Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MaggieBsBoat · 06/10/2026 00:12

No loved one of mine would want me to. I don’t love the kind of people that would expect or want that of me. I wouldn’t. My loved ones’ lives aren’t worth more than anyone else’s. The sort of people who would without compunction give me pause for thought. I only hope that the people they love would be good enough people to talk them out of it.

NuffSaidSam · 06/10/2026 00:11

Of course I would.

According to Google an estimated 150,000 people die each day. I don't know them and it doesn't really bother me if I'm honest!

It's sad when you hear any individual story, but if we're honest none of us are losing sleep over the 150,000 people we don't know who died today.

muggart · 06/10/2026 00:06

NoisyHiker · 06/10/2026 00:00

For my children? I would kill every last man, woman and child on this earth.

They would probably never forgive me (well, ds wouldn't. Dd is like me so would probably just say thanks) but I wouldn't care, they would be alive.

Sometimes humanity makes me wish I was a better person. And sometimes it makes me wish the Thanos inifinity gauntlet was real.

out of curiosity would you also be the sort of parent to cover up their son’s crime if he kills a girl?

i was reading about a mum that did that the other day but i can’t remember the details. she washed the blood off his clothes and got a small amount of prison time for it.

PurpleAxe · 06/10/2026 00:05

Yep, no problem.

My people are my people.

SplendidUtterly · 06/10/2026 00:04

Yes.
I have thought about this before and I would definitely do it.

muggart · 06/10/2026 00:02

of course not and I’m genuinely horrified so many people have voted yanbu. no wonder the uk is so easy to lead into illegal wars if we attach so little moral judgement to killing others the moment we face any potential threat to ourselves.

Bourneyesterday · 06/10/2026 00:01

This thread is bringing out the lunatics

NoisyHiker · 06/10/2026 00:00

For my children? I would kill every last man, woman and child on this earth.

They would probably never forgive me (well, ds wouldn't. Dd is like me so would probably just say thanks) but I wouldn't care, they would be alive.

Sometimes humanity makes me wish I was a better person. And sometimes it makes me wish the Thanos inifinity gauntlet was real.

Bourneyesterday · 05/10/2026 23:57

No, I'm not a psychopath

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 05/10/2026 23:55

Shloopie · 05/10/2026 23:29

Kill 10,000 people by hand. Ok, hun.

Okay if you want to get technical manually hun.

InOverMyHead84 · 05/10/2026 23:40

No. But I would gladly kill myself to save them.

Persephonia1966 · 05/10/2026 23:35

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 21:29

Yes you're right. The answers will be different I imagine. Albeit not reflected in voting choices.

It's impossible to imagine a real life scenario where that is the case though. Working out the real life consequences of ones actions/government spending to that extent is horribly complicated to the point that making exact predictions isn't possible (chaos theory). It could as easily work out that not spending money on disease prevention in Africa winds up killing your own child in the long run through some unpredictable falling of dominos. (This is also why effective altruism was always a con).

A better, real life scenario would be if your child was dying and needed a viral organ transplant to save them and none could be procured from legal donors, would you commission someone to find and kill a healthy child for their organ? It's a sick idea but it's more of a "realistic" dilemma. And faced with that I would honestly have to say no, even though when the question was more dramatic (10,000 children) and vague I hesitated.

Shloopie · 05/10/2026 23:29

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 05/10/2026 22:33

In a heart beat. Tbh to save my kids, husband or family members I wouldn’t care if I had to do it by hand or if I knew them.

Kill 10,000 people by hand. Ok, hun.

Aussiesgettingsmashed · 05/10/2026 23:12

There is a film with Cameron Diaz where her and her husband get a million pounds if they press a button that kills lots of people they don’t know. I think they pressed it. It’s really really rubbish.

XigDoop · 05/10/2026 23:08

Is this AI fishing for accomplices 😦

MannyTeddy · 05/10/2026 23:06

Can we choose the 100 strangers? Maybe all the dictators around the world could be first in line? Then all the paedophiles, rapists and abusers next?

