Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
gullgal · 06/10/2026 19:35

I really hope not because that's repulsive

ThistleTits · 06/10/2026 19:32

@CurdinHenry what if some of your loved ones were amongst those "sacrificed?"

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 19:31

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 19:20

Your so-called moral compass isn't as great as you think it is.

Reproduction is why the human species exists. Usually, except in circumstances that are considered abhorrent/abnormal, that goes hand-in-hand with an inbuilt instinct to protect at all costs the family unit. nearest and dearest.

I don't believe anybody who when it came down to it would choose to save 10,000 strangers.
I just don't.
It's just a weird form of virtue-signalling.

We'll never know of course but that's my opinion.

Would you kill 10,000 children to save your own child?

If not, you don’t truly love your own child?

Because how far are people taking these scenarios? I’m fascinated as to where people are drawing the line.

What’s the right number of victims to prove you do in fact love your own child?

lljkk · 06/10/2026 19:26

No. And if my parents did that for me I'd feel guilty if I found out they'd done it.

Solobanana · 06/10/2026 19:26

To save my children, I wouldn’t hesitate.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 19:24

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 19:20

Your so-called moral compass isn't as great as you think it is.

Reproduction is why the human species exists. Usually, except in circumstances that are considered abhorrent/abnormal, that goes hand-in-hand with an inbuilt instinct to protect at all costs the family unit. nearest and dearest.

I don't believe anybody who when it came down to it would choose to save 10,000 strangers.
I just don't.
It's just a weird form of virtue-signalling.

We'll never know of course but that's my opinion.

What a weird little rambling post

Just my opinion.

carchi · 06/10/2026 19:20

50Balesofgrey · 05/10/2026 19:39

I would do anything for love,
But I won't do that

Not even for meatloaf ?

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 19:20

SurvivalInstinctsOfABakedPotato · 06/10/2026 19:01

No. Not even to save my child who I love more than anything. He's only 15 but would be disgusted if he ever found out he only lives because other people died.
We do believe in God though so are not 'afraid' of death.
I'd Mourne him massively and never be the same again but no, my moral compass is strong and not a chance.
Not even if I knew all the others were murders etc.

Your so-called moral compass isn't as great as you think it is.

Reproduction is why the human species exists. Usually, except in circumstances that are considered abhorrent/abnormal, that goes hand-in-hand with an inbuilt instinct to protect at all costs the family unit. nearest and dearest.

I don't believe anybody who when it came down to it would choose to save 10,000 strangers.
I just don't.
It's just a weird form of virtue-signalling.

We'll never know of course but that's my opinion.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 19:16

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 18:52

It is interesting that those who choose the 10,000 strangers think they've got the moral upper hand.
I wouldn't be so sure.

If it were not for bonds between people-familial or otherwise-we would not exist today.

Pretending that that stranger's life is as worth as much to you as your own child's is virtue-signalling hogswash.

it's not 'a stranger's life'. It's 10,000 lives.

Goatsarebest · 06/10/2026 19:14

These theoretical questions are just Bull. First of all they just don't happen so why bother thinking about them. Secondly, nobody knows how they will react under extreme trauma or pressure until it happens. We might like to think we know, but we don't. How do we know what having to kill a 1000 people would feel like.
So all you are trying to do is evaluate how much you love someone on some scale of other people's lives.
But, there is an example in our community in 1969 (before I lived here) where a they were offering boat rides across the bay as part of a festival and a boat capsized with 49 people on. There were very strong currents and children ended up swept away from the boat. Some onshore adults went out to rescue them in small boats. There is a very much reported incident in our community of one parent in a small boat passing by two young people to get to his own son first who was further away. The two he passed by drowned as did 7 other children. There was other talk around selective rescuing of own children.
So that is a real life example of how one parent reacted. I know his son quite well who was rescued. He knew exactly what happened.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?
pinkspeakers · 06/10/2026 19:12

Shrigley · 05/10/2026 19:41

I think the honest answer must be yes, when you consider what else we do eg I've spent the best part of £1m just on my children's education alone so far- how many children would that have saved in sub Saharan Africa?

Others may not have such an extreme example to share but the principle still applies- how many lives could you have saved just for the cost of non-essentials spent on your children? If it's a large number (and I'm sure it is) how likely is it really that you'd put 10000 lives over your child's life?

Yes it's interesting. I think it is all in the framing of the question. I think if you ask someone if they would murder 10,000 people to save just 1, many people would instinctively say no. Including me. But you're absolutely right that the decisions (or omissions) that we make every day have basically the same effect.

Dmsandfloatydress · 06/10/2026 19:11

Hell no!! How incredibly selfish. I would naturally offer myself in their place but I would offer myself to save other peoples beloved children too. My child is my life but they would be horrified that I caused such horror in their name and neither of us would have any life worth living afterwards. You would be a mass murderer!

Vanillaicelatte · 06/10/2026 19:10

Yes I would

SleeplessInWherever · 06/10/2026 19:09

Isinglass20 · 06/10/2026 19:05

So let’s get to where we may be in a few years- your sons and daughters called up for military service- giving their lives to save thousands- including your own in your own country as well as those in other countries- no chance of protecting them in that situation.
Many say they would refuse national service but that would result bad feeling by others and time in gaol

I can definitely confirm mine won’t be called up for any national service.

He’s 10 years old and currently can’t be trusted with a juice bottle, or his own hands, nevermind a weapon.

It’s unlikely he’ll ever be more than 6ft away from us, for our whole lives, so I reckon we will actually be able to protect him (as best we can).

