Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thread 27 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film?

790 replies

DisappointedReader · 25/06/2026 20:01

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL

Please see the OP of Thread 25 for all the links to The Observer's reporting and podcast series, our threads one to 24 and so on:
Thread 25 : To feel disappointed - and disgusted and vindicated now too - after reading this in The Observer about the author and her husband from The Salt Path book and film? | Mumsnet

New posters joining us in the genuine spirit of our civil discourse are always welcome. It would be helpful to get the background from some of Investigative Journalist Chloe Hadjimatheou's excellent exposé items before posting. Chloe's podcast series for The Observer 'The Walkers' covers most things:
The Walkers: The real Salt Path | The Observer
Another suggestion:
BBC Sounds - Secrets of the Salt Path - Available Episodes
To all - Please be extremely cautious when it comes to naming or implicating people and addresses not in the public eye or with no direct connection to the story, especially where details are unclear or still emerging. Remember, even Hollywood rabbits attract the odd flea: please do not engage with drive-by scolders who seem to have their own agenda and seek to derail. Avoid @'ing and quoting them as - from experience - this will only encourage them back to the threads. For nearly a year we have done amazingly well together for 26 very interesting, very serious and very silly, threads so far. I can't be here as much as I'd like so all help with keeping our discussion walking along in our usual reasonable and respectful fashion is very welcome.

We are still here after 26,000 posts and fast approaching our one year anniversary together on 6th July 2026, 12 months on from the start of our first thread in response to Our Chloe's somewhat stunning initial exposé. Little did we know what else would come out. Our longevity comes as both a total surprise and a pleasure (mostly!). We've seen charabancers come and go, come back again, delurk and join us for the first time. All are welcome. Threads have both filled up in a day and moved at a more stately pace. Thank you everyone for sharing your time, thoughts, opinions, experience, questions, sleuthing (there's that word!), kindness (there's that other word!) and great humour with me and with each other. As ever, as we embark on our 27th thread riding the community charabanc - this time all holding our brollies and fans aloft for much-needed shade and breeze - keep to the path, no saltiness, eat fudge and drink cider, (but not too much in the current heatwave).

NO POSTS PLEASE UNTIL THREAD 26 IS FULL:
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/5506717-thread-26-to-feel-disappointed-and-disgusted-and-vindicated-now-too-after-reading-this-in-the-observer-about-the-author-and-her-husband-from-the-salt-path-book-and-film?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
102
Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 02/10/2026 08:52

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 02/10/2026 08:48

What I wondered lately, in a purely hypothetical situation, is what the backlash (or lack thereof) would have been had it been discovered that TSP etc had been written by AI. Would that have been viewed as more egregious? Would fans still support because "the story is still inspirational"?

I don't see much difference tbh because both hypothetical AI and RW written narratives would ultimately be grounded in deception.

Horrible to say it, but increasingly people don't care if something has been written by AI. They pretend that it's all right, because the 'author' had to feed the prompts into AI in the first place, so it's still 'their story'.

And Sal would probably say that she HAD to use AI because she had some dreadful, accountancy-related injury that meant she was now unable to write herself but wanted her inspirational story out there for the public to read.

YourMoneyforFrothingandYourChipsforFree · 02/10/2026 08:48

What I wondered lately, in a purely hypothetical situation, is what the backlash (or lack thereof) would have been had it been discovered that TSP etc had been written by AI. Would that have been viewed as more egregious? Would fans still support because "the story is still inspirational"?

I don't see much difference tbh because both hypothetical AI and RW written narratives would ultimately be grounded in deception.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 02/10/2026 07:50

HatStickBoots · 02/10/2026 00:03

Just had an idea for another book in the same vein as Where’s Wally?
Yes, you guessed it. Where’s Moth?!

Yes, his non-appearance causes more questions than it answers. He was so spry and lively (and keen for his moment of fame) when the film came out; Chloe's investigation goes public and BAM, he becomes Schrodinger's Moth. Unseen, unmentioned, unphotographed and yet any enquiries seem to be brushed off with 'he's fine'.

If he's fine - where is he?
If he's ill - where is he? I'd have thought at least regular hospital visits would be incurred and nobody has reported seeing him so much as in a hospital car park.

So his absence looks more suspicious than illness...

HatStickBoots · 02/10/2026 00:03

Just had an idea for another book in the same vein as Where’s Wally?
Yes, you guessed it. Where’s Moth?!

