Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 07:43

Yesitsweird · 05/10/2026 22:14

Not to pick on you specifically, but I find answers like yours bizarely cold. Why is the love for a child cringe? How old are you? Do you find people hugging their mums cringe too?

Of course the right to live for 10000 people outweighs the right of one.

But I would save my own child.

If you wouldn't, if you apply cold robotic logic to it and feel your child is a fair sacrifice, well, I would say no you clearly don't feel the same as me.
I don't think I love my child more than anyone else, I assume all parents would do the same. It's the most natural, primal thing. And I think it's very very sad if a parent wouldn't.

Ah so you’re one of those im referring to then.

I have two children and pregnant with no. 3.

Anyone saying they’d murder/kill 10,000 (does anyone here even comprehend how many people that is) without ‘any qualms’ because they ‘love their kids’ and is ‘shocked’ thay anyone else feels differently is cringe and embarrassing. You don’t love your child any more than anyone else.

Beyond weird, anyone who proclaims wanting to kill other random innocent people is a measure of their love for their loved ones, even hypothetically.

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 07:17

@GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · Yesterday 22:33

In a heart beat. Tbh to save my kids, husband or family members I wouldn’t care if I had to do it by hand or if I knew them.

😆

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?
PolkaDotPorridge · 06/10/2026 06:25

boredsmored · 06/10/2026 01:49

Jack Reacher has entered the chat 🙄

🤣

boredsmored · 06/10/2026 06:03

@gostickyourheadinapig don’t let this thread be any indicator of normal parenting.

We know soldiers etc suffer PTSD and yet there is a bunch of MNs who whilst not answering their doors at night can shoot 10000 people in the head and sleep soundly 🤔

EmeraldShamrock000 · 06/10/2026 02:50

No. I don’t think I could inflict the pain on that amount of people. Life is fragile enough.
Traumatic death has a knock on effect throughout the entire family and friends of the victim.
It is a very unlikely scenario.
No I actually couldn’t kill innocent people.

gostickyourheadinapig · 06/10/2026 02:38

Boreded · 06/10/2026 02:04

I’d kill my own mother or husband to save my child, 10,000 strangers…no problem

This is why I'm glad I am not a parent: it plays merry hell with people's objectivity and morals.

ForeverTheOptomist · 06/10/2026 02:29

This is a revolting OP. I kind of hit a Yabu/YANBU, no idea which one, as I mis-read the post. Now I don't want anything to do with this. Hideous.

Boreded · 06/10/2026 02:15

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

It’s because it was a question on a tv show that has been on recently…Widow’s Bay, it won tonnes of Emmys.

i really don’t understand why so many people are struggling with a random hypothetical. It’s just the trolley problem…we’ve all been asked it in other variations so why take offense today

McSilkson · 06/10/2026 02:06

Wow, this thread sure attracted the Reddit edgelords, huh...? WTF...

I mean, just look at all these super-cool, unfazed, wannabe serial killer types, bro... 🙄

Riiiiggggght.

Boreded · 06/10/2026 02:04

I’d kill my own mother or husband to save my child, 10,000 strangers…no problem

LeaderBee · 06/10/2026 01:56

Yes of course, 10,000 is not that much in the grand scheme of things.

10,000 is 0.000111111111% of the 9 billion worlds population

boredsmored · 06/10/2026 01:49

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 05/10/2026 22:33

In a heart beat. Tbh to save my kids, husband or family members I wouldn’t care if I had to do it by hand or if I knew them.

Jack Reacher has entered the chat 🙄

boredsmored · 06/10/2026 01:44

NoisyHiker · 06/10/2026 00:00

For my children? I would kill every last man, woman and child on this earth.

They would probably never forgive me (well, ds wouldn't. Dd is like me so would probably just say thanks) but I wouldn't care, they would be alive.

Sometimes humanity makes me wish I was a better person. And sometimes it makes me wish the Thanos inifinity gauntlet was real.

Er, how long would they be alive for if everyone else is dead? Do they not have friends or extended family they may miss? if

boredsmored · 06/10/2026 01:42

muggart · 06/10/2026 00:06

out of curiosity would you also be the sort of parent to cover up their son’s crime if he kills a girl?

i was reading about a mum that did that the other day but i can’t remember the details. she washed the blood off his clothes and got a small amount of prison time for it.

Yes, they would which is grim

NuffSaidSam · 06/10/2026 01:25

takealettermsjones · 06/10/2026 01:00

Y'all need Jesus

Tbf his Dad was big into killing people.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 01:04

Bubstar · 06/10/2026 00:53

Of course I would. In a heartbeat and I will sleep well afterwards.

People who think this makes them sound so cool and nonchalant.

takealettermsjones · 06/10/2026 01:00

Y'all need Jesus

Bubstar · 06/10/2026 00:53

Of course I would. In a heartbeat and I will sleep well afterwards.

caringcarer · 06/10/2026 00:20

alcovecupboards · 05/10/2026 21:06

To save my children? Without question. Even if I had to see it happen, it's not even a choice. I'd probably do it for the dogs too if I'm quite honest.

Unhinged.

MaIeficent · 06/10/2026 00:18

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

Wishing revenge on the murderer of a loved one isn't really the same as murdering an innocent person.

NuffSaidSam · 06/10/2026 00:17

MaggieBsBoat · 06/10/2026 00:13

I think people dying and actively murdering people are very much different things.

True, but pressing a button and not having to ever see the result of that button press isn't really the same as actively murdering people either.

Summer26woohoo · 06/10/2026 00:17

Yesitsweird · 05/10/2026 22:14

Not to pick on you specifically, but I find answers like yours bizarely cold. Why is the love for a child cringe? How old are you? Do you find people hugging their mums cringe too?

Of course the right to live for 10000 people outweighs the right of one.

But I would save my own child.

If you wouldn't, if you apply cold robotic logic to it and feel your child is a fair sacrifice, well, I would say no you clearly don't feel the same as me.
I don't think I love my child more than anyone else, I assume all parents would do the same. It's the most natural, primal thing. And I think it's very very sad if a parent wouldn't.

Agree.

The logical part of me knows that the worth of thousands of people is more than any one person. But in reality if I could save dh and the dc by killing a million other people, I'd still do it. You don't and can't think entirely analytically when it's so personal.

I'm staunchly against the death penalty for instance. For any crime. But if it was my family member that was killed, i'd press the button myself.

Millie2008 · 06/10/2026 00:17

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:43

And yes precisely. Who even gives up a family holiday to send money to save an African school from malaria. Basically nobody.

I would kill the whole world to save my children. I know that the aftermath would be really really bad and thus probably an overall wrong move but I still would (sorry everyone).

Me too OP.

InterIgnis · 06/10/2026 00:17

Yes, certainly.

MaggieBsBoat · 06/10/2026 00:13

NuffSaidSam · 06/10/2026 00:11

Of course I would.

According to Google an estimated 150,000 people die each day. I don't know them and it doesn't really bother me if I'm honest!

It's sad when you hear any individual story, but if we're honest none of us are losing sleep over the 150,000 people we don't know who died today.

I think people dying and actively murdering people are very much different things.