Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Noshowlomo · 06/10/2026 18:24

Wildefish · 06/10/2026 18:03

Really…

Yes. Wouldn’t any parent do anything to save their child.
I mean, this is a totally mad question, and it would never happen though

TwinklySquid · 06/10/2026 18:22

HelsinkiLights · 05/10/2026 19:49

Yes for my DC & the scary thing is I would still sleep peacefully at night, probably because of the anonymity.

Edited

I think this is the honest answer that few would admit. People would do a lot for their loved ones, especially if there was no consequence. Those that say otherwise are being dishonest with themselves.

Coconutter24 · 06/10/2026 18:20

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 06/10/2026 11:46

If there was a button in front of me and I knew my kids would die if I didn't press it, could I resist pressing it despite the horrible (but to me, entirely abstract) consequences. No, I don't think I could.

So you’d sacrifice your kids?

Coconutter24 · 06/10/2026 18:18

tripleginandtonic · 05/10/2026 19:53

You'd kill innocent women and children?

What if the three people they’d save are also innocent people?

Forevergardening · 06/10/2026 18:18

Absolutely would. Nothing to see. Would I feel some guilt, yeah but as a mother I do anyway.

SleepQuest33 · 06/10/2026 18:09

I can’t see this scenario ever playing out so I’m not going to even contemplate it.
can you give me a more realistic situation?

Skates · 06/10/2026 18:04

After the day Iv had at work I would happily press the button

Wildefish · 06/10/2026 18:03

Noshowlomo · 05/10/2026 19:13

Yes to save my son I’d do anything

Really…

knor · 06/10/2026 18:01

I would to save my daughter.
however I do wonder if the guilt afterwards would haunt me forever and become too much. But I would 100% for my daughter (but only her, no one else.)

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 06/10/2026 11:46

If there was a button in front of me and I knew my kids would die if I didn't press it, could I resist pressing it despite the horrible (but to me, entirely abstract) consequences. No, I don't think I could.

Duncantoldme2 · 06/10/2026 09:10

I suppose it's like eating meat. Had to kill it yourself, far fewer people would eat meat. Go to the shop and buy some, fine. Kill 10000 people in person no they wouldn't do that. Press a button so don't see any of the death destruction and heartache, totally fine.

Although one pp did say she she would kill the 10,000 people, in person with her bare hands (or something like that). Not sure she thought it through tbh.

Agrumpyknitter · 06/10/2026 08:48

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

No, I wouldn’t. All lives hold meaning and worth and I wouldn’t take the karma on for killing all those people while saving one person I loved. Death is inevitable as soon as we are born.

ZeStreoving · 06/10/2026 08:46

100% Id press that button if it saved a family member. No hesitation. No second thoughts.

LaurieFairyCake · 06/10/2026 08:42

No, I could not kill 10,000 strangers to save someone I love. The decision may kill me though, the grief at my loss of my daughter or my partner may also kill me.

The agony of murdering 10,000 would have me live in hell forever.

Mosee · 06/10/2026 08:08

Yes. I’m selfish. I’d feel awful about it though

gannett · 06/10/2026 08:06

I consider myself more OK than most with the idea of killing someone, but it's only specific people. Pete Hegseth or Jair Bolsonaro? I'd happily pull the trigger and laugh as they bled out. 10,000 anonymous people that I don't know about or have to think about beyond pressing a button seems inhuman on a different level to me.

I also can't imagine a scenario in which any of my loved ones would want to speak to me again if I did it on their behalf, so it's a no from me on this one.

Tillow4ever · 06/10/2026 08:04

CurdinHenry · 06/10/2026 07:57

I have a sense that the I WOULD NEVER DO THIS YOU DISGUST ME posters would in practice and behind closed doors be giving it three or four pushes of the button to be certain

Chuckling at "you are a man you engage in distasteful hypotheticals and only THEY do that"

Why would you think that? I certainly wouldn’t assume that about someone so set in their morals that they couldn’t do it (not wouldn’t, couldn’t).

My initial thought was absolutely not - but I went on to think and realised in some very niche scenarios I would. I think most people that would do it would admit they’d do it in response to a hypothetical question on an anonymous forum.

You clearly have some discomfort with the thought that not everyone would do this and would judge you if you would.

CurdinHenry · 06/10/2026 08:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

gannett · 06/10/2026 08:03

The posters calling this an offensive hypothetical thought experiment would do well to think about the reasons that 10,000 or more have been killed in wars with the full support of ordinary people - it's because the justification for those wars is very often sold as "this other group is a danger to your children".

CurdinHenry · 06/10/2026 08:02

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 08:00

Yeah, your 'sense' that people would do this ('push the button,') is wrong in the majority of cases, and certainly for me.

You keep telling yourself that if it makes you feel better though hun. Smile You keep on chuckling there gurl! Grin

It's just that you don't have a very empathetic or thoughtful energy. It's one thing to say it would be tough but I couldn't live with myself. Quite another to say variations of "no you scum how do you SLEEP at night with your death button chat!"

OP posts:
PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 08:01

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 07:56

It’s all very performative.

If you wouldn’t slaughter every last child on this Earth with your own hand to save your own child, you can’t possibly love them. Right?

I know right. Ridiculous thread. 'I wubz my babies more because I would kill 10,000 people to save them!'

LOLz

PrettyLittleRose · 06/10/2026 08:00

CurdinHenry · 06/10/2026 07:57

I have a sense that the I WOULD NEVER DO THIS YOU DISGUST ME posters would in practice and behind closed doors be giving it three or four pushes of the button to be certain

Chuckling at "you are a man you engage in distasteful hypotheticals and only THEY do that"

Yeah, your 'sense' that people would do this ('push the button,') is wrong in the majority of cases, and certainly for me.

You keep telling yourself that if it makes you feel better though hun. Smile You keep on chuckling there gurl! Grin

Tillow4ever · 06/10/2026 08:00

Not read the full thread, so apologies if someone else has asked this.

It seems most that I’ve read, who have said they would do it, would be doing it for their child/children only. So if the scenario is to save your child, would your answer still be yes to any of the following:

The 10,000 you kill have to be the same age as the person you are saving

The 10,000 you kill are all under 18’s

The 10,000 you kill are all under 12’s

The 10,000 you kill are all under 5’s

Curious then, if your answer changed to no for any of them, would it be a yes it the numbers were lower… eg 1 life for 1 life.

I initially voted that I wouldn’t do it. But on further reflection, I could see scenarios where I would - eg if the 10,000 were all convicted (and no ambiguity over guilt) paedophiles, rapists and murderers, or if the 10,000 people were all people who had been told they had less than 6 months to live and had willingly volunteered to be killed in this way.

CurdinHenry · 06/10/2026 07:57

I have a sense that the I WOULD NEVER DO THIS YOU DISGUST ME posters would in practice and behind closed doors be giving it three or four pushes of the button to be certain

Chuckling at "you are a man you engage in distasteful hypotheticals and only THEY do that"

OP posts:
SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 07:56

It’s all very performative.

If you wouldn’t slaughter every last child on this Earth with your own hand to save your own child, you can’t possibly love them. Right?

Swipe left for the next trending thread