Definitely for my family, without hesitation.

Strawberriesandpears · 05/10/2026 23:06

This is traumatic to think about and I don't really see the point of the question.

InterIgnis · 05/10/2026 23:02

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 22:34

I thought that I had read somewhere that Colleens mother wanted to watch the execution but afterwards she said that no one deserved what Christa Pike went through. She has more humanity than a lot on this thread.

She did not say that. She actually said she wanted to finish Christa Pike off herself. Understandable.

Pigeonatthewheel · 05/10/2026 23:01

tripleginandtonic · 05/10/2026 19:53

You'd kill innocent women and children?

Innocent men not making it on to your exemption list! Also do we really need to specify ‘innocent’ or would you kill 10’000 women provided they had on occasion done something a wee bit nasty at least once in their life?

sleepwouldbenice · 05/10/2026 23:00

BIossomtoes · 05/10/2026 19:29

No. Nobody I love would want that. And I certainly wouldn’t want anyone to do it to save me. Ridiculous idea.

Edited

This

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 23:00

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 22:43

Actually, Milgram's experiments have been successfully replicated multiple times in various countries over the intervening decades, with pretty consistent results (in fact, some iterations found an even higher rate of compliance).

https://www.bps.org.uk/research-digest/new-milgram-replication-poland-finds-90-cent-participants-willing-deliver-highest

https://www.apa.org/monitor/2009/03/milgram

It's possible to research this in much greater depth, and I did so at uni.

And I don't think of it as a utilitarian calculation. I see it as murdering 10,000 "innocent" people - most of them mothers, fathers, sons and daughters themselves - for ultimately selfish reasons. How can that be "right"? No calculation is required. What if the 10,000 people were all babies/children? Would that affect anyone's decision?

Edited

(If you've studied it you'll be aware that even Milgram couldn't replicate his own findings https://www.forskningsetikk.no/en/resources/the-research-ethics-magazine/2021-1/are-we-not-evil-after-all/ and cherry picked his data to show the result he wanted. (This is a bit of a diversion from the thread though.))

I think you are making a utilitarian calculation. Why do you think it's worse to kill 10000 than to kill 1? Because there are more of them. That's a utilitarian approach, The fact that it seems obvious to you doesn't mean that it's not based on a utilitarian premise (such as, it is morally better to cause suffering to fewer people than to more people).

For people who would kill their own child rather than 10000 people, I'd love to know whether you have a cut off. Would you make the same decision if it was 1000 people? 100? 10? 2?

Are we not evil after all?

The two most famous social psychology experiments in history revealed the underlying evil of human beings – or did they? Several quarters now claim that the scientists who achieved world fame manipulated the results.

https://www.forskningsetikk.no/en/resources/the-research-ethics-magazine/2021-1/are-we-not-evil-after-all

LizzieW1969 · 05/10/2026 22:54

No, I wouldn’t ever do that. I wouldn’t want anyone to do that for me and I couldn’t imagine having to admit to my DDs what I’d done. And killing another person, let alone 10,000, is always wrong.

Thankfully it’s a theoretical question.

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 22:46

PrettyLittleRose · 05/10/2026 22:33

So @McSilkson 66% are saying they would do it, kill 10,000 people to save someone close to them?

Thank you, I was wondering what the split was!

Well, it's actually 61% "for" in this thread at the moment, but it's close enough.

TempestToo · 05/10/2026 22:46

For my kids or my husband, yeah. I’m not sure how I’d cope afterwards but I would do anything for my family.

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 22:43

MissFancyDay · 05/10/2026 22:34

I thought that I had read somewhere that Colleens mother wanted to watch the execution but afterwards she said that no one deserved what Christa Pike went through. She has more humanity than a lot on this thread.

Thanks - I knew she was in favour of the execution and that she wanted to watch it but I hadn't heard what she said afterwards.