Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
crackerjackbaby · 06/10/2026 18:57

I can’t think of a number that I wouldn’t end with a button to save my DC.

Bringemout · 06/10/2026 18:57

McSilkson · 05/10/2026 21:43

Interesting that the roughly two-thirds of people on here who would commit mass-murder at the press of a button corresponds with the equivalent number who would torture a stranger to death at the behest of an authority figure, via the press of a button, in the Stanley Milgram experiment.

I would deem this significant majority those lacking a strong moral compass or backbone.

I think torturing someone because someone in a white coat told you to is very different to making a choice to save a loved one, in the second scenario you are highly motivated by love, the first one is just fear of authority.

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 06/10/2026 18:57

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:47

Same as me 100% ! I’m shocked mums here would let their kids die to save strangers … I’m like wtf , the world could vanish if o don’t have my kids and family . They are my everything

To be honest I know objectively my children are not more important than anyone else, and they’re not more important than 10,000 people but like… obviously to me they are. I kind of assumed it was a no brainer.

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:54

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 18:52

It is interesting that those who choose the 10,000 strangers think they've got the moral upper hand.
I wouldn't be so sure.

If it were not for bonds between people-familial or otherwise-we would not exist today.

Pretending that that stranger's life is as worth as much to you as your own child's is virtue-signalling hogswash.

So true , a bit like the hen peole say “ all life’s are worth the same “ I’m like “ no they are not “ .

pinkypoo8 · 06/10/2026 18:54

Yours is a ridiculous thread by the way shame you haven't got anything better to do

pinkypoo8 · 06/10/2026 18:52

So you are anti-death penalty so what ? If proved beyond a reasonable doubt if the most heinous crime has been committed they need to go I've got no time for your sensibilities

plutopuff · 06/10/2026 18:52

I'm a Libra, so in my made up scenario there's also a countdown and I would leave it to whatever happened at the end of that just so I didn't have to make a decision.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 18:52

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 18:34

Lol. So true. Scared to open the front door to a neighbour but would definitely march on out and snap 10,000 peoples necks.

It is interesting that those who choose the 10,000 strangers think they've got the moral upper hand.
I wouldn't be so sure.

If it were not for bonds between people-familial or otherwise-we would not exist today.

Pretending that that stranger's life is as worth as much to you as your own child's is virtue-signalling hogswash.

BIossomtoes · 06/10/2026 18:51

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:47

Same as me 100% ! I’m shocked mums here would let their kids die to save strangers … I’m like wtf , the world could vanish if o don’t have my kids and family . They are my everything

My son would be absolutely horrified if I did it. He’d ask me wtf was going on in my head. I’d feel exactly the same as him if the situation was reversed.

pinkypoo8 · 06/10/2026 18:50

Huh I would feel much better about it if that
savage had killed my daughter.... even more so as it didn't seem to work first time

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:47

GreenCaterpillarOnALeaf · 05/10/2026 22:33

In a heart beat. Tbh to save my kids, husband or family members I wouldn’t care if I had to do it by hand or if I knew them.

Same as me 100% ! I’m shocked mums here would let their kids die to save strangers … I’m like wtf , the world could vanish if o don’t have my kids and family . They are my everything

fumingrightnow1 · 06/10/2026 18:45

VioletsTale · 05/10/2026 20:04

Does the child have to know what happened?

I'd tell them everytime they refused to clean their room or didn't eat their peas

PetuniaT · 06/10/2026 18:42

What do the voices in YOUR tell you to do? You're weird

inappropriateraspberry · 06/10/2026 18:41

No. No one person is worth 10,000 lives.

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:39

I will set the whole world on fire for the people I love . Literally, this is not a way of speaking or a dramatic way of saying things . When it comes to my kids , husband , parents , best friend I would literally kill anyone with my bare hands . If it was saving them or press a button that would kill the 9 billion people in world o would press the button with no second thoughts.
My family is my everything and I’m loyal to them 1000%

Emeraldforest · 06/10/2026 18:35

No, that reminds me of that film Taken, when Liam Neeson kills loads of people to find his daughter...I always hated that,a lot of them were innocent. Why was she more important than all those others,in world terms?
I would die myself for one of my loved ones, but I wouldn't be thrilled about it.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 18:34

boredsmored · 06/10/2026 06:03

@gostickyourheadinapig don’t let this thread be any indicator of normal parenting.

We know soldiers etc suffer PTSD and yet there is a bunch of MNs who whilst not answering their doors at night can shoot 10000 people in the head and sleep soundly 🤔

Lol. So true. Scared to open the front door to a neighbour but would definitely march on out and snap 10,000 peoples necks.

XenoBitch · 06/10/2026 18:32

What about 'would you kill your loved one to save 10000 people?'

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 18:31

Skates · 06/10/2026 18:04

After the day Iv had at work I would happily press the button

😂

envbeckyc · 06/10/2026 18:30

Interesting scenario…, however the people who I love most of all respect and love me because they know that I wouldn’t make a decision to kill somebody, let alone 10,000 people!

I would sell everything I own to pay for treatment to save the life of a loved one… I would even sell a kidney!

But I could never choose to deliberately cause harm or kill others or indeed anyone!

I guess that rules me out from being a genocidal dictator, having my own palace, and army… but that’s honestly ok!

Wildefish · 06/10/2026 18:30

Noshowlomo · 06/10/2026 18:24

Yes. Wouldn’t any parent do anything to save their child.
I mean, this is a totally mad question, and it would never happen though

No I would not kill 19,000 people to save someone I loved. I may killed someone who is trying to kill someone I loved to save them.

Stompythedinosaur · 06/10/2026 18:29

The whole world can burn if it saves my dc.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 18:28

I think, because of course there's no way of knowing nor would there ever be, the answer would be yes.

It's human nature to save nearest and dearest.

Wildefish · 06/10/2026 18:28

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 19:41

I think the honest answer must be yes, when you consider what else we do eg I've spent the best part of £1m just on my children's education alone so far- how many children would that have saved in sub Saharan Africa?

Others may not have such an extreme example to share but the principle still applies- how many lives could you have saved just for the cost of non-essentials spent on your children? If it's a large number (and I'm sure it is) how likely is it really that you'd put 10000 lives over your child's life?

Not quiet the same as actually killing 10,000

Wildefish · 06/10/2026 18:26

Gengha · 05/10/2026 19:36

I am against the DP and appalled by the CP situation but what has this got to do with OP’s question?

OP yes I would but only to save my child/ren. No one else

10,000 dead to save your children. What if those mothers each killed 10,000 to save theirs.