

Actually, Milgram's experiments have been successfully replicated multiple times in various countries over the intervening decades, with pretty consistent results (in fact, some iterations found an even higher rate of compliance).

https://www.bps.org.uk/research-digest/new-milgram-replication-poland-finds-90-cent-participants-willing-deliver-highest

https://www.apa.org/monitor/2009/03/milgram

It's possible to research this in much greater depth, and I did so at uni.

And I don't think of it as a utilitarian calculation. I see it as murdering 10,000 "innocent" people - most of them mothers, fathers, sons and daughters themselves - for ultimately selfish reasons. How can that be "right"? No calculation is required. What if the 10,000 people were all babies/children? Would that affect anyone's decision?

New Milgram replication in Poland finds 90 per cent of participants willing to deliver highest shock | BPS

In one version of the study, 26 out of 40 participants continued to the highest shock level – two steps beyond the button labelled “Danger: severe shock”.

https://www.bps.org.uk/research-digest/new-milgram-replication-poland-finds-90-cent-participants-willing-deliver-highest

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 22:39

I think what I object to on this thread, is the assumption that not being a utilitarian = not being moral. I am with Antony- "Let Rome in Tiber melt and the wide arch/ Of the ranged empire fall. Here is my space." It's not that you weigh the life of your child (or other beloved) against the lives of all the other people and decide that your child is worth more. Rather, choosing to save your child is a rejection of the notion that your love for them is something that can be outweighed, that attempting to weigh these things is anything other than an obscene kind of category error.

(This is the sort of decision that people often take in tragedy and the consequences are generally death and destruction, and yet this is still a better outcome than the bean-counting alternative.)

XmasCrackPies · 05/10/2026 22:38

Yeah but wouldn't feel great about it.

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 22:34

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 22:31

Judgemental?
Yes i am Judgemental: my Judgement is capital punishment is wrong.
Killing Christa Pike won't bring back Colleen Slemmer. Nothing can do that. And yes it is absolutely horrendous for her mother to lose her daughter in such an awful way but how will watching Christa being put to death make it any better?

Edited

I thought that I had read somewhere that Colleens mother wanted to watch the execution but afterwards she said that no one deserved what Christa Pike went through. She has more humanity than a lot on this thread.

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:34

🙄

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 05/10/2026 22:33

In a heart beat. Tbh to save my kids, husband or family members I wouldn’t care if I had to do it by hand or if I knew them.

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:33

So @McSilkson 66% are saying they would do it, kill 10,000 people to save someone close to them?

Thank you, I was wondering what the split was!

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 22:31

Devonshiregal · 05/10/2026 22:14

Well, I’d imagine you might be less judgemental had you ever experienced what that poor woman has.

Judgemental?
Yes i am Judgemental: my Judgement is capital punishment is wrong.
Killing Christa Pike won't bring back Colleen Slemmer. Nothing can do that. And yes it is absolutely horrendous for her mother to lose her daughter in such an awful way but how will watching Christa being put to death make it any better?

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 22:28

VioletsTale · 05/10/2026 21:54

And as a result, a lot of the participants suffered severe distress and negative emotional responses. What does that tell you?

That the people in this thread boasting about not losing sleep are almost certainly talking shit, or are actual psychopaths (they walk among us).

But that the need to obey authority/follow the rules/conform/avoid conflict is stronger in most people than any moral scruples they might possess. Spineless moral cowards.

Just look at the Covid regime - a Little Hitler's paradise - for a recent example of how people will do blatantly immoral and inhumane things when ordered or encouraged to by authority figures/the status quo. We had people willingly keeping people away from their dying relatives - forcing people to die alone. We had women forced to give birth and spend the post-partum period alone, some in extremely traumatic circumstances - they and their babies being denied the comfort of a single kind human face. We had elderly people with advanced dementia condemned to solitary confinement and denied the familiarity of human faces and the necessity of human contact.