HatStickBoots · 01/10/2026 20:32

DisappointedReader · 01/10/2026 14:36

Perhaps 'the Moth problem' will be dealt with by ignoring it? Maybe he will just never be mentioned again, but we will know he is there, like the elephant in the room or rather the moth in the fake tent?

It’s so ridiculous it’s farcical. The reality is like the plot of a Marx Brothers film 🍿 with ‘Moth’ being kept hidden while she trots out the dialogue she still wants everyone to believe. It’s like she’s trying to rewrite and cover up history again as though Chloe’s expose never happened, her rebuttal never happened and the timeline can be moved around like a child’s wooden railway track to remove the diversion and fit us neatly back onto the run towards On Winter Hill. We are expected to believe that she walked alone because she had to come to terms with the truth about Moth (which is ironically a lie) that he wasn’t cured by the walking, even though her books said the contrary but he was absolutely fine when promoting the film. We need to suspend belief and really separate these two fraudsters from their fictional alter egos. We’ve actually got to play along with this deluded woman’s narrative that Sally and Tim don’t exist, they’ve gone back into a box. Just thinking about this nonsense makes my head spin! 😵‍💫

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 01/10/2026 17:08

Oeufs · 01/10/2026 13:55

Someone remind me whether OWH, or whatever the next thrilling instalment might be called, is supposedly due out in early 2027 or early 2028 now?

The fact of the continuance of the 'brand' on Instagram with regular Mothless photos, does suggest that Brand Raynor has not been packed up like a teeny, teeny rucksack, and that there is more to come. I suppose time will tell whether PRH thinks it has legs. And what the 'absence of Moth' story will look like.

It's inteesting, because Googling OWH it pops up still saying it released in October 2025, and I had to hunt around quite hard to find that it's supposedly released January 2028.

But AI seems to believe that it's out already.

BrandiedAromatics · 01/10/2026 16:57

“A lot of people were enjoying [the film], regardless, and it is special in its own right. I hope people are able to experience it as its own entity, separate from what may or may not be true or whatever controversy there is.”

Only if I split up my soul and place it in different spaces, Gillian Anderson. I had sympathy for the film makers and actors - it is still not their fault, or even the publishers. But, doesn't money talk?

The Salt Path scandal may have scared off US film distrib...

The Salt Path scandal may have scared off US film distrib...

The Salt Path scandal may have scared off US film distrib...

Gillian Anderson says a Sony deal was due to be signed the week The Observer exposed the real story behind Raynor Winn’s memoir

https://observer.co.uk/news/national/article/the-salt-path-scandal-may-have-scared-off-us-film-distributor-star-reveals

DisappointedReader · 01/10/2026 14:36

Perhaps 'the Moth problem' will be dealt with by ignoring it? Maybe he will just never be mentioned again, but we will know he is there, like the elephant in the room or rather the moth in the fake tent?

OP posts:
Oeufs · 01/10/2026 13:55

Someone remind me whether OWH, or whatever the next thrilling instalment might be called, is supposedly due out in early 2027 or early 2028 now?

The fact of the continuance of the 'brand' on Instagram with regular Mothless photos, does suggest that Brand Raynor has not been packed up like a teeny, teeny rucksack, and that there is more to come. I suppose time will tell whether PRH thinks it has legs. And what the 'absence of Moth' story will look like.

Oeufs · 01/10/2026 13:49

DisappointedReader · 01/10/2026 13:39

Interesting comments amongst the family/blinkered sycophant ones: how is Moth, laughing emoji, insanity, brass neck, very posed picture, that tent shouldn't be there...try Wales.

Yes, and one from someone who said quite openly that they'd loved all the books and felt as though they'd been betrayed by a friend when the revelations emerged, and if only RW had just labelled them 'fiction'. Also one from someone who said he/she 'didn't care' if the books were 'complete fiction' because 'It's about the message' (about nature and inspiration to walk).

A few people telling critical commenters to read RW's statement which 'makes perfect sense'. And that they too have 'been the victim of a smear campaign' and 'it is so easy to spin anything'.

If it weren't so depressing, it would be a fascinating study of suspension of disbelief and credulity.

DisappointedReader · 01/10/2026 13:39

Interesting comments amongst the family/blinkered sycophant ones: how is Moth, laughing emoji, insanity, brass neck, very posed picture, that tent shouldn't be there...try Wales.

OP posts:
Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 01/10/2026 06:56

But presumably no clue as to whether this photograph of her stoic and set-jawed solo travels was actually taken this decade?