To be fair, doesn’t make him worth more or less than 10,000 people, apart from to us he obviously is because he’s ours.

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 19:08

Isinglass20 · 06/10/2026 19:05

So let’s get to where we may be in a few years- your sons and daughters called up for military service- giving their lives to save thousands- including your own in your own country as well as those in other countries- no chance of protecting them in that situation.
Many say they would refuse national service but that would result bad feeling by others and time in gaol

My kids have double nationality I would just take them if the country , no 2 ways about it . Nobody should yo be forced to military service , if you want to go fair game if not then nobody should .
Funny enough I have very close friends whose son was conscribed to go to war last year and they did just that . Why on earth would I allow my kid to fight a war I probably wouldn’t even support ?

MsWicked · 06/10/2026 19:08

I can imagine my own mother would mindlessly claim she’d kill the 10,000 but the fact that I know my mother would say this, is an illustration that it’s not a declaration of love. It’s an easy answer to a ridiculous question.
I couldn’t murder other people babies and children. Committing such an evil act with the excuse of saving your own, who’d want a mother like that.

Bringemout · 06/10/2026 19:05

SuperMaria · 05/10/2026 21:58

Not to pick on you specifically, but these answers are so unbearably cringe.

Like @nomas said, yours and nobody else’s kids are worth 10,000 other people dying. This is such a stupid hypothetical scenario, but even so, it’s insanely selfish. Other innocent men, women, children, babies. Bonus points for anyone who has ‘no qualms’ about it either, I mean fgs.

Saying you’d do this doesn't mean you love your kids so much more than anyone else.

No my my childs life is objectively not worth the same as 10’000 other lives in total. BUT to me subjectively it is and I’m the one with the button in this scenario.

It’s a bit like an army rescue, there could be one person stranded but a whole team is at risk of they attempt a rescue, yet it is often still done because what binds is the special status we give to people, whether it’s love or friendship or duty. PP is right imo, the cold utilitarian approach of saying all lives are equal to you is actually quite inhumane. It’s a bit like saying I could afford to buy my child a winter coat but she’s no more important to me than the next door neighbours kid so it doesn’t matter if I give them the coat because the net result is A child is warm.

Isinglass20 · 06/10/2026 19:05

So let’s get to where we may be in a few years- your sons and daughters called up for military service- giving their lives to save thousands- including your own in your own country as well as those in other countries- no chance of protecting them in that situation.
Many say they would refuse national service but that would result bad feeling by others and time in gaol

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 19:03

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 19:00

This reminds me of people saying after a tragedy in the news: ‘I don’t know how people can go on without their mum/son/daughter whatever, I would end my life (or kill the perpetrator if applicable)’.

Like ok, maybe you would, but it doesn’t mean you love your child more than anyone else because they aren’t willing to murder 10,000 people or whatever else. What exactly is there to be shocked by, thay some people wouldn’t want to inflict the same pain on others? Truly baffling.

We will have to disagree on that !

Lollipop81 · 06/10/2026 19:02

Blankitout · 05/10/2026 19:21

I'm still reeling after reading about the botched attempted state killing of Christa Pike in Tenessee. Absolutely repulsed by the fact the mother of the murder victim , Colleen Slemmer, was actually present at the execution. Horrible that her daughter was murdered but how does watching someone being murdered by the state make her any better then those who murdered her daughter.
I dont like your thread at all OP.

Totally agree what a pointless question.

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 19:02

But tbh, I think this thought experiment is a bit boring and not particularly thought-provoking. It’s too far removed from any real life scenario, it’s just absurd.

SurvivalInstinctsOfABakedPotato · 06/10/2026 19:01

No. Not even to save my child who I love more than anything. He's only 15 but would be disgusted if he ever found out he only lives because other people died.
We do believe in God though so are not 'afraid' of death.
I'd Mourne him massively and never be the same again but no, my moral compass is strong and not a chance.
Not even if I knew all the others were murders etc.

SleeplessInWherever · 06/10/2026 19:00

fumingrightnow1 · 06/10/2026 18:45

I'd tell them everytime they refused to clean their room or didn't eat their peas

Mines just nipped me for trying to teach him to use the toilet.

He’d definitely be getting a reminder 😂

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 19:00

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:47

Same as me 100% ! I’m shocked mums here would let their kids die to save strangers … I’m like wtf , the world could vanish if o don’t have my kids and family . They are my everything

This reminds me of people saying after a tragedy in the news: ‘I don’t know how people can go on without their mum/son/daughter whatever, I would end my life (or kill the perpetrator if applicable)’.

Like ok, maybe you would, but it doesn’t mean you love your child more than anyone else because they aren’t willing to murder 10,000 people or whatever else. What exactly is there to be shocked by, thay some people wouldn’t want to inflict the same pain on others? Truly baffling.

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 18:58

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 07:43

Ah so you’re one of those im referring to then.

I have two children and pregnant with no. 3.

Anyone saying they’d murder/kill 10,000 (does anyone here even comprehend how many people that is) without ‘any qualms’ because they ‘love their kids’ and is ‘shocked’ thay anyone else feels differently is cringe and embarrassing. You don’t love your child any more than anyone else.

Beyond weird, anyone who proclaims wanting to kill other random innocent people is a measure of their love for their loved ones, even hypothetically.

See but for us , those who replied as above it’s shocking that you wouldn’t do anything to save your kids . In this hypothetical scenario my kids husband and close family would be my top priority . For me it’s shocking to think others wouldn’t protect them above anything and anyone else .