When my cat was rushed to hospital and died - in a largely empty building full of people in Hazmat gear - we weren't allowed to see him unless he was brought out into the car park. A dying cat, hooked up to machinery. Absolute cruelty and absurdity everywhere.

Many rule followers were gung-ho or even gleeful about this systemic desecration of human rights. "It's da rooooolz," they mindlessly intoned, as they routinely inflicted immense cruelty and suffering at the proverbial press of a button. You can bet that most of them would be in the 66%.

MsSmartShoes · 05/10/2026 22:28

I would decline to choose.

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:26

Shloopie · 05/10/2026 20:31

Christ, it's all gone very Peter 'I luv my kids' Andre in here.

Only one pack of baccy til payday, nothing but snakes in this town, just me and the kids now, if U can't handle me at my worst, U don't deserve me at my best. taps the anchor tattoo, with 'I refuse to sink' written underneath it....

LeopardPrintHeels · 05/10/2026 22:26

I would to save my children.

Duncantoldme2 · 05/10/2026 22:25

Devonshiregal · 05/10/2026 22:18

Kemp? Or Ross from friends?

not sure why killing 100 is ok but then suddenly it starts to become all too much…

Ha ha - both fit, actually!

Duncantoldme2 · 05/10/2026 22:24

I'd prefer a different thought experiment. Something along the lines of is there a carrot in the box?

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:22

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 21:23

I'm a woman who loves males and thinks you have a weird attitude.

You love males? What males? Stallions? Bulls? Boars? Strange thing to say.

Wewinnow · 05/10/2026 22:22

Fishwife2 · 05/10/2026 19:34

Absolutely not and also shocked by the result.

This

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:19

Fishwife2 · 05/10/2026 19:34

Absolutely not and also shocked by the result.

I can't see it as I have not voted on the poll. What's the result right now?

Whatawickedgametochoose · 05/10/2026 22:19

BorgQueen · 05/10/2026 19:25

Absolutely. There are 3 people I would kill or die for.
I’d put a bullet in peoples’ heads myself if I had to, no qualms at all.

This. No question about it and zero fucks given

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This. ^

I'm not answering this ludicrous question.

Devonshiregal · 05/10/2026 22:18

Duncantoldme2 · 05/10/2026 22:08

Ross?

Kemp? Or Ross from friends?

not sure why killing 100 is ok but then suddenly it starts to become all too much…

StroppyBulldog · 05/10/2026 22:17

For my children yes and I wouldn't even think about it

Cel77 · 05/10/2026 22:15

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

What a horrible question.

What would YOU do, and I really hope you never have to choose.

Devonshiregal · 05/10/2026 22:14

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

Well, I’d imagine you might be less judgemental had you ever experienced what that poor woman has.

Yesitsweird · 05/10/2026 22:14

SuperMaria · 05/10/2026 21:58

Not to pick on you specifically, but these answers are so unbearably cringe.

Like @nomas said, yours and nobody else’s kids are worth 10,000 other people dying. This is such a stupid hypothetical scenario, but even so, it’s insanely selfish. Other innocent men, women, children, babies. Bonus points for anyone who has ‘no qualms’ about it either, I mean fgs.

Saying you’d do this doesn't mean you love your kids so much more than anyone else.

Not to pick on you specifically, but I find answers like yours bizarely cold. Why is the love for a child cringe? How old are you? Do you find people hugging their mums cringe too?

Of course the right to live for 10000 people outweighs the right of one.

But I would save my own child.

If you wouldn't, if you apply cold robotic logic to it and feel your child is a fair sacrifice, well, I would say no you clearly don't feel the same as me.
I don't think I love my child more than anyone else, I assume all parents would do the same. It's the most natural, primal thing. And I think it's very very sad if a parent wouldn't.

mrssunshinexxx · 05/10/2026 22:13

Yep to bring my mum back. In a heartbeat