HatStickBoots · 30/09/2026 23:41

Grin lol Neckless! Thank you, I can picture the curation of this scene so clearly. The roving pop up tent strikes again accompanied by a bludgeon of words on the theme of stoic Alone-ness lest we forget 🥱

NecklessMumster · 30/09/2026 19:38

View from out of tent flap to a beach, 'the moment when the light's new, the sand's cold and the ocean belongs only to you' with one pair of boots in view..so yes, that's the implication.
The only time I ever pitched a tent on sand it collapsed overnight 😊

HatStickBoots · 30/09/2026 18:48

Thanks for the update @NecklessMumster . Does it continue the ‘walking alone’ theme?

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 30/09/2026 17:00

NecklessMumster · 30/09/2026 16:56

Another Instagram post, more fawning messages

She must be getting anxious by now about the final release. I think PRH are hoping it will all blow over and OWH can come out, albeit with minimal publicity. At least her days of being on the gravy train of literary festivals seems well and truly over.

NecklessMumster · 30/09/2026 16:56

Another Instagram post, more fawning messages

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 23/09/2026 14:54

PullTheBricksDown · 23/09/2026 07:55

Bringing this over, with some additions, from a thread discussing Earl Spencer's book, where I'd posted:
Once again, in the style of The Salt Path, the publishing industry gets caught out due to its failure to proof read and fact check. The error is obvious once flagged and all the relevant information was in the public domain. Hope Morgan takes them to the cleaners. Charles S will need to look elsewhere for his retirement payday. Maybe his favourite nephew is good for a loan? 😆

I'm genuinely surprised that fact checking like this was so poorly done for a) such a high profile book and b) for statements relating to, let's say, individuals known to be combative. What were Penguin doing? Morgan is asking for the book to be pulped. Perhaps this, finally, will be the expensive lesson the publishing industry needs. Might give them pause for thought about On Winter Hill too.

It does increasingly seem that publishers are just 'taking the authors word for it' and letting things go. Which is absurd when I got an editor querying in my most recent plot where I'd mentioned an actor's name, whether we were actually allowed to use his name? I pointed out that as long as we aren't bringing him into disrepute then of COURSE we can use his name - but this was me, the author, telling the editor, who surely should know better than me!

PullTheBricksDown · 23/09/2026 07:55

Bringing this over, with some additions, from a thread discussing Earl Spencer's book, where I'd posted:
Once again, in the style of The Salt Path, the publishing industry gets caught out due to its failure to proof read and fact check. The error is obvious once flagged and all the relevant information was in the public domain. Hope Morgan takes them to the cleaners. Charles S will need to look elsewhere for his retirement payday. Maybe his favourite nephew is good for a loan? 😆

I'm genuinely surprised that fact checking like this was so poorly done for a) such a high profile book and b) for statements relating to, let's say, individuals known to be combative. What were Penguin doing? Morgan is asking for the book to be pulped. Perhaps this, finally, will be the expensive lesson the publishing industry needs. Might give them pause for thought about On Winter Hill too.

DisappointedReader · 20/09/2026 21:11

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/09/2026 15:27

I would assume that JI and GA have been told not to comment on any of the negative stuff. They will be contractually obliged to be positive and upbeat about any new release. You very rarely hear anyone on the publicity circuit talking about what a nightmare to make a film was, how everyone fell out with everyone else and the director was drunk every day. It's all about how lovely it all was and how good friends the crew have become/

They lie, basically. Because it's their job.

That video is crying out for some comments to be added.

OP posts:
DierdreDaphne · 20/09/2026 17:07

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/09/2026 09:17

It does look as though the Americans are seeing through the flimsy fabric that constructed this whole tale.

"Is the indomitable human spirit enough to indomitable one’s way out of a terminal illness?"

Haha, loved that! 😂

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/09/2026 15:27

ThompsonTwin · 20/09/2026 13:16

Interview with JI with zero mention of the controversy surrounding the book and film!

I would assume that JI and GA have been told not to comment on any of the negative stuff. They will be contractually obliged to be positive and upbeat about any new release. You very rarely hear anyone on the publicity circuit talking about what a nightmare to make a film was, how everyone fell out with everyone else and the director was drunk every day. It's all about how lovely it all was and how good friends the crew have become/

They lie, basically. Because it's their job.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 20/09/2026 09:17

ThompsonTwin · 19/09/2026 19:48

It does look as though the Americans are seeing through the flimsy fabric that constructed this whole tale.

Swipe left for the next trending thread