Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill 10000 people to save the person you love most?

537 replies

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Yesitsweird · 06/10/2026 20:47

SurvivalInstinctsOfABakedPotato · 06/10/2026 19:01

No. Not even to save my child who I love more than anything. He's only 15 but would be disgusted if he ever found out he only lives because other people died.
We do believe in God though so are not 'afraid' of death.
I'd Mourne him massively and never be the same again but no, my moral compass is strong and not a chance.
Not even if I knew all the others were murders etc.

I'm sorry, you wouldn't kill 10000 murderers to save your own son? And you think that makes you a superior person in some way?

ControlYourDog · 06/10/2026 20:38

I'd press that button twice.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 20:32

namechangetheworld · 06/10/2026 20:19

Any mother saying no and feigning outrage over this hypothetical situation is a virtue signaler of the highest order.

I'd do it and feel no guilt whatsoever.

I agree with you but I would feel terrible about it.
I think it's totally natural and expected to put loved ones before strangers, I wouldn't feel great about it, though.
Probably be guilt-ridden for life but still loved ones would come before strangers.

Mirsine · 06/10/2026 20:29

I’d kill 10000 people if it meant I got the last sausage roll at Greggs!

Fairy25 · 06/10/2026 20:28

Wow… half of you would be happy to murder other people’s children to save your own.

RatsCatsandPuppies · 06/10/2026 20:25

I’d kill 10,000 people to save my cat.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 20:24

namechangetheworld · 06/10/2026 20:19

Any mother saying no and feigning outrage over this hypothetical situation is a virtue signaler of the highest order.

I'd do it and feel no guilt whatsoever.

You'd do it and feel no guilt whatsoever. Again, it just demonstrates a slowish kind of mind, to boast with this kind of bravado.

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 20:24

WhatMyNameis · 06/10/2026 20:05

11,000.

Always good to know in advance, we have a birthday coming up in the family!

namechangetheworld · 06/10/2026 20:19

Calenia · 06/10/2026 20:07

Yes. Of course. Any mother saying no is unhinged.

Any mother saying no and feigning outrage over this hypothetical situation is a virtue signaler of the highest order.

I'd do it and feel no guilt whatsoever.

WhatMyNameis · 06/10/2026 20:16

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 20:09

My kind is f person ! I’m glad I’m not the only one thinking the same way .

😂😂😂

Laura95167 · 06/10/2026 20:13

Wouldn't hesitate.

I think its wrong, but I wouldnt care.

Though there is a film on this premise, I dont remember all the specifics but it was like.. you get a box and if you open it or press the button in it.. something like that you get $1 million, but someone you dont know dies. You get the box for like 24hrs or something to decide.

And at the end if the film the box is collected from the current family who have it.. and theyre told the box is going to the next person on the list.... but dont worry its no one they know

Deadlykitten · 06/10/2026 20:10

yes, without question and there is not a maximum number for me

Goatsarebest · 06/10/2026 20:10

According to the Book of Genesis Noha took his wife and three sons and their wives and let literally everyone else in the world drown. So that's equivalent today of 8 billion deaths to save your family. That's a high bar set by Noha.
Goats get saved, so I'm comfortable with this.

ThatLemonBee · 06/10/2026 20:09

WhatMyNameis · 06/10/2026 20:04

I would kill you, I would kill your family, I would boil rivers, set the world on fire and pull the stars from the skies to save someone I loved 🤷‍♀️

My kind is f person ! I’m glad I’m not the only one thinking the same way .

Calenia · 06/10/2026 20:07

Yes. Of course. Any mother saying no is unhinged.

WhatMyNameis · 06/10/2026 20:05

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 19:31

Would you kill 10,000 children to save your own child?

If not, you don’t truly love your own child?

Because how far are people taking these scenarios? I’m fascinated as to where people are drawing the line.

What’s the right number of victims to prove you do in fact love your own child?

11,000.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 20:05

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 19:56

You can keep your passive-aggressive little post.
I'd much prefer it if you told me to fuck off.

But why would I tell you to fuck off? I found it weird so I described it as such 🤷

WhatMyNameis · 06/10/2026 20:04

I would kill you, I would kill your family, I would boil rivers, set the world on fire and pull the stars from the skies to save someone I loved 🤷‍♀️

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 20:01

SuperMaria · 06/10/2026 19:31

Would you kill 10,000 children to save your own child?

If not, you don’t truly love your own child?

Because how far are people taking these scenarios? I’m fascinated as to where people are drawing the line.

What’s the right number of victims to prove you do in fact love your own child?

It's not about proving anything about loving anybody.
That's not the point.
The natural inclination is to protect nearest and dearest over strangers.

What's the point of forming relationships, marrying, having children-which most people are inclined to do - if everybody is interchangeable to us?

TotaleclipseinFrance · 06/10/2026 19:56

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 19:24

What a weird little rambling post

Just my opinion.

You can keep your passive-aggressive little post.
I'd much prefer it if you told me to fuck off.

Cailleach1 · 06/10/2026 19:54

Goatsarebest · 06/10/2026 19:14

These theoretical questions are just Bull. First of all they just don't happen so why bother thinking about them. Secondly, nobody knows how they will react under extreme trauma or pressure until it happens. We might like to think we know, but we don't. How do we know what having to kill a 1000 people would feel like.
So all you are trying to do is evaluate how much you love someone on some scale of other people's lives.
But, there is an example in our community in 1969 (before I lived here) where a they were offering boat rides across the bay as part of a festival and a boat capsized with 49 people on. There were very strong currents and children ended up swept away from the boat. Some onshore adults went out to rescue them in small boats. There is a very much reported incident in our community of one parent in a small boat passing by two young people to get to his own son first who was further away. The two he passed by drowned as did 7 other children. There was other talk around selective rescuing of own children.
So that is a real life example of how one parent reacted. I know his son quite well who was rescued. He knew exactly what happened.

That is slightly different. Would you aim to save your child first, if 10,000 others were in equal danger? You wouldn’t be killing them, or putting them in danger. You would be choosing to rescue your own child first.

That sounds horrendous, though. The alternative possible scenario was if the man rescued the two poor children (who subsequently drowned), and his own child might have drowned instead whilst he was doing that.

Shloopie · 06/10/2026 19:46

Cailleach1 · 06/10/2026 19:41

But your children are on the planet. Are we supposing they are in a self sufficient earth colony on Mars, or elsewhere, whilst you blow up planet earth?

Don't bamboozle them 😂

FreddysFingers · 06/10/2026 19:43

I would if I could ensure that the 10,000 people were convicted rapists, child molesters or murderers.

jac67 · 06/10/2026 19:41

CurdinHenry · 05/10/2026 19:12

Context -

You would just have to press a button and you wouldn't have to see it happen

You would be guaranteed not to know any of them beforehand

No one would know it was you unless you confessed

Yanbu yes
Yabu no

Wow just wow

Cailleach1 · 06/10/2026 19:41

nearlylovemyusername · 05/10/2026 20:05

Just yesterday I told my DC that if I had to blow up this planet to save them, I wouldn't think twice. They disagreed with my view but never doubted it

But your children are on the planet. Are we supposing they are in a self sufficient earth colony on Mars, or elsewhere, whilst you blow up planet